Whistleblowing Remedies in New Jersey

The New Jersey Supreme Court provided a victory for whistleblowers in a case where they held lost wages were recoverable in a CEPA case, even in the absence of a constructive discharge.

2011-12-29

December 29, 2011 (Press-News.org) Recent decisions by the New Jersey Supreme Court and the Appellate Division clarify the definition of "adverse employment action" that triggers New Jersey's "whistleblower law," known as the Conscientious Employee Protection Act (CEPA).

Adverse Employment Action

John Seddon had worked for Dupont 30 years when he filed a complaint with OSHA, the federal office for occupational safety and health. Seddon's complaint involved DuPont's practice of inspecting employee vehicles at the gate of the plant.

Employees had to stand by the side of a busy road, in the dark, with traffic passing nearby. After this, DuPont made Seddon report to a new shift supervisor, a significant change, as he had never had a supervisor before.

Seddon later reported a possible safety issue with a chemical reactor for which he was responsible, comparing the risk of chemical explosion to the infamous one in Bhopal, India. At that point DuPont began falsely accusing him of forging his time cards and gave him first-time negative job reviews, culminating in his taking a six month medical leave for "significant dysphoria and vulnerability to depression."

No Proof of Constructive Discharge

Seddon eventually took a disability retirement. A trial jury awarded him $1.5 million in damages for pain and suffering, lost wages, and punitive damages, and the trial judge awarded him significant counsel fees. DuPont appealed.

The Appellate Division reversed, stating that because Seddon did not allege and prove that he was fired or constructively discharged (the equivalent of firing), then he could not recover lost wages or pain and suffering damages.

Without such damages, said the Appellate Division, Seddon's punitive damages claim also had to fall. And without such damages, they said, Seddon also was not eligible as a "prevailing party" to receive counsel fees and costs.

The Supreme Court reversed the Appellate Division in every particular, holding that "lost wages are recoverable in a CEPA case, even in the absence of a constructive discharge."

CEPA and Constructive Discharge

The Appellate Division would have required Seddon to prove a case for constructive discharge. In New Jersey, the "standard" for constructive discharge is that the employer has allowed conditions to become so intolerable that a reasonable person would quit.

This is a very fact-intensive inquiry, and the "reasonable person" standard is objective, but in this case, there was substantial testimony from experts that Seddon had suffered actual psychological damage that rendered him unable to continue working and that his decision to stop working was entirely justified.

The Supreme Court appeared more sympathetic to granting damages, because it determined that even where the employee did not argue constructive discharge, nevertheless, under CEPA he had a right to damages. This was because the employer had retaliated against him while he engaged in protected "whistleblowing" activity.

The Court applied traditional tort law to explain why the DuPont was liable for the damages that flowed from its illegal retaliatory behavior, which included "the right to recover damages for diminished-earning capacity."

Conclusion

If you, your friends, or loved ones have a New Jersey workplace crisis or concern involving "whistleblower" activities or any other aspect of the employment relationship, make sure to bring those concerns to the attention of a qualified and knowledgeable employment law attorney.

Article provided by Hanan M. Isaacs, P.C.
Visit us at www.hananisaacs.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Targeted blocking of cell death prevents fatal condition septic shock

2011-12-29

Ghent, Belgium 27 December 2011 - Researchers of VIB and UGent have discovered a new approach to preventing septic shock, an often fatal extreme inflammatory reaction of the body. It is the most frequent cause of death at intensive care departments in hospitals. In sepsis, acute inflammation is attended by low blood pressure and blood clots, causing the organs to stop working. Only recently, the Brazilian football legend Socrates, died of the consequences of this condition. In a new study in the top journal Immunity, Peter Vandenabeele and colleagues of VIB-UGent described ...

Toasting the chemistry of champagne: New Year's Eve video from the American Chemical Society

2011-12-29

WASHINGTON, Dec. 27, 2011 — Just in time for those New Year's Eve toasts, which might include a farewell to the International Year of Chemistry, the world's largest scientific society today posted online a video on the chemistry of champagne. The latest addition to the award-winning Bytesize Science series from the American Chemical Society (ACS) is available at www.BytesizeScience.com. It explains that champagne, unlike other wines, undergoes a second fermentation in the bottle to trap carbon dioxide gas, which dissolves into the wine and forms the fabled bubbles in ...

Elderly can be as fast as young in some brain tasks, study shows

2011-12-29

COLUMBUS, Ohio – Both children and the elderly have slower response times when they have to make quick decisions in some settings. But recent research suggests that much of that slower response is a conscious choice to emphasize accuracy over speed. In fact, healthy older people can be trained to respond faster in some decision-making tasks without hurting their accuracy – meaning their cognitive skills in this area aren't so different from younger adults. "Many people think that it is just natural for older people's brains to slow down as they age, but we're finding ...

Debt and Divorce

2011-12-29

According to a recent study in the Journal of Law, Economics and Organization reported more "households would benefit financially from bankruptcy than actually file." Although no one anticipates filing for bankruptcy, for some it is a viable option for future financial success. The Wisconsin State Bar outlines the following benefits associated with bankruptcy: - Keeping all or most property - Easing credit card debts - Avoiding certain liens and involuntary transfers The Bar also cautions consideration of the disadvantages prior to filing. Including that ...

Children don't give words special power to categorize their world

2011-12-29

COLUMBUS, Ohio – New research challenges the conventional thinking that young children use language just as adults do to help classify and understand objects in the world around them. In a new study involving 4- to 5-year-old children, researchers found that the labels adults use to classify items – words like "dog" or "pencil" – don't have the same ability to influence the thinking of children. "As adults, we know that words are very predictive. If you use words to guide you, they won't often let you down," said Vladimir Sloutsky, co-author of the new study and professor ...

Mutation in gene that's critical for human development linked to arrhythmia

2011-12-29

(SALT LAKE CITY)— Arrhythmia is a potentially life-threatening problem with the rate or rhythm of the heartbeat, causing it to go too fast, too slow or to beat irregularly. Arrhythmia affects millions of people worldwide. The cardiac conduction system (CCS) regulates the rate and rhythm of the heart. It is a group of specialized cells in the walls of the heart. These cells control the heart rate by sending electrical signals from the sinoatrial node in the heart's right atrium (upper chamber) to the ventricles (lower chambers), causing them to contract and pump blood. The ...

Childhood hypersensitivity linked to OCD

2011-12-29

In childhood, rituals like regular schedules for meal, bath, and bed times are a healthy part of behavioral development. But combined with oral and tactile sensitivities, such as discomfort at the dentist or irritation caused by specific fabrics, these rituals could be an early warning sign of adult Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD). According to Prof. Reuven Dar of Tel Aviv University's Department of Psychology, hypersensitivity and excessive adherence to childhood rituals may foreshadow the onset of OCD as the child ages. He first suspected the link while working ...

Missouri Mesothelioma Victims Not Limited to Workers' Comp Claims

2011-12-29

Generally, under Missouri law, workers' compensation provides an "exclusive remedy" to employees who suffer work-related injuries. Thus, most workers must rely on workers' compensation benefits when they are injured on the job and generally are not able to bring a civil negligence lawsuit against their employers. However, a recent state Court of Appeals decision has changed this rule as it relates to Missouri asbestos exposure victims and workers suffering from other occupational diseases. These injured workers are no longer limited by the workers' compensation ...

Time for a change?

2011-12-29

Researchers at The Johns Hopkins University have discovered a way to make time stand still -- at least when it comes to the yearly calendar. Using computer programs and mathematical formulas, Richard Conn Henry, an astrophysicist in the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, and Steve H. Hanke, an applied economist in the Whiting School of Engineering, have created a new calendar in which each new 12-month period is identical to the one which came before, and remains that way from one year to the next in perpetuity. Under the Hanke-Henry Permanent Calendar, for instance, ...

Badwater Basin: Death Valley microbe thrives there

2011-12-29

Nevada, the "Silver State," is well-known for mining precious metals. But scientists Dennis Bazylinski and colleagues at the University of Nevada Las Vegas (UNLV) do a different type of mining. They sluice through every water body they can find, looking for new forms of microbial magnetism. In a basin named Badwater on the edge of Death Valley National Park, Bazylinski and researcher Christopher Lefèvre hit pay dirt. Lefèvre is with the French National Center of Scientific Research and University of Aix-Marseille II. In this week's issue of the journal Science, ...