(Press-News.org) The fate of nearly half a million immigrants hoping for U.S. citizenship may have been determined randomly, at least in part, according to a new study by a Michigan State University researcher who found the high-stakes civics test isn't a reliable measure of civics knowledge.
To be awarded citizenship, immigrants must correctly answer six of 10 questions on the verbally administered civics portion of the U.S. Naturalization Test, said Paula Winke, assistant professor of second language studies.
Questions are randomly selected by an immigration officer from a pool of 100. But contrary to ethical high-stakes testing standards, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services has never released data demonstrating the 100 questions are reliable or valid, she said. More problematic, according to Winke, is that some test forms may be more difficult than others.
"If your citizenship status hangs upon this one test as it does for many, the award of citizenship or noncitizenship may be arbitrarily made, based on the form that's pulled out of the drawer from the immigration officer," Winke said.
Winke's study, which is published in the winter edition of the journal Language Assessment Quarterly, is the first to measure the reliability of the test. She found that despite immigration services spending six years and $6.5 million to make the test more standardized and fair, it's not.
USCIS rolled out a new test in 2008, and that's the last time it was updated. That same year, immigration services received $375 million in fees from naturalization applicants and administered 1.65 million interviews, approving 1.05 million people for citizenship, Winke said.
Applicants spend $675 each to take the test and sometimes wait years to meet with an immigration officer. That's why it's baffling that immigration services doesn't keep or publish data on the reliability of the test, Winke said.
To be reliable, the test should measure what Americans know and what noncitizens who haven't studied for the test don't know, Winke said. But in her research, Winke found 77 of the 100 possible questions were equally difficult for both groups.
Winke also found 13 questions were easier for noncitizens to answer. One such question: "Name one war fought by the United States in the 1900s."
USCIS should collect data to determine which questions are hard and which are easy for Americans and noncitizens alike, Winke said, to ensure that only those questions that reliably assess Americans' core civics knowledge are on the test.
For most high-stakes tests – such as SAT or ACT – testing companies collect and publish test data demonstrating the test is reliable. But immigration services doesn't, Winke said.
"There's a lot about accountability in testing and education these days. I think the same applies to our government," Winke said. "As educators, we have to prove that every test under No Child Left Behind is reliable and valid, so why isn't the government doing this for the civics test?"
###
Michigan State University has been working to advance the common good in uncommon ways for more than 150 years. One of the top research universities in the world, MSU focuses its vast resources on creating solutions to some of the world's most pressing challenges, while providing life-changing opportunities to a diverse and inclusive academic community through more than 200 programs of study in 17 degree-granting colleges.
END
Super 8 Monroe NC Hotel offers convenient lodging to students and their parents attending upcoming Top Scholars Days at Wingate University. The events will take place on campus March 17, 2012 and April 21, 2012; reservations are required. Top Scholars Day was created for admitted students to have the opportunity to chat with current students and professors at Wingate University. Attending students may compete for free tuition in the Tweet for Tuition Challenge.
"Situated only 5 miles from the school, our hotel near Wingate University is looking forward to welcoming ...
Los Angeles, March 12, 2012 – Cedars-Sinai researchers have unlocked the mystery of how an inflammatory molecule is produced in the body, a discovery they say could lead to advances in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis, Type 2 diabetes and numerous other chronic diseases that affect tens of millions of people.
The study, funded by the National Institutes of Health, is published online by the peer-reviewed journal Immunity and will appear in the March print edition.
The researchers identified for the first time the mechanism that leads to the production of the ...
CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — In the beginning – of the ribosome, the cell's protein-building workbench – there were ribonucleic acids, the molecules we call RNA that today perform a host of vital functions in cells. And according to a new analysis, even before the ribosome's many working parts were recruited for protein synthesis, proteins also were on the scene and interacting with RNA. This finding challenges a long-held hypothesis about the early evolution of life.
The study appears in the journal PLoS ONE.
The "RNA world" hypothesis, first promoted in 1986 in a paper in the ...
AUDIO:
This is an audio recording of the distinctive "ribbit " call of the Pacific chorus frog (28 seconds long, MP3 file, WAV file available on request).
This noisy frog is a potent...
Click here for more information.
Known for its distinctive "ribbit" call, the noisy Pacific chorus frog is a potent carrier of a deadly amphibian disease, according to new research published today in the journal PLoS ONE. Just how this common North American frog survives chytridiomycosis ...
Four articles in the current issue draw attention to policy initiatives and implications of the rapidly changing U.S. health care environment. Collectively, they examine some of the challenges and opportunities facing the country following the 2010 passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
Researchers Project Cost of Family Health Insurance Premiums Will Surpass Household Income by 2033
Updating estimates of who will be able to afford health insurance in the future in light of the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act that reformed health ...
Using injectable diacetylmorphine — the active ingredient in heroin — to treat chronic opioid addiction is cheaper and more effective than methadone, states an article in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).
Methadone is the most common treatment for people who are dependent on opioids such as heroin, although research indicates that most people over time go back to using illicit drugs. The North American Opiate Medication Initiative, a randomized controlled trial, indicated that diacetylmorphine is more effective in keeping opioid-dependent people in treatment. ...
A 21,626-person study published today in the Journal of Clinical Oncology found that the five-year survival rate for children and adolescents with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), the most common childhood cancer, improved from 83.7 percent in those diagnosed during the years 1990-1994, to 90.4 percent for those diagnosed in the years 2000-2005.
"The improved survival is due to using existing drugs better, not because of the introduction of new drugs. We're indebted to all the families who choose to join these clinical trials, allowing us to optimize these combinations," ...
PHILADELPHIA (March 12, 2012) – Scientists from the Monell Center report that seven of 12 related mammalian species have lost the sense of sweet taste. As each of the sweet-blind species eats only meat, the findings demonstrate that a liking for sweets is frequently lost during the evolution of diet specialization.
Previous research from the Monell team had revealed the remarkable finding that both domestic and wild cats are unable to taste sweet compounds due to defects in a gene that controls structure of the sweet taste receptor.
Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning ...
Medically prescribed heroin is more cost-effective than methadone for treating long-term street heroin users, according to a new study by researchers at Providence Health Care and the University of British Columbia.
The study, published today in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ), attributed most of the economic benefits to the fact that recipients of medically prescribed heroin (diacetylmorphine) stayed in treatment longer and spent less time in relapse than those receiving methadone. Both results are associated with reduced criminal activity and lower health ...
The diagnosis of localized bladder cancer carries an 80 percent five-year survival rate, but once the cancer spreads, the survival rate at even three years is only 20 percent. A major study published today in the Journal of Clinical Investigation not only shows how bladder cancer metastasizes to the lungs but pinpoints a method for stopping this spread.
Specifically, the study shows that versican, a protein involved in cancer cell migration, is a driver of lung metastasis and that high levels of versican are associated with poor prognosis in bladder cancer patients. The ...
