(Press-News.org) Are members of the public divided about climate change because they don't understand the science behind it? If Americans knew more basic science and were more proficient in technical reasoning, would public consensus match scientific consensus?
A study published today online in the journal Nature Climate Change suggests that the answer to both questions is no. Indeed, as members of the public become more science literate and numerate, the study found, individuals belonging to opposing cultural groups become even more divided on the risks that climate change poses.
Funded by the National Science Foundation, the study was conducted by researchers associated with the Cultural Cognition Project at Yale Law School and involved a nationally representative sample of 1500 U.S. adults.
"The aim of the study was to test two hypotheses," said Dan Kahan, Elizabeth K. Dollard Professor of Law and Professor of Psychology at Yale Law School and a member of the study team. "The first attributes political controversy over climate change to the public's limited ability to comprehend science, and the second, to opposing sets of cultural values. The findings supported the second hypothesis and not the first," he said.
"Cultural cognition" is the term used to describe the process by which individuals' group values shape their perceptions of societal risks. It refers to the unconscious tendency of people to fit evidence of risk to positions that predominate in groups to which they belong. The results of the study were consistent with previous studies that show that individuals with more egalitarian values disagree sharply with individuals who have more individualistic ones on the risks associated with nuclear power, gun possession, and the HPV vaccine for school girls.
In this study, researchers measured "science literacy" with test items developed by the National Science Foundation. They also measured their subjects' "numeracy"—that is, their ability and disposition to understand quantitative information.
"In effect," Kahan said, "ordinary members of the public credit or dismiss scientific information on disputed issues based on whether the information strengthens or weakens their ties to others who share their values. At least among ordinary members of the public, individuals with higher science comprehension are even better at fitting the evidence to their group commitments."
Kahan said that the study supports no inferences about the reasoning of scientific experts in climate change.
Researcher Ellen Peters of Ohio State University said that people who are higher in numeracy and science literacy usually make better decisions in complex technical situations, but the study clearly casts doubt on the notion that the more you understand science and math, the better decisions you'll make in complex and technical situations. "What this study shows is that people with high science and math comprehension can think their way to conclusions that are better for them as individuals but are not necessarily better for society."
According to Kahan, the study suggests the need for science communication strategies that reflect a more sophisticated understanding of cultural values.
"More information can help solve the climate change conflict," Kahan said, "but that information has to do more than communicate the scientific evidence. It also has to create a climate of deliberations in which no group perceives that accepting any piece of evidence is akin to betrayal of their cultural group."
###In addition to Dan Kahan and Ellen Peters, other study researchers were Maggie Wittlin of the Cultural Cognition Project, Paul Slovic of Decision Research, Lisa Larrimore Ouellette of the Cultural Cognition Project, Donald Braman of George Washington University, and Gregory Mandel of Temple University.
Citation: The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks, Nature Climate Change, DOI: 10.1038/NCLIMATE1547.
The Cultural Cognition Project at Yale Law School is an interdisciplinary group of scholars interested in studying how cultural values shape public risk perceptions and related policy beliefs. Previous studies, funded by the National Science Foundation and the Oscar M. Ruebhausen Fund at Yale Law School, have looked at perceptions of environmental and public health risks and of expert scientific consensus on such issues. For more information, visit www.culturalcognition.net.
Yale study concludes public apathy over climate change unrelated to science literacy
2012-05-28
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Reed.co.uk Supports '4G Britain' Campaign
2012-05-28
One of the UKs leading job sites, www.reed.co.uk, is supporting the '4G Britain' campaign encouraging the government to invest in 4G services, pointing out that the new technology could create thousands of jobs in the UK.
The job site is advocating a recent report published by Everything Everywhere, the UKs largest network operator, which suggests 125,000 jobs could be created with sufficient investment in 4G mobile data services.
Everything Everywhere, the company formed after the merging of Orange and T-Mobile phone networks, have been strong proponents of the ...
Computer model pinpoints prime materials for efficient carbon capture
2012-05-28
When power plants begin capturing their carbon emissions to reduce greenhouse gases – and to most in the electric power industry, it's a question of when, not if – it will be an expensive undertaking.
Current technologies would use about one-third of the energy generated by the plants – what's called "parasitic energy" – and, as a result, substantially drive up the price of electricity.
But a new computer model developed by University of California, Berkeley, chemists shows that less expensive technologies are on the horizon. They will use new solid materials like ...
PawnUp.com Online Pawn Shop Makes it Clear: Customer Satisfaction is Our Top Priority
2012-05-28
"Life is full of moments when a need for financial help arises unexpectedly. Some of those moments are not easy by any means. A few weeks ago my grandmother passed away, and, with the void of losing a loved one, came the responsibility of making all the final arrangements for her, in Texas," said Mr. Reynolds.
"We needed to have all funeral expenses covered fast, but it was not very easy for my family financially. After doing my fair share of research online, PawnUp.com looked like the most obvious choice to help us with the money ASAP, and definitely ...
T cells 'hunt' parasites like animal predators seek prey, a Penn Vet-Penn Physics study reveals
2012-05-28
PHILADELPHIA — By pairing an intimate knowledge of immune-system function with a deep understanding of statistical physics, a cross-disciplinary team at the University of Pennsylvania has arrived at a surprising finding: T cells use a movement strategy to track down parasites that is similar to strategies that predators such as monkeys, sharks and blue-fin tuna use to hunt their prey.
With this new insight into immune-cell movement patterns, scientists will be able to create more accurate models of immune-system function, which may, in turn, inform novel approaches ...
'Unzipped' carbon nanotubes could help energize fuel cells and batteries, Stanford scientists say
2012-05-28
Multi-walled carbon nanotubes riddled with defects and impurities on the outside could replace some of the expensive platinum catalysts used in fuel cells and metal-air batteries, according to scientists at Stanford University. Their findings are published in the May 27 online edition of the journal Nature Nanotechnology.
"Platinum is very expensive and thus impractical for large-scale commercialization," said Hongjie Dai, a professor of chemistry at Stanford and co-author of the study. "Developing a low-cost alternative has been a major research goal for several decades."
Over ...
Timing is everything
2012-05-28
At first glance, it's hard to see how a common house sparrow and a Tyrannosaurus Rex might have anything in common. After all, one is a bird that weighs less than an ounce, and the other is a dinosaur that was the size of a school bus and tipped the scales at more than eight tons.
For all their differences, though, scientists now say that two are more closely related than many believed. A new study, led by Harvard scientists, has shown that modern birds are, essentially, living dinosaurs, with skulls that are remarkably similar to those of their juvenile ancestors.
As ...
New Website launches by a group of psychologists, to council and connect with people more conveniently
2012-05-24
Psychological Affiliates, a private practice of psychologists established by Dr. Deborah O. Day in 1988, is proud to announce the launch of their new website. This new website will make it easier for Psychological Affiliates professional consultation services. "There are a growing number of families in need of comprehensive outpatient services for a wide variety of mental health issue," mentioned Dr. Deborah O. Day in an interview.
Psychological Affiliates service provide a way to professionally address a wide variety of issues such as child abuse, play therapy, ...
Morgan Law Group Provides Suits for Women Getting Back To Work
2012-05-24
Darlynn Morgan, and Morgan Law Group of Newport Beach, are pleased to announce their sponsorship of WHW's 2nd annual Suits for a Cause clothing drive. WHW collects men's and women's clothing as well as accessories and provides, at no charge, comprehensive employment support services to empower disadvantaged men, women and teens to achieve economic self-sufficiency through employment success.
"It is amazing what hundreds of lawyers at dozens of law firms can do when they join together to support a charity like WHW." says Janie Wolicki, WHW's Executive Director.
"We ...
3-Day Free Shipping Promo Launched by 'The Question Journey' Author
2012-05-24
Touch lives today with hope and encouragement as Trish Bishop of "The Question Journey" offers a 3-day shipping promo anywhere in North America. A Spiritual Coach, Speaker and Author, Trish Bishop is happy to give back and touch lives in any way from her book called "The Question Journey." This book takes you into a conscious awareness of oneself and deals with the realms of the soul by unlocking the secrets to the journey of truth.
"I'm feeling like I want to touch some lives today - yours, or perhaps someone you love," Trish Bishop said ...
L.U. Simon Builders: A History of Excellence
2012-05-24
In Australia, no other construction company can boast of an outstanding track record like that of L.U. Simon Builders' . Through decades of delivering and completing construction projects of every calibre and sector, L.U. Simon Builders has become one of Australia's most successful construction companies, and an award-winning one at that.
Since its establishment in 1955 by its eponymous founder, L.U. Simon Builders has developed an extensive base of experience, spanning the various commercial, industrial, residential and institutional markets. It has also won numerous ...