(Press-News.org) Montreal, June 13, 2012 – A recent international study led by researchers from McGill University and the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC) examines the complex and controversial interplay of conflicts of interest between physician experts, medicine and the pharmaceutical or medical device industry. The results of the analysis, which are published in the Annals of Internal Medicine, aim to advance the management of conflicts of interest in medical guidelines.
"Over the last decade governments, medical specialty societies and academia have increasingly confronted an ethical dilemma in the development of influential, independent, expert medical guidelines," says lead author, Derek J. Jones of McGill University's Faculty of Law Research Group on Health and the Law.
According to the study, clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) on heart conditions, mental disorders, flu and diabetes have been criticized, questioned or annulled because of Conflicts of Interest (COIs) issues in the US, Canada, France and World Health Organization. "Should physician experts who have, or had, financial relations with industry be included, excluded, or limited from the development of international clinical practice guidelines," Jones asks. "What if their expertise is rare, unique or essential?"
The interdisciplinary project developed and analyzed the impact of an ethics framework designed to manage COIs in an international CPG on gastroenterology. They found the initiative fruitful, if challenging. "Given the absence of uniform COI definitions, procedures or standards in the international arena, we found that an ethics framework helps to identify COIs, ethics issues, and COI management options in the process," explains Jones.
"We further sought to measure the impact of COIs on voting and discussing the CPG recommendations," explained Dr. Alan Barkun, corresponding author of the study and chief of gastroenterology at the MUHC and professor of medicine at McGill. "Our analysis of the COI management tool used revealed little impact on voting recommendations for the guideline and some impact on discussion. These important issues demand further analysis and initiatives."
The study thus recommends targeted research, the use of ethics frameworks, a financing model, and international and institutional policy initiatives to better manage conflicts of interest in the development of future CPGs.
###
About this study:
The study "Conflicts of Interest Ethics: Silencing Expertise in the Development of International Clinical Practice Guidelines" was coauthored by Derek J. Jones, JD; Alan N. Barkun, MDCM, MSc (Clinical Epidemiology); Yidan Lu, MDCM; Robert Enns, MD; Paul Sinclair, MSc; Myriam Martel, BSc; Ian Gralnek, MD; Marc Bardou, MD, PhD; Ernst J. Kuipers, MD; and Joseph Sung, MD, PhD, for the International Consensus Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding Conference Group
This work was supported by funds from the Canadian Association of Gastroenterology; European
Association for Gastroenterology and Endoscopy; Asian Pacific Society of Digestive Endoscopy; and Canadian Institutes of Health Research Institute of Diabetes, Metabolism and Nutrition and arms-length contributions from AstraZeneca Mölndal (Sweden), Abbott Canada, and Olympus Canada. The Canadian Association of Gastroenterology also provided in-kind support and administered the meeting.
Related links:
Cited study:
www.annals.org
McGill University Health Centre (MUHC):
www.muhc.ca
Research Institute of the MUHC (RI MUHC):
www.muhc.ca/research/dashboard
McGill University:
www.mcgill.ca
Ethics framework urged to manage conflicts of interest in medicine
2012-06-14
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New York Medical Malpractice Lawyer from The Perecman Firm Comments on Medical Error Risk Following Death of Kidney Donor
2012-06-14
A New York woman died during a kidney transplant operation she was undergoing. She had wanted to donate the organ to her younger brother, Roberto Medina, the New York Post reported (6/8/2012).
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/bronx/kidney_hope_is_dashed_again_tGenmeWqNyPzTWtry2ywzO?utm_medium=rss&utm_content=Bronx
Yolanda Medina died after her aorta was cut during surgery at Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx, according to the New York Post.
Roberto Medina suffers from renal failure and has been on kidney dialysis since February. He never received his sister's ...
Anxious mice make lousy dads: study
2012-06-14
Normally, male California mice are surprisingly doting fathers, but new research published in the journal Physiological and Biochemical Zoology suggests that high anxiety can turn these good dads bad.
Unlike most rodents, male and female California mice pair up for life with males providing extensive parental care, helping deliver the pups, lick them clean, and keep them warm during their first few weeks of life. Experienced fathers are so paternal that they'll even take care of pups that aren't theirs. "If we place a male California mouse in a test cage and present ...
Normal bacterial makeup has huge implications for health, says CU professor
2012-06-14
For the first time a consortium of researchers organized by the National Institutes of Health, including a University of Colorado Boulder professor, has mapped the normal microbial makeup of healthy humans.
The team made up of 200 researchers from the Human Microbiome Project Consortium, or HMP, and based at 80 research institutions, reports that while nearly everyone carries pathogens -- which are microorganisms that cause illness -- pathogens cause no disease in healthy individuals. Instead, they co-exist with their host and the rest of the human microbiome, which is ...
The Rise in Healthcare Fraud Investigations by Bill Wirskye
2012-06-14
Healthcare fraud has been an investigative priority since the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act established a National Healthcare Fraud and Abuse Control Program to coordinate Federal, State, and Local law enforcement regarding healthcare fraud and abuse in 1996. Since that time, the federal government has recovered over $18 billion for healthcare fraud and abuse. States have also ramped up their enforcement efforts, with Texas recovering $418 million in 2010.
If you are a provider currently under audit or investigation, you should retain an attorney ...
Self-assembling nanocubes for next generation antennas and lenses
2012-06-14
Researchers at the University of California, San Diego Jacobs School of Engineering have developed a technique that enables metallic nanocrystals to self-assemble into larger, complex materials for next-generation antennas and lenses. The metal nanocrystals are cube-shaped and, like bricks or Tetris blocks, spontaneously organize themselves into larger-scale structures with precise orientations relative to one another. Their findings were published online June 10 in the journal Nature Nanotechnology.
This research is in the new field of nanoplasmonics, where researchers ...
Construction Jobs in New York Facing Salary Cuts
2012-06-14
Once again the workers of New York are under attack. The Wall Street Journal reports that the Center for Urban Real Estate at Columbia University has issued a report challenging the minimum salary set by law for construction workers on public projects. The prevailing wage law under attack requires that trade workers on public projects be paid the same wages that union workers receive.
New York is one of the most expensive states in the country to live and work and raise a family. Construction workers, painters and allied tradesman and women, recycling and general industrial ...
No Longer Satisfied With the Terms of Your Divorce? Explore Modification
2012-06-14
A divorce becomes final either through a settlement agreement or a court decision. Yet, even the symbolic conclusiveness of a divorce decree does not mean your divorce terms can never be revisited.
Under Massachusetts law, you may modify your divorce agreement to better reflect the changing circumstances of your life. Obtaining a divorce modification is not always easy, but with the help of the right attorney, you could be well on your way toward fairer child support, child custody, visitation and alimony terms.
Material and Substantial Change in Circumstances Key ...
London researchers discover novel mechanism involved in key immune response
2012-06-14
LONDON, ON – A team of researchers at Lawson Health Research Institute and Western University have identified a novel way that a common virus, called adenovirus, causes disease. In doing so, they have discovered important information on one of the body's key immune responses. Their findings, published today in Cell Host & Microbe, may have implications for infectious diseases and cancer.
Adenovirus infections most often cause mild illnesses of the respiratory system, resulting in runny noses, coughs and sore throats. However, researchers have been interested in adenoviruses ...
Web-based tool helps parents improve on kids' asthma treatment
2012-06-14
SEATTLE: June 13, 2012 — Asthma is the most common chronic illness in adolescents and children, affecting an estimated seven million children up to the age of 17 in the United States. The burden of asthma on children is substantial: kids with asthma have a three-fold greater risk of school absence than children without asthma, and asthma is the third leading cause of hospitalization among children under the age of 15.
Some parents of children with asthma have a tough time complying with treatment guidelines. Numerous surveys report between 40 to 60 percent of kids ...
NightVision Outdoor Lighting Will Take Over Competitors' Atlanta Outdoor Lighting Systems
2012-06-14
If you've been burned by your Atlanta outdoor lighting company, NightVision Outdoor Lighting is here to help. The company is happy to take over any competitor's outdoor lighting system if you are dissatisfied by the competitor's performance.
Many Atlanta homeowners find themselves in the tough position of being unhappy with their Atlanta landscape lighting company but feeling like they can't leave. NightVision Outdoor Lighting wishes to put to bed the idea that only one lighting company can maintain your lighting system.
A significant portion of NightVision's clientele ...