November 02, 2012 (Press-News.org) The United States Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case coming out of Missouri that could very well have implications for police, prosecutors, defense attorneys and motorists all over the country: whether law enforcement agencies have the right to obtain blood samples from those suspected of drunk driving without either the person's consent or a valid warrant.
Vocal Arguments on Both Sides
Criminal defense attorneys and human rights watchdog groups like the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) argue that warrantless blood draws are the very height of government overreaching, violating the sanctity of a person's body without his or her consent. The ACLU points out that more than half of the states - 27 of them, in fact - have policies directly prohibiting the non-consensual taking of blood samples from a suspect without a signed warrant unless "special" or "exigent" circumstances exist.
Law enforcement agencies and prosecutors feel that the rapid rate of alcohol's dissipation in the body is - in and of itself - an exigent circumstance that should allow samples to be forcibly taken if no warrant is present and no consent is given. They view it as an important part of the police's commitment to public safety to gather as much evidence as possible against the roughly 1.4 million drivers charged with driving under the influence (DUI) in America each year.
Public safety advocacy group Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) is also in support of the practice. Some of the most persuasive evidence used to support the practice of warrantless blood draws comes from an unexpected source: the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration (NHTSA). The NHTSA doesn't make an express statement supporting the taking of non-consensual blood samples, but the data they have compiled about drunk driving is persuasive nonetheless. Figures released by the NHTSA reveal that someone is killed in America every 28 minutes because of the actions of a drunk driver.
A Country-Wide Movement?
In spite of the fact that, as the ACLU points out, 27 states have expressly prohibited wholesale warrantless blood draws for DUI/DWI cases, there is still a healthy debate in many jurisdictions across America. Some have chosen to handle the topic of warrantless, involuntary breath or blood testing for the presence of alcohol with so-called "No Refusal" policies. For example, Bexar County, Texas, has had a "No Refusal" policy in place for more than a year now, and it doesn't allow a suspect to avoid giving a breath or blood sample when allegations of drunk driving arise.
The Waiting Game
Given the pace of past Supreme Court decisions, it is likely the matter of warrantless blood draws will not be settled until well into 2013. In the mean time, if you or a loved one has been charged with DUI, you may or may not have a right to refuse (depending on where you are at the time of an arrest) to give a breath or blood sample. You do, however, have the right to consult an attorney, and you should strongly consider doing so in order to better protect your legal rights and options.
Article provided by Law Offices of David P. Schwarz
Visit us at http://www.orangecountycriminaldefenselawfirm.com
U.S. Supreme Court to Take Up Warrantless Blood Draws for DUI Cases
The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether law enforcement agencies can obtain blood samples from those suspected of drunk driving without the person's consent or a valid warrant.
2012-11-02
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Massachusetts Crime Lab Issue Leaves Thousands of Drug Cases in Question
2012-11-02
As expected, the summer of 2012 brought plenty of heat and dry weather to the citizens of Massachusetts. What wasn't expected, however, was the scandal coming out of one of the state's premier law enforcement testing lab facilities.
That scandal is now leaving police and prosecutors in the state scrambling to sift through more than 34,000 closed and pending drug cases to ensure that sufficient evidence aside from the tainted chemical samples exists to keep those convicted behind bars, to release those whose guilt was determined solely upon the strength of the improper ...
Program Provides Deportation Relief for Young Undocumented Immigrants
2012-11-02
In the summer of 2012, President Barack Obama announced a controversial change to U.S. immigration policy designed to indefinitely postpone the deportation of certain undocumented young immigrants who were brought to the U.S. as children. The initiative, known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, also provides an opportunity for young undocumented immigrants to obtain employment authorization, allowing them to work legally in the United States.
Program Targets Those Brought to US as Children
The U.S. Customs and Immigration Service began accepting applications ...
Custody Determinations for Same-Sex Couples in Pennsylvania
2012-11-02
Custody Determinations for Same-Sex Couples in Pennsylvania
One quarter of all same-sex households are raising children, according to the 2010 U.S. census. In Pennsylvania, the number is slightly lower. According to the census, 20 percent of same-sex families are raising children. However, marriage between individuals of the same sex is not recognized in Pennsylvania and a same-sex marriage from another state is void in Pennsylvania.
Many same-sex couples use assisted reproduction and artificial insemination by donor sperm. In these situations, the child is only biologically ...
New Short Sales Rules to Increase Eligibility For Palm Beach Homeowners
2012-11-02
New Short Sales Rules to Increase Eligibility For Palm Beach Homeowners
According to the latest data, the U.S. real estate market remains catastrophic. Foreclosure and underwater mortgages all across the country are, unfortunately, still commonplace. In Palm Beach County Florida alone, roughly 44 percent of homeowners have mortgage loans for more than what their house is worth.
Fortunately, short sales are one avenue borrowers can utilize to help get out from an underwater mortgage or one they can no longer afford to pay. Despite this option, short sales haven't always ...
Foreclosure Filings Down in Utah and Other Non-Judicial States
2012-11-02
Foreclosure Filings Down in Utah and Other Non-Judicial States
In Utah and across much of the United States, recent foreclosure statistics have shown some improvement when compared to this time last year. The states showing improvement, though, appear to be primarily those with non-judicial foreclosure processes. In contrast, many judicial states have actually seen a rise in the number of foreclosure filings in the past months.
Judicial states are those in which courts must approve foreclosures. In many of those states, the foreclosure process slowed dramatically ...
An Overview of Domestic Violence Charges in Washington State
2012-11-02
An Overview of Domestic Violence Charges in Washington State
Washington State law defines domestic violence broadly as almost any criminal act committed by one member of a family or household against another. Thus, domestic violence in Washington may include a wide range of offenses such as:
-Assault
-Harassment
-Destruction of property
-Intimidation with a weapon
-Reckless endangerment
-Violation of a protection order
For purposes of Washington domestic violence law, anyone in the following relationships may be considered members of the same family or ...
Patricia Gerbarg, MD and Richard P. Brown MD, Teach Mind-Body Practices at Yoga and Mental Health Conference in London, England
2012-11-02
Patricia Gerbarg, MD and Richard P. Brown, MD, award-winning authors and leaders in Complementary and Alternative Medicine for psychiatry, will teach "The Language of Breath: How Respiratory Messages Improve Emotion Regulation" November 2-4, 2012 at Confer UK, an international conference which brings the world's leading researchers and healthcare practitioners together to explore how yoga can be used in a therapeutic context. The gathering will be held at The Brunei Gallery, SOAS, University of London, Thornbaugh Street, London, WC1H 0XG.
As keynote speakers, ...
Tech Start-Up, Upperatus, Helps Heal the Bay One Shirt at a Time
2012-11-02
Well-known non-profit, Heal the Bay, is gearing up for a big splash in November. Upperatus and site users help spread the campaign message, while Dan McCauley provided the limited-edition design. Each month, Upperatus plans on connecting a graphic artist with an important, charitable cause to develop limited-edition shirt designs which will directly impact the cause's operations.
In November, Upperatus will donate $11 per item sold to Heal the Bay through their website which focuses on awareness apparel for women and men. Nina Borin, Heal the Bay's Development Manager ...
Popular Pastor & Author Bill Winston Celebrates First Stellar Award Nomination For Church Choir's Debut CD, Released
2012-11-02
Pastor Bill Winston has empowered the Christian community with enlightening and life-changing sermons for years now. The pastor of Chicago's 20,000-member Living Word Christian Center is also known for his insightful books like the Law of Confession and Transform Your Thinking. Now the renowned Pastor and his church choir are being recognized for accomplishments in the Gospel music industry.
The church's first project, Bill Winston Presents Living Word: Released, featuring the talents of church members and award-winning artists such as Donald Lawrence, Kim Stratton and ...
D&J Sports Swim Backpacks Available for Christmas
2012-11-02
D&J Sports is pleased to announce they carry some of the top swim backpacks for swimmers on all experience levels. With Christmas quickly approaching, it can sometimes be difficult for some people to find the perfect gifts for the people in their lives. Anyone who is looking for the perfect gift for the swimmer in their lives can find swim backpacks from some of the top names in swimming, including Speedo, TYR, Swim Stuff and Arena.
Each of these swim backpacks provides ample storage room for everything a swimmer needs to take with him to the pool. While all swim ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Study confirms that people with ADHD can be more creative. The reason may be that they let their mind wander
Research gives insight into effect of neurodegenerative diseases on speech rhythm
Biochar and plants join forces to clean up polluted soils and boost ecosystem recovery
Salk scientist Joseph Ecker awarded McClintock Prize for Plant Genetics and Genome Studies
ADHD: Women are diagnosed five years later than men, despite symptoms appearing at the same age.
Power plants may emit more pollution during government shutdowns
Increasing pressures for conformity de-skilling and demotivating teachers, study warns
Researchers develop smarter menstrual product with potential for wearable health monitoring
Microwaves for energy-efficient chemical reactions
MXene current collectors could reduce size, improve recyclability of Li-ion batteries
Living near toxic sites linked to aggressive breast cancer
New discovery could open door to male birth control
Wirth elected Fellow of American Physical Society
The Journal of Nuclear Medicine Ahead-of-Print Tip Sheet: October 10, 2025
Destined to melt
Attitudes, not income, drive energy savings at home
The playbook for perfect polaritons
‘Disease in a dish’ study of progressive MS finds critical role for unusual type of brain cell
Solar-powered method lights the way to a ‘de-fossilized’ chemical industry
Screen time linked to lower academic achievement among Ontario elementary students
One-year outcomes after traumatic brain injury and early extracranial surgery in the TRACK-TBI Study
Enduring outcomes of COVID-19 work absences on the US labor market
Affirmative action repeal and racial and ethnic diversity in us medical school admissions
Cancer progression illuminated by new multi-omics tool
Screen time and standardized academic achievement tests in elementary school
GLP-1RA order fills and out-of-pocket costs by race, ethnicity, and indication
Study finds HEPA purifiers alone may not be enough to reduce viral exposure in schools
UVA Health developing way to ID people at risk of dangerous lung scarring even before symptoms appear
How can we know when curing cancer causes myocarditis?
Male infertility in Indian men linked to lifestyle choices and hormonal imbalances
[Press-News.org] U.S. Supreme Court to Take Up Warrantless Blood Draws for DUI CasesThe U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether law enforcement agencies can obtain blood samples from those suspected of drunk driving without the person's consent or a valid warrant.