(Press-News.org) Economists and professionals praise the merits of competition, as it leads to lower prices and improvements in quality. But in the automobile smog-testing industry, competition can lead to corruption and even public health problems, according to research by USC Marshall School of Business Assistant Professor of Management Victor Bennett.
Bennett, along with colleagues Lamar Pierce of Washington University's Olin School of Business, Jason Snyder at the UCLA Anderson School of Management and Michael W. Toffel of Harvard Business School, found that the structure of the smog-testing industry can lead some firms to cheat on their customers' smog-check results And this cheating takes place because it can actually lead to better customer relationships. The findings are outlined in "Customer-driven Misconduct: How Competition Corrupts Business Practices," which will appear in a forthcoming issue of Management Science. The study found that:
Smog check firms that were clustered among other competing smog-check firms were more likely to be lenient, ensuring that customer cars passed when they should have failed.
Firms that were new to the business also were more likely to pass cars that likely should have failed.
In New York State alone, these practices could have passed 39,000 cars that should have failed.
"There's a strong sentiment that competition is a positive thing," Bennett said. "It makes firms more efficient, makes service quality and products better, and drives down prices. But it works through giving customers what they want, and sometimes doing so is bad for others."
The research looked at 28 million emissions tests from 11,000 smog check facilities in New York. Smog check firms that faced more local competitors gave cars a passing grade at higher rates than firms that enjoyed less competition. The researchers' findings suggest that competing firms passed more cars because they were afraid if they failed a customer's car, that customer would get it tested somewhere else.
One problem leading to potentially illicit competition is the way the smog-check industry is regulated, the study shows. In New York State, smog-testing facilities must charge $27 for tests in the New York City area, and $11 in the rest of the state. Since these prices are fixed for all firms, "facilities must compete on quality," the researchers wrote. "In emissions testing, the critical dimension of quality is the test outcome." By passing customers illegally, the emissions testing firm provides what the customer perceives as quality service. If they don't pass the customer's car, the customer goes to a firm that will, researchers wrote.
Falsely passing cars has consequences beyond economic corruption. Carbon monoxide, a common tailpipe emission, can ultimately block the healthy transport of oxygen into our cells and tissues, while emitted carbon compounds and nitrogen oxides produce ozone, which can accelerate respiratory problems. Smog testing has been a major weapon against this type of air pollution produced by motor vehicles.
"In New York, our results suggest that 1 of every 100 cars tested that should fail, pass instead," said Bennett. "We can't specify exactly how many cases are due to manipulated passing, but the study ties competition to illicit quality. This brings front and center the trade-off between the benefits of competition and the costs."
Bennett is now hoping to look at the effects of crackdowns on facilities by government regulators, and whether such action yields any real results in the industry.
### END
When good service means bad behavior
Competition in smog-test industry can lead to corruption, USC Marshall study finds
2012-11-29
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Study reinforces safety of whooping cough vaccine for older adults
2012-11-29
PASADENA, Calif., Nov. 29, 2012 – Immunizing older adults with the tetanus-diphtheria-acellular-pertussis vaccine (Tdap) to prevent pertussis (more commonly referred to as whooping cough) was found to be as safe as immunizing them with the tetanus and diphtheria (Td) vaccine, according to a study by Kaiser Permanente published in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases.
Researchers examined the electronic health records of nearly 120,000 people ages 65 and older at seven U.S. health systems between Jan. 1, 2006 and Dec. 31, 2010. The study looked at a number of medical ...
A new anti-windup design paradigm for control systems with actuator saturation was developed
2012-11-29
Actuator saturation is ubiquitous in engineering systems. Anti-windup approach to dealing with actuator saturation has been receiving considerable attention from both the industry and the academic community during the past decades. Professor Zongli Lin and his student Xiongjun Wu developed a new anti-windup design paradigm that is capable of achieving significantly improved performances of the resulting closed-loop system. Their work, entitled "Design of multiple anti-windup loops for multiple activations," was published in SCIENCE CHINA Information Sciences, 55(9), 2012. ...
Method for accurate extraction of a target profile developed at Beijing Institute of Technology
2012-11-29
The detection and recognition of an object with small RCS, such as a stealth target, is the most difficult problem to solve for the modern radar system. Professor Hu Cheng and his group at Radar Research Lab, Beijing Institute of Technology set out to tackle this problem. After seven years of innovative research, they have developed a series of methods to detect, track and recognize some targets with small RCS. In particular, they proposed a novel imaging method based on the principle of shadow inverse synthetic aperture radar (SISAR) to extract the target profile accurately ...
Technology use in the classroom helps autistic children communicate
2012-11-29
The use of technology in the classroom is nothing new, but Topcliffe Primary School in Birmingham is breaking new ground by using technology to help pupils with autism communicate more effectively.
The school, which teaches around 30 children with various levels of autism, was one of four schools across UK, which participated in the ECHOES research project, jointly funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) and the Engineering and Physical Science Research Council (EPSRC) from universities across the UK to explore how technology can make a difference in ...
Scientific advice to ensure the sustainability of shark populations in Ocean waters
2012-11-29
Together with the Basque R+D centre's researchers, the group of advisers is made up of researchers from the Spanish Institute of Oceanography (IEO), the French Institute for Exploration of the Sea (IFREMER), the French Institute for Research for Development (IRD),and the Portuguese Institute for Fisheries and Sea Research (IPIMAR).This work comes within the 'European Community's Action Plan on Sharks' which has funding from the European Commission's Directorate-General for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, and is set to take 15 months.
Shark are caught with fishing gear ...
Next-generation treatments for Fragile X syndrome
2012-11-29
Philadelphia, PA, November 29, 2012 – A potential new therapeutic strategy for treating Fragile X syndrome is detailed in a new report appearing in the current issue of Biological Psychiatry, from researchers led by Dr. Lucia Ciranna at University of Catania in Italy.
Fragile X syndrome (FXS), the most common heritable form of autism and intellectual disability, is one of the most exciting areas in brain research at the moment.
A decade ago, Dr. Mark Bear and his colleagues discovered that an animal model for FXS was associated with a distinctive alteration in brain ...
Researchers create a fly to study how a normal cell turns cancerous
2012-11-29
The wing of a fruit fly may hold the key to unraveling the genetic and molecular events that transform a normal cell into a cancerous one. The study, conducted on Drosophila melanogaster by scientists at the Institute for Research in Biomedicine (IRB Barcelona) and led by ICREA researcher Marco Milán, has reproduced each of the steps known to take place when a healthy cell turns cancerous. The researchers have thus provided an inexpensive and effective model that will allow the scientific community to scrutinize the genes and molecules involved in each step. Given that ...
Homicide spreads like infectious disease
2012-11-29
EAST LANSING, Mich. — Homicide moves through a city in a process similar to infectious disease, according to a new study that may give police a new tool in tracking and ultimately preventing murders.
Using Newark, N.J., as a pilot case, a team of Michigan State University researchers led by April Zeoli successfully applied public health tracking methods to the city's 2,366 homicides between 1982 and 2008. They found the killings were not randomly located but instead followed a pattern, evolving from the city's center and moving southward and westward over time.
Like ...
Cancer drug shows promise in eradicating latent HIV infection
2012-11-29
Bethesda, MD—Breakthrough drugs have made it possible for people to live with HIV longer than ever before, but more work must be done to actually cure the disease. One of the challenges researchers face involves fully eradicating the virus when it is latent in the body. A new report appearing in the December 2012 issue of the Journal of Leukocyte Biology suggests that a cancer drug, called JQ1, may be useful in purging latent HIV infection by activating the virus in the presence of potent therapy – essentially a dead end for the virus.
"This drug may be useful as adjunctive ...
Travels in northeastern Brazil: Unfolding the reptile fauna of Lençóis Maranhenses
2012-11-29
In order to be effective, a Conservation Unit must have available a list of the species that live within it. They also should have detailed information about the distribution of species among the available habitats. It would be difficult to correctly plan the conservation actions and/or monitoring programs without some minimal knowledge about the species (who are the object of those measures). "This is why our study is so important to the park", said Dr. Miranda from Universidade Federal do Maranhão (CCAA/UFMA), leading author of the article, published in the open access ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Heart rate changes predict depression treatment success with magnetic brain stimulation
Genetics pioneer transforms global depression research through multi-omics discoveries
MDMA psychiatric applications synthesized: Comprehensive review examines PTSD treatment and emerging therapeutic indications
Psychedelics offer new therapeutic framework for stress-related psychiatric disorders
Brain cell discoveries reshape understanding of psychiatric disorders
Mom’s voice boosts language-center development in preemies’ brains, study finds
Development of silicon ultrasound patch achieves both eco-friendliness and performance enhancement
Measles immunity 90% in BC’s Lower Mainland
Women’s brain regions may lose ability to synchronize after sexual assault
Quitting smoking, even late in life, linked to slower cognitive decline
Critical raw materials are a vital new currency; Europe’s e-waste is the vault
Anesthesiologist-led care helps hip-fracture patients get to surgery faster, with fewer complications
Two-dose recombinant shingles vaccine is effective even accounting for prior receipt of live shingles vaccine
Excessive daytime sleepiness may raise risk of cognitive problems after surgery
Flipping the switch on sperm motility offers new hope for male infertility
Twisting sound: Scientists discover a new way to control mechanical vibrations in metamaterial
Drip by drip: The hidden blueprint for stalagmite growth
mRNA therapy restores sperm production and fertility in mice
New way to weaken cancer cells could supercharge prostate cancer treatment
How sound—but not touch—shapes rhythm in the brain
Exploring the therapeutic potential of hypothermia
Research alert: Bioengineering breathes new life into failed cancer treatment
AI, health, and health care today and tomorrow – the JAMA Summit Report on artificial intelligence
Large genetic study links cannabis use to psychiatric, cognitive and physical health
Social media use trajectories and cognitive performance in adolescents
Music for the brain: Study tests the effect of slow-tempo relaxing music to address delirium in critically ill older adults
AI models predict sepsis in children, allow preemptive care
Liraglutide vs semaglutide vs dulaglutide in veterans with type 2 diabetes
Antenatal corticosteroids and infectious diseases throughout childhood
New lab-grown human embryo model produces blood cells
[Press-News.org] When good service means bad behaviorCompetition in smog-test industry can lead to corruption, USC Marshall study finds