PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

What We Do Does Not Matter. Anymore.

The new position of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists on Electronic Fetal Monitoring.

2010-10-20
October 20, 2010 (Press-News.org) In 2009, approximately 3.9 million fetuses were assessed with electronic fetal monitoring (EFM). EFM is, by far, the most common obstetric procedure in the United States. In fact, it is considered the standard of care to utilize EFM for the assessment of fetal heart rate patterns and uterine activity during labor.

Hospitals in the United States spend millions of dollars annually to purchase the latest technology in EFM equipment and to train their nurses on the use of EFM's. The reason so much time and money is spent on EFM equipment and training on its use is because it is currently the most reliable and sensitive screening tool available for damaging intrauterine fetal asphyxia.

In July 2009, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) came out with ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 106 entitled: Intrapartum Fetal Heat Rate Monitoring: Nomenclature, Interpretation, and General Management Principles. Instead of providing guidance and clarifying the issues relative to EFM interpretation and management, ACOG only further muddied the waters on one of the most important procedures in obstetrics. All one has to do is look back in time to the first pronouncement by ACOG on EFM guidelines in 1975 and follow their ongoing emasculation of EFM interpretation and management principles to see how they have rendered this important screening device almost meaningless.

In June 1975 ACOG issued its first set of guidelines for EFM contained in Technical Bulletin Number 32 entitled "Fetal Heart Rate Monitoring". With respect to intrapartum evaluation, ACOG stated as follow:

"The intrapartum period, with repeated stresses secondary to uterine contractions, poses a potential threat to every fetus. Fortunately, fetal tolerance or reserve is usually adequate to withstand the rigors of labor and the fetus emerges from its intrauterine state apparently unscathed. However, the exceptions of intrapartum death and depressed or damaged newborns are not infrequent. Fetal monitoring is now commonly used to identify and hopefully prevent these undesirable outcomes.

The clinical management of labor is frequently guided or altered by the observations of fetal heart rate and uterine activity data. The evoked fetal response in terms of FHR to the stresses of labor is the fundamental principle on which current understanding and management is based. Abnormal FHR observations, i.e. patterns, smoothness, can be associated with fetal acidosis and neonatal depression. Fortunately, when abnormal fetal responses are encountered, therapeutic steps can usually be taken to correct the problem."

Technical Bulletin number 32 did not ignore the purpose for which EFM was intended; that is to make management decisions based on the evoked fetal responses to the stresses of labor as observed on the EFM strip and intervention to prevent fetal death, neonatal depression and fetal damage.

In September 1989, ACOG replaced Technical Bulletin number 32 with number 132 which was simply entitled, "Intrapartum Fetal Heart Rate Monitoring". Recognizing that intervention is the key to prevention, ACOG acknowledged that: "The goal of inrapartum fetal heart rate monitoring is the detection of signs that warn of potential adverse events in time to permit intervention." Specific FHR patterns associated with fetal compromise were discussed as well as interventions to alleviate those patterns. However, ACOG did acknowledge that if such measures were not effective, "preparations should be made for prompt delivery by the most expeditious route..." Again, ACOG acknowledged that EFM allows the clinician to assess the fetal state relative to hypoxia and acidosis and make management decisions in time to prevent the known adverse outcomes associated with fetal hypoxia and acidosis.

In July 1995 ACOG replaced Technical Bulletin number 132 with number 207 which was entitled: "Fetal Heart Rate Patterns: Monitoring, Interpretation, and Management". Again, ACOG continued to recognize the association between intervention and prevention. In that regard Technical Bulletin number 207 states: "Intrapartum fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring can help the physician identify and interpret changes if FHR patterns that may be associated with such fetal conditions as hypoxia, umbilical cord compression, tachycardia, and acidosis." ACOG recognized that the ability to interpret FHR patterns and understand their correlation to fetal conditions allows the clinician to institute management techniques including prompt delivery by the most expeditious route.

Up to this point, ACOG gave credence to the physiologic basis for EFM by recognizing that alterations in the fetoplacental unit resulting from labor or intrapartum complications can subject the fetus to decreased oxygenation, leading to potential damage to any organ system or even fetal death. The scientific basis upon which the EFM was developed was to allow the clinician to answer the following question: "At the present time what is the condition of the fetus?" That is the most relevant question for any one making management decisions based on the data provided by the EFM.

There is an old saying that goes something like this: If you get them to ask the wrong questions, you don't have to worry about the answers. ACOG adopted that philosophy in 2005 with Practice Bulletin Number 62 entitled "Intrapartum Fetal Heart Rate Monitoring" which replaced Technical Bulletin Number 207 from 1995.

ACOG simply changed the focus of their inquiry from helping pregnant women and their unborn babies to protecting their members from lawsuits. ACOG is no longer asking how to most effectively use EFM to help prevent adverse outcomes associated with fetal hypoxia and asphyxia. Instead, the question asked in Practice Bulletin Number 62 is: How good is EFM in predicting the outcome of cerebral palsy?

In response to the irrelevant question, ACOG responded as follows: "There is an unrealistic expectation that a nonreassuring FHR tracing is predictive of cerebral palsy. The positive predictive value of a nonreassuring pattern to predict cerebral palsy among singleton newborns....is 0.14%, meaning that out of 1,000 fetuses with a nonreassuring FHR pattern, only one or two will develop cerebral palsy."

This statement and the conclusions and recommendations in Practice Bulletin 62 constitute a collection of red herons. It was never the intention EFM to predict the occurrence of cerebral palsy. It was designed to prevent it. But ACOG asked the wrong questions and gave self-serving answers.

In July 2009, ACOG dramatically changed the rules that apply to EFM. ACOG took license from the NICHD (National Institute of Child Health and Human Development) Workshop Report on Electronic Fetal Monitoring. Over the course of two only, days the "experts" that made up the workshop decided to abandon the nomenclature for EFM that has been universally recognized and taught to obstetricians and nurses for decades. Today, EFM patterns are described as "Category I, Category II or Category III". These terms were chosen out of the "significant concerns" for the "medical-legal implications" they would have for obstetricians.

The new ACOG guidelines for EFM have been widely criticized by obstetricians and labor and delivery nurses as being dangerously over broad and ambiguous. No longer does ACOG recommend preparations for prompt delivery by the most expeditious means when the FHR pattern suggests the potential for fetal compromise. Instead, the new ACOG guidelines recommend that clinicians watch ominous FRH patterns and wait until there is the need for emergent cesarean section in order to rescue the fetus from damage or death.

The new guidelines put mothers and their unborn babies at unnecessary risk. There is solid scientific evidence that certain FHR patterns are associated with significant fetal academia. The new guidelines allow obstetricians and labor and delivery nurses to not only push fetuses to the edge of the cliff, but allow them to push them off the cliff and hope that someone catches them before they hit the ground. There can be little doubt the babies will be harmed by the EFM guidelines adopted by ACOG. When that happens, hopefully, someone will take them to task.

Source: Lancione & Lancione, PLL
Website: Cleveland Birth Injury Attorneys (www.lancionelaw.com)


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Atlanta Moving Company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Move To New Location

Atlanta Moving Company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage Move To New Location
2010-10-20
Atlanta moving company Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage has moved its headquarters. The Atlanta movers are now located in a larger office space in Norcross, GA. The move to the new location has not disrupted the company's Atlanta moving service in any way. On the contrary, the larger warehouse has allowed the Atlanta movers to better serve their moving and storage customers. "We have been contemplating this move for some time," explains Sharon Brown, an Atlanta moving consultant at Coast 2 Coast Moving & Storage. "Business has been thriving, and we had outgrown our ...

House of Fraser Launches New Winter 2010 Shoes Collection Online

2010-10-20
House of Fraser, the premium department store, has launched its winter 2010 footwear collection by Kurt Geiger group online. The Kurt Geiger Group offers affordable luxury shoes on the House of Fraser website. Customers can shop online to purchase this season's on-trend shoes from Kurt Geiger, KG by Kurt Geiger and Carvela. They offer the latest fashion and a variety of shoe collections inspired by the latest catwalk trends. Kurt Geiger's winter footwear collection focuses on three main trends. 'And God Created Woman!' celebrates all that is startlingly stunning ...

npower Treats its Customers to Free Electricity Monitors this Halloween

2010-10-20
npower is treating its customers this Halloween with the offer of a free home electricity monitor for any existing customer signing up for paperless billing. What's more, households with a home electricity monitor, which provide a 'real time display' of the amount of electricity being used at any given time, are proven to reduce their energy consumption by up to 15%* in their first year of use. The limited npower smartpower offer will run in conjunction with its Revenge of the Killer Watts advert, starring Wallace & Gromit, which is back on screens again. The ...

Kuoni Launches Latest Caribbean Brochure

2010-10-20
Kuoni has launched its latest brochure for Caribbean holidays, with pages full of information on the laid-back and beautiful islands of the region, offering magnificent beaches and underwater paradise for divers. Summing up the new brochure, Sarah Jackson, Market Manager for the Caribbean at Kuoni, said: "Our new Caribbean and Mexico holidays brochure is bigger, brighter and full of great Kuoni Exclusives such as free nights throughout the islands, room upgrades, early booking discounts and fabulous new hotels and destinations." Cancun is included in the brochure ...

Russell Jones & Walker Solicitors Represents Ten Families at 7/7 Bombings Inquest

2010-10-20
Russell Jones & Walker Solicitors is representing ten families of victims of the 7/7 London bombings at the ongoing inquest into the incidents, which began on 14th October 2010. The independent Coroner's Inquests into the London Bombings of 7 July 2005, which will be overseen by the Right Honourable Lady Justice Hallett D.B.E., will examine the details of the case and the lead up to the bombings on 7th July 2005 and have been welcomed by the victims' families, who continue to seek answers about the terrorist attacks more than five years later. 52 civilians were killed ...

Bestweddingaway Launches Tuscany Weddings

2010-10-20
Bestweddingaway launches new destination Mood to provide clients the opportunity to get married in Tuscany. Tuscany has been a popular tourist spot for centuries with the aristocracy using it as their playground and writers and artists taking inspiration for their next work of art. In fact the beautiful countryside and historic architecture is still popular with modern-day celebrities, with many famous people like musician Sting, best-selling writer Frances Mayes and 'Goodfellas' star Debi Mazar making Tuscany their home. With an undeniable attraction to both Italians ...

RealMoneyOnlineCraps.com Launches Complete Craps Guide

2010-10-20
Over the years, casino craps has always been a fan favorite, appealing to gambling enthusiasts all over the world. As new generations arise, the need for a comprehensive guide to playing real money craps becomes more prevalent. Alleviating the requisite is RealMoneyOnlineCraps.com who has proudly announced the launch of its latest web site. The new site presents a wealth of resources devoted to all things relevant to playing real money online craps. To start things off, visitors will find an inclusive craps rules section that teaches new players how to play craps. ...

Tom Dreesen to Lead the Hosting Team of 'Allstate GLORY DAYS', the Official '85 Bears Reunion

2010-10-20
The official Allstate GLORY DAYS 25th Anniversary Reunion show will be hosted by comedian and entertainer Tom Dreesen. The 1985 Chicago Bears Super Bowl Championship winning team are reuniting for one night only to celebrate Chicago's Super Bowl XX win at the Arie Crown Theater on November 5th. The evening will be a mixture of storytelling and entertainment as the legends relive their glory days, as Coach Ditka puts it, "It's like a roast, only BIGGER!" Dreesen will be the Master of Ceremonies and host for the show, keeping the laughs coming throughout the evening. ...

Corcentric Announces New Webinar on How to Build a Case to Your CFO for Accounts Payable Automation

Corcentric Announces New Webinar on How to Build a Case to Your CFO for Accounts Payable Automation
2010-10-20
Corcentric, a leading provider of accounts payable automation solutions, today announced a new live Webinar: How to Sell Accounts Payable Automation to Your CFO. The 45-minute Webinar, which is the second in a series of educational Webinars about AP automation, will take place on Thursday, October 28th at 2:00 PM EDT. Rob DeVincent, Vice President of Product Marketing for Corcentric, is the Webinar's featured speaker. He will discuss the following topics, which can help build the case for automating invoicing processes: - Why you'll need more than ROI to get your ...

Offshore Group President Encourages Investors to Attend National Industry Conference

2010-10-20
Mexico's National Maquiladora Industry Association (CNIME) will hold its annual convention in the city of Merida, Yucatan from October 27-30th. The group is Mexico's foremost advocate for issues affecting Mexico's vibrant manufacturing sector and foreign investment before the Mexico's national government. Some of the topics to be addressed during the convention will include: - Best practices in the Development of Human Capital; - National and Global Perspectives - Securing the Supply Chain - The Economy in a Post Recession Context According to Luis Felipe Seldner, ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Researchers show complex relationship between Arctic warming and Arctic dust

Brain test shows that crabs process pain

Social fish with low status are so stressed out it impacts their brains

Predicting the weather: New meteorology estimation method aids building efficiency

Inside the ‘swat team’ – how insects react to virtual reality gaming 

Oil spill still contaminating sensitive Mauritius mangroves three years on

Unmasking the voices of experience in healthcare studies

Pandemic raised food, housing insecurity in Oregon despite surge in spending

OU College of Medicine professor earns prestigious pancreatology award

Sub-Saharan Africa leads global HIV decline: Progress made but UNAIDS 2030 goals hang in balance, new IHME study finds

Popular diabetes and obesity drugs also protect kidneys, study shows

Stevens INI receives funding to expand research on the neural underpinnings of bipolar disorder

Protecting nature can safeguard cities from floods

NCSA receives honors in 2024 HPCwire Readers’ and Editors’ Choice Awards

Warning: Don’t miss Thanksgiving dinner, it’s more meaningful than you think

Expanding HPV vaccination to all adults aged 27-45 years unlikely to be cost-effective or efficient for HPV-related cancer prevention

Trauma care and mental health interventions training help family physicians prepare for times of war

Adapted nominal group technique effectively builds consensus on health care priorities for older adults

Single-visit first-trimester care with point-of-care ultrasound cuts emergency visits by 81% for non-miscarrying patients

Study reveals impact of trauma on health care professionals in Israel following 2023 terror attack

Primary care settings face barriers to screening for early detection of cognitive impairment

November/December Annals of Family Medicine Tip Sheet

Antibiotics initiated for suspected community-acquired pneumonia even when chest radiography results are negative

COVID-19 stay-at-home order increased reporting of food, housing, and other health-related social needs in Oregon

UW-led research links wildfire smoke exposure with increased dementia risk

Most U.S. adults surveyed trust store-bought turkey is free of contaminants, despite research finding fecal bacteria in ground turkey

New therapy from UI Health offers FDA-approved treatment option for brittle type 1 diabetes

Alzheimer's: A new strategy to prevent neurodegeneration

A clue to what lies beneath the bland surfaces of Uranus and Neptune

Researchers uncover what makes large numbers of “squishy” grains start flowing

[Press-News.org] What We Do Does Not Matter. Anymore.
The new position of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists on Electronic Fetal Monitoring.