PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

'Default' options influence patient choices in advance care directives, Penn study shows

2013-02-05
(Press-News.org) PHILADELPHIA – Advance care directives allow patients to provide instructions about their preferences for the care they would like to receive if they develop an illness or a life-threatening injury and lose the capacity to make decisions for themselves. While many people may assume that patients have strong preferences for the type and aggressiveness of care they wish to receive near life's end, a new study by researchers at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania suggests that for many patients, preferences for end-of-life care are constructed on the spot and heavily influenced by the ways in which the options are presented. Specifically, the investigators found that even when it comes to such seemingly personal decisions as end-of-life care, people tend to accept options that are presented as the default, much as they accept the default in choosing automobile insurance or whether to contribute to 401(k) programs. The research is published in the February 2013 issue of Health Affairs.

"We found that default options have large influences on the care patients choose near the ends of their lives," said Scott D. Halpern, MD, PhD, MBE, assistant professor of Medicine, Epidemiology, and Medical Ethics and Health Policy, and director of the Fostering Improvement in End-of-Life Decision Science (FIELDS) Program at Penn. "Although this result will be surprising to many, it makes a lot of sense on closer inspection – how could we expect patients to have deep-seated preferences about choices that are rarely encountered, difficult to contemplate, and about which we do not get feedback as to whether previous, similar, choices did or did not promote our broader goals?"

Halpern said that despite national policies and laws promoting the use of advance care directives, there has never before been a study comparing different types of advance directives. As a result, clinicians have no way of knowing what type of directives to recommend for patients to help them make and document these difficult decisions. To explore how patients make these decisions, the researchers randomly assigned 132 seriously ill patients with life expectancies of two years or fewer to complete one of three types of advance directives. Two types had end-of-life care options already checked on the form — resulting in a "default" choice—but one of these prioritized care focused on comfort, and the other, care focused on extending life by all means possible. The third type was a standard advance directive with no options pre-selected. On each form, patients could easily choose from among all possible options.

The research team found that overall, most of these seriously ill patients preferred comfort-oriented care, but the default options influenced those choices dramatically. For example, 77 percent of patients in the comfort-oriented default group chose an overall plan of care that prioritized comfort, while 43 percent of those in the life-extending default group rejected that default and selected comfort-oriented care instead. Among the standard advance directive group with no option already selected, 61 percent of patients selected comfort-oriented care. The authors found similarly large influences of default options on patients' desires to receive feeding tubes, mechanical ventilation, dialysis, or admission to an intensive care unit.

The researchers note that what makes the findings eye-opening is that these large differences were not due to patients just failing to recognize the default. Instead, after patients completed their directives and had them signed by a witness, the team called patients, helped them focus on the default option used (or not used) in their assigned directive, and asked them if they would like to change any of their choices. Only after patients had the opportunity to change their stated preferences did the directives become parts of the patients' medical records. The researchers found that none of these patients changed their original selections about their preferred care plans. Furthermore, patients in all groups expressed equally high satisfaction with their advance care planning, suggesting that patients were content to be guided in making such decisions.

"This study strongly suggests that many patients do not hold deep-seated preferences regarding their end-of-life care," said Halpern. "However, the study does not yet tell us whether we should use advance directives with default options in clinical practice. Instead, this work provides motivation for future research examining whether using default options in advance directives may improve important outcomes, including patients' receipt of wanted and unwanted services, resource use, survival, and quality of life."

### Other study authors from Penn include Kevin G. Volpp, MD, PhD, Elizabeth Cooney, MPH, Caroline M. Quill, MD, Mary S. Mckenzie, MD, Michael O. Harhay, MPH, and Nicole B. Gabler, PhD, MHA.

The research was supported by grants from the Greenwall Foundation, Kornfeld Foundation, Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics at the University of Pennsylvania, and Center for Excellence in Cancer Communication Research of the Universities of Michigan and Pennsylvania. The FIELDS program, which is part of the Leonard Davis Institute's Center for Health Incentives and Behavioral Economics, is supported by the Haas Family Charitable Trust.


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Experimental therapy crosses blood-brain barrier to treat neurological disease

2013-02-05
CINCINNATI – Researchers have overcome a major challenge to treating brain diseases by engineering an experimental molecular therapy that crosses the blood-brain barrier to reverse neurological lysosomal storage disease in mice. Posted online in PNAS Early Edition on Feb. 4, the study was led by scientists at Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center. "This study provides a non-invasive procedure that targets the blood-brain barrier and delivers large-molecule therapeutic agents to treat neurological lysosomal storage disorders," said Dao Pan, PhD, principal investigator ...

Body language can predict outcomes for recovering alcoholics

2013-02-05
To predict whether a problem drinker will hit the bottle again, ignore what they say and watch their body language for displays of shame, a University of British Columbia study finds. The study, which explored drinking and health outcomes in newly sober recovering alcoholics, is the first to show that physical manifestations of shame – from slumped shoulders to narrow chests – can directly predict a relapse in people who struggle with substances. "Our study finds that how much shame people display can strongly predict not only whether they will go on to relapse, but ...

20 hours of TV a week almost halves sperm count

2013-02-05
Healthy young men who watch TV for more than 20 hours a week have almost half the sperm count of men who watch very little TV, indicates a study published online in the British Journal of Sports Medicine. Conversely, men who do 15 or more hours of moderate to vigorous exercise every week have sperm counts that are 73% higher than those who exercise little, the findings show. Semen quality seems to have deteriorated over the past few decades, although it's not clear why, say the authors. To find out if an increasingly sedentary lifestyle might be a contributory ...

The last Neanderthals of southern Iberia did not coexist with modern humans

The last Neanderthals of southern Iberia did not coexist with modern humans
2013-02-05
The theory that the last Neanderthals –Homo neanderthalensis– persisted in southern Iberia at the same time that modern humans –Homo sapiens– advanced in the northern part of the peninsula, has been widely accepted by the scientific community during the last twenty years. An international study, in which researchers of the Spanish National Distance Education University (UNED) participate, questions this hypothesis. "It is improbable that the last Neanderthals of central and southern Iberia would have persisted until such a late date, approximately 30,000 years ago, as ...

Mutations in ASXL3 cause problems similar to Bohring-Opitz syndrome

2013-02-05
Mutations which affect the gene ASXL3 cause a novel syndrome similar to Bohring-Opitz syndrome, finds a study published in BioMed Central's open access journal Genome Medicine. This molecular definition distinguishes these children from those with Bohring-Opitz, and other similar syndromes, and highlights a technique able to help define rare diseases. When Dr Ropers from the Max-Planck Institute for Molecular Genetics in Berlin found a child with non-specific symptoms, including small size at birth, difficulties with movement and feeding, severe intellectual disability, ...

Researchers pioneer treatment for viral infection common in children

2013-02-05
Researchers at Imperial College London have discovered a new way in which a very common childhood disease could be treated. In the first year of life, 65 per cent of babies get infected by Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV). This causes bronchiolitis, and is thought to kill nearly 200,000 children every year worldwide. In 1966 and 1967, vaccines were tested for RSV. These had disastrous effects on the immune response, leading to a worsening of the disease and, in many cases, death. Scientists have so far not been able to fully explain this effect, which continues to ...

Could the humble sea urchin hold the key to carbon capture?

2013-02-05
A chance discovery that sea urchins use Nickel ions to harness carbon dioxide from the sea to grow their exoskeleton could be the key to capturing tonnes of CO2 from the atmosphere. Experts at Newcastle University, UK, have discovered that in the presence of a Nickel catalyst, CO2 can be converted rapidly and cheaply into the harmless, solid mineral, calcium or magnesium carbonate. This discovery, which is published today in the academic journal Catalysis Science & Technology, has the potential to revolutionise the way we capture and store carbon enabling us to significantly ...

Study examines potential transmission of AD, Parkinson's disease protein in cadaver hGH

2013-02-05
A group of recipients of cadaver-derived human growth hormone (c-hGH) does not appear to be at increased risk for Alzheimer and Parkinson disease despite their likely exposure to neurodegenerative disease (ND)-associated proteins and elevated risk of infectious prion protein-related disease, according to a report published Online First by JAMA Neurology, a JAMA Network publication. David J. Irwin, M.D., of the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia, and colleagues looked for evidence for human-to-human transmission of Alzheimer disease (AD), ...

Study suggests glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists related to adolescent weight loss

2013-02-05
Preliminary evidence from a clinical trial suggests that treatment with glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor agonists was associated with reduced body mass index and body weight in adolescents with severe obesity, according to a report published Online First by JAMA Pediatrics, a JAMA Network publication. GLP-1 receptor agonist therapy, approved for adults with type 2 diabetes mellitus, reduces body weight by enhancing satiety and suppressing appetite, even in patients without diabetes, according to the study background. Aaron S. Kelly, Ph.D., of the University ...

Around 1 in 10 young mentally ill teens drinks, smokes, and uses cannabis

2013-02-05
[Frequent alcohol, nicotine, or cannabis use is common in young persons presenting for mental healthcare: a cross sectional study doi 10.1136/bmjopen-2012-002229] Around one in 10 young teens with mental health issues also drinks alcohol, smokes cigarettes, and uses cannabis on a weekly basis, indicates Australian research published in the online only fully journal BMJ Open. The prevalence of this pattern of substance use increased with age, the study found, prompting the authors to raise concerns that these behaviours are likely to worsen both mental and physical ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Sinuses prevented prehistoric croc relatives from deep diving

Spirited away: Key protein aids transport within plant cells

Britain’s brass bands older than we thought and invented by soldiers from the Napoleonic Wars, new study reveals

The Lancet: Health threats of climate change reach record-breaking levels, as experts call for trillions of dollars spent on fossil fuels to be redirected towards protecting people’s health, lives and

‘Weekend warrior’ exercise pattern may equal more frequent sessions for lowering cognitive decline risk

Physical activity of any intensity linked to lower risk of death after dementia diagnosis

Brain changes seen in lifetime cannabis users may not be causal

For the love of suckers: Volunteers contribute to research on key freshwater fishes

Bill and Mary Anne Dingus commit $1M to fund Human Impacts on the Earth Fund at Rice

Most patients can continue GLP-1 anti-obesity drugs before surgery

Computational tool developed to predict immunotherapy outcomes for patients with metastatic breast cancer

Cerebral embolic protection by geographic region

12 new Oriental weevil species discovered using advanced imaging tools

Ultrasound can be used as search and rescue tool for the brain

Department of Defense funds study of gene therapy for muscular degeneration

People’s exposure to toxic chemicals declined in the U.S. following listing under California law

Trauma, homelessness afflict gender affirming care patients at higher rates

New $5 million DoE award supports KU startup’s green hydrogen energy research

A navigation system for microswimmers

Study finds early TAVR can be beneficial for patients with asymptomatic severe aortic stenosis

Implantable microparticles can deliver two cancer therapies at once

Early intervention in patients with asymptomatic severe aortic stenosis and myocardial fibrosis falls short of expected benefits

The surprising reason a classical computer beat a quantum computer at its own game

Researchers Aim To Get Leg Up on Bone Repair with 3D-Printed Femur

Transforming patient care: study finds bedside interdisciplinary rounds boost satisfaction for patients and providers

Radioprotective effects of licochalcone B: DNA protection, cytokine inhibition, and antioxidant boost

Complete response to encorafenib + binimetinib in BRAF V600E-mutant tumor

Gold bugs: Spectacular new fossil arthropod preserved in fool’s gold

Optimal standing positions and ventilation in airport smoking lounges

Ancient gene influences immunity of First Nations Peoples of Oceania

[Press-News.org] 'Default' options influence patient choices in advance care directives, Penn study shows