DALLAS, TX, March 18, 2013 (Press-News.org) This article might be about the trouble with polygraphs inside the Chicago police department, but the lessons learned apply to anyone charged with a crime in the U.S. The state in which we defend people charged with crimes (Texas) is one with severe punishment - and if you've been accused of committing a violent crime or any other crime, you better make sure the police are following the rules.
Because when they don't, the consequences can mean a wrongful conviction.
Beware the 'Pre-test Interview'
Coercing a false confession out of a suspect is similar to unlawful search and seizure in drug cases, from the perspective that the police have constitutional boundaries that should not be crossed, but sometimes are.
As Duaa Eldeib reports for the Chicago Tribune, the police may have been using the polygraph machine as a way to get false confessions out of suspects. Take Donny McGee, for example.
He was charged with the murder of a neighbor but later cleared by both a jury and DNA evidence.
Yet, earlier, the police somehow managed to get a "confession" out of him, even though he was in the room for a polygraph and never even took the test.
It all boils down to the pre-test interview, which, according to Eldeib's report, should consist of explaining the polygraph, getting consent, and reviewing the questions to be asked.
However, rather than following standard polygraph procedure, court documents allege that the police examiner would berate, threaten, and lie. This would, in turn, lead to false confessions.
Confessions Admissible in Court
A confession, false or otherwise, is a damaging piece of evidence. In many states, prosecutors cannot introduce polygraph evidence in court, but they can use confessions that the police get out of suspects, even though the polygraph may have been used as a tool to get that confession.
Local rules often state that's exactly what the police cannot do, and if the polygraph test is not done correctly and/or a false confession arises out of it, an innocent person can be wrongly convicted.
In Texas, polygraph results are generally not admissible in court. Even if they were, it takes some measure of skill to correctly administer a polygraph test, so that the evidence would mean something. The polygraph test measures stress, not lying, according to Diane Jennings with the Dallas Morning News, so there's a good chance for false positive results.
Ignored Standards for Polygraphs
Eldeib reports that the Chicago P.D. has systematically ignored standards for polygraphs, often getting false confessions during the pre-test. According to the American Association of Police Polygraphists, basic pre-test standards include:
- Getting consent and advising of rights related to polygraph testing
- Not doing the examination if the subject isn't in a suitable condition to be tested, either mentally or physically
- Maintaining an objective approach throughout the test
This isn't even the whole list of pre-test standards, but consent, suitability, and objectivity are three big ones. And if someone has been threatened and lied to during the pre-test, it's clear that some cops simply don't care much about standards.
Speak to a Texas Criminal Defense Attorney
If you've been arrested or charged with a crime in Texas, or a federal crime, contact the Dallas lawyers of Crain Lewis, LLP. Call 214-522-9404 or contact us online for a free consultation. It's important that you protect your rights as soon as you become a suspect.
Crain & Lewis, LLP
3400 Carlisle St, Suite 200
Dallas TX 75204
Website: http://criminal.dfwattorneys.com
The Lie Detector is Nothing More Than a Police Setup
If you've been accused of committing a violent crime or any other crime, make sure the police are following the rules.
2013-03-18
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Why Pregnant Mothers Should Wear Their Seat Belts
2013-03-18
If you think that your baby is safer by not wearing a seat belt, think again.
According to Kerry Grens's Reuters report, a new study shows that more fetuses die when their mothers aren't wearing seat belts in a car wreck than mothers who are buckled.
A 3.5 Percent vs. 25 Percent Difference
Of course, everyone needs to decide for themselves whether or not they'll wear a seat belt. Grens quotes the study's senior author, Dr. Haywood Brown, of Duke University Medical Center: "[L]ike all individuals, some choose and some do not choose to wear their seat belt."
Authors ...
Security Settings in File-Sharing Software May Lead to Unintended Sharing of Child Pornography
2013-03-18
Peer-to-peer or P2P file-sharing software allows computer users to remotely share files, including images and videos, with other users across the world with the same software installed. It may seem harmless, but it can get you into a lot of trouble - including criminal trouble - if you are not careful about your privacy settings.
Whether you were using Limewire, Shareaza, BitTorrent, Kazaa or another file-sharing program, making sure that your security settings are properly set may save you from dealing with the North Carolina or federal authorities. Without properly ...
Work of Fiction - ATRA's So-Called "Judicial Hellhole" Report Has No Basis in Fact
2013-03-18
Over the last few weeks, much has been written and said about MTV's new reality show Buckwild and its negative depiction of West Virginia and the people who live here. Everyone from elected officials to business leaders to people you meet on the street are furious about how they believe the program will mislead the country about life in the Mountain State.
I have just one question: Where is this same sustained outrage over the American Tort Reform Association calling our state a "hellhole" for a decade now? Just like this MTV program, ATRA's so-called "Judicial ...
2012 Fatal Car Accidents Stem From Drunk Driving, Other Causes
2013-03-18
Illinois saw 867 fatal car accidents in 2012, according to the Illinois Department of Transportation. Specific data is not yet available with regard to how many of those crashes were related to alcohol use. Though holiday accident data for 2012 is also not yet available, historically accidents related to alcohol increase during holiday weekends such as Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, in 2010, more than 10,000 people died in U.S. highway accidents involving a drunk driver. Fatal accidents can result ...
Travel Deemed More Important than Marriage & Starting a Family
2013-03-18
As the world prepares to recognize the first ever International Day of Happiness on March 20, a day established by the United Nations General Assembly, a new poll reveals how travel factors into happiness worldwide.
A large majority of respondents (83%) of the 2013 G Adventures Happiness Survey said travel is very important to their happiness. In fact, in terms of making people happy travel was deemed more important than marriage and having a baby.
"At G Adventures, Creating Happiness & Community is one of our Core Values. We understand the positive effects ...
Sierra Pacific Mortgage Continues Successful Track Record with Several Key Accomplishments in 2012
2013-03-18
Sierra Pacific Mortgage has released their final results for 2012 which showcase a banner year for the national mortgage banking leader. With 312% growth in Retail production in 2012, Sierra Pacific Mortgage has validated its retail banking strategy, capitalizing on its dominance in the wholesale mortgage marketplace.
Sierra Pacific set a company record with over 25% of their funding coming from retail originations, and funded over $2 billion in retail production in 2012. Mr. Chuck Iverson, company Vice President states "Our move from 8% retail to over 25% shows ...
Health Journeys' New Audio Program Tackles Hefty Consequences of Procrastination
2013-03-18
Procrastination is on the rise. Recent studies show the percentage of college students who admit they procrastinate is as high as 95%, up from 25 percent in the 1970's.
For some people it is a minor annoyance, but for others, procrastination can take a costly toll. A survey by H & R Block estimated that procrastination costs a person an average of $400 on his or her taxes, resulting in more than $473 million in overpayments each year. Economists cite budgetary crises from delayed action by corporations and governments; and medical professionals note the growing number ...
Renzo Piano's Shard and Jacqueline Durran's Anna Karenina Costumes Compete for the Prestigious Design of the Year Award
2013-03-18
Having won the Design of the Year award in 2012 for the London 2012 Olympic Torch, it's time for Edward Barber and Jay Osgerby to hand the title over to another deserving designer. Spread across seven categories - Architecture, Digital, Fashion, Furniture, Graphics, Product and Transport - the awards are regarded as 'the Oscars of the design world' and showcase some of the most innovative and creative works from London and around the world.
The Designs of the Year 2013 exhibition opens to the public on 20th March 2013 at London's Design Museum and the category winners ...
AgilQuest's OnBoard Desk and Conference Room Booking Technology Now Supports Clustering and HA
2013-03-18
AgilQuest Corporation announced a support service for OnBoard, their hoteling and conference room management technology, and its use in clusters and similar high availability configurations in large organizations. Automatic failover of servers within a cluster allows IT departments to keep mission-critical applications running and available for their employees with little or no interruption. This new service offering supports IT departments in configuring and testing OnBoard and its components within their existing HA environment.
"With a single installation of ...
Back Up the Spring Baby Boom With Life Insurance Cover For Your Little Loved Ones
2013-03-18
According to a report from the Daily Mail on February 1st 2013, the Duchess of Cambridge's baby news had encouraged a huge surge in home fertility testing sales, which soared by 60% as women rushed to share the experience of a princess.
The craze coincides with the tradition of many conceptions talking place between the months of February and March - spring signalling the distant sound of tiny baby feet by autumn.
As pregnancy planning takes hold, many expectant parents think of saving for cots, prams and nappies; for new nurseries and university funds.
However, ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Menopause drug reduces hot flashes by more than 70%, international clinical trial finds
FGF21 muscle hormone associated with slow ALS progression and extended survival
Hitting the right note: The healing power of music therapy in the cardiac ICU
Cardiovascular disease risk rises in Mexico, despite improved cholesterol control
Flexible optical touch sensor simultaneously pinpoints pressure strength and location
Achalasia diagnosis simplified to AI plus X-ray
PolyU scholars pioneer smart and sustainable personal cooling technologies to address global extreme heat
NIH grant aims for childhood vaccine against HIV
Menstrual cycle and long COVID: A relation confirmed
WMO report on global water resources: 2024 was characterized by both extreme drought and intense rainfall
New findings explain how a mutation in a cancer-related gen causes pulmonary fibrosis
Thermal trigger
SNU materials science and engineering team identifies reconstruction mechanism of copper alloy catalysts for CO₂ conversion
New book challenges misconceptions about evolution and our place in the tree of life
Decoding a decade of grouper grunts unlocks spawning secrets, shifts
Smart robots revolutionize structural health monitoring
Serum-derived hsa_circ_101555 as a diagnostic biomarker in non-hepatocellular carcinoma chronic liver disease
Korea University study identifies age 70 as cutoff for chemotherapy benefit in colorectal cancer
Study explores brain cell communication called ‘crosstalk’
4 beer and wine discoveries
Massage Therapy Foundation awards $299,465 research grant to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia
Chung-Ang University develops chloride-resistant Ru nanocatalysts for sustainable hydrogen production from seawater
Afghanistan’s August 2025 earthquake reveals the cost of international isolation, UN scientists warn
Shortlist announced for Panmure House Prize
Small nuclear RNA base editing a safer alternative to CRISPR, UC San Diego researchers find
Can Hayabusa2 touchdown? New study reveals space mission’s target asteroid is tinier and faster than thought
Millisecond windows of time may be key to how we hear, study finds
Graz University of Technology opens up new avenues in lung cancer research with digital cell twin
Exoplanets are not water worlds
Study shows increasing ‘healthy competition’ between menu options nudges patients towards greener, lower-fat hospital food choices
[Press-News.org] The Lie Detector is Nothing More Than a Police SetupIf you've been accused of committing a violent crime or any other crime, make sure the police are following the rules.