Are warrantless blood tests constitutional? Supreme Court will decide

The Supreme Court will decide whether a warrant is required to force a DUI suspect to submit to a blood test.

2013-04-17

April 17, 2013 (Press-News.org) Later this spring, the United States Supreme Court is expected to issue a decision in a case that could profoundly affect the rights of those who are accused of drunk driving in Virginia and across the nation. The issue at stake in the case is whether the Fourth Amendment, which protects citizens against unreasonable search and seizure by the police, prohibits alcohol blood tests without a warrant.

What happened in the case?

The case, Missouri v. McNeely, started when a highway patrol officer in Missouri stopped Tyler McNeely for speeding. During the course of the stop, the officer found reason to suspect that McNeely had been drinking. Because of this, he asked him to perform a battery of field sobriety tests, which were performed poorly. The officer then asked McNeely to take a breath test, but he refused.

The officer then drove McNeely to a hospital and asked a staff member to take a sample of his blood over his objections. The blood test results indicated that McNeely's blood alcohol level was about twice the legal limit. He was then arrested and charged with drunk driving.

Before McNeely's trial, his attorneys successfully excluded the results of the blood test from evidence, by arguing that his Fourth Amendment rights were violated, because the police failed to get a warrant first.

However, on appeal, this decision was reversed. The prosecutors successfully argued that getting a warrant would lead to destruction of evidence, as McNeely's body would have metabolized the alcohol in the time it would take to get a warrant. Since this was an emergency situation, the prosecution argued that police were justified in taking the blood without a warrant.

The case was then appealed to the Missouri Supreme Court, which agreed with the trial court that a warrant was required. Prosecutors then appealed the case to the United States Supreme Court.

Earlier this year, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the case. Although how it will rule is unknown, the justices seemed critical of the prosecutors' arguments that alcohol metabolism would constitute a sufficient emergency to excuse the need to get a warrant, especially for an intrusive procedure like a blood test. The court's decision is expected in late spring.

An attorney can help

If the Supreme Court decides that warrants are required for alcohol blood tests, it would strengthen the rights of those accused of drunk driving. Regardless of how the court decides, if you have been charged with DUI, it is important to assert your rights or they may be considered waived, which can severely weaken your defense. Contact an experienced criminal defense attorney to insure that your rights are protected.

Article provided by John J. Rice, Attorney & Counselor at Law
Visit us at www.johnjrice.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Co-parenting presents unique challenges for parents

2013-04-17

One of the biggest challenges during divorce is determining child custody. In Georgia, judges typically encourage a custody plan that is in the best interests of the children and grants both parents visitation time. Judges also grant either sole custody or joint custody. If sole custody is granted, the non-custodial parent retains visitation rights but is not allowed to make significant legal decisions concerning items such as health care, religious upbringing or education. With joint custody, both parents share in the decision-making process regarding these critical ...

Know your rights when arrested for drunk driving in Massachusetts

2013-04-17

While everyone knows that driving while intoxicated is against the law, sometimes the punishment vastly exceeds the circumstances. A man arrested for drunk driving in 2005 recently received a $15.5 million settlement for injuries suffered during his wrongful incarceration. According to a NBC News report, the man was placed into solitary confinement shortly after his arrest and he languished there for two years without the benefit of a trial. During that time, his mental health deteriorated, he was not allowed to bathe on a regular basis and he was forced to pull his ...

Payroll tax problems can overwhelm a company and prove criminal

2013-04-17

Sloppy accounting is no excuse when the Internal Revenue Service audits a company. IRS investigations looking at payroll tax problems are complex and costly. Business owners who fail to account for wages paid or withhold employee payroll taxes could face criminal penalties including jail time and large fines. It may even become a struggle to keep a company open and operating. Businesses need to make regular payroll tax deposits based on actual wages paid. A conviction from last year details what can occur when a company underreports wages paid to employees. An Ohio ...

Nevada DUI laws and problems with the Breathalyzer test

2013-04-17

Las Vegas residents may recall hearing about a Las Vegas constable who had his DUI criminal charges dropped, even after his preliminary Breathalyzer test showed a blood alcohol content over the legal limit of 0.08 percent. The constable's criminal charges were dropped because his second breath test showed that he had a BAC of 0.069 percent, which is below the 0.08 percent legal BAC limit. According to Nevada law, it is unlawful to use the initial breath test result as evidence in court. If wrongful DUI charges were brought against a constable, they could be brought ...

Texting and driving concerns in the Pittsburgh area

2013-04-17

Car accidents sometimes happen unavoidably, but more and more collisions occur because one individual was not paying attention and was, instead, texting while driving. Recent reports show that texting and driving is becoming more and more prominent, increasing the risk of injury while on the road. United States' ranking for texting and driving Federal government researchers found that two out of every three individuals admits to texting while driving. When looking comparatively at how the United States stands in relation to other countries, the United States was ...

DUI concerns for Georgia residents

2013-04-17

Driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs is a criminal charge that can change a person's life forever. The state of Georgia regulates drinking and driving with an interest in making the roads a safe place for all. Holidays often involve an increased number of individuals partaking in alcohol-related events, and officers tend to increase patrols in order to respond to the increased activity. St. Patrick's Day crackdowns St. Patrick's Day is often associated with Irish culture, leprechauns, luck and green beer. It is a holiday where many individuals venture ...

Vehicle faults prove concerning

2013-04-17

Driving a vehicle can, in itself, be a dangerous activity. Inclement weather, obstacles in the road and other distracted drivers are all disconcerting to drivers. One factor many do not expect to cause an accident, however, is the car itself. Being aware of current recalls and fixing faulty parts prove important to a driver's safety. Ford's latest recall According to multiple news sources, Ford decided to voluntarily recall 5,675 of its 2013 C-Max hybrids, Escape SUVs and Ford Focus sedans. This recall is due to faulty child safety door locks. The vehicles affected ...

Californians can expect a crackdown on distracted driving soon

2013-04-17

Individuals who text and drive or talk on their cell phone while driving should beware -- California law enforcement is expected to do a mega crackdown on such activities in April 2013. Texting while driving and talking on handheld cell phones has been illegal in the state since 2009; however, statistics show that a large number of distracted driving tickets have been issued throughout those years. Not only that, but statistics exist to show that a large percentage of car accidents that occur in the state stem from a driver being distracted. The Mercury News reports ...

Marietta Tree Removal Company, Yellow Ribbon, Discusses Dangers in Tree Topping

2013-04-17

Tree topping, also known as heading, tipping, or rounding over, is a term that describes the indiscriminate cutting of tree branches down to stubs or lateral branches. This pruning technique lops off entire tops of trees, leaving only smaller branches that are not large enough to assume the role of a terminal leader. Even after over 25 years of research and literature describing the hazards of tree topping, it remains a common pruning practice. The Marietta tree service experts at Yellow Ribbon explain that his technique is dangerous to trees for a variety of reasons. ...

Older Professionals Are Turning to Temp Work, Notes Birmingham Staffing Agency, TRC Staffing Services, Inc.

2013-04-17

The Birmingham Staffing Agency is seeing a rise in temp jobs for older candidates. TRS Staffing Services, Inc, a well known Birmingham staffing agency, is discussing the increased number of older workers seen in their offices. In a nation that is haunted by historically high unemployment rates, any opportunity for work can be considered a blessing. This is particularly true for the country's older generation. Job loss and a saturated market of young professionals have made the lives of these people all the more difficult. The number of older workers performing temp labor ...