Intoxilyzer 8000 breath tests questioned in Ohio

The Intoxilyzer 8000, a machine used to test blood alcohol levels, is facing significant controversy in Ohio.

2013-04-19

April 19, 2013 (Press-News.org) Four years after their introduction, doubts have surfaced about the reliability of the Intoxilyzer 8000, a machine that is used to test the blood alcohol level of those accused of operating a vehicle under the influence (OVI). These doubts have led to questions of whether such machines should be able to be challenged in court.

Intoxilyzer controversy

In 2008, the Ohio Department of Health used federal grants to purchase 700 Intoxilyzer 8000 machines at a total cost of $6.4 million. The reason that the machines were purchased was to make alcohol breath tests uniform across the various Ohio counties. Before this time, each county used a different machine to test OVI suspects.

The approval of the machine was shrouded in some controversy, as at the time of purchase, it was under scrutiny in other states because of questions of accuracy. Soon after the machines were instituted, Ohio judges in municipal courts--courts that hear OVI cases--began to vocalize several issues with the machine.

For example, a judge in Athens County said in a 2011 opinion that the machine was vulnerable to interference from smart phones. Additionally, the judge noted that if a large volume of breath is blown into the machine, it could register an artificially high blood alcohol value.

Additionally, experts say that the police can manipulate the machine. Under Ohio law, police must take two breath samples within two to 10 minutes of each other when using the Intoxilyzer 8000. To be considered valid, each sample must register a blood alcohol level of within .02. However, the machine allows the officer to force the suspect to blow into it just long enough to keep the second sample within the .02 range. The longer the suspect blows into the machine, the higher the reading is.

These complaints have been echoed in other jurisdictions such as Florida and Arizona, leading to legal challenges of the machine's use in OVI prosecutions.

Possible legal challenges to follow

Although widely criticized, the Intoxilyzer 8000 is still being used in many Ohio counties, largely due to a 1984 Ohio Supreme Court ruling. In the ruling, Ohio v. Vega, the court ruled that once an alcohol-testing machine has been approved by the Ohio Department of Health, its reliability is presumed. This limits the ability of OVI suspects to challenge the machine's accuracy in court.

Despite the earlier court decision, some individuals across the state have persuaded many judges to dismiss OVI charges based on the machine's result. In addition, many Ohio judges have expressed disagreement about whether Vega would prohibit legal challenges to the machine, given the problems surrounding the machine in Ohio and other jurisdictions. This possibly signals that the Ohio Supreme Court will eventually decide this issue in the future.

Consult a criminal defense attorney

If you have been arrested on suspicion of drunk driving, you face the possibility of losing a significant amount of your freedoms. An experienced Ohio OVI defense attorney can analyze the case against you for any weaknesses and ensure that your rights are protected.

Article provided by Heckert & Associates Co., LPA
Visit us at www.heckertlaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Texting while driving still happening in Pennsylvania despite legal ban

2013-04-19

At the conclusion of the first year of a state ban on texting behind the wheel in Pennsylvania, the House of Representatives has declared April 2013 to be "Distracted Driving Awareness Month" in the commonwealth. The resolution cites national statistics from 2011 when 3,331 people died and 387,000 were hurt in distracted-driving motor vehicle crashes. The resolution defines "distracted driving" as anything that pulls a driver's attention away concentrating primarily on the road, including cell phone usage of any kind as well as other activities like ...

Waco fertilizer plant explosion leaves many dead, dozens injured

2013-04-19

Wednesday night, a fertilizer plant exploded in the small town of West, Texas, just north of Waco. According to the Waco Tribune-Herald, up to 15 people are dead, several firefighters remain missing and more than 160 people are being treated for injuries at local hospitals. Some fear that these numbers may increase as authorities begin searching the area for survivors. At approximately 6:00pm local time, firefighters received a report of a fire at a fertilizer plant operated by the West Fertilizer Company. Emergency personnel responded to the call and began evacuating ...

Who can be held accountable for drunk drivers on Pennsylvania roadways?

2013-04-19

According to a report issued by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), there were 9,878 deaths attributed to alcohol-impaired-driving car accidents in 2011, which is the most recent year for which complete data is available. Of these, 407 fatalities occurred right here in Pennsylvania - which represents an alarming 32 percent of all traffic deaths throughout the entire state that year. Adding to these horrific numbers is the harsh reality that for every drunk driving fatality there are several additional non-fatal injuries attributed to intoxicated ...

Studies: Longer Hours Not To Blame For Medical Mistakes

2013-04-19

The number of hours that medical interns work is legendary. As of 2003, a typical young doctor was on call for up to 36 hours at a time. As of 2011, that number was 30 hours. It's not surprising that many people have come to fear that exhausted interns may cause more medical or surgical errors. As a result, in 2011, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) passed nationwide standards limiting interns to 16-hour shifts. However, according to two recent studies published in JAMA Internal Medicine, shorter shifts may not lead to safer hospitals. ...

Left-behind items in surgery a common problem

2013-04-19

With healthcare costs the way they are, when you are having surgery, you would expect the surgeon to perform the operation in a nearly perfect manner. Although nobody is perfect, you certainly expect that the surgeon would not make an obvious error. However, the reality is that this is often the case. A recent article in USA Today points out that surgeons leave behind surgical items in their patients more than 12 times per day. In addition, an investigation conducted by USA Today found that although items such as clamps, forceps and other surgical items are sometimes ...

Springtime brings a higher chance of Connecticut pedestrian accidents

2013-04-19

As spring arrives, countless Connecticut residents will be hitting the town's streets and sidewalks on foot to work off some of the "cabin fever" caused by a long, hard winter. With more people out and about, though, there is a higher risk of pedestrian versus car accidents, so it is a good time for a refresher on the rights and responsibilities of both walkers and motorists. Taking some basic precautions can ensure that the road is shared safely and can prevent tragic accidents like the high-profile one that devastated a Milford family in February. Rules of ...

DNA analysis: A futuristic fingerprint or something more?

2013-04-19

Many states across the nation have passed laws requiring the collection DNA from those arrested for violent crimes, even before conviction for the crime. In Virginia, an individual arrested for a violent felony or for the attempt to commit such a crime must provide a saliva or tissue sample for DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) analysis. The criminal charge itself is enough to trigger the requirement. DNA samples are then stored in a DNA data bank by the state Department of Forensic Science. In some cases, the state provides the DNA samples to CODIS, which is a database of ...

Researchers develop new mesothelioma detection method

2013-04-19

Mesothelioma is a terrible disease. It is a serious cancer that is caused by exposure to asbestos fibers. Sadly, mesothelioma is difficult to treat and is almost always fatal. A lot of the challenge comes from the fact that mesothelioma is so hard to detect. The cancer forms in the lining of the lungs or other organs and develops slowly over time, sometimes becoming apparent only decades after the initial exposure to asbestos. Researchers have been working on new ways to diagnose mesothelioma with the hope that earlier detection could improve survival rates, or, at ...

Minnesota foreclosure rate drops, but problems persist

2013-04-19

There's no disputing that the foreclosure crisis has taken a huge toll all throughout Minnesota. Nearly everyone knows someone who lost their home during the Great Recession, or who got into serious trouble after falling behind on their mortgage. Thankfully, data suggests that the problem is getting better. A recent report from the Minnesota Homeownership Center shows that the number of Minnesota homes lost to foreclosure in 2012 was lower than at any point since the crisis began in 2006. Statewide, the number of foreclosure sales fell by 16 percent from the year before. ...

Chapter 7 bankruptcy: might an alternative approach be better for you?

2013-04-19

Overwhelming debt can happen to anyone and it's not a reflection on character. Especially in the current economy, a financial challenge can be the tipping point for an individual or family toward crushing debt. For example, unexpected and unplanned-for divorce, medical emergency, interruption of medical insurance coverage, job loss, breadwinner death or another similarly serious situation could send many an American into a financial abyss. If you face a financial crisis, talk to an experienced bankruptcy attorney about whether bankruptcy might be the right answer for ...

Intoxilyzer 8000 breath tests questioned in Ohio

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: