(Press-News.org) CAMBRIDGE, Mass-- The recent factory collapse in Bangladesh has renewed attention to the global issue of workplace standards. In many countries, similar problems have arisen from a lack of enforcement for existing laws pertaining to safety, wages and overtime, or an absence of labor contracts for workers.
These problems occur for a variety of reasons, including a lack of funding for regulators; difficulties acquiring solid information about potential problems in the first place; and corruption in the enforcement process.
"We have a huge problem with enforcement," says Matthew Amengual, an assistant professor of management at the MIT Sloan School of Management, who has studied the issue in multiple countries.
Now, after extensive on-the-ground research in Argentina, Amengual has a distinctive new paper on the subject that will be published in Industrial and Labor Relations Review.
In the paper, titled "Pathways to Enforcement," Amengual details his findings, including the observation that effective regulators can overcome the constraints on their work by creating informal fact-finding alliances with advocacy groups and others who may have unique information about dubious labor practices. Or, as Amengual writes in the paper, "Regulators can use these groups to make up for state weakness."
So while some people may view effective regulation as a process that needs to be free of political influence, Amengual has discovered that just isn't so: For better or worse, underfunded regulators will try to connect with outside groups where it is politically feasible, and those alliances tend to generate the instances where laws are firmly enforced. Reducing political influence on the inspection process, he notes, is not the only way to increase enforcement.
Explaining enforcement
Indeed, follow-up on regulations is so rare, Amengual says, that academic researchers essentially need to examine why it happens at all, and what it consists of when it does take place. Or, as he says, "How do we explain enforcement in areas where we don't expect it to occur?"
Argentina provides a good window into this question because it has a set of national regulations, but a regional system of enforcement. That provided Amengual with the opportunity to examine the differences in enforcement that occur among and within regions. He spent 16 months conducting research in Argentina in 2008 and 2009, interviewing more than 190 government officials, inspectors, labor leaders and firm managers; conducting an original survey of labor inspectors; studying government data and documents; and even reviewing about 1,400 local newspaper articles about labor regulation.
In the paper, Amengual details the enforcement process in two provinces, based around the cities of Córdoba and Buenos Aires, in which enforcement varied from industry to industry.
In Córdoba, the Labor Secretariat was charged with enforcing regulations, and conducted a relatively large number of inspections — higher than the number per capita in France, for instance — but those investigations were uneven. In the informal brick-kiln industry, where workers form mud into bricks that are then baked in small ovens, labor problems had been publicized in the local press, but few enforcement actions were taken. In the larger-scale metal industry, workplace problems appear to have been less extreme, but the regulators took far more action.
Why? Local unions were stronger in the metal industry, and could provide inspectors with copious amounts of information on labor standards. In Córdoba, as Amengual writes, "there is enforcement, but it is skewed toward industries with large numbers of union demands."
A related story holds in Buenos Aires, with a few twists. There, regulators had fewer ties with the metal industry unions, and did not investigate the industry as fully as their counterparts in Córdoba — but established a strong working relationship with an advocacy group, La Alameda, that supported Bolivian immigrants in the garment industry. The enforcement that followed was heavily oriented toward violations pertaining to the garment-makers.
Such working relationships were necessary because informal sweatshops are not necessarily obvious from the outside. Rather than, say, trying to study electricity-usage records to deduce where off-the-books production was occurring, inspectors could get information from the advocacy groups that had direct ties to workers.
"This allowed them to find highly vulnerable workers they never would have been able to locate," Amengual says. Or, as one senior official in charge of inspectors told Amengual about how he approached his job: "I went looking for allies."
The pitfalls of outside help
Amengual emphasizes that he is not offering the tactics of the Argentine regulators as a one-size-fits-all prescription for better factory-law enforcement around the globe. After all, the pattern he discovered — of regulators seeking information from outside sources — could be used to justify keeping enforcement budgets small, and it does represent a politicized process of enforcement.
"This shouldn't be a replacement for strengthening bureaucracies," says Amengual, who is turning his research into a book about industry and regulation, including workplace and environmental issues.
At the same time, Amengual does not endorse leaving enforcement in the hands of companies themselves, as some would prefer. Amengual is among many MIT-based scholars who have conducted research on the subject with Richard Locke, the former head of MIT's Department of Political Science and a former associate dean at MIT Sloan, who once advocated for self-enforcement among firms, but has since come to view state action as an essential part of safe factory conditions.
"We need the state to do this," Amengual agrees.
###
Written by Peter Dizikes, MIT News Office
Study shows how some inspectors are able to uphold factory labor rules
While factory labor rules are notoriously hard to enforce, a new study shows how some inspectors are able to uphold workplace standards
2013-08-26
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Development of a therapeutic algorithm for optimal nosebleed management
2013-08-26
Approximately 60 percent of people experience epistaxis, commonly known as nosebleed, at least once in their lifetime. Of those who experience nosebleed, six percent require medical treatment. A study in the September 2013 issue of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, explores which nosebleed treatment options demonstrate the best outcomes.
"Although data exist on the efficacy of the different epistaxis management techniques, outcome comparisons between the modalities for both primary management as well as management of cases of recurrence are currently lacking," the ...
Study offers insight into the origin of the genetic code, team reports
2013-08-26
CHAMPAIGN, Ill. -- An analysis of enzymes that load amino acids onto transfer RNAs -- an operation at the heart of protein translation -- offers new insights into the evolutionary origins of the modern genetic code, researchers report.
Their findings appear in the journal PLOS ONE.
The researchers focused on aminoacyl tRNA synthetases, enzymes that "read" the genetic information embedded in transfer RNA molecules and attach the appropriate amino acids to those tRNAs. Once a tRNA is charged with its amino acid, it carries it to the ribosome, a cellular "workbench" on ...
UCI, UCLA study reveals new approach to remedying childhood visual disorders
2013-08-26
Irvine, Calif., Aug. 26, 2013 — By discovering the role of key neurons that mediate an important part of vision development, UC Irvine and UCLA neurobiologists have revealed a new approach to correcting visual disorders in children who suffer from early cataracts or amblyopia, also known as lazy eye.
Such youngsters can have permanent defects in vision, even after surgery to remove cataracts or correct lazy eye. These flaws are often a result of improper brain development due to visual deprivation during childhood. In contrast, when cataracts in adults are surgically ...
Why do haters have to hate?
2013-08-26
PHILADELPHIA (August 26, 2013) – New research has uncovered the reason why some people seem to dislike everything while others seem to like everything. Apparently, it's all part of our individual personality – a dimension that researchers have coined "dispositional attitude."
People with a positive dispositional attitude have a strong tendency to like things, whereas people with a negative dispositional attitude have a strong tendency to dislike things, according to research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. The journal article, "Attitudes ...
Penn study finds earlier peak for Spain's glaciers
2013-08-26
The last glacial maximum was a time when Earth's far northern and far southern latitudes were largely covered in ice sheets and sea levels were low. Over much of the planet, glaciers were at their greatest extent roughly 20,000 years ago. But according to a study headed by University of Pennsylvania geologist Jane Willenbring, that wasn't true in at least one part of southern Europe. Due to local effects of temperature and precipitation, the local glacial maximum occurred considerably earlier, around 26,000 years ago.
The finding sheds new light on how regional climate ...
Northwestern Medicine uses new minimally invasive technique for melanoma
2013-08-26
CHICAGO – At first, Krista Easom figured the little red bump on her foot was nothing more than a blister.
It didn't hurt, but after a couple months, it didn't go away either.
She booked an appointment with a dermatologist to have it removed. She wasn't worried. Easom, a 24-year-old law school student from New Jersey, was healthy, had no family history of cancer and was getting ready to enjoy some time in her newly adopted city of Chicago.
That's when she received the results from her dermatologist, who removed a part of the blister and had it tested.
It turns out ...
Researchers develop software tool for cancer genomics
2013-08-26
Researchers at the Medical College of Wisconsin (MCW) have developed a new bioinformatics software tool designed to more easily identify genetic mutations responsible for cancers.
The tool, called DrGaP, is the subject of a new paper published in the American Journal of Human Genetics.
Xing Hua, Ph.D., postdoctoral fellow in biostatistics at the National Cancer Institute, and a former visiting scholar at MCW, is the first author of the paper. Yan Lu, Ph.D., assistant professor of physiology, is corresponding author; and Pengyuan Liu, Ph.D., associate professor of ...
Size matters as nanocrystals go through phases
2013-08-26
Understanding what happens to a material as it undergoes phase transformations – changes from a solid to a liquid to a gas or a plasma – is of fundamental scientific interest and critical for optimizing commercial applications. For metal nanocrystals, assumptions about the size-dependence of phase transformations were made that now need to be re-evaluated. A team of researchers at the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)'s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) has demonstrated that as metal nanocrystals go through phase transformations, size can make a much bigger ...
Carbon-sequestering ocean plants may cope with climate changes over the long run
2013-08-26
SAN FRANCISCO -- A year-long experiment on tiny ocean organisms called coccolithophores suggests that the single-celled algae may still be able to grow their calcified shells even as oceans grow warmer and more acidic in Earth's near future.
The study stands in contrast to earlier studies suggesting that coccolithophores would fail to build strong shells in acidic waters. The world's oceans are expected to become more acidic as human activities pump increasing amounts of carbon dioxide into the Earth's atmosphere.
But after the researchers raised one strain of the ...
Insight into marine life's ability to adapt to climate change
2013-08-26
A study into marine life around an underwater volcanic vent in the Mediterranean, might hold the key to understanding how some species will be able to survive in increasingly acidic sea water should anthropogenic climate change continue.
Researchers have discovered that some species of polychaete worms are able to modify their metabolic rates to better cope with and thrive in waters high in carbon dioxide (CO2), which is otherwise poisonous to other, often closely-related species.
The study sheds new light on the robustness of some marine species and the relative resilience ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Can grapevines help slow the plastic waste problem?
People disregard advice when making tough decisions
Study reveals how small changes in walking technique may help treat knee osteoarthritis
Reciprocal links likely between certain groups of gut bacteria and insomnia risk
Taste and price, not calories, key drivers for online takeaway orders, survey suggests
Patients still view doctor’s white coat as symbol of professionalism and trust
The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology: Routine AI assistance may lead to loss of skills in health professionals who perform colonoscopies, study suggests
Obese surgical patients’ medication lifeline can reduce risk - study
How to relieve arthritic knee pain without drugs or surgery
Mental health care needs urgent reform to include lifestyle interventions
Understanding readers’ imaginations could enhance mental health therapies
Musicians do not demonstrate long-believed advantage in processing sound
Potential link between fatigue and breast cancer recurrence
Biophysical Society announces the results of its 2025 elections
Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Clinic for Special Children discover ultra rare form of neuroinflammatory disease is much more common in Old Order Amish than general population
We’re in the game: Paul “Bear” Bryant Coach of the Year Award to be featured in EA Sports College Football 26
Black metal could give a heavy boost to solar power generation
We now have the math to describe ‘matrix tides’ and other complex wave patterns seen in Qiantang River
Personalized pricing can backfire on companies, says study
Tiny robots use sound to self-organize into intelligent groups
Laser therapy enhances treatment of fungus resistant to conventional medication
Galactic Rosetta Stone: Study measuring magnetic field near the center of the Milky Way helps to decode the precise astrophysical dynamics at the heart of our galaxy
OU researchers study effects of cannabis on facial wound healing after surgery
New species of ancient whale discovered on Victoria's Surf Coast
The ISSCR and STEMCELL Technologies partner to launch free, on-demand course on standards for human stem cell use in research
Women with Down syndrome may develop Alzheimer’s disease more rapidly than men
Study: Long COVID remains a substantial financial and medical burden
Mount Sinai receives $4 million grant from American Cancer Society to launch Cancer Health Research Center
Tan to conduct investigation of ferroelectric oxides as heterogeneous photocatalysts for ethane dehydrogenation
Sun to study software vulnerability detection & remediation
[Press-News.org] Study shows how some inspectors are able to uphold factory labor rulesWhile factory labor rules are notoriously hard to enforce, a new study shows how some inspectors are able to uphold workplace standards