Different stories play different roles in patients' health decision-making, MU researcher says
Narratives about treatment processes and experiences inform patients without persuading
2013-09-19
(Press-News.org) COLUMBIA, Mo. – Individuals often turn to others for advice when making choices. Perhaps, it seems fitting then, that individuals would seek out others when they are faced with important health decisions. Yet, health communicators have debated whether stories should be included in patient decision-aids (which are informational materials designed to help patients make educated choices about their health) because they worry stories are too biased. Now, an MU researcher has found that stories used in decision-aids don't necessarily bias patients' decision-making; rather, certain types of stories can help patients confidently make informed decisions that fit their individual health needs.
"Stories are not all the same, and they don't all have the same effect on patients' decision-making; therefore, calls to avoid using stories in patient decision-aids is not advisable," said Victoria Shaffer, an assistant professor of health sciences and psychological sciences at MU. "Different types of narratives have different effects on patients' decision-making processes. The question isn't whether it's good or bad to include patient stories in decision aids; rather, the question is what type of stories should health communicators use to have the intended effect?"
Shaffer and her colleagues examined two types of stories in their study: process narratives and experience narratives. Process narratives are stories that include details about how a patient made a particular health care decision. Experience narratives include details about what it is like to have particular treatments or procedures.
The researchers told more than 300 healthy women to imagine they had received diagnoses of early-stage breast cancer. The women randomly were assigned to a process narrative condition, an experience narrative condition or a control condition with no patient stories. Participants in the narrative conditions then viewed four videotaped stories. Afterward, the women were asked to choose a treatment option: mastectomy, which includes complete removal of the breast tissue, or radiation and lumpectomy, which includes partial removal of the breast tissue.
"We found that neither type of story affected patients' treatment decisions," Shaffer said. "About two-thirds of the women chose lumpectomy and radiation and one-third of the women chose mastectomy regardless of which type of narrative they viewed."
In addition, the researchers found that women who viewed process narratives spent more time searching for information. Women who viewed experience narratives reported they could better envision what it would be like to undergo the treatments, and the women also evaluated their decisions more favorably.
Both early-stage breast cancer treatment options have similar survival rates, which means patients' treatment options really depend on the patients' individual preferences and lifestyles, Shaffer said.
"Previous research has shown that people make healthcare decisions based on their predictions about how these choices will affect their lives in the future," Shaffer said. "The problem is that most of us aren't very good at predicting how we'll feel in the future, which can lead us to make poor decisions or decisions that we later regret. Our results suggest that experience narratives increased patients' confidence in their treatment decisions. Perhaps, using experience narratives in future decision-aids can help patients make more confident health decisions."
Most of the controversy related to using stories in patient decision-aids focuses on outcome narratives, which are stories that evaluate the results of individuals' decisions. Previous research has shown that outcome stories are persuasive. However, process and experience narratives can inform patients' decision-making without biasing their treatment decisions, Shaffer said.
"After receiving a cancer diagnosis, patients may focus on survival or recurrence while making their treatment decisions and don't always consider the long-term tradeoffs associated with different treatment choices," Shaffer said. "Process narratives, in these instances, might help patients consider other treatment attributes, such as appearance, they wouldn't have otherwise considered."
Shaffer is an assistant professor in the Department of Health Sciences in the MU School of Health Professions and in the Department of Psychological Sciences in the MU College of Arts and Science. The study, "The Effects of process-focused versus experience-focused narratives in a breast cancer treatment decision task," was published online earlier this month by Patient Education and Counseling. Co-authors included Lukas Hulsey from Wichita State University and Brian Zikmund-Fisher from the University of Michigan. The Informed Medical Decisions Foundation and the American Cancer Society funded the research.
INFORMATION: END
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
2013-09-19
ROCHESTER, Minn. -- A genetic mutation, known as GBA, that leads to early onset of Parkinson's disease and severe cognitive impairment (in about 4 to 7 percent of all patients with the disease) also alters how specific lipids, ceramides and glucosylceramides are metabolized. Mayo Clinic researchers have found that Parkinson's patients who do not carry the genetic mutation also have higher levels of these lipids in the blood. Further, those who had Parkinson's and high blood levels were also more likely to have cognitive impairment and dementia. The research was recently ...
2013-09-19
MIAMI, FLORIDA, (September 18, 2013)—You might find it hard to believe that dust clouds from the African Sahara can travel thousands of miles across the Atlantic Ocean, but it does every year and in large quantities. In a recent study, Joseph Prospero, professor emeritus at the University of Miami Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science and collaborators at the University of Houston and Arizona State University found that the average air concentrations of inhalable particles more than doubled during a major Saharan dust intrusion in Houston, Texas.
...
2013-09-19
Using technology he helped develop, Vanderbilt University scientist Bryan Venters, Ph.D., has shed new light on the "dark matter" of the genome and has begun to explore a possible new approach to treating cancer.
"Clarity is everything," said Venters, assistant professor of Molecular Physiology and Biophysics who further developed the high-resolution technology as a postdoctoral fellow in the lab of Frank Pugh, Ph.D., at Pennsylvania State University before moving to Vanderbilt in January.
Venters and Pugh are co-authors of a paper published this week in the journal ...
2013-09-19
The extra demands on parents of chronically ill children cause stress that affects the whole family, according to a systematic review conducted by Case Western Reserve University researchers that also explored what factors in the child's care most contribute to the added strain.
The findings, reported in the August issue of the Journal of Pediatric Psychology article, "Parenting Stress Among Caregivers of Children With Chronic Illness: A Systematic Review," were based on an assessment of 96 peer-reviewed studies in 12 countries between 1980 and 2012.
Researchers examined ...
2013-09-19
Sequencing the DNA of an organism, whether human, plant, or jellyfish, has become a straightforward task, but assembling the information gathered into something coherent remains a massive data challenge. Researchers using computational resources at the San Diego Supercomputer Center (SDSC) at the University of California, San Diego, have created a faster and more effective way to assemble genomic information, while increasing
In a paper presented the past month at the 39th International Conference on Very Large Databases (VLDB2013) in Riva del Garda, Italy, Xifeng Yan, ...
2013-09-19
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — To stay ahead in the race against drug-resistant infections, scientists constantly search for and exploit vulnerabilities in deadly bacteria. Now, researchers from Brown and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology have used a novel compound to exploit an Achilles' heel in the bacterium that causes tuberculosis.
In a series of laboratory experiments, the researchers have shown that it is possible to kill Mycobacterium tuberculosis by inhibiting ClpP, a cellular enzyme that is not targeted by any antibacterial drug on the market. ...
2013-09-19
CLEMSON, S.C. — Cattle are what they eat. The forage — grasses and other plants — beef cattle eat affects the nutrition and tastiness of the meat. Clemson University animal science researchers report that steers grazing on one of five forages kept in paddocks showed significant differences in growth, carcass and meat quality.
The research can help cattle producers with alternatives to corn and feed when they are looking to add weight and value to their animals prior to sale.
A team of researchers supported by the Clemson University Experiment Station, Extension Service ...
2013-09-19
Wednesday, September 18, 2013 [Granada, Spain] – New research findings on avocado consumption, presented as two posters at the IUNS 20th International Congress of Nutrition, in Granada, Spain suggest that although calorie consumption at dinner was unchanged, inclusion or addition of fresh Hass Avocado to a meal may help to reduce hunger and the desire to eat in overweight adults. Results also showed that including or adding avocado to a meal resulted in smaller post-meal rises in insulin compared to eating a meal without avocado.
Findings were based on a Hass Avocado ...
2013-09-19
When it comes to fat, you want the brown type and not so much of the white variety because brown fat burns energy to keep you warm and metabolically active, while white fat stores excess energy around your waist, causing health problems. Researchers at The University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston (UTHealth) Medical School are studying brown fat with a goal of fighting obesity.
Right now, it is hard for researchers to spot brown fat cells at the molecular level, which is hindering efforts to harness their ability to guard against obesity. To address that issue, ...
2013-09-19
We often ignore what we cannot see, and yet organisms below the soil's surface play a vital role in plant functions and ecosystem well-being. These microbes can influence a plant's genetic structure, its health, and its interactions with other plants. A new series of articles in a Special Section in the American Journal of Botany on Rhizosphere Interactions: The Root Microbiome explores how root microbiomes influence plants across multiple scales—from cellular, bacterial, and whole plant levels to community and ecosystem levels.
Plants are teeming with microbial organisms; ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
[Press-News.org] Different stories play different roles in patients' health decision-making, MU researcher says
Narratives about treatment processes and experiences inform patients without persuading
