(Press-News.org) Partial knee replacement surgery is safer than total knee replacement, according to a new study published in The Lancet today (July 8).
A team of researchers from the University of Oxford, funded by Arthritis Research UK and the Royal College of Surgeons, found that:
Although the risk of life-threatening complications from knee replacement surgery is very small, people who undergo total knee replacement are four times more likely to die in the first month after surgery compared to those who have partial knee replacement, and 15 per cent more likely to die in the first eight years.
Patients undergoing total replacement are twice as likely to have a thrombosis, heart attack or deep infection, three times as likely to have a stroke and four times as likely to need blood transfusions, compared to those having partial replacement. In addition, after total knee replacement patients are in hospital longer and the chance of being readmitted or requiring a re-operation during the first year is higher.
Patients who had a partial knee replacement are 40 per cent more likely to have a re-operation, known as revision surgery, during the first eight years after the replacement, than those that had a total knee replacement.
Up to half of knees that require replacement, usually because of severe osteoarthritis, can be treated with either partial or total replacements. With partial replacements, also known as unicompartmental replacements, only the damaged parts of the knee are replaced and the remaining surfaces and all the ligaments are preserved.
Because of the higher revision rate of partial knee replacement surgery, which is traditionally regarded as the most important factor to determine the choice of implant, its use in the treatment of end-stage osteoarthritis is controversial, with only about 7,000 being performed annually in the UK. Partial knee replacements are often offered to younger people who, because of their higher activity levels, have increased failure rates.
Total knee replacement is one of the most common surgical procedures, with over 76,000 performed annually in the UK. Only five per cent of patients require revision surgery over a 10-year period.
Revision, re-operation and death were uncommon outcomes of either procedure, stressed the research team.
Professor David Murray, from the Nuffield Departmental of Orthopaedics, Rheumatology and Musculoskeletal Sciences at the University of Oxford, who led the research, said: 'For an individual patient, the decision whether to have a partial or total is based on an assessment of the relative risks and benefits. The main benefit of the partial knee is that it provides better function.
'The risks have been assessed in this study, which found that partial knees have fewer complications and deaths; however they do lead to more re-operations. Patients will however be more concerned to avoid death and major complications, such as heart attack or stroke, than re-operations.
'To put the risks in perspective, if 100 patients had a partial knee rather than a total knee replacement there would be one fewer death and three more re-operations in the first four years after surgery.'
If the number of partial replacements were to increase from 8 to 20 per cent, the NHS could potentially prevent 170 deaths, at the cost of 400 additional revisions.
Professor Murray added: 'Patients will be concerned about death following joint replacement. However patients who have severe arthritis are very immobile and therefore tend to be unfit. Joint replacement overall, by making patients more mobile and fit tends to save lives.'
His colleague Alex Liddle, an Arthritis Research UK clinical research fellow who ran the study, added: 'Partial and total knee replacements are both successful treatments and a large proportion of patients with end-stage knee osteoarthritis are suitable for either.
'Both have advantages and disadvantages, and the choice of which procedure to offer will depend on the requirements and expectations of individual patient.'
The team's study used data from the National Joint Registry for England and Wales on the adverse outcomes of more than 100,000 matched patients who had undergone both types of knee surgery.
Medical director of Arthritis Research UK Professor Alan Silman said: 'This is a comprehensive study that provides both patients and surgeons with valuable information about the risk and benefits of two effective types of knee replacement operations. This new knowledge will enable them to make an informed decision about which type of surgery is best for particular individuals.
'Even in the elderly, with other health problems, knee replacement is a very safe and effective procedure. These data remind us that there are still patients, who fortunately very rarely, can develop life threatening complications following surgery and we still need to find surgical approaches that takes away these risks whilst retaining a successful outcome for patients.'
INFORMATION:
Note to editors
Arthritis Research UK is the charity dedicated to stopping the devastating impact that arthritis has on people's lives. Everything that we do is focused on taking the pain away and keeping people active. Our remit covers all conditions which affect the joints, bones and muscles including osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, back pain and osteoporosis. We fund research into the cause, treatment and cure of arthritis, provide information on how to maintain healthy joints and bones and to live well with arthritis. We also champion the cause, influence policy change and work in partnership with others to achieve our aims. We depend on public support and the generosity of our donors to keep doing this vital work.
http://www.arthritisresearchuk.org
http://www.twitter.com/arthritisRUK
http://www.facebook.com/arthritisresearchuk
Partial knee replacement safer than total knee replacement
2014-07-08
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Premature newborn survival 30 percent higher in high volume neonatal centres
2014-07-08
The advantage is particularly evident for very premature babies born after less than 27 weeks of pregnancy, where the figure rises to 50%, prompting the authors to conclude that new services for newborns should promote delivery of very preterm babies in high volume units.
How best to organise critical care for newborns has been the focus of intense debate, with the results of various studies indicating that centralised care is linked to better outcomes.
But after a review in 2003, the government in England decided to reconfigure services into managed clinical networks ...
Study suggests consuming whey protein before meals could help improve blood glucose control in people with diabetes
2014-07-08
New research published in Diabetologia (the journal of the European Association for the Study of Diabetes) suggests that consuming whey protein before a regular breakfast reduces the blood sugar spikes seen after meals and also improves the body's insulin response. Thus whey protein could be an additional tool to help control blood sugar in patients with diabetes. The research was conducted in Israel by Professor Daniela Jakubowicz and Dr Julio Wainstein (Wolfson Medical Center, Tel Aviv University), Professor Oren Froy (Hebrew University of Jerusalem), Professor Bo Ahrén ...
Larger newborn care units provide better protection for very preterm babies
2014-07-08
Preterm babies admitted to high volume neonatal units are less likely to die compared to those admitted to low volume units, according to researchers.
A study, published in BMJ Open, has provided new estimates to assess how organisational factors in England impact clinical outcomes of infants born preterm.
Results demonstrated that for preterm babies born at less than 33 weeks gestation, the odds of dying in hospital were 32 per cent less if they were admitted to high volume units at the hospital of birth than if they were admitted to low volume units (odds ratio 0.68). ...
Annals of Internal Medicine tip sheet for July 8, 2014
2014-07-08
1. Task Force recommends against screening for carotid artery stenosis in general adult population
The United States Preventive Services Task Force recommends against screening for asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis in the general adult population, according to a recommendation statement being published in Annals of Internal Medicine. Stroke is a leading cause of death and disability in the United States and having carotid artery stenosis (a buildup of plaque in the carotid arteries that causes them to narrow) is a risk factor. although it accounts for a smaller number ...
Home visits by nurse may help reduce mortality in moms, children
2014-07-07
Women who had prenatal and infant/toddler nurse visits at home were less likely to die than women who did not and children whose mothers were visited by nurses were less likely to have died by age 20 from preventable causes.
Since 1990, the authors have been conducting a randomized clinical trial of a program of prenatal and infant/toddler home visits by nurses for very low-income, largely black mothers, having their first child.
The study assigned 1,138 mothers to 1 of 4 treatment groups: treatment 1 (transportation for prenatal care, n=166), treatment 2 (transportation ...
SAR11, oceans' most abundant organism, has ability to create methane
2014-07-07
CORVALLIS, Ore. – The oxygen-rich surface waters of the world's major oceans are supersaturated with methane – a powerful greenhouse gas that is roughly 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide – yet little is known about the source of this methane.
Now a new study by researchers at Oregon State University demonstrates the ability of some strains of the oceans' most abundant organism – SAR11 – to generate methane as a byproduct of breaking down a compound for its phosphorus.
Results of the study are being published this week in Nature Communications. It was funded ...
EARTH Magazine: Preserving Peru's petrified forest
2014-07-07
Alexandria, Va. — Tucked high in the Andes Mountains of northern Peru is a remarkable fossil locality: a 39-million-year-old petrified forest preserved in nearly pristine condition: stumps, full trees, leaves and all. With its existence unknown to scientists until the early 1990s — and its significance unbeknownst to villagers — this ancient forest hosts the remains of more than 40 types of trees, some still rooted, that flourished in a lowland tropical forest until they were suddenly buried by a volcanic eruption during the Eocene.
Since its discovery a little more than ...
New study of largely unstudied mesophotic coral reef geology
2014-07-07
MIAMI – A new study on biological erosion of mesophotic tropical coral reefs, which are low energy reef environments between 30-150 meters deep, provides new insights into processes that affect the overall structure of these important ecosystems. The purpose of the study was to better understand how bioerosion rates and distribution of bioeroding organisms, such as fish, mollusks and sponges, differ between mesophotic reefs and their shallow-water counterparts and the implications of those variations on the sustainability of the reef structure.
Due to major advancements ...
Discovery of Neandertal trait in ancient skull raises new questions about human evolution
2014-07-07
Re-examination of a circa 100,000-year-old archaic early human skull found 35 years ago in Northern China has revealed the surprising presence of an inner-ear formation long thought to occur only in Neandertals.
"The discovery places into question a whole suite of scenarios of later Pleistocene human population dispersals and interconnections based on tracing isolated anatomical or genetic features in fragmentary fossils," said study co-author Erik Trinkaus, PhD, a physical anthropology professor at Washington University in St. Louis.
"It suggests, instead, that ...
Bruce Museum scientist identifies world's largest-ever flying bird
2014-07-07
GREENWICH, CT, EMBARGOED UNTIL JULY 7, 2014 (3:00 PM EST) -- Scientists have identified the fossilized remains of an extinct giant bird that is likely to have the largest wingspan of any bird ever to have lived. A paper announcing the findings, "Flight Performance of the Largest Volant Bird," was published July 7 in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, and is authored by Dr. Daniel Ksepka, the newest Curator of Science at the Bruce Museum in Greenwich.
With a wingspan of 20 to 24 feet, Pelagornis sandersi was more than twice as big as the Royal ...