(Press-News.org) RIVERSIDE, Calif. (http://www.ucr.edu) -- Ideas from mid-level managers that can benefit an organization are less likely to be passed up to superiors as hierarchy in the organization increases, according to a just published paper by an assistant professor at the University of California, Riverside.
"I like to call this hermit crab syndrome," said Boris Maciejovsky, an assistant professor of management at UC Riverside's School of Business Administration. "When mid-level managers feel their ideas are not reflected in top management decisions they withdraw, like a hermit crab retreating into its shell."
Maciejovsky co-authored the paper, "Corporate Hierarchy and Vertical Information Flow Inside the Firm: A Behavioral View," which was just published online in the Strategic Management Journal, with Markus Reitzig, a professor of strategy at the University of Vienna.
The researchers set out to study how corporate hierarchies influence managers' propensity to pass information upward within an organization. Two research fields arrive at seemingly conflicting and untested conclusions on this question.
Information economists argue that middle managers pass more suggestions up the firm's line of command as the corporate hierarchy increases to avoid "omission errors," that is dismissing ideas that could have been profitable.
In contrast, organizational psychologists assume, and have some preliminary evidence, that mid-level managers shy away from promoting risky ideas because if they turn out to be non-profitable there is fear of negative repercussions. Researchers call this evaluation apprehension.
The second thing that might happen according to psychologists is that if superiors weed out these ideas, managers might feel detached from the organization and no longer contribute. Researchers call this lack of control.
In both cases, organizational psychologists predict the more hierarchical an organization, the fewer ideas that are passed on.
In the just published paper, the researchers study these two points of view by using three methods.
First, they used a dataset based on nearly 10,000 observations from employees at a large, multi-national consumer good firm headquartered in Europe. Second, they conducted simulation studies to outline the mechanisms that increase or decrease the propensity of managers to pass up information to their superiors. Finally, they conducted an experimental study with business students that tested whether people are more likely to be characterized by the informational economics view or the organizational psychology view.
The researchers' findings add to the more refined picture developing of the true role of middle managers. Specifically, the findings back up previous research that highlights the challenges of using middle managers to counterbalance the actions of CEOs who pursue overly narrow strategic trajectories.
The researchers argue the most interesting practical consequence is that organizational designers can promote or counterbalance their employees' behavior.
"Ultimately, top management needs to decide how the costs of screening ideas compare to the costs of omitting good ideas," Reitzig said. "What we can tell them, however, is how they can adjust the idea funnel to either see more or fewer suggestions from their subordinates end up on their table - by understanding the effects hierarchies have on the behavior of their employees."
INFORMATION:
In a breakthrough that could substantially improve physicians' ability to rapidly evaluate patients with suspected Ebola, radiologists at Emory University Hospital have devised a protocol for obtaining chest radiographs using portable computed radiography. The protocol not only limits the exposure of personnel and equipment to body fluids, it also minimizes the risk of contaminants leaving the isolation unit by use of thorough decontamination procedures.
The step-by-step protocol is outlined in an article published ahead of print in the American Journal of Roentgenology ...
A biological process in the brains of zebra finches shows that the songbirds respond quickly to trauma and are capable of controlling the natural inflammation that occurs to protect the brain from injury.
Understanding the process well enough could lead to therapies in humans to control inflammation and hasten recovery from brain injury such as stroke, said American University Prof. Colin Saldanha, who presented new research findings during the annual meeting of the Society for Neuroscience. Through experiments, Saldanha and his colleagues' found that estrogen-producing ...
The adage 'you are what you eat' has been around for years. Now, important new research provides another reason to be careful with your calories.
Neuroscientists at NYU Langone Medical Center have shown that calorie-reduced diets stop the normal rise and fall in activity levels of close to 900 different genes linked to aging and memory formation in the brain.
In a presentation prepared for the Society for Neuroscience annual meeting in Washington, D.C., on Nov. 17, researchers say their experimental results, conducted in female mice, suggest how diets with fewer calories ...
CHICAGO - Routine heart imaging screenings for people with diabetes at high risk to experience a cardiac event, but who have no symptoms of heart disease, does not help them avoid heart attacks, hospitalization for unstable angina or cardiac death, according to a major new study.
Instead, high-quality diabetes care is still the most effective way for diabetics to avoid heart attacks, according to the study by researchers at the Intermountain Medical Center Heart Institute in Murray, Utah.
Researchers will present their findings from the study at the 2014 American ...
In contrast to previous assumptions, conservation schemes that focus only on forests may thus fail to significantly reduce CO2 emissions from land-use change. If ecosystem protection policies aim at climate protection, they need to cover the whole range of land types, according to comprehensive computer simulations. To compensate for such restrictions on land use, intensification of agriculture to generate higher yields is important.
"While protecting forests to abate climate change is definitely worthwhile, our results illustrate for the first time that forest protection ...
BOSTON - Since the discovery that microRNAs play key roles in regulating human disease, the hope has been that these short non-coding RNA molecules could be translated into a therapeutic strategy for the treatment of cancer. But this promising application has been significantly hampered by a number of physiological and cellular barriers that prevent microRNA-based therapies from actually reaching tumor cells.
Now scientists have identified a novel delivery platform by which an antisense molecule - akin to the mirror image of the microRNA - can be used to exploit a unique ...
Small pieces of synthetic RNA trigger a RNA interference (RNAi) response that holds great therapeutic potential to treat a number of diseases, especially cancer and pandemic viruses. The problem is delivery -- it is extremely difficult to get RNAi drugs inside the cells in which they are needed. To overcome this hurdle, researchers at University of California, San Diego School of Medicine have developed a way to chemically disguise RNAi drugs so that they are able to enter cells. Once inside, cellular machinery converts these disguised drug precursors -- called siRNNs -- ...
Northwestern Medicine scientists have discovered a new potential drug therapy for a rare, incurable pediatric brain tumor by targeting a genetic mutation found in children with the cancer.
By inhibiting the tumor-forming consequences of the mutation using an experimental drug called GSKJ4, they delayed tumor growth and prolonged survival in mice with pediatric brainstem glioma.
Also known as diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG), the disease occurs when tumors form in the brainstem, which controls essential body functions such as breathing, heartbeat and motor and ...
BOSTON - A research team led by Brigham and Women's Hospital (BWH) and Dana-Farber Cancer Institute (DFCI) has uncovered surprising new findings that underscore the role of an important signaling pathway, already known to be critical in cancer, in the development of type 2 diabetes. Their results, published in the November 17, 2014 advance online issue of the journal Nature, shed additional light on how a longstanding class of diabetes drugs, known as thiazolidinediones (TZDs), work to improve glucose metabolism and suggest that inhibitors of the signaling pathway -- known ...
PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] -- Ample evidence of ancient rivers, streams, and lakes make it clear that Mars was at some point warm enough for liquid water to flow on its surface. While that may conjure up images of a tropical Martian paradise, new research published today in Nature Geoscience throws a bit of cold water on that notion.
The study, by scientists from Brown University and Israel's Weizmann Institute of Science, suggests that warmth and water flow on ancient Mars were probably episodic, related to brief periods of volcanic activity that spewed tons ...
