(Press-News.org) Due to a lack of suitable studies, no conclusions can be drawn on the patient-relevant benefit or harm of screening for asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) in pregnant women. The benefit of antibiotic treatment of ASB following screening is also an open issue, as the results of the over 40-year-old studies cannot be applied to the current healthcare situation. This is the result of the final report published by the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) on 23 April 2015, which was commissioned by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA).
Maternity guidelines specify routine screening for ASB
In ASB, the bacteria in the urine do not cause symptoms of a urinary tract infection; ASB can thus be detected only by tests. The midstream urine of pregnant women is usually tested. According to old studies, untreated ASB leads to a kidney infection (pyelonephritis) in about a quarter of cases. A link may also exist between bacteriuria and an increased risk of preterm birth.
To evaluate the benefit of screening for ASB for the mother and the child, it would seem reasonable to compare this strategy with a management strategy without screening. In Germany, like in many other countries, screening for ASB has been a fixed component of antenatal screening for many years due to its alleged benefit. This is why no such comparative study could be identified. Alternatively, the Institute investigated the benefit and harm of treatment of ASB detected by screening compared with non-treatment or placebo. If the benefit of such treatment in affected women were proven, at least the basic precondition for a benefit of screening would be fulfilled.
Healthcare situation has changed
Three studies on this question published between 1960 and 1969 were identified. The most important patient-relevant outcomes were neonatal morbidity, pyelonephritis, and lower urinary tract infection. For the two latter outcomes, in each case a hint of an effect of antibiotic treatment was found.
But these over 40-year-old study results are not applicable to the current healthcare situation. In part, before the study the participants were subjected to measures that are no longer common in healthy pregnant women and that could have influenced the treatment effect. It part it remains unclear how ASB was determined, so that effects cannot be clearly allocated to a diagnostic procedure. In addition, in all studies information on the main characteristics of the study populations is missing, which makes the interpretation of results more difficult.
Furthermore, potential harm from the antibiotics commonly used in the 1960s was hardly investigated. As different antibiotics are currently used to treat ASB, the benefit-harm ratio could have shifted since then - either in favour of screening or in favour of a watchful waiting strategy. The question of whether pregnant women or their children benefit from screening is therefore just as unclear as the question of whether they benefit from antibiotic treatment of ASB detected by Screening.
Complications caused by ASB rarer than expected
In the Netherlands screening for ASB is so far only recommended for high risk groups. This is why studies including unscreened control groups are possible. However, in a current comparative study there was a problem in the interim analysis: The events defined as study outcomes, pyelonephritis and preterm birth, occurred considerably less often than expected. In comparison with former times, this indicates a markedly decreased incidence of upper urinary tract infections. It is possible that nowadays pregnant women with ASB experience far fewer complications; this could have also shifted the ratio between the advantages and disadvantages of screening.
Clarification meaningful and feasible
"The question as to how beneficial a general screening for ASB in pregnant women is should also be posed again in Germany", says Stefan Sauerland, Head of IQWiG's Non-Drug Intervention Department. "Such a study would be feasible and ethically justifiable if one excluded certain high-risk groups so that antibiotic treatment would not be withheld from them in the placebo arm.
However, the termination of recruitment in the Dutch study shows that the sample size must be planned on the basis of the current incidence of pyelonephritis, which is apparently lower than it was 40 or 50 years ago. It could then also be determined which screening strategy is shown to be the better choice; for instance, one-off screening by means of urine culture or several paper strip tests during the course of pregnancy. In addition, both the mother and the child should be monitored beyond birth to detect late complications."
Process of report production
IQWiG published the preliminary results in the form of the preliminary report in October 2014 and interested parties were invited to submit comments. At the end of the commenting procedure, the preliminary report was revised and sent as a final report to the commissioning agency in February 2015. The written comments submitted were published in a separate document at the same time as the final report. The report was produced in collaboration with external experts.
The (German-language) executive summary provides an overview of the background, procedure and further results of the final report. An English-language summary will soon be available.
INFORMATION:
A team of scientists has shed light on the dynamics of the creation, collaboration and dissemination processes involved in classical music works and styles. Their study focuses on analysing networks of composers contemporary to CD publications, using modern data analysis and data modelling techniques. These findings have just been published in EPJ Data Science by Doheum Park from the Graduate School of Culture Technology at Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology in Daejeon and colleagues. This work explores the nature of culture in novel ways, as part of a broader ...
This news release is available in French. Quebec City, April 30, 2015--Noroviruses, a group of viruses responsible for over 50% of global gastroenteritis cases, can spread by air up to several meters from an infected person according to a new study by Université Laval researchers. The discovery, details of which are presented in the latest issue of Clinical Infectious Diseases, suggests that measures applied in hospitals during gastroenteritis outbreaks may be insufficient to effectively contain this kind of infection.
The team led by Caroline Duchaine, professor ...
TAMPA, Fla. - DNA can be damaged by different environmental insults, such as ultraviolet light, ionizing radiation, oxidative stress or certain drugs. If the DNA is not repaired, cells may begin growing uncontrollably, leading to the development of cancer. Therefore, cells must maintain an intricate regulatory network to ensure that their DNA remains intact. Moffitt Cancer Center researchers have discovered a novel mechanism that controls a cell's response to DNA damage.
The protein SIRT1 plays an important role in controlling DNA damage. It can sense the presence of ...
Few doctors are prescribing a low-cost drug that has been proven effective in preventing the onset of diabetes, according to a UCLA study. The study, published in the peer-reviewed journal Annals of Internal Medicine, found that only 3.7 percent of U.S. adults with pre-diabetes were prescribed metformin during a recent three-year period.
Metformin and lifestyle changes both can prevent the onset of diabetes, but people often struggle to adopt healthier habits, according to Dr. Tannaz Moin, the study's lead author and an assistant professor of medicine in the division ...
The international Solar Wind Sherpas team, led by Dr. Shadia Habbal of the University of Hawaii at Manoa Institute for Astronomy, braved Arctic weather to successfully observe the total solar eclipse of March 20 from Longyearbyen on the island of Spitsbergen in the Svalbard archipelago east of northern Greenland. Their preliminary results are being presented Thursday at the Triennial Earth-Sun Summit in Indianapolis, IN.
It was no easy feat. Ever-changing weather predictions, subfreezing temperatures of -4 degrees F (-20 C) and the danger from polar bears were some of ...
Silica dust hazards in large gold mines have been well documented, but the situation is far worse in small-scale gold mining according to a new study.
The new research in the article "Silica Exposures in Artisanal Small-Scale Gold Mining in Tanzania and Implications for Tuberculosis Prevention" shows that exposures to silica are more than two hundred times greater in small-scale artisanal mines than in larger mines. Hundreds of thousands of miners have already come down with silicosis and rates of tuberculosis (TB) among miners in Africa are approximately 5-6 times higher ...
Pathological gamblers "see" patterns in things that are actually quite random and not really there, to such a degree that they are quite willing to impulsively bet good money on such illusory nonrandomness. This is confirmed by Wolfgang Gaissmaier of the University of Konstanz in Germany and Andreas Wilke of Clarkson University in the USA, leaders of a study in Springer's Journal of Gambling Studies that sheds light on why some people are gamblers and others not.
The findings of the study add to a large body of research that suggests that cognitive distortions (or people's ...
Researchers at the Helmholtz Zentrum München now report the discovery of a very unexpected role for one such lncRNA, which they call PARTICLE, in regulating the response of cells to ionizing radiation.
Biophysical studies have shown that the damage arising to cells from an exposure to ionizing radiation declines in a linearly manner with decreasing dose, with some damage still occurring even at the lowest doses. This linear no-threshold (LNT) dose-response relationship has been used to extrapolate the risks of low doses of radiation from epidemiological studies that ...
Researchers at the University of Liverpool have found that people who eat different types and brands of commonly available food items, such as pizza, are more likely to overeat than people who tend to consume the same brand.
Psychologists from the Universities of Liverpool and Bristol undertook the first study of its kind to look at the effect of the wide variety of types and brands of mass-produced foods on consumption. Importantly.
The number of varieties of the same food product that are available to consumers has increased dramatically since the 1970s and the use ...
For the past 50 years, researchers at Sahlgrenska Academy have followed the health of 855 Gothenburg men born in 1913. Now that the study is being wrapped up, it turns out that ten of the subjects lived to 100 and conclusions can be drawn about the secrets of their longevity.
Over the past half century, the University Gothenburg has hosted one of the world's first prospective studies of aging. The subjects are 855 Gothenburg men born in 1913.
The first surveys were conducted in 1963.Now that it has been determined that ten of the men lived to 100, the study is being ...
