(Press-News.org) Weekly COVID-19 testing, with two-week isolation of positive cases, is the most cost-effective strategy to mitigate spread of the virus in the USA when transmission is high in affected areas until vaccines are widely available.
When transmission rates are low to moderate, monthly testing and a one-week isolation period is the most cost-effective approach.
Monthly population testing is more cost-effective than the current strategy of testing only people showing symptoms and their close contacts.
Weekly COVID-19 testing, coupled with a two-week isolation period for positive cases, may be the most cost-effective strategy to tackle the spread of SARS-CoV-2 in the USA when transmission is high until vaccines are widely available, a modelling study published in The Lancet Public Health journal suggests.
The study is the first to identify cost-effective strategies based on local transmission rates, the cost of testing and hospitalisations, and a societal willingness to pay in order to prevent COVID-19 deaths.
Since the pandemic began, countries worldwide have taken robust steps to mitigate the spread of the virus, including restrictions on movement, social distancing measures, and face mask requirements. To date, there have been more than 24 million confirmed COVID-19 cases in the USA and in excess of 400,000 deaths. Globally, more than 96 million cases and over two million deaths have been reported. Estimated economic costs in the USA exceeded $21 trillion in 2020.
This study suggests that until effective vaccines or antiviral drugs become widely available, mass testing is the best way to quickly identify and isolate infected cases. While testing was initially slow and relatively expensive, costs have decreased rapidly, with $5 tests that produce results in 15 minutes now becoming more available.
To evaluate the economic trade-offs of expanding and accelerating COVID-19 testing in the USA, the authors devised a model of 1,000 households that was scaled-up to represent the country's 328 million residents. The model incorporated population-level transmission rates and viral load dynamics - the amount of virus being produced by infected people - at the individual level.
The authors performed statistical analyses on eight scenarios in which people are tested at a frequency ranging from daily to monthly, coupled with a one- or two-week isolation period for confirmed cases. For each scenario, the authors assumed each rapid test cost $5, and that members of society are willing for government to spend $100,000 to prevent each year of life potentially lost due to COVID-19. The effectiveness of each strategy was determined taking account of rates of illness and death from COVID-19, testing and hospitalisation costs, and salary lost while in isolation.
The authors found that the most cost-effective strategy when transmission is high - when the reproduction number, or R number, is 2 or above - is weekly testing of everyone in the affected area followed by a two-week isolation period for confirmed cases. At present, the R number at state level is estimated to range from around 0.59 to 1.57 [1], though local-level transmission within states can vary widely.
When transmission is low to moderate - an R number below 1.9 - monthly testing followed by one week of isolation, rather than two, is likely to be most cost-efficient. The analysis indicated that loss of salary in the second week outweighs the costs of infections that occur during the same period.
The study also reveals that monthly testing across the USA - which would require 12 million tests per day - is more cost-effective than the current status quo approach of testing only people with symptoms and their close contacts, assuming each test cost $75 or less. The current cost of a single at-home test in the USA tends to range from around $25-$50.
Professor Lauren Ancel Meyers, of the University of Austin at Texas, USA, said: "Vastly expanding COVID-19 testing capacity in the US, and tailoring testing and isolation strategies depending on the local rate of transmission, has the potential to help deliver vital public health and economic benefits. While the up-front costs of mass testing might seem high, our results show that this approach is a cost-effective way of saving lives and mitigating the unprecedented threats posed by the pandemic until many more people are vaccinated.
"The logistics of implementing the mass testing could prove very challenging, requiring not only large quantities of tests, but also community compliance with the recommended testing and isolation procedures and coordinated distribution plans that may involve school, university and workplace testing, as well as the delivery of home testing kits and the establishment of public testing sites. We hope our study will help to inform policies that make these strategies more feasible."
The authors acknowledge some limitations to their study. Optimal testing strategies - which require large quantities of tests and sophisticated distribution plans - may not be logistically feasible everywhere. For the purposes of the study, it was also assumed that people who have had COVID-19 cannot be re-infected. However, there is uncertainty about long-term immunity, with some evidence suggesting it may reduce over time following recovery.
The team's economic calculations have limited scope, as they consider only testing costs and loss of salary during isolation. However, asymptomatic people who test positive may incur additional costs by seeking healthcare when they would otherwise not have suspected they were infected. While the authors quantified the economic benefits of averting deaths and hospitalisations, they did not consider the impact of preventing non-fatal illness, or indirect health and mental health effects.
INFORMATION:
NOTES TO EDITORS
This study was funded by US National Institutes of Health, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and a donation from Love, Tito's (the philanthropic arm of Tito's Homemade Vodka, Austin, TX, USA) to the University of Texas to support the modeling of COVID-19 transmission and mitigation strategies. It was conducted by researchers from University of Texas at Austin, Yale School of Public Health, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Northeastern University, US, and University of Hong Kong, China.
The labels have been added to this press release as part of a project run by the Academy of Medical Sciences seeking to improve the communication of evidence. For more information, please see: http://www.sciencemediacentre.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/AMS-press-release-labelling-system-GUIDANCE.pdf if you have any questions or feedback, please contact The Lancet press office pressoffice@lancet.com
[1] Estimates according to https://rt.live/
[2] Quote direct from author and cannot be found in the text of the Article.
Peer-reviewed / Modelling / People
A biologist from RUDN University confirmed that selenium nanoparticles and garlic extract can effectively reduce the negative impact of stress on the health of grass carp in the breeding industry. The results of his study were published in the Journal of the World Aquaculture Society.
Grass carp or Ctenopharyngodon Idella is a valuable commercial fish type. In order to increase productivity, fish farms tend to breed more and more fish in small reservoirs. This extreme population density causes stress in carps that negatively affects their health, namely, reduces immunity, slows down growth, suppresses digestion, and interferes with intestinal functions. To mitigate ...
Cancer is a significant cause of death worldwide and many efforts have been devoted to the development of methods for early detection. Telomerase are considered as a tumor biomarker for early diagnosis because the telomerase of more than 80% immortalized cells are reactivated and provides the sustained proliferative capacity of these cells, but the telomerase activity are not detectable in normal somatic cells. Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein complex that is thought to add telomeric repeats onto the ends of chromosomes during the replicative phase (S ...
DETROIT - Wayne State University School of Medicine researchers have reported that zinc supplements for men and women attempting to conceive either naturally or through assisted reproduction during the COVID-19 pandemic may prevent mitochondrial damage in young egg and sperm cells, as well as enhance immunity against the virus.
In "Potential Role of Zinc in the COVID-19 Disease Process and its Probable Impact on Reproduction," published in Reproductive Sciences, Husam Abu-Soud, Ph.D., associate professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology and the C.S. Mott Center for Growth and Development, ...
Sexual assault and sexual harassment are significant problems in the U.S. military and military service academies in the United States. In 2018, 15.8% of female and 2.4% of male cadets and midshipmen across the military service academies reported unwanted sexual contact in the past year. This unwanted behavior can contribute to a variety of negative mental and behavioral health outcomes.
While the military service academies have implemented multiple sexual assault prevention programs and social marketing campaigns to improve awareness of and response to sexual assault, prevention initiatives have been hindered by an absence of evidence ...
Gun violence among children is lower in states with more gun laws, according to a Rutgers-led study.
The study, published in the Journal of Youth and Adolescence, examined youth gun and weapon carrying data from 2005 and 2017 across several states. Researchers found the rates of youths carrying guns was higher in states and lower in states with more gun laws. According to researchers, this phenomenon could be associated with large urban areas and more significant safety concerns within these areas.
Louisiana and Arkansas reported the highest percentages of youth reporting gun carrying behavior in 2017 and 2013 respectively, with 12.7 percent and 12.5 percent respectively. These two states had 13 gun laws in place while the lowest rates of gun carrying among ...
If you're about to buy something online and its only customer review is negative, you'd probably reconsider the purchase, right? It turns out a product's first review can have an outsized effect on the item's future -- it can even cause the product to fail.
Shoppers, retailers and manufacturers alike feel the effects of customer reviews. Researchers at the University of Florida's Warrington College of Business looked at the influence of the first review after noticing the exact same products getting positive reviews on one retailer's website but negative reviews on others, said Sungsik Park, Ph.D., who studied the phenomenon ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio - Considering the greater good by social distancing during a pandemic turns out to have an attractive personal benefit: A new study has found that staying away from others also reduces an individual person's chances of contracting COVID-19.
Researchers presented study participants with virtual behavior scenarios of various public settings - a grocery store, a crowded beach, a crosswalk - and asked them to place themselves or fictional people in those contexts based on their social distancing preferences.
Four months later, the participants were asked if they had tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 infection or otherwise believed they had been sick with a case of COVID-19.
Statistical analyses ...
Scientists like the John A. Moran Eye Center's Paul S. Bernstein, MD, PhD, know a special class of lipids, or fatty acids, found in the retina of the eye and in just a few other parts of the body play an important role in maintaining vision.
But it's been difficult to study whether giving these lipids, called very-long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (VLC-PUFAs), to patients as a supplement could prevent blinding eye diseases like age-related macular degeneration, diabetic retinopathy, and some inherited retinal diseases. Made in the body by the ELOVL4 enzyme but rarely consumed as part of a normal diet, VLC-PUFAs weren't commercially available ...
In nuclear physics so-called magic number are such nuclear proton and/or neutron numbers, for which the nucleus is more stable compared to neighboring isotopes on the nuclear chart. Researchers in both experimental and theoretical nuclear physics from University of Jyväskylä, Finland, took part of international research team, which studied the nuclear charge radii of potassium isotopes. Isotopes were studied by using the collinear resonance ionization spectroscopy technique. The results indicated that the potassium isotope with a neutron number of 32 does not conform with criteria of magic neutron number. The results were published in Nature Physics journal on January 2021.
Far from the stable ...
Lead halide perovskites, with high refractive index and excellent optoelectronic property, have been used in both constructing high-quality optical resonators/lasers and fabricating high-efficiency light-emitting devices for advanced displays. Lenticular printing provides an illusion of depth and shows varying images upon view angles, which is considered as a promising approach towards future stereoscopic displays. To realize lenticular-printing-based display, it is required to modulate the outcoupling direction of emission light rather than that of incident light. Ideally, the lenticular-lens-like structures would be integrated into the active layer of light-emitting devices. Therefore, the hybrid perovskite becomes a promising candidate for ...
