(Press-News.org) Study: "Do Students in Gifted Programs Perform Better? Linking Gifted Program Participants to Achievement and Nonachievement Outcomes"
Authors: Christopher Redding (University of Florida), Jason A. Grissom (Vanderbilt University)
This study will be presented today at the AERA 2021 Virtual Annual Meeting.
Session: On the Road to Equity: Studies of the Impact and Influences of Education Policy
Date/Time: Saturday, April 10, 2:30 p.m. - 4:00 p.m. ET
Main Findings:
Participating in elementary school gifted programs is associated with reading and math achievement for the average student, though the observed relationships are small. Black and low-income students do not see the academic gains that their peers experience when receiving gifted services.
There is no evidence that participating in a gifted program is related to nonachievement outcomes such as student absences, engagement in school, or whether a student leaves or stays in a school.
Details:
The authors note that the growing concerns about inequitable access have made public investment in gifted programs controversial in many school districts. However, some believe that gifted services provide necessary enrichment for exceptional students to succeed at schools.
Although prior research has shown participation in gifted programs in single school districts can have positive effects on student achievement, whether such positive effects hold on average across school districts is less clear.
For their study, the authors analyzed nationally representative data from the National Center for Educational Statistics that followed a cohort of 18,170 students who began kindergarten in the 2010-2011 school year through their elementary years.
In reading, the authors found that the typical student who ever received gifted services scores at the 78th percentile in years in which he or she does not receive services but the 80th percentile in years of service receipt. In math, the typical student scores at the 76th percentile in years he or she does not receive gifted services but the 77th percentile in years of service receipt.
Study findings indicate that Black and low-income students do not see the academic gains that their peers experience when receiving gifted services.
The authors found no evidence that gifted programs were positively related to nonachievement outcomes tested.
The study confirmed prior research that indicates Black and Hispanic students are underrepresented in gifted programs, and students in gifted programs have much higher socioeconomic status. Students in gifted programs are more likely to speak English at home, be rated by their parents as having excellent health, and were slightly older when entering kindergarten.
The study does not find evidence that state policies--including the presence of a formal definition of giftedness, mandates for gifted services or identification, guidance on gifted identification, required teacher training in gifted education or monitoring of gifted programs, and funding for gifted programs--are associated with differential gains in math and reading.
"Gifted education has faced longstanding criticism that historically marginalized groups have insufficient access to gifted and talented programs," said coauthor Christopher Redding, an assistant professor of educational leadership at the University of Florida. "Even among Black and low-income students who gain access to gifted programs, our results suggest that the benefits of gifted services may not be equally distributed."
"This amplifies questions by others about the capacity of the typical gifted program to support and enrich increasingly diverse student populations," Redding said. "We urge gifted educators to take a close look at their offerings to assess whether they are adequate for serving the needs of high-ability students from historically marginalized groups."
"State policymakers can also take steps to increase the effectiveness of gifted programs in their states, both on average and for diverse student populations," said Redding. "While our study did not find clear evidence of an association between state-level gifted policies and positive student outcomes, we suggest state policymakers closely review the guidance they provide on what gifted services should be offered and how students should be identified to receive them."
To request a copy of the working paper, or to talk to study authors, please contact AERA Communications: Tony Pals, Director of Communications, tpals@aera.net, cell: (202) 288-9333; Tong Wu, Communications Associate, twu@aera.net, cell: (202) 957-3802
INFORMATION:
About AERA
The American Educational Research Association (AERA) is the largest national interdisciplinary research association devoted to the scientific study of education and learning. Founded in 1916, AERA advances knowledge about education, encourages scholarly inquiry related to education, and promotes the use of research to improve education and serve the public good. Find AERA on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
There are many questions surrounding the elementary particle neutrino, in particular regarding its mass. Physicists are also interested in whether besides the "classic" neutrinos there are variants such as the so-called sterile neutrinos. The KATRIN experiment has now succeeded in strongly narrowing the search for these elusive particles. The publication appeared recently in the journal Physical Review Letters.
Strictly speaking, the neutrino is not a singleparticle but rather comprises several species: the electron neutrino, the muon neutrino, and the tau neutrino. These particles are constantly transforming ...
A team of researchers from the Max Planck Institutes of Developmental Biology in Tübingen and the Max Planck Computing and Data Facility in Garching develops new search capabilities that will allow to compare the biochemical makeup of different species from across the tree of life. Its combination of accuracy and speed is hitherto unrivalled.
Humans share many sequences of nucleotides that make up our genes with other species - with pigs in particular, but also with mice and even bananas. Accordingly, some proteins in our bodies - strings of amino acids assembled according to the blueprint of the genes - can also be the same as (or similar to) some proteins in other species. These similarities might sometimes indicate that two species ...
A team of scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology in Tübingen and the University of Bayreuth have created a novel tool that provides a real-time visualization of the growth-regulating hormone auxin in living plant cells. This new biosensor enables them to observe spatial and temporal redistribution dynamics of the plant hormone, for example in conjunction with changing environmental conditions.
Auxin plays a central role in plant life. The hormone regulates various processes, from embryonic development to the formation of roots and the directional growth in response to light and gravity. Auxin binds to specific receptors in the nucleus of a cell, leading to an activation of signaling cascades that ...
Study: "The Infrastructure of Social Control: A Multi-Level Counterfactual Analysis of Surveillance, Punishment, Achievement, and Persistence"
Authors: Odis Johnson (Johns Hopkins University), Jason F. Jabbari (Washington University in St. Louis)
This study will be presented today at the AERA 2021 Virtual Annual Meeting.
Session: The School-to-Prison and Prison-to-School Pipelines: Studies of the Nexus of Schooling and the Justice System
Date/Time: Sunday, April 11, 10:40 a.m. - 12:10 p.m. ET
Main Findings:
After controlling for levels of school social disorder and student misbehavior, students attending ...
New research by Yale Cancer Center shows insights into modeling resistance to immune checkpoint inhibitors, a form of cancer immunotherapy. The study was presented today at the American Association of Cancer Research (AACR) virtual annual meeting.
"Acquired resistance to immune checkpoint inhibitors is a growing clinical challenge. About 50% of lung cancer patients who initially respond to immune checkpoint inhibitors eventually develop acquired resistance to these therapies," said Camila Robles-Oteiza, lead author of the study from Yale Cancer Center. ...
CORVALLIS, Ore. - Coastal communities face increasing danger from rising water and storms, but the level of risk will be more closely tied to policy decisions regarding development than the varying conditions associated with climate change, new research by Oregon State University suggests.
The findings, published in the journal Water, provide an important framework for managing the interactions between human-made and natural systems in cities and towns along shorelines as the Earth continues to warm, the researchers said.
Professor Peter Ruggiero of OSU's College of Earth, Ocean, and Atmospheric Sciences and John Bolte, chair of OSU's Biological and Ecological Engineering program, led the study, which employed a modeling platform known as ...
Groundbreaking research from Tel Aviv University may lead to a significant breakthrough in the battle against deadly brain cancer. To begin with, the researchers identified a failure in the brain's immune system, leading to the amplification of cell division and spread of Glioblastoma cancer cells. The failure results partially from the secretion of a protein called P-Selectin (SELP), which, when bound to its receptor on the brain immune cells, alters their function so that instead of inhibiting the spread of cancer cells, they do the opposite, enabling them to proliferate and penetrate brain tissues.
At the next stage of the study, the researchers were able to inhibit the secretion of the SELP protein, thereby neutralizing the failure in the immune system, restoring its normal activity, ...
A comprehensive analysis of 80 scientific studies has identified a 'window of impairment' of between three and 10 hours caused by moderate to high doses of the intoxicating component of cannabis, tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). The findings have implications for the application of drug-driving laws globally, researchers say.
The study found the exact duration of impairment depends on the dose of THC, whether the THC is inhaled or taken orally, whether the cannabis user is regular or occasional and the demands of the task being undertaken while intoxicated.
The study represents the first ...
The search for life on other planets has received a major boost after scientists revealed the spectral signatures of almost 1000 atmospheric molecules that may be involved in the production or consumption of phosphine, a study led by UNSW Sydney revealed.
Scientists have long conjectured that phosphine - a chemical compound made of one phosphorous atom surrounded by three hydrogen atoms (PH3) - may indicate evidence of life if found in the atmospheres of small rocky planets like our own, where it is produced by the biological activity of bacteria.
So when an international team of scientists last year claimed to ...
The economies of northern Central Asia rely heavily on agriculture and are particularly affected by changes in the local hydrological cycle. However, this region is one of the largest dryland regions in the Northern Hemisphere and is facing a crisis of water resources shortage in recent decades. One example is the rapid desiccation and salinization of the Aral Sea. While the construction of dams, diversion of waterways and wasting of water have been blamed for the shortage, how climate change has influenced regional water resources remains unknown.
In a recently published research article in Geophysical Research Letters (drying trend over northern Central Asia), Jie Jiang and Tianjun Zhou from the Institute of Atmospheric Physics, Chinese ...
