PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

As plant/animal diversity wanes, is microbial life changing too? A perilously 'profound Ignorance'

The unknown direction and pace of change in microbial -- including viral -- biodiversity may have deep consequences for all life on Earth

As plant/animal diversity wanes, is microbial life changing too? A perilously 'profound Ignorance'
2021-04-19
(Press-News.org) With alarms sounding about the declining diversity of plants and animals, a related concern with equally profound implications is posed: is the variety of microbial life, including viruses, changing too -- and if so, in which direction and how fast?

In a paper published today, David S. Thaler of the University of Basel, Switzerland, and Guest Investigator at The Rockefeller University's Programme for the Human Environment (PHE), notes the well-documented, "clearly downwards" trajectory of plant and animal diversity, constituting "a key issue of the Anthropocene."

Whether change is underway also in the world of microbes -- the tiniest cogs in planetary functioning -- is "a complete unknown. We have no idea whether global microbial diversity is increasing, decreasing, or staying the same," says Dr. Thaler.

"Most scientific papers tell us new facts. This is a different kind of paper; it does not answer anything but asks a new question," says Dr. Thaler.

"Socrates called ignorance of what we do not know 'profound ignorance.' This kind of ignorance was also famously termed 'unknown unknowns' (youtu.be/GiPe1OiKQuk) by former US Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. Today's paper identifies what is (or was, as of now) a biological 'unknown unknown'."

Dr. Thaler points out that assessing plant and animal biodiversity involves counting different species within a given timeframe, and then comparing a subsequent count. By doing so, we learned that some species have recently become extinct, and many exist in fewer numbers, with an estimated one million at risk of extinction within decades.

The same approach has been used to monitor, for example, changes in microbial diversity in an intestine due to dietary changes.

Unfortunately, says Dr Thaler, it may be impossible to "count everything at different times" to figure out the direction of change in global microbial biodiversity because: The extent of current microbial biodiversity is unknown, and a large fraction of the microbial world may exist in hard-to-access, rare, or extreme environments -- the deeper the depth, the less we know. Previous research has theorized that the deep hot biosphere may contain the majority of our planet's microbial biodiversity. Resolving this problem might require 20 years before there is a sufficient understanding of the deep biosphere and other hard-to-access environments.

A possible 'chicken and egg' paradox may prove hard to resolve: Establishing a baseline sequence library may never be finished because new diversity is generated more rapidly than it is measured. If some or all parts of microbial diversity are rapidly increasing, then survey approaches may never catch up to this dynamic process. Says Dr. Thaler: The world is finding hundreds of variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes COVID-19, one of a very roughly estimated 10 billion different kinds of microbes each evolving in its own ways.

(Dr. Thaler cites a Harvard Medical School video, at https://youtu.be/plVk4NVIUh8, documenting how quickly bacteria can mutate to overcome increasing higher concentrations of antibiotics. Meanwhile, a recent study (bit.ly/IPBESpandemics) also estimates that there are more than 1 million animal viruses, about half of them potentially infectious to humans.)

"Microbial evolution is not always toward greater diversity, microbes can also become extinct, smallpox virus being an example," he adds. "Countless other viruses and bacteria probably have also come and gone without our ever having known of their existence. Some microbes are specific in their associations with certain animals and plants. As these plants and animals become extinct, it seems likely that specialized microbes associated with them have also vanished."

"The key point is that with plants and animals we know that the current overall trajectory of Earth's biosphere is toward fewer species, but there is no comparable understanding of the overall trajectory or detailed fine-structure trajectories of microbial evolution."

Possible implications in the trajectory of microbial evolution are not limited to the evolution of pathogens that attack humans or the few species we depend on for our food.

Changes in non-pathogenic microbial life might also have major implications for the biosphere. The importance of these complex communities of microorganisms -- with estimates of up to 10 billion types of microbes alone -- is hard to overstate: They maintain Earth's habitability.

(In 2011, scientists estimated that Earth's plant and animal species (or "macrobes") numbered almost 10 million, meaning therefore that for every "macrobe" species there are 1,000 kinds of microbes, with the same macrobe/microbe ratio applicable to both terrestrial and marine species.)

Humanity depends on the ecological services performed by bacteria, archaea, fungi and protists, which recycle nutrients, nurture plant growth, purify water, make cheese and wine, and decompose wastes. And, by turning atmospheric carbon dioxide back into carbon to be stored in soils or the ocean depths (and doing likewise with nitrogen, sulfur, iron, manganese and more), microbes are key to Earth's atmosphere and climate.

Globally today, heritable DNA sequence information "is probably dominated by microbes, including viruses," Dr. Thaler says. "The intriguing possibility is that macroscopically visible animals and plants may constitute an ever-shrinking proportion of the biosphere's heritable information. We really don't know."

"We probably ought to know if we are on the losing end of a biological information race, however, and might even want to take practical steps to increase the information content of 'our team.' There is also a purely intellectual interest to learn more about our place in the universe of biological information, perhaps analogous to our place in an expanding physical universe."

This is a hard question but hard does not mean impossible, he adds, "what approaches at least begin to address it?"

DNA technologies are an obvious place to look. How might current technologies be applied and how might future developments help?

Two approaches suggest themselves, says Dr. Thaler.

One is to focus on "modulators and vectors" of microbial evolution such as bacterial sex. Other new approaches that might be harnessed include single molecule or single cell (DNA) sequencing.

DNA barcodes and other sequence-based methods used to identify species of plants and animals and to assess the amount of variation within species "invite comparison to measures of microbial biodiversity," Dr Thaler says.

"The clustering pattern seen in macroscopic life seems in a general way also a property of microscopic forms of life. The details of comparison are of interest. There might be quantitative general principles behind the truism that 'life is lumpy'."

In both the microbial and the macroscopic world of visible plants and animals, a 'species' may be considered a cluster "in sequence space," which can be thought of in terms of stars and galaxies, where individuals are stars and species are galaxies.

Concludes Jesse Ausubel, Director of The Rockefeller University's PHE, a sponsor of the study: "Linnaeus started his Systema Naturae in 1735, almost 300 years ago, and we still do not have a complete list of the species of plants and animals that he started to catalogue. It will not be easy to do something similar with probably 1,000 times as many microbes, and measure the changes!"

Visual images from the laboratories of Gary Borisy (Forsyth Institute) and Jessica Mark Welch (Marine Biological Laboratory) show the difficulty of direct counts. A few tens of micrometers, the width of a human hair, span entire diverse, populous communities of microbes.

Dr. Thaler says this paper does not offer "protocols to solve the problem," but tries "to frame the rate of change of microbial biodiversity as an interesting and possibly important question on which progress is possible. I hope that someone reading this paper is stimulated to think of new approaches better than the ones suggested in it."

Adds Mr. Ausubel: "There is no agency yet monitoring the state of the microbial world, and no World Wildlife Fund, no Nature Conservancy for microbes. Perhaps one day soon we will realize and rectify our neglect and lift our respect for the diversity of microbial life."

INFORMATION:

About

Biozentrum, University of Basel
https://bit.ly/3d32Cdn

Programme for Human Environment, The Rockefeller University
https://bit.ly/3dJwgU5


[Attachments] See images for this press release:
As plant/animal diversity wanes, is microbial life changing too? A perilously 'profound Ignorance'

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Under 30 and sexually active? It's a good idea to get tested for chlamydia and gonorrhea

2021-04-19
Anyone sexually active under age 30 should be offered testing for chlamydia and gonorrhea, according to a new guideline from the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care published in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal). Chlamydia and gonorrhea are the most commonly reported sexually transmitted bacterial infections (STIs) in Canada and are treatable with antibiotics. Without treatment, these infections can lead to pelvic inflammatory disease, pain and possibly infertility. "If people are under 30 and sexually active, it's a good idea to get tested," says Dr. Ainsley Moore, a family physician and associate clinical professor, Department of Family Medicine, McMaster University, and chair of the task force chlamydia ...

Videoconferences more exhausting when participants don't feel group belonging

2021-04-19
Videoconferences may be less exhausting if participants feel some sense of group belonging, according to new research published by the American Psychological Association. As remote work and the use of videoconferences have dramatically increased during the coronavirus pandemic, more people are fatigued from meeting through computer screens instead of in person. In this study, 55 employees in various fields in the United States were surveyed about their feelings about videoconferences. The researchers thought longer meetings and being on video would cause the most fatigue, but their findings surprised them, said lead researcher Andrew Bennett, PhD, an assistant professor at Old Dominion University. "We expected that aspects of being on video would be related to fatigue, such ...

Common plants and pollinators act as anchors for ecosystems

Common plants and pollinators act as anchors for ecosystems
2021-04-19
The next time you go for a hike, take an extra moment to appreciate the seemingly ordinary life all around you. A house fly, humble yarrow weed and other "generalist" plants and pollinators play a crucial role in maintaining biodiversity and may also serve as buffers against some impacts of climate change, finds new University of Colorado Boulder research. The findings, published this month in Ecology, provide valuable insights for prioritizing the conservation of species that contribute to the strength of ecological communities. "A lot of times, conservation efforts are geared toward things that are rare. But oftentimes, species that are common are also in decline and could go extinct, and that could have really big repercussions for maintaining biodiversity," ...

Online farmers' markets valuable when crisis events like COVID occur

2021-04-19
New research is shining light on the importance of farmers' markets' ability to mitigate potential disruptions to distribution networks in the face of system shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic. In a recent study, the researchers found the markets' regional characteristics play a key role in the decision to move all or parts of their operations online -- and how that decision can help or hinder its surrounding community. "By building online communities through their social media and website tools, farmers' markets can play a role in keeping the community connected and supporting a sustainable and just food system through the pandemic and beyond," said researcher Josalyn Radcliffe, a PhD student in Waterloo's School of Public Health and ...

Heart patients advised to move more to avoid heart attacks and strokes

2021-04-17
Sophia Antipolis - 17 April 2021: Elevated blood pressure, high cholesterol and diabetes increase the risk of heart disease. But a large study today reveals that in people with these conditions, increasing activity levels is associated with a reduced likelihood of heart events and mortality. The research is presented at ESC Preventive Cardiology 2021, an online scientific congress of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC).1 Study author Dr. Esmée Bakker of Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, the Netherlands said: "Previous research showed that improvements in physical activity are beneficial to health. However, those studies were performed in the general population. In our study, we were interested to see if there were similar effects in individuals with cardiovascular ...

New amphibious centipede species discovered in Okinawa and Taiwan

New amphibious centipede species discovered in Okinawa and Taiwan
2021-04-17
Tokyo, Japan - Researchers from Tokyo Metropolitan University and Hosei University have discovered a new species of large, tropical centipede of genus Scolopendra in Okinawa and Taiwan. It is only the third amphibious centipede identified in the world, and is the largest in the region, 20 cm long and nearly 2 cm thick. It is also the first new centipede to be identified in Japan in 143 years, testament to the incredible biodiversity of the Ryukyu Archipelago. Scolopendra is a genus of large, tropical centipede, one of the original genera named by the father of modern taxonomy himself, Carl Linnaeus. They are strong predators in any soil ecosystems they inhabit, with around 100 different species found in tropical regions around the world. Of these, only five have been ...

Scientists may detect signs of extraterrestrial life in the next 5 to 10 years

Scientists may detect signs of extraterrestrial life in the next 5 to 10 years
2021-04-16
Research shows that a new telescope could detect a potential signature of life on other planets in as little as 60 hours. "What really surprised me about the results is that we may realistically find signs of life on other planets in the next 5 to 10 years," said Caprice Phillips, a graduate student at The Ohio State University, who will share preliminary findings at a END ...

The fate of the planet

The fate of the planet
2021-04-16
From engineered pandemics to city-toppling cyber attacks to nuclear annihilation, life on Earth could radically change, and soon. Scientists will forecast the fate of the planet at a END ...

Tarantula's ubiquity traced back to the cretaceous

2021-04-16
Tarantulas are among the most notorious spiders, due in part to their size, vibrant colors and prevalence throughout the world. But one thing most people don't know is that tarantulas are homebodies. Females and their young rarely leave their burrows and only mature males will wander to seek out a mate. How then did such a sedentary spider come to inhabit six out of seven continents? An international team of researchers, including Carnegie Mellon University's Saoirse Foley, set out on an ancestry.com-like investigation to find the answer to this question. They looked to the transcriptomes, ...

On the pulse of pulsars and polar light

On the pulse of pulsars and polar light
2021-04-16
Faced with the tragic loss of the Arecibo observatory in Puerto Rico and the often prohibitive cost of satellite missions, astronomers are searching for savvy alternatives to continue answering fundamental questions in physics. At a END ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Age matters: Kidney disorder indicator gains precision

New guidelines for managing blood cancers in pregnancy

New study suggests RNA present on surfaces of leaves may shape microbial communities

U.S. suffers from low social mobility. Is sprawl partly to blame?

Research spotlight: Improving predictions about brain cancer outcomes with the right imaging criteria

New UVA professor’s research may boost next-generation space rockets

Multilingualism improves crucial cognitive functions in autistic children

The carbon in our bodies probably left the galaxy and came back on cosmic ‘conveyer belt’

Scientists unveil surprising human vs mouse differences in a major cancer immunotherapy target

NASA’s LEXI will provide X-ray vision of Earth’s magnetosphere

A successful catalyst design for advanced zinc-iodine batteries

AMS Science Preview: Tall hurricanes, snow and wildfire

Study finds 25% of youth experienced homelessness in Denver in 2021, significantly higher than known counts

Integrated spin-wave quantum memory

Brain study challenges long-held views about Parkinson's movement disorders

Mental disorders among offspring prenatally exposed to systemic glucocorticoids

Trends in screening for social risk in physician practices

Exposure to school racial segregation and late-life cognitive outcomes

AI system helps doctors identify patients at risk for suicide

Advanced imaging uncovers hidden metastases in high-risk prostate cancer cases

Study reveals oldest-known evolutionary “arms race”

People find medical test results hard to understand, increasing overall worry

Mizzou researchers aim to reduce avoidable hospitalizations for nursing home residents with dementia

National Diabetes Prevention Program saves costs for enrollees

Research team to study critical aspects of Alzheimer’s and dementia healthcare delivery

Major breakthrough for ‘smart cell’ design

From CO2 to acetaldehyde: Towards greener industrial chemistry

Unlocking proteostasis: A new frontier in the fight against neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's

New nanocrystal material a key step toward faster, more energy-efficient computing

One of the world’s largest social programs greatly reduced tuberculosis among the most vulnerable

[Press-News.org] As plant/animal diversity wanes, is microbial life changing too? A perilously 'profound Ignorance'
The unknown direction and pace of change in microbial -- including viral -- biodiversity may have deep consequences for all life on Earth