PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Machine learning analysis of research citations highlights importance of federal funding for basic scientific research

Researchers found patterns to help identify the citations that were more likely to be important to each piece of published science

2023-09-19
(Press-News.org) Biomedical research aimed at improving human health is particularly reliant on publicly funded basic science, according to a new analysis boosted by artificial intelligence.

“What we found is that even though research funded by the National Institutes of Health makes up 10% of published scientific literature, those published papers account for about 30% of the substantive research — the important contributions supporting even more new scientific findings — cited by further clinical research in the same field,” says B. Ian Hutchins, a professor in the University of Wisconsin–Madison’s Information School, part of the School of Computer, Data & Information Sciences. “That's a pretty big over-representation.”

Hutchins and co-authors Travis Hoppe, now a data scientist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and UW–Madison graduate student Salsabil Arabi, published their findings recently in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Published research papers typically include lengthy sections citing all the previous work supporting or referenced within the study. “Predicting substantive biomedical citations without full text,” the paper by Hutchins and Hoppe that you are reading about right now, cited no fewer than 64 other studies and sources in its “References” section.

Citations represent the transfer of knowledge from one scientist (or group of scientists) to another. Citations are extensively catalogued and tracked to measure the significance of individual studies and of the individuals conducting them, but not all citations included in any given paper make equally important contributions to the research they describe.

“We're taught that as scientists, when we make a factual claim, we're supposed to back it up with some kind of empirical evidence,” Hutchins says. “Like in Wikipedia entries, you can't have the little ‘citation needed here’ flag. You have to add that citation. But if that fact you’re citing isn't actually describing key prior work that you built upon, then it doesn't really support the interpretation that the citation represents a necessary earlier step toward your results.”

Hutchins and his collaborators figured citations added later in the publication process, like those that appear at the behest of peer reviewers — the subject-matter experts that evaluate scientific papers submitted to journals — are less likely to have been truly important to the authors’ research.

“If you’re building on other people's work, you probably identify that work earlier on in the research process,” Hutchins says. “That doesn't mean all the references that are in an early version of the manuscript are important ones, but the important ones are probably more concentrated in that earlier version.”

To make the early-late distinction, the researchers trained a machine learning algorithm to judge citations on their importance by feeding it citation information from a pool of more than 38,000 scholarly papers. Each paper’s citation data came in two versions: a preprint version, posted publicly before peer review, and the eventual published version that had undergone peer review.

The algorithm found patterns to help identify the citations that were more likely to be important to each piece of published science. Those results revealed NIH-funded basic biological science appearing in the weightier citations at a rate three times the size of its share of all published research.

“Federal funding for basic research is under constant scrutiny from members of the public and congressional leadership,” Hutchins says. “This gives us some evidence, not just anecdotes, that this kind of basic research funding is really important for stimulating the kind of clinical research — treatments and cures for people — that Congress tends to be more receptive to funding.”

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Fast-track strain engineering for speedy biomanufacturing

Fast-track strain engineering for speedy biomanufacturing
2023-09-19
Using engineered microbes as microscopic factories has given the world steady sources of life-saving drugs, revolutionized the food industry, and allowed us to make sustainable versions of valuable chemicals previously made from petroleum.  But behind each biomanufactured product on the market today is the investment of years of work and many millions of dollars in research and development funding. Berkeley Lab scientists want to help the burgeoning industry reach new heights by accelerating and streamlining the process of engineering microbes to produce important compounds with ...

Firearm violence exposure in Black and American Indian/Alaska Native communities linked to poorer health

2023-09-19
There is a widening health disparity among Black, American Indian and Alaska Native adults exposed to gun violence, according to Rutgers researchers who say these communities have more mental and physical health issues because they witness or are victimized at a higher rate.   In a new study published in Health Affairs Scholar, 3,015 Black and 527 American Indian/Alaska Native (AI/AN) adults residing in the United States were surveyed between April and May 2023. Participants were asked whether they were threatened with a firearm, shot with a firearm, had a family or friend shot with a firearm, or witnessed or heard about a shooting. The results found that these ...

New evidence indicates vitiligo-associated autoimmunity may contribute to reduced morbidity and mortality risk

2023-09-19
Philadelphia, September 19, 2023 – According to a new study comparing patients with and without vitiligo in South Korea, patients with vitiligo were associated with a 25% decreased risk of mortality compared with controls. This suggests that vitiligo-associated autoimmunity may play a role in reducing morbidity and mortality. The results appear in the Journal of Investigative Dermatology, published by Elsevier. Previous studies have documented a reduced risk of cancer in patients with vitiligo, however, there has been limited research on the relationship between vitiligo-associated autoimmunity and the risk of morbidity and mortality ...

Eurosceptics more likely to think of the EU as less democratic than it is, study shows

2023-09-19
A significant share of voters see the EU as less democratic than it really is and believe the European Commission can steamroll its member states, a new study shows. The research shows that key channels of legitimation in the EU are not well known by the citizens of large member states. Whether people see themselves only as citizens of their nation, or simultaneously as a European, is linked to what they believe about the EU. A substantial share of EU voters who took part in the study believed that the members of the European Parliament are not directly elected. Many assumed the European Parliament is unimportant for decision ...

Poor water, sanitation, and hygiene in low-income countries may help fuel the emergence of deadly pathogens

2023-09-19
A new study suggests that Escherichia coli and other disease-causing microbes are passing easily between humans and animals in Cambodia, a country where clean water, sanitation and hygienic controls are lacking in many regions. The continuous exchange, along with unregulated antibiotic use, leads to the emergence and spread of drug-resistant E. coli, the authors say. Maya Nadimpalli, a scientific collaborator at the Antibiotic Research Action Center at the George Washington University and her international colleagues, conducted the research in Phnom Penh, an urban area where humans and animals are often living in close proximity without clean water or other ...

Durability of hepatitis b surface antigen seroclearance studied in real-world data from electronic health records

Durability of hepatitis b surface antigen seroclearance studied in real-world data from electronic health records
2023-09-19
In a study published in the journal Genes & Diseases, researchers from The Second Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University analyzed data from an extensive dataset comprising over 70,000 HBsAg-positive individuals at The Second Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University. They compared two groups: those achieving HBsAg seroclearance through NAs monotherapy (168 patients) and those through IFN monotherapy (30 patients). NAs monotherapy patients were older, with a higher proportion achieving HBsAg seroclearance during ...

Tiny sea creatures reveal the ancient origins of neurons

Tiny sea creatures reveal the ancient origins of neurons
2023-09-19
A study in the journal Cell sheds new light on the evolution of neurons, focusing on the placozoans, a millimetre-sized marine animal. Researchers at the Centre for Genomic Regulation in Barcelona find evidence that specialized secretory cells found in these unique and ancient creatures may have given rise to neurons in more complex animals.  Placozoans are tiny animals, around the size of a large grain of sand, which graze on algae and microbes living on the surface of rocks and other substrates found in shallow, warm seas. The blob-like and pancake-shaped creatures are so simple that they live without any body parts or organs. These animals, thought to have ...

Argyle study reveals crucial third clue to finding new diamond deposits

2023-09-19
Curtin University researchers studying diamond-rich rocks from Western Australia’s Argyle volcano have identified the missing third key ingredient needed to bring valuable pink diamonds to the Earth’s surface where they can be mined, which could greatly help in the global hunt for new deposits. While it is known that for diamonds to form there needs to be carbon deep in the Earth, and for these diamonds to turn pink they must be subjected to forces from colliding tectonic plates, the new study has found the third ingredient needed for the presence of pink diamonds at surface ...

Assessing unintended consequences in AI-based neurosurgical training

Assessing unintended consequences in AI-based neurosurgical training
2023-09-19
Virtual reality simulators can help learners improve their technical skills faster and with no risk to patients. In the field of neurosurgery, they allow medical students to practice complex operations before using a scalpel on a real patient. When combined with artificial intelligence, these tutoring systems can offer tailored feedback like a human instructor, identifying areas where the students need to improve and making suggestions on how to achieve expert performance.   A new study from the Neurosurgical Simulation and Artificial Intelligence Learning Centre at The Neuro (Montreal Neurological Institute-Hospital) of McGill University, ...

USPSTF recommendation on screening for hypertensive disorders of pregnancy

2023-09-19
Bottom Line: The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends screening for hypertensive disorders in pregnant persons with blood pressure measurements throughout pregnancy. Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy are among the leading causes of maternal morbidity and mortality in the U.S. The rate has been increasing from approximately 500 cases per 10,000 deliveries in 1993 to 1,021 cases per 10,000 deliveries in 2016 to 2017. The USPSTF routinely makes recommendations about the effectiveness of preventive care services and this recommendation is consistent with its 2017 recommendation statement. To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media website ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

USC medical school dean appointed to CIRM board

Antibiotic pollution disrupts the gut microbiome and blocks memory in aquatic snails 

Researchers expose new symbiosis origin theories, identify experimental systems for plant life

Q&A: How AI affects kids’ creativity

Virtual lab meetings improve undergraduate research experience and foster diversity in academia

Study shows effectiveness of updated COVID-19 vaccines wanes moderately over time, is lower against currently circulating variants

Researchers expose new ‘origin’ theories, identify experimental systems for plant life

Researchers honored for outstanding contributions to cancer care

A new Hungarian method may aid protein research

AIM algorithm enhances super-resolution microscope images in real time

Rice researchers uncover surprising role of opioid receptors in gut development

Cleveland Clinic and IBM researchers apply quantum computing methods to protein structure prediction

Blood flow makes waves across the surface of the mouse brain

More out-of-state patients seek abortions in Washington state

Researchers take step toward development of universal COVID-19 antibodies

Do epilepsy medications taken during pregnancy affect a child’s creativity?

First hints of memory problems associated with changes in the brain

Mass General Brigham study finds that memory complaints can predict biological changes in the brain

JPMorgan Chase, Argonne and Quantinuum show theoretical quantum speedup with the quantum approximate optimization algorithm

AI browser plug-ins to help consumers improve digital privacy literacy, combat manipulative design

Grant funds CU project to develop novel mechanism to expand NF1 treatments

A drying Salton Sea pollutes neighboring communities

Wild megalopolis: Study shows unexpected pockets of biodiversity pepper Los Angeles

Slugs and snails love the city, unlike other animals

Ideas that cross international borders may have powerful impact on elections

YouTube’s comments section: Political echo chamber or constructive cross-partisan forum?

Babies babble squeals and growls in clustering patterns observable from birth through the first year, suggesting this active vocal exploration is important to speech development

The sweat bee, H. rubicundus, is less sociable in Scotland than in Cornwall, but is genetically differentiated and genetically isolated too

Smartphone use may help adolescents feel better - at least in the moment, finds real-time survey of US teens

Public have no difficulty getting to grips with an extra thumb, study finds

[Press-News.org] Machine learning analysis of research citations highlights importance of federal funding for basic scientific research
Researchers found patterns to help identify the citations that were more likely to be important to each piece of published science