(Press-News.org) Increasing human input when AI is used for public services boosts acceptance of the technology, a new study shows.
The research shows citizens are not only concerned about AI fairness but also about potential human biases. They are in favour of AI being used in cases when administrative discretion is perceived as too large.
Researchers found citizens' knowledge about AI does not alter their acceptance of the technology. More accurate systems and lower cost systems also increased their acceptance. Cost and accuracy of technology mattered more to them than human involvement.
The study, by Laszlo Horvath from Birkbeck, University of London and Oliver James, Susan Banducci and Ana Beduschi from the University of Exeter, is published in the journal Government Information Quarterly.
Academics carried out an experiment with 2,143 people in the UK. Respondents were asked to select if they would prefer more or less AI in systems to process immigration visas and parking permits.
Researchers found more human involvement tended to increase acceptance of AI. Yet, when substantial human discretion was introduced in parking permit scenarios, respondents preferred more limited human input.
System-level factors such as high accuracy, the presence of an appeals system, increased transparency, reduced cost, non-sharing of data, and the absence of private company involvement all boosted both acceptance and perceived procedural fairness.
Dr Horvath said: “Our results suggest resistance to the accumulation and sharing of citizens' data—but we also show, in the context of other system-level characteristics, that citizens want working technology in which case are willing to forgo heavy human supervision.”
Professor Banducci said “Our results contribute to the understanding of technology acceptance in digital government and AI. Citizens who have a baseline resistance to new technologies in other contexts will prefer greater human administrative involvement.”
Professor James said: “Many routine interactions with the government involve permit applications similar to the kinds we examined such that the findings are of broad relevance to government services using AI.
“Respondents appeared to be more strongly influenced by the costs and accuracy of the technology than by concerns about “humans in the loop,” transparency, or even data sharing. This suggests citizens may perceive legitimacy more profoundly in terms of the system's efficiency and its ability to deliver accurate and cost-effective results.”
END
Human input boosts citizens’ acceptance of AI and perceptions of fairness, study shows
2023-10-31
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Sharper images: A breakthrough in microscopy resolution
2023-10-31
Obtaining high-resolution images in the world of microscopy has long been a challenge. Deconvolution, a method to enhance image clarity, often amplifies noise between the sample and the image. Researchers at Boston University recently developed a novel deblurring algorithm that avoids these issues, improving the resolution of images with photon intensity conservation and local linearity.
As reported in the Gold Open Access journal Advanced Photonics, the innovative deblurring algorithm is adaptable to various fluorescence microscopes, requiring minimal assumptions about the emission point spread function (PSF). It works on both a sequence of raw images and even a single image, enabling ...
FSU-led research shows shifting nesting timing not enough to prevent fewer sea turtle hatchlings
2023-10-31
New research led by a Florida State University professor shows that potential adaptive responses by sea turtles, such as shifting the timing of when they nest, may not be enough to counteract the projected impacts from climate change on hatchling production.
Warmer temperatures cause lower hatchling success and a greater percentage of female turtles, both of which can disrupt the viability of a species. Sand temperatures at sea turtle nesting sites globally are projected to increase by about 0.6 degrees Celsius to ...
Study aims to remove barriers to veterans seeking mental health services
2023-10-31
Suicide and mental health distress disproportionately affect veterans in the United States. According to a report from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, more than 5 million veterans suffered from these adverse behavioral health issues in 2020. That same year, after adjusting for age and sex differences in the population, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) estimated that veterans were 57.3 percent more likely to commit suicide than non-veterans.
While the Veterans ...
The first ‘birder’s guide’ to meteor showers
2023-10-31
The First ‘Birder’s Guide’ to Meteor Showers
Peter Jenniskens new comprehensive guide describes over 500 meteor showers that appear in our night skies.
October 31, 2023, Mountain View, CA -- The SETI Institute is proud to announce a new book by SETI Institute meteor astronomer Dr. Peter Jenniskens. Called “Atlas of Earth’s Meteor Showers,” this comprehensive guide describes over 500 meteor showers that appear in our night skies and adds a wealth of detail to the tapestry of our solar system.
“Just as in a birder’s guide, the book describes the outward appearance, ...
Better access to diagnostic tests raises incidence of thyroid cancer in more affluent areas
2023-10-31
The incidence of thyroid cancer in São Paulo State, part of Brazil’s relatively developed Southeast region, varies considerably according to socioeconomic status (education, poverty, wealth, income, segregation, mobility, and access to resources and services) and access to screening, but is highest in higher-income areas and the state capital. Mortality rates are similar across regions and income groups, however.
These are the main findings of a study reported in the journal Endocrine Practice by researchers ...
Combining cell types may lead to improved cardiac cell therapy following heart attack
2023-10-31
Researchers at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and Academia Sinica of Taiwan have harnessed a combination of lab-grown cells to regenerate damaged heart muscle.
The study, published in Circulation — which addresses major challenges of using heart muscle cells, called cardiomyocytes, grown from stem cells — takes a crucial step toward future clinical applications.
Previous research has shown that transplanting cardiomyocytes made from induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSC) can replace muscle in the hearts of mammals. Researchers have struggled to bring the treatment to the clinic, in part because the implanted cells haven’t developed enough ...
Cary Institute to co-lead $4.8 million study on how environmental conditions shape viral outbreaks in wild rodents
2023-10-31
When, where, and why do diseases jump from animals to people? A new project will monitor how changing seasons, land use, and human behavior influence viral outbreaks in wild rodent populations, to identify hotspots with high potential for spillover into people. The project is co-led by Barbara Han, a disease ecologist at Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, in an international team of scientists from the Smithsonian Institution, Royal Veterinary College, Oxford University, and the University of ...
Wiley announces the release of KnowItAll 2024 with new multi-technique quantitation tool and additional advances for spectral analysis workflows
2023-10-31
Hoboken, NJ — October 31, 2023 — Wiley, a knowledge company and global leader in research, publishing and knowledge solutions, today announced the release of the KnowItAll 2024 Analytical Edition, the latest version of its spectral software that offers solutions to analyze, identify, quantify, and manage analytical and chemical data.
When it comes to chemical quantitative analysis, researchers often find themselves navigating multiple software packages. Mastering multiple software packages to achieve the same level of expertise, reproducibility, and ...
Cary Institute to co-lead $4.8M study on how environmental conditions shape RNA virus outbreaks in wild rodents
2023-10-31
When, where, and why do diseases jump from animals to people? A new project will monitor how changing seasons, land use, and human behavior influence viral outbreaks in wild rodent populations, to identify hotspots with high potential for spillover into people. The project is co-led by Barbara Han, a disease ecologist at Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, in an international team of scientists from the Smithsonian Institution, Royal Veterinary College, Oxford University, and the University of Glasgow.
Until now, it has been difficult to study how changing environmental conditions impact virus transmission in the wild. With $2.9 million in funding ...
For the sunflower, turning toward the sun requires multiple complex systems
2023-10-31
A sunflower’s ability to track the sun east to west during the day, and to face east again before the next sunrise, relies on multiple types of photoresponses, according to a new study publishing October 31st in the open access journal PLOS Biology by Stacey Harmer and colleagues at the University of California Davis, US. The results deepen the understanding of this well-known plant behavior, and upend previous assumptions about its dependence on a canonical light-dependent response pathway.
Because plants are ...