(Press-News.org) Receiving a heart transplant is a matter of life and death for many patients. Every time a heart becomes available, a “match run” is created to generate a list of transplant candidates ranked by an algorithm based on medical urgency, geography and pediatric status. Unfortunately, deceased donor organs are very scarce in the United States – so much so that some patients aren’t even placed on waitlists because it’s too unlikely that a heart will become available to them.
A research team led by experts at the University of Chicago Medicine developed a new risk score designed to predict the likelihood that a patient will die without a heart transplant. This innovation aims to address the limitations of the current therapy-based 6-status system, offering a more precise and fair approach to prioritizing candidates based on medical urgency. A paper detailing the development and initial validation of the proposed U.S. Candidate Risk Score (US-CRS) was published in JAMA in February 2024.
“The goal is to identify the sickest patients. Each candidate on the list is sick and needs a heart transplant, but some can wait marginally longer than others,” said William F. Parker, MD, PhD, Assistant Professor of Medicine and Public Health at UChicago Medicine and senior author on the paper. “This new risk score improves upon the status quo. Among other things, it’s not as reliant on the treatment decisions of individual physicians.”
Incorporating objective physiological measurements
Instead of only considering the treatments patients were receiving – the metric currently used to allocate deceased donor hearts – Parker and his team also looked at clinical and laboratory measurements associated with end-stage heart failure, such as levels of molecules in the blood associated with liver and kidney failure. They chose an initial list of variables based on the current French Candidate Risk Score (French-CRS) model, which incorporates more clinical measurements than the current U.S. system, and added others they had identified as important.
Combining these variables into a single risk score (the US-CRS), the researchers analyzed data from over 16,900 adult heart transplant candidates from the US heart allocation system to determine the relationship between the US-CRS and mortality within 6 weeks of being placed on the transplant waitlist.
“We initially expected that advanced deep learning and machine learning – more of a black-box algorithm – would lead to a model that was much more accurate, but it turned out that a pretty standard regression was quite accurate in predicting mortality,” Parker said. “It just goes to show that we picked good variables to measure. The resulting model has the benefit of being easy to understand.”
The team compared their new US-CRS model to the current U.S. heart allocation system and found that it was much better in accurately predicting mortality in patients who didn’t receive a heart transplant within 6 weeks.
Parker emphasized the contributions of the entire research team, especially first author Kevin Zhang, MS, a data scientist at UChicago Medicine.
“It was a tremendous amount of data science on his part,” Parker said. “He’s the first person in the country to pull together all these laboratory values. It’s the reason we could do this work.”
Turning scientific insights into policy improvements
The US-CRS will need to make it through many additional rounds of validation and committees in order to get adopted. It would also only represent one part of the forthcoming continuous distribution algorithm for allocating hearts. Parker and his collaborators are already working on grant proposals for follow-up research aimed at improving heart allocation overall. Their broad goals include designing a fair and resilient continuous distribution system for deceased donor hearts that mitigates health inequity.
In the long term, Parker believes this work may lay important groundwork as researchers, technology experts and policymakers tackle the larger problem of how to use algorithms to distribute scarce healthcare resources.
“Organ transplantation gives us the opportunity to take on this issue in very concrete ways,” Parker said. “We’re hopeful that the lessons we uncover can be generalized."
The study, "Development and Validation of a Candidate Risk Score: Predicting Death Without Transplant in Adult Heart Transplant Candidates," was published in JAMA in February 2024. Co-authors include Kevin C. Zhang, Nikhil Narang, Carine Jasseron, Richard Dorent, Kevin A. Lazenby, Mark N. Belkin, Jonathan Grinstein, Anoop Mayampurath, Matthew M. Churpek, Kiran K. Khush and William F. Parker.
END
Updating allocation algorithms could help donor hearts reach the transplant patients who need them most
2024-02-13
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
New study reveals dynamic impact of nicotine on brain regions responsible for reward and aversion
2024-02-13
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. – A new study led by researchers at the Marshall University Joan C. Edwards School of Medicine sheds light on the intricate interplay of brain regions involved in nicotine's effects on the human brain.
The research, published in eNeuro, an open-access, peer-reviewed scientific journal published by the Society for Neuroscience, explores how nicotine influences key areas associated with reward and aversion, showcasing a nuanced relationship that varies based on dosage, sex and distinct brain regions. The medial ...
New assay identifies clinically relevant gene fusions in pediatric tumors more accurately and efficiently
2024-02-13
Philadelphia, February 13, 2024 – Identification of specific gene fusions is critical for the successful targeted treatment of pediatric cancer patients. Researchers at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles have developed a novel assay that automatically integrates the data from multiple fusion identification tools (callers) and efficiently and accurately identifies clinically relevant gene fusions in pediatric tumors. Their results are reported in The Journal of Molecular Diagnostics, published by ...
Pediatric sickle cell disease team uses pain screening to improve care
2024-02-13
CLEVELAND -- A recent study from researchers at University Hospitals (UH) Connor Whole Health and UH Rainbow Babies & Children’s Hospital describes a quality improvement project where pain screening procedures were embedded within an outpatient pediatric sickle cell disease (SCD) clinic. The study examined (1) the feasibility of routine pain screening, (2) the prevalence of various clinical pain presentations, and (3) what integrative health and medicine modalities were preferred by youth aged 8 to 18 with SCD.
The study, entitled “Pain Screening in Youth with Sickle Cell Disease: A Quality Improvement ...
Grantees selected for The Mark Foundation for Cancer Research and the Samuel Waxman Cancer Research Foundation Aging and Cancer Initiative
2024-02-13
New York, NY – February 13, 2024 – The Mark Foundation for Cancer Research and the Samuel Waxman Cancer Research Foundation (SWCRF) have selected six investigators to receive three grants for their collaborative, two-year program aimed at improving our understanding of the links between aging and cancer. With additional support from the Melanoma Research Alliance (MRA), $1.5 million will fund three innovative projects, each pairing one lab focused on aging with another working on cancer research.
Aging is a major risk factor for developing and dying of cancer. In fact, 90 percent of cancer diagnoses and deaths occur in people ...
Benefits of heat pumps detailed in new NREL report
2024-02-13
Millions of U.S. households would benefit from heat pumps, but the cost of installing the technology needs to come down to make their use a more attractive proposition, according to researchers at the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL).
The findings, detailed in the journal Joule, quantify the costs and benefits of air-source heat pumps across the United States and consider various climates, heating sources, and types of homes. The researchers based their conclusions on simulations of 550,000 statistically ...
School Of Public Health team receives funding for mobile app to prevent dementia In Asian Americans
2024-02-13
By Ann Kellett, Texas A&M University School of Public Health
A research team led by Junhyoung “Paul” Kim, Ph.D., an associate professor of health behavior in the School of Public Health at Texas A&M University, has been awarded a two-year grant from a Korean foundation to design mobile technology to help older Chinese American and Korean American adults in the United States prevent dementia.
The project is in line with the National Institute on Aging’s priority on increasing participation by Asian Americans in dementia care. This cohort is the nation’s ...
Road features that predict crash sites identified in new machine-learning model
2024-02-13
AMHERST, Mass. – Issues such as abrupt changes in speed limits and incomplete lane markings are among the most influential factors that can predict road crashes, finds new research by University of Massachusetts Amherst engineers. The study then used machine learning to predict which roads may be the most dangerous based on these features.
Published in the journal Transportation Research Record, the study was a collaboration between UMass Amherst civil and environmental engineers Jimi Oke, assistant ...
Johns Hopkins Medicine-led study shows rapid COVID-19 tests done at home are reliable
2024-02-13
In a study involving nearly 1,000 patients seen at the Baltimore Convention Center Field Hospital (BCCFH) during a five-month period in 2022 — researchers at Johns Hopkins Medicine, the University of Maryland School of Medicine and five other collaborators report that a rapid antigen test (RAT) for detecting SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, can be used at home with accuracy comparable to the same test being administered by a health care professional.
The study was first posted online Feb. 13, 2024, in the American Society ...
Researchers learn how nectar-laden honey bees avoid overheating
2024-02-13
Honey bees carrying nectar have the remarkable ability to adjust their flight behavior to avoid overheating when air temperatures increase, according to research led by a University of Wyoming scientist.
Jordan Glass, a postdoctoral research associate in UW’s Department of Zoology and Physiology, conducted the study to determine how high air temperatures may limit the ability of honey bees to forage for nectar. His research findings appear in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, one of the world’s most prestigious multidisciplinary scientific journals covering the biological, physical ...
Dr. Jeanne Lackamp to lead university hospitals’ behavioral health efforts
2024-02-13
CLEVELAND – Jeanne Lackamp, MD, DFAPA, FACLP, has been selected to serve as Chair of Department of Psychiatry, Psychiatrist in Chief for University Hospitals (UH), and Director of the UH Behavioral Health Institute.
The need for behavioral health services continues to increase locally and across the country. The population is still struggling with the effects of the pandemic, while more people report a sense of isolation and depression. An unprecedented number of Americans are dying from drug overdoses. From popular media to medical literature, calls to address behavioral health needs are on the rise.
“Behavioral health is health. It’s ...