PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis

Study by UChicago paleontologists and colleagues uncovers major issues with earlier suggestions that the sail-backed mega-predator Spinosaurus pursued prey underwater.

Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis
2024-03-06
(Press-News.org) For years, controversy has swirled around how a Cretaceous-era, sail-backed dinosaur—the giant Spinosaurus aegyptiacus—hunted its prey. Spinosaurus was among the largest predators ever to prowl the Earth and one of the most adapted to water, but was it an aquatic denizen of the seas, diving deep to chase down its meals, or a semiaquatic wader that snatched prey from the shallows close to shore?

A new analysis led by paleontologists from the University of Chicago reexamines the density of its bones as a way of determining its life habits in water.

Deep water swimmer or shoreline predator?

When detailed descriptions of a nearly complete specimen of Spinosaurus were first published in Science in 2014, a UChicago-led research team pitched it as a shoreline stalking or surface swimming demon, not a fully aquatic underwater predator (read more about the history of Spinosaurus and its initial discovery). Later in 2020, an international group of researchers countered that description with a study in Nature, using its newly discovered, tall-spined tail bones to suggest that it propelled itself like an eel to hunt underwater.

A 2022 Nature study by many of those same authors confirmed their 2020 assessment showing that Spinosaurus had dense bones to use as ballast in diving like a penguin. They also argued that some other spinosaurids, such as its older African cousin Suchomimus, had less dense bones and were likely waders.

About the same time in 2022, a group of paleontologists at UChicago teamed up with colleagues elsewhere to test these ideas by creating digital skeletons and flesh models of the Spinosaurus and Suchomimus. Their results, published in eLife, found that both species would have been unstable when swimming at the surface and far too buoyant to dive and fully submerge.

Now that same team has taken on the question of bone density, led by senior author Paul Sereno, PhD, from UChicago and first author Nathan Myhrvold, PhD, Founder and CEO of Intellectual Ventures. Their study, “Diving dinosaurs? Caveats on the use of bone compactness and pFDA for inferring lifestyle,” appeared in the journal PLOS ONE.

“We had made the thin sections of these species that were used for bone density calculations, and so we thought we would start by trying to replicate their measurements,” said Sereno, who is a Professor of Organismal Biology and Anatomy at UChicago and co-led the initial discovery of the new Spinosaurus specimen in 2014. “But we encountered many factors that generated a range of values—enough to undermine the conclusions.”

New calculations for ancient fossils

The team began by asking new questions about bone density, such as how to digitize thin sections, where to slice through the thigh and rib bones, and whether to include bones from more than one individual.

Some modern aquatic mammals like manatees have swollen, dense bones to help them stay underwater, like a scuba diver’s weight belt. Large land animals, like elephants and dinosaurs, also have dense bones to support their increased body mass. Most modern birds and many dinosaurs including Spinosaurus have the opposite condition, with air sacs attached to lungs or inside bones that act like a life vest preventing submergence. Assessing the aquatic abilities of an extinct species like Spinosaurus needs to take account of all these factors.

Given the complexity of understanding the meaning of bone density, Sereno and team worked with Myhrvold to reevaluate how the statistical technique used in the 2022 Nature study was applied to support the claim that Spinosaurus was a deep diver. The approach, known as phylogenetic flexible discriminant analysis (pFDA), is like machine-learning: the pFDA technique trains a classification algorithm on a group of species whose lifestyle is well understood.

In principle, researchers could then use the algorithm to estimate the likelihood that a poorly understood species such as Spinosaurus falls into one behavioral group or another. In practice, however, Myhrvold said there are problems that must be overcome.

“Unfortunately, that technique does not work properly unless you have lots of data, you make apples-to-apples comparisons, and you check that the data meet certain statistical prerequisites,” he said. “None of those requirements were met in that earlier study, so the results just didn’t hold up under reexamination.”

The new paper should help paleontologists understand the pitfalls of pFDA and other kinds of broad statistical analyses and how to avoid them. The researchers show that it is important to use consistent and objective criteria to decide which species to include and exclude, as well as how to classify their behavior. The findings also demonstrate the importance of taking measurement errors and individual variations into account when assessing bone density.

“We think Spinosaurus, one of the largest predatory animals ever to have evolved, needed extra bone strength to support its weight on its relatively short hind limbs,” Sereno said. “Spinosaurus was able to wade into waterways more than six feet deep without floating, where it could ambush fish of any size with its claws and jaws—but all while keeping its toes firmly anchored in the mud.”

Additional authors on the study include Stephanie L. Baumgart from the University of Florida; Daniel Vidal and Evan T. Saitta from UChicago; Frank E. Fish from West Chester University in Pennsylvania; and Donald M. Henderson from the Royal Tyrrell Museum of Paleontology, Alberta, Canada.

END

[Attachments] See images for this press release:
Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis 2 Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis 3

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

New deep-sea worm discovered at methane seep off Costa Rica

New deep-sea worm discovered at methane seep off Costa Rica
2024-03-06
Greg Rouse, a marine biologist at UC San Diego’s Scripps Institution of Oceanography, and other researchers have discovered a new species of deep-sea worm living near a methane seep some 50 kilometers (30 miles) off the Pacific coast of Costa Rica. Rouse, curator of the Scripps Benthic Invertebrate Collection, co-authored a study describing the new species in the journal PLOS ONE that was published on March 6.  The worm, named Pectinereis strickrotti, has an elongated body that is flanked by a row of feathery, gill-tipped appendages called ...

Nanosurgical tool could be key to cancer breakthrough

Nanosurgical tool could be key to cancer breakthrough
2024-03-06
The high-tech double-barrel nanopipette, developed by University of Leeds scientists, and applied to the global medical challenge of cancer, has - for the first time - enabled researchers to see how individual living cancer cells react to treatment and change over time – providing vital understanding that could help doctors develop more effective cancer medication.     The tool has two nanoscopic needles, meaning it can simultaneously inject and extract a sample from the same cell, expanding its potential uses. And the platform’s high level of semi-automation has sped ...

Genetic mutation in a quarter of all Labradors hard-wires them for obesity

Genetic mutation in a quarter of all Labradors hard-wires them for obesity
2024-03-06
New research finds around a quarter of Labrador retriever dogs face a double-whammy of feeling hungry all the time and burning fewer calories due to a genetic mutation. This obesity-driving combination means that dog owners must be particularly strict with feeding and exercising their Labradors to keep them slim. The mutation is in a gene called POMC, which plays a critical role in hunger and energy use. Around 25% of Labradors and 66% of flatcoated retriever dogs have the POMC mutation, which researchers previously showed causes increased interest in food ...

MIT scientists use a new type of nanoparticle to make vaccines more powerful

2024-03-06
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Many vaccines, including vaccines for hepatitis B and whooping cough, consist of fragments of viral or bacterial proteins. These vaccines often include other molecules called adjuvants, which help to boost the immune system’s response to the protein. Most of these adjuvants consist of aluminum salts or other molecules that provoke a nonspecific immune response. A team of MIT researchers has now shown that a type of nanoparticle called a metal organic framework (MOF) can also provoke a strong immune response, by activating the innate immune system — the body’s first line of defense against ...

A noninvasive treatment for “chemo brain”

2024-03-06
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Patients undergoing chemotherapy often experience cognitive effects such as memory impairment and difficulty concentrating — a condition commonly known as “chemo brain.” MIT researchers have now shown that a noninvasive treatment that stimulates gamma frequency brain waves may hold promise for treating chemo brain. In a study of mice, they found that daily exposure to light and sound with a frequency of 40 hertz protected brain cells from chemotherapy-induced damage. The treatment also helped to prevent memory loss and impairment of other ...

Film festivals are becoming more diverse in several ways, new study reports

Film festivals are becoming more diverse in several ways, new study reports
2024-03-06
A group of Tallinn University researchers has published an innovative study that sheds light on the intricate dynamics of the global film festival circuit, revealing insights into diversity and public value creation within the industry. The research demonstrates that festival programming has become more thematically diverse, and the inclusion of films by women creatives has increased between 2012–2021. The study “Quantifying the global film festival circuit: Networks, diversity, and public value creation,” published open access in the PLOS ONE journal, provides a comprehensive analysis of over 600 film festivals worldwide, spanning a period ...

New hydrogen producing method is simpler and safer

New hydrogen producing method is simpler and safer
2024-03-06
Researchers in Sweden unveiled a new concept for producing hydrogen energy more efficiently, splitting water into oxygen and hydrogen without the dangerous risk of mixing the two gases. Developed at KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm, the new method decouples the standard electrolysis process for producing hydrogen gas, which splits water molecules by applying an electric current. In contrast with prevailing systems it produces the resulting oxygen and hydrogen gases separately rather than simultaneously in the same cell, where they need to be separated by membrane barriers That separation eliminates the possibility of the gases mixing with the risk of explosions, says ...

Studying the relationship between cancer-promoting proteins

Studying the relationship between cancer-promoting proteins
2024-03-06
By Simonne Griffith-Jones, Predoctoral Fellow, EMBL Grenoble Researchers from the Bhogaraju Group at EMBL Grenoble have gained new insights into how a cancer-relevant family of proteins bind their targets. The results of the study, published in The EMBO Journal, could potentially help in the development of drugs against certain chemotherapy- and radiotherapy-resistant cancers.   The Melanoma Antigen Gene (MAGE) family consists of more than 40 proteins in humans, most of which are only present in the ...

UTA educating schoolchildren about solar eclipse

UTA educating schoolchildren about solar eclipse
2024-03-06
The University of Texas at Arlington has received a grant from the National Science Foundation (NSF) to support educational activities related to the upcoming eclipse. UTA faculty and graduate students are visiting elementary, middle and high schools in the DFW area in March to give talks to about 4,000 students explaining the natural phenomena occurring during the eclipse and the physics behind it. UTA will also provide special eclipse glasses for students to use to avoid eye damage. The $50,000 grant will also provide for about 1,500 students to take field trips to the UTA Planetarium, one of the three largest in Texas, to learn ...

Espresso yourself: Wearable tech measures emotional responses to coffee

Espresso yourself: Wearable tech measures emotional responses to coffee
2024-03-06
Researchers in Italy have introduced a novel approach for assessing the quality of coffee. In a pioneering new study, they have demonstrated the feasibility of using wearable technology to measure the emotional responses of coffee experts during tastings. Published in SCI’s Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, the study provides an innovative solution for reducing judgement biases that can result from traditional and more subjective methods of coffee quality assessment. Coffee is one of the most popular and widely consumed beverages in the world, ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Underserved youth less likely to visit emergency department for concussion in Ontario, study finds

‘Molecular shield’ placed in the nose may soon treat common hay fever trigger

Beetles under climate stress lay larger male eggs: Wolbachia infection drives adaptive reproduction strategy in response to rising temperature and CO₂

Groundbreaking quantum study puts wave-particle duality to work

Weekly injection could be life changing for Parkinson’s patients

Toxic metals linked to impaired growth in infants in Guatemala

Being consistently physically active in adulthood linked to 30–40% lower risk of death

Nerve pain drug gabapentin linked to increased dementia, cognitive impairment risks

Children’s social care involvement common to nearly third of UK mums who died during perinatal period

‘Support, not judgement’: Study explores links between children’s social care involvement and maternal deaths

Ethnic minority and poorer children more likely to die in intensive care

Major progress in fertility preservation after treatment for cancer of the lymphatic system

Fewer complications after additional ultrasound in pregnant women who feel less fetal movement

Environmental impact of common pesticides seriously underestimated

The Milky Way could be teeming with more satellite galaxies than previously thought

New study reveals surprising reproductive secrets of a cricket-hunting parasitoid fly

Media Tip Sheet: Symposia at ESA2025

NSF CAREER Award will power UVA engineer’s research to improve drug purification

Tiny parasitoid flies show how early-life competition shapes adult success

New coating for glass promises energy-saving windows

Green spaces boost children’s cognitive skills and strengthen family well-being

Ancient trees dying faster than expected in Eastern Oregon

Study findings help hone precision of proven CVD risk tool

Most patients with advanced melanoma who received pre-surgical immunotherapy remain alive and disease free four years later

Introducing BioEmu: A generative AI Model that enables high-speed and accurate prediction of protein structural ensembles

Replacing mutated microglia with healthy microglia halts progression of genetic neurological disease in mice and humans

New research shows how tropical plants manage rival insect tenants by giving them separate ‘flats’

Condo-style living helps keep the peace inside these ant plants

Climate change action could dramatically limit rising UK heatwave deaths

Annual heat-related deaths projected to increase significantly due to climate and population change

[Press-News.org] Giant dinosaur was “heron from hell,” not a deep diver, says new analysis
Study by UChicago paleontologists and colleagues uncovers major issues with earlier suggestions that the sail-backed mega-predator Spinosaurus pursued prey underwater.