PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Research warns of “systematic weaknesses in jury decisions”

2024-07-30
(Press-News.org) There are “systemic weaknesses” in the way juries make decisions – and these are likely to be contributing to the conviction of innocent people, failures to convict the guilty, and inequalities, new research warns.

The current legal rules involving procedure and evidence are not consistently designed based on robust evidence about how the juries make decisions, but the system could function better, according to a new book.

Dr Rebecca Helm, from the University of Exeter, outlines how juries are likely to struggle to make effective legal decisions in predictable case types, including cases involving sexual offences in which testimony from a defendant and complainant is often central evidence. In such cases juries are particularly susceptible to reaching decisions that are based on uninformed intuition and biased by legally irrelevant information. However well-designed legal infrastructure can improve the ability of the jury to make decisions in these cases.

How Juries Work: And How They Could Work Better, published by Oxford University Press, highlights how existing changes to legal procedure have failed to address many of the underlying causes of wrongful convictions in trials by jury in England and Wales. Recently there has also been growing dissatisfaction with failures to effectively prosecute defendants, and the potential role of juror bias in these failures.

Dr Helm said: “The procedure surrounding the modern jury is, in many ways, still grounded in common-sense and in tradition from as far back as the 1200s. However, today we have the knowledge and the data to allow us to design procedure to help the jury convict the guilty and acquit the innocent, and to do so in a way that does not exacerbate inequality in the criminal justice system.  

“Jurors, as human decision-makers, utilise their own intuitions to interpret case evidence and to reach a verdict. Although these intuitions are likely to be highly effective in allowing us to function in society, they also have predictable weaknesses particularly in the legal context. For example, intuitions are likely to be misleading where they arise in the absence of sufficiently representative experience or where they arise as the result of mental shortcuts which we are all regularly influenced by.”

“Jurors are particularly likely to make sub-optimal decisions when they are considering cases involving a part of society that they are not familiar with (e.g., people from a different socio-economic group), and where evidence is ambiguous or difficult to understand.”

The book outlines how improving jury diversity and ensuring that contributions of individual jurors with most relevant experience are appropriately valued has the potential to enhance the performance of the jury. It also highlights how evidence-based jury directions can educate intuition to enhance the accuracy of decisions and reduce the influence of harmful biases.

 

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

NYU Tandon School of Engineering and Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur announce seven joint research projects launching their new partnership

2024-07-30
NYU Tandon School of Engineering and Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur (IIT Kanpur) have unveiled their inaugural roster of collaborative research projects, the first such initiatives under the broad partnership that NYU and IIT Kanpur established last year. The seven projects, jointly led by researchers from each institution, aim to advance innovations across vital scientific fields including cybersecurity, biotechnology, artificial intelligence, robotics, and wireless communications.  NYU and IIT Kanpur announced their initial partnership agreement in September 2023, ...

Study finds genetic variant among people who experience a rare recovery from ALS

2024-07-30
DURHAM, N.C. – Though exceedingly rare, some people diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) partially or fully recover from the lethal neurodegenerative disease.   A better understanding of this baffling phenomenon, reported in medical literature for at least 60 years, could point to potential new treatment approaches. To that end, researchers at Duke Health and St. Jude’s Research Hospital launched a study of ALS recovery patients and found certain genetic factors that appear to protect ...

Watch ut IKEA: CMU Researchers eye knitted furniture

Watch ut IKEA: CMU Researchers eye knitted furniture
2024-07-30
Yuichi Hirose has a dream — a dream that someday everyone will have access to a machine capable of knitting furniture.  This machine wouldn't just knit the furniture's exterior fabric, but would use knitting to fashion solid three-dimensional chairs, tables and other objects. Tired of that love seat? Just unravel it and reuse the yarn to knit yourself an ottoman. This new fabrication technique — first envisioned by Hirose, a robotics Ph.D. student in Carnegie Mellon University's School of Computer Science — is called solid knitting. The idea captured his imagination more than a decade ago. And now, working with a research team headed by James ...

Enjoy your work? Don’t sell yourself short. Buyers are willing to pay more for products you enjoy producing

2024-07-30
Researchers from Tilburg University, Northwestern University, and Lehigh University published a new Journal of Marketing study that examines how a seller’s enjoyment in making a product influences buyers’ willingness to pay and the price the seller charges.  The study, forthcoming in the Journal of Marketing, is titled “Production Enjoyment Asymmetrically Impacts Buyers’ Willingness to Pay and Sellers’ Willingness to Charge” and is authored ...

Recent study reveals key immune cells as critical factors in lung cancer prognosis

Recent study reveals key immune cells as critical factors in lung cancer prognosis
2024-07-30
(LOS ANGELES, July 30, 2024) – An extensive analytical study performed at the Terasaki Institute and published in Frontiers in Immunology highlights the crucial role of tissue-resident memory T cells and how they influence the immune environment of patients with non-small cell lung cancer and their overall prognosis. Non-small cell lung cancer accounts for ~85% of lung tumors and is a leading cause of death in adults. Tissue-resident memory T cells, a specialized subset of immune cells residing in peripheral tissues, have been ...

Accuracy of diagnostic blood tests for Alzheimer’s disease varies

2024-07-30
Neurologists diagnose cognitive impairment with a clinical exam of memory and thinking skills. To determine whether Alzheimer’s disease is the cause of the cognitive impairment, evidence of the specific brain changes that characterize Alzheimer’s must be obtained, typically via a brain scan or spinal tap. Identifying people whose cognitive symptoms are due to Alzheimer’s disease is critical now that new Alzheimer’s therapies are available that could change the course of the illness. To make diagnosis more convenient for patients, many companies have begun selling Alzheimer’s ...

Ze’ev Ronai steps down as cancer center director at Sanford Burnham Prebys

Ze’ev Ronai steps down as cancer center director at Sanford Burnham Prebys
2024-07-30
Ze’ev Ronai, PhD, is stepping down as director of the National Cancer Institute-designated cancer center at Sanford Burnham Prebys, effective August 1. Cosimo Commisso, PhD, deputy director of the cancer center, will serve as interim head while a national search is conducted for a new cancer center director.   Ronai is moving to Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles where he will focus on translational research.   “During my 20 years at Sanford Burnham Prebys, I’ve had the honor of developing new research directions, institutionally, as well as in my lab,” said Ronai.   “As the director of the cancer ...

FSU researchers identify unique phenomenon in Kagome metal

FSU researchers identify unique phenomenon in Kagome metal
2024-07-30
In traditional Japanese basket-weaving, the ancient “Kagome” design seen in many handcrafted creations is characterized by a symmetrical pattern of interlaced triangles with shared corners. In quantum physics, the Kagome name has been borrowed by scientists to describe a class of materials with an atomic structure closely resembling this distinctive lattice pattern. Since the latest family of Kagome metals was discovered in 2019, physicists have been working to better understand their properties and potential applications. A new study led by Florida State University Assistant Professor of ...

Ochsner-Xavier Institute for Health Equity and Research publishes strategic plan

2024-07-30
NEW ORLEANS – The Ochsner-Xavier Institute for Health Equity and Research, or OXIHER, has published its first strategic plan, outlining strategic priorities and achievements since the institute began in 2020.   The strategic plan is available here.  A partnership between Ochsner Health and Xavier University of Louisiana, OXIHER examines health disparities at the community level while educating healthcare providers on creating and nurturing a culture of equity, and training more students for advanced careers in healthcare. The new plan details OXIHER’s substantial progress in its first three years in addressing ...

Argonne receives U.S. Department of Energy funding for four next-generation clean-energy projects

Argonne receives U.S. Department of Energy funding for four next-generation clean-energy projects
2024-07-30
The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory has been awarded funding from DOE’s Office of Technology Transitions for four new projects that will help with commercialization of innovative clean-energy technology for a sustainable future. Argonne scientists will work to turn their innovative ideas into next-generation technology necessary to build cleaner, more resilient energy systems. These projects build on Argonne’s decades-long role at the forefront of the quest to decarbonize ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Milky Way-like galaxy M83 consumes high-speed clouds

Study: What we learned from record-breaking 2021 heat wave and what we can expect in the future

Transforming treatment outcomes for people with OCD

Damage from smoke and respiratory viruses mitigated in mice via a common signaling pathway

New software tool could help better understand childhood cancer

Healthy lifestyle linked to lower diverticulitis risk, irrespective of genetic susceptibility

Women 65+ still at heightened risk of cervical cancer caused by HPV

‘Inflammatory’ diet during pregnancy may raise child’s diabetes type 1 risk

Effective therapies needed to halt rise in eco-anxiety, says psychology professor

Nature-friendly farming boosts biodiversity and yields but may require new subsidies

Against the odds: Endometriosis linked to four times higher pregnancy rates than other causes of infertility, new study reveals

Microplastics discovered in human reproductive fluids, new study reveals

Family ties and firm performance: How cousin marriage traditions shape informal businesses in Africa

Novel flu vaccine adjuvant improves protection against influenza viruses, study finds

Manipulation of light at the nanoscale helps advance biosensing

New mechanism discovered in ovarian cancer peritoneal metastasis: YWHAB restriction drives stemness and chemoresistance

New study links blood metabolites and immune cells to increased risk of urolithiasis

Pyruvate identified as a promising therapeutic agent for ulcerative colitis by targeting cytosolic phospholipase A2

New insights into the clinical impact of IKBKG mutations: Understanding the mechanisms behind rare immunodeficiency syndromes

Displays, imaging and sensing: New blue fluorophore breaks efficiency records in both solids and solutions

Sugar, the hidden thermostat in plants

Personality can explain why some CEOs earn higher salaries

This puzzle game shows kids how they’re smarter than AI

Study suggests remembrances of dead played role in rise of architecture in Andean region

Brain stimulation can boost math learning in people with weaker neural connections

Inhibiting enzyme could halt cell death in Parkinson’s disease, study finds

Neurotechnology reverses biological disadvantage in maths learning

UNDER EMBARGO: Neurotechnology reverses biological disadvantage in maths learning

Scientists target ‘molecular machine’ in the war against antimicrobial resistance

Extending classical CNOP method for deep-learning atmospheric and oceanic forecasting

[Press-News.org] Research warns of “systematic weaknesses in jury decisions”