(Press-News.org) A new study has identified over 240 scientific publications on animal models of hemorrhagic stroke that contain potentially problematic images, thereby raising concerns about the trustworthiness of the body of literature this field. The findings come from a team led by René Aquarius and Kim Wever at Radboud university medical center in the Netherlands, and are published October 30th in the open-access journal PLOS Biology.
Researchers often use images in their publications to provide evidence of whether a treatment works, for example, by showing the presence or absence of specific proteins or cells or changes in brain tissue. But the researchers found many instances of image duplication within publications, as well as across different publications, even when authors claimed the images came from separate experiments with different experimental conditions. This kind of duplication can cast doubt on the validity of the study’s conclusions and its scientific integrity.
Originally, the team set out to systematically review animal studies on early brain injury following hemorrhagic stroke to find promising treatments suitable for clinical testing. But after noticing suspicious images in some papers in mid-2023, they set out to perform a systematic investigation of image-related problems in all 608 potentially relevant publications. The researchers uncovered that 243 papers (40%) were found to be problematic, most often for containing problematic images.
These findings raise concerns about the overall trustworthiness of animal-based research in this field. The authors stress the need for journals and publishers to investigate these issues carefully and take corrective editorial action where necessary. The scientific record needs to be as error-free as possible in order for scientists, clinicians and policymakers to make well-informed, evidence-based decisions that benefit patients’ health.
The authors add, “We found a high prevalence (40%) of papers with image-related issues among preclinical literature on early brain injury after hemorrhagic stroke.
“These findings shocked us to our core and might explain why, in spite of hundreds of animal studies published in this field, we still do not have any effective treatments for early brain injury in hemorrhagic stroke patients.
“During the summer break of 2023 we were texting each other figures from papers to collectively find image overlaps. Every time a new message came in, we knew somebody had found yet another inappropriate image overlap. It was at this moment that we knew that we had a serious problem on our hands that we needed to investigate in a systematic way.”
In your coverage, please use this URL to provide access to the freely available paper in PLOS Biology: https://plos.io/3KMbgzY
Citation: Aquarius R, van de Voort M, Boogaarts HD, Reesink PM, Wever KE (2025) High prevalence of articles with image-related problems in animal studies of subarachnoid hemorrhage and low rates of correction by publishers. PLoS Biol 23(10): e3003438. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3003438
Author countries: The Netherlands
Funding: see manuscript
END
Hundreds of animal studies on brain damage after stroke flagged for problematic images
2025-10-30
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Prize winner’s research reveals how complex neural circuits are correctly wired during brain development
2025-10-30
Cheng Lyu is the winner of the 2025 Eppendorf & Science Prize for Neurobiology for her work in understanding how neural circuits assemble with such remarkable precision during development. Neural circuit assembly is a daunting challenge: young neurons must form specific connections with their correct synaptic partner among billions of others. How does the developing brain achieve such exquisite precision? What happens when it fails? To explore this unknown, Cheng Lyu and her research team turned to the fruit fly Drosophila, ...
Supershear rupture sustained in thick fault zone during 2025 Mandalay earthquake, study in research package shows
2025-10-30
A massive March 2025 earthquake in Myanmar tore through nearly 500 kilometers of the Sagaing Fault at extremely high speeds. In a new study – part of a package of four research articles on seismic activity in Myanmar – researchers show that an unusually thick, low-velocity fault zone acted like a high-speed corridor, driving one of the fastest and longest continental ruptures ever recorded. The largest earthquakes that occur within continental crusts can rupture faults extending for hundreds of kilometers and pose significant seismic threats. Many of these powerful events evolve into supershear ruptures – earthquakes in which the rupture front ...
Study reveals how brain cell networks stabilize memory formation
2025-10-30
Newly decoded brain circuits make memories more stable as part of learning, according to a new study led by NYU Langone Health researchers.
Published online in Science on Oct. 30, the study shows that activity in signaling pathways connecting two brain regions, the entorhinal cortex and the CA3 region of the hippocampus, help mice encode in brain circuitry maps of places.
The entorhinal/hippocampal circuit is known from past studies to be crucial for both memory formation, and the recalling of memories by completing patterns from partial cues. Reliable recall requires that hippocampal place maps remain stable, withstanding to some degree changes in the environment.
Problems ...
CTE: More than just head trauma, suggests new study
2025-10-30
Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) – most often found in athletes playing contact sports – is known to share similarities with Alzheimer’s disease (AD), namely the buildup of a protein called tau in the brain. New research published today in Science finds even more commonalities between the two at the genetic level, showing CTE (like AD) is linked to damage to the genome and not just caused by repeated head impact (RHI).
The research team, a collaboration between Boston Children’s Hospital, Mass General Brigham, and Boston University, used single-cell genomic sequencing to identify somatic genetic mutations (changes in DNA that ...
New psychology study suggests chimpanzees might be rational thinkers
2025-10-30
Chimpanzees may have more in common with human thinkers than previously thought. A new study published in Science by researchers provides evidence that chimpanzees can rationally revise their beliefs when presented with new information.
The study, titled “Chimpanzees rationally revise their beliefs,” was conducted by a large research team that included UC Berkeley Psychology Postdoctoral Researcher Emily Sanford, UC Berkeley Psychology Professor Jan Engelmann and Utrecht University Psychology Professor Hanna Schleihauf. Their findings showed that chimpanzees — like humans ...
Study links genetic variants to higher 'bad' cholesterol and heart attack risk
2025-10-30
PITTSBURGH, Oct. 30, 2025 – An international team led by a University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine scientist has created a first-of-its-kind resource to identify those with a genetic risk for elevated ‘bad’ cholesterol -- a major contributor to heart disease.
Published today in Science, this resource can assist clinicians in predicting patient risk for heart attacks and strokes, allowing time for prevention and early treatment.
Heart disease remains the leading cause of death in the United States, claiming nearly 700,000 ...
Myanmar fault had ideal geometry to produce 2025 supershear earthquake
2025-10-30
A UCLA-led team of scientists has uncovered how the devastating magnitude 7.7 earthquake that struck Myanmar in March 2025 produced one of the longest and fastest-moving ruptures ever recorded on land.
The study, published in Science, shows that the earthquake ruptured about 530 kilometers of the Sagaing Fault, with a 450-kilometer segment racing faster than the speed of seismic shear waves—a rare phenomenon known as a supershear rupture. These “Mach-like” ruptures generate shock waves that can greatly amplify ground shaking and damage.
“Supershear earthquakes are like breaking the sound barrier, but in rock,” said Lingsen Meng, a professor of ...
Breakthrough in BRCA2 research: a novel mechanism behind chemoresistance discovered
2025-10-30
One of the biggest challenges in cancer treatment is chemoresistance: tumors that initially respond well to chemotherapy become resistant over time. When that happens, treatment options are often limited.
The research team led by Arnab Ray Chaudhuri has now uncovered a mechanism by which BRCA2-deficient tumors develop this resistance. The proteins BRCA2 and FIGNL1 appear to have a different function than previously assumed. “These findings change the paradigm of thought,” says Ray Chaudhuri. The team also ...
New funding for health economics research on substance use disorder treatments
2025-10-30
A team led by Weill Cornell Medicine and University of Miami’s Miller School of Medicine investigators has been awarded a five-year, $4 million grant from the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) for health economics research. The team will study the economics of substance use disorder treatments and overdose prevention strategies for individuals who are incarcerated or otherwise involved in the United States’ criminal legal system.
Interventions for people with substance use disorders are often inadequate in the criminal-legal ...
Tying protein to fraying DNA solves mystery of illness for patients around the world
2025-10-30
MADISON — New research from the University of Wisconsin–Madison reveals that dysfunction in a protein essential to maintaining stability in our chromosomes may be responsible for serious — and sometimes deadly — diseases.
Their findings, published today in Science, could provide patients and their doctors with new protein mutations to test for certain cancers and bone marrow diseases.
Our chromosomes (bundles of proteins and DNA that store all our genetic information), are protected from degradation by telomeres — the protective caps at the ends of chromosomes made from repetitive DNA ...