(Press-News.org) Around 14 hours before a partial solar eclipse passed over the Dolomites in Northern Italy, a group of spruce trees showed a sudden, synchronized increase in electrical activity. A widely publicized paper by Chiolerio et al. claimed that the trees were anticipating and preparing for the impending solar eclipse. In an opinion paper publishing February 6 in the Cell Press journal Trends in Plant Science, researchers debunked this claim by examining the evidence and offering a simpler explanation: a local thunderstorm coincided with the trees’ increased electrical activity, during which a cluster of lightning strikes struck near the study site.
“To me, this paper represents the encroachment of pseudoscience into the heart of biological research,” says first author Ariel Novoplansky, an evolutionary ecologist at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev in Israel. “Instead of considering simpler, well-documented environmental factors, like a heavy rainstorm and a cluster of nearby lightning strikes, the authors leaned into the more seductive idea that the trees were anticipating the impending solar eclipse.”
It is well documented that plants can perceive and respond to changes in environmental conditions and can even anticipate and prepare for future competition from currently harmless neighbors or impending stresses. However, this type of response only occurs when the anticipated event poses a significant challenge and is tightly correlated with predictive cues. In the case of the solar eclipse in question, the event was not significant enough to warrant anticipation, the researchers say, because it was short and involved only a small reduction in light—less of an interruption than some passing clouds.
“The eclipse only reduced light by about 10.5% for two short hours, during which the level of sunlight was approximately twice what the trees could practically use,” says Novoplansky. “Frequent fluctuations in cloud cover at the study location change light quality and quantity by much bigger amplitudes.”
Even if the solar eclipse was significant enough to warrant a preemptive response, the researchers showed that the trees would not have had the ability to anticipate its coming. The solar eclipse was the 53rd in the Saros 124 sequence, a series of eclipses that occur every 18 years, 11 days, and 8 hours. Chiolerio et al. showed that older, larger trees displayed greater increases in electrical activity compared to younger trees and claimed that this showed that the older trees were communicating with the younger trees based on their previous eclipse experiences. However, the debunkers note that each solar eclipse is unique in its path, magnitude, and duration, so even if older trees could “remember” previous eclipses, that information wouldn’t help them anticipate future eclipses. Additionally, they note that the gravitational changes associated with solar eclipses—the signal the trees were supposedly responding to—are similar in magnitude to the gravitational differences that occur during a new moon and are therefore uninformative.
Finally, the researchers note that Chiolerio et al. only measured a very small number of trees: three living trees and five stumps. They caution researchers and members of the media and general public from succumbing to sensational narratives that lack evidence and defy reason.
“The electrical activity of trees is a real phenomenon but it’s still a nascent field of inquiry,” says Novoplansky. “The idea that variations in electrical signals, observable even in dead logs, might encode memory, anticipation, or collective responsiveness requires a few extraordinary leaps, none of which were supported in the study. The forest is wondrous enough without inventing irrational yet superficially fantastic claims of anticipatory responsiveness or communication based only on correlation.”
###
This research was supported by funding from the Israel Science Foundation (ISF) and the V. Kann Rasmussen Foundation.
Trends in Plant Science, Novoplansky et al., “Eclipse of reason: Debunking speculative anticipatory behavior in trees” http://cell.com/trends/plant-science/fulltext/S1360-1385(25)00355-3
Trends in Plant Science (@TrendsPlantSci), published by Cell Press, is a monthly review journal that features broad coverage of basic plant science, from molecular biology through to ecology. Aimed at researchers, students, and teachers, its articles are authoritative and written by both leaders in the field and rising stars. Visit http://www.cell.com/trends/plant-science. To receive Cell Press media alerts, please contact press@cell.com.
END
Boston, MA— A new study led by the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute evaluates the impact of a voluntary code intended to improve ethical recruitment of physicians from World Health Organization-designated shortage countries. While the Code initially reduced physician migration from these countries, the research finds it did not improve their physician supply, highlighting the need for broader investments to strengthen global health systems.
The study is published on February 6 in JAMA Health Forum.
Global health care workforce shortages are intensified when physicians from lower-to-middle income countries (LMICs) migrate to high-income ...
“The concept of time has troubled philosophers and physicists for thousands of years, and the advent of quantum mechanics has not simplified the problem,” says Professor Hugo Dil, a physicist at EPFL. “The central problem is the general role of time in quantum mechanics, and especially the timescale associated with a quantum transition.”
Quantum events, like tunnelling, or an electron changing its state by absorbing a photon, happen at mind‑bending speeds. Some take only a few tens of attoseconds (10-18 seconds), ...
Tungsten carbide–cobalt (WC–Co) is prized for its hardness, but that same property makes it unusually difficult to shape. The current process is wasteful and expensive for the yield produced, and an economically sensible method for creating these materials is long overdue.
WC-Co cemented carbides are important in fields that require high wear resistance and hardness, such as cutting and construction tools. Currently, these carbides are made using powder metallurgy, utilizing high pressure and sintering machines to combine the WC and Co powders to yield a manufactured cemented carbide. Though this method does produce highly durable and hard final products, a lot of expensive ...
Iron-based molecular sieves show great promise for high-temperature NH3-SCR due to their intrinsic shape selectivity and thermal stability. However, excessive ammonia oxidation at high temperatures limits NOx conversion and long-term stability, and its kinetic transition remains poorly understood. A team led by Zhiqiang Sun, Hanzi Liu, and Xinlin Xie has developed a high-temperature Fe@ZSM-5 catalyst and established a coupled kinetic model to describe ammonia oxidation behavior at high temperatures. Their work is published in the journal Industrial Chemistry & Materials on December 2025.
The authors synthesized HZSM-5 zeolites via ...
WUHAN, CHINA — A research team from the Wuhan National Laboratory for Optoelectronics (WNLO) and the School of Optical and Electronic Information at Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST) has reported a new advancement in all-perovskite tandem solar cells. By utilizing quantitative Silvaco TCAD simulations, the team has elucidated the fundamental physics of the tunnel junction, providing a definitive design rule to overcome efficiency bottlenecks in all-perovskite tandem solar cells.
The Bottleneck: Unbalanced Charge Tunneling
All-perovskite tandem solar cells are a high-potential technology ...
Fukuoka, Japan—Cancer is one of the leading causes of death worldwide, marked by the uncontrolled growth of abnormal cells. What makes it more dangerous is the ability of cancer cells to move quickly through the body, allowing them to invade surrounding tissues. While this behavior is well known, the mechanism behind this rapid spread remains unclear. Researchers from Kyushu University set out to fill this gap and unveiled a new physical process that helps cancer cells move rapidly throughout the body.
This study was led by Professor Junichi Ikenouchi from Kyushu University’s Faculty of Medical Sciences, along with his colleagues at Kyushu University, in collaboration with ...
COLUMBUS, Ohio – A new study in mice hints at the potential to use tiny particles made with RNA molecules to deliver chemotherapy drugs and other therapies directly to tumors, killing cancer cells without generating an immune response or toxicity-related side effects.
Researchers constructed tiny molecular clusters called RNA micelles, loaded them with potent chemo drugs and an RNA molecule that blocks cancer survival, and placed a tumor targeting molecule on their outer wall that attaches to receptors on cancer cell surfaces to enhance delivery.
Treatment with these RNA micelles almost ...
Materials scientists have long sought to enhance the durability of thermal/environmental barrier coatings (T/EBCs) under extreme conditions, particularly against corrosion caused by calcium‑magnesium‑alumino‑silicate (CMAS) melts. Understanding the corrosion mechanisms and accurately predicting the long‑term service life of coating materials remain critical challenges for aerospace and energy applications.
Recently, a research team from Harbin Institute of Technology and Shanghai University achieved a significant breakthrough. They designed two novel high‑entropy rare‑earth disilicates—(Er1/4Y1/4Lu1/4Yb1/4)2Si2O7 and ...
Invisible light beyond the range of human vision plays a vital role in communication technologies, medical diagnostics, and optical sensing. Ultraviolet and near-infrared wavelengths are routinely used in these fields, yet detecting them directly often requires complex instrumentation. Developing materials that can convert invisible light into visible signals could serve as essential components for measurement technologies and sensors, and play a major role in understanding the fundamental photophysical processes. However, developing those materials remains a key challenge in ...
Earth’s surface is covered by more than a dozen tectonic plates, and in subduction zones around the world—including the Japanese Islands—plates converge and dense oceanic plates sink into the Earth’s interior. These regions, especially plate boundaries, are known for frequent seismic activity. In recent years, scientists have increasingly emphasized that water plays a crucial role in earthquake phenomena in subduction zones, and thus conducted active research to investigate the influence of water on various processes occurring within earthquake source regions.
When water is supplied, peridotite—the primary constituent of ...
