Pennsylvania May Require DNA Samples For All Felony Arrests

Legislation has been introduced that would require suspects charged with felonies and some misdemeanors to be swabbed for DNA samples in Pennsylvania.

2011-05-13

May 13, 2011 (Press-News.org) Legislation has been introduced that would require suspects charged with felonies and some misdemeanors to be swabbed for DNA samples in Pennsylvania.

The bill is expected to move rapidly through the legislative process. Prosecutors favor the move as making it easier to obtain convictions.

The present law limits DNA samples to those convicted or where permitted by a search warrant.

The Pittsburg Tribune-Review quotes Sgt. Joe Gannon, from the Pittsburg police sex assault squad, and he explained that as evidence, it could go either way, "I think it's a good thing both ways," he said. "It can work to help prove a case and it can help to exonerate a person."

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) opposes the legislation. The Pennsylvania director noted that it would allow someone's DNA to be "searched" in all jurisdictions, without probable cause, when they have never been convicted of a crime.

The law also would expand the collection of DNA to some misdemeanors, casting a very wide net.

Prosecutors want to gather as much DNA as possible, as it allows them to test suspects against ever larger databases, such as the national CODIS database.

The concern here is justification for gathering the DNA from those not convicted seems to conflict with the Fourth Amendment and it is prohibition against unreasonable search and seizures.

A court, it would seem, would need to find that it was reasonable that obtaining the DNA of someone who was not convicted of the crime with which they are charged, and then maintain that information, on a nationwide database, to make it easier for police to convict them for a future crime.

This, while convenient for police, seems constitutionally infirm. If that were the standard, why not take DNA samples of everyone at birth, load them into a database, and anytime a crime is committed, it would be an easy matter to search the records until a match is found.

Pennsylvania courts have permitted the use of DNA databanks, based on U.S. Supreme Court precedent, but they have done so in very specific circumstances:

"In the instant case, the blood-testing program subjects a target population of convicted inmates with reduced privacy expectations, to a relatively minimal intrusion in furtherance of the Commonwealth's need to maintain an identification system to deter recidivism. The slight intrusion occasioned by the withdrawal of blood is outweighed by the special public interest in maintaining an identification data bank.

The U.S. Supreme Court has not review this topic recently, (Justice Stevens wrote the last opinion) so it is a very open question how the present court would rule on a question of creating a database of DNA from those convicted of no crime.

Article provided by The Law Offices of David S. Shrager
Visit us at www.shragerlawfirm.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Interactive teaching methods double learning in undergraduate physics class: UBC research

2011-05-13

Interactive teaching methods significantly improved attendance and doubled both engagement and learning in a large physics class, according to a University of British Columbia study published today in Science. Led by Louis Deslauriers, a post-doctoral researcher at UBC's Carl Wieman Science Education Initiative (CWSEI), the study compared the amount of learning students experienced when taught – in three hours over one week – by traditional lecture and by using interactive activities based on research in cognitive psychology and physics education. The research team ...

Scottsboro Hotel Near Goose Pond Colony Offers Convenient Lodging to Guests Attending Men's National Jr. College Golf Championship

2011-05-13

Hampton Inn & Suites Hotel Scottsboro offers nearby lodging to golfers and fans attending the National Junior College Athletic Association (NJAA) Division II Men's Golf Championship. The tournament will take place on Tuesday, May 17 at Goose Pond Colony Golf Course and will feature the best young golfers from across the country. Colleges that participate in Division II NJCC Golf are located across the country. Goose Pond Colony is a municipally owned resort located on the banks of the Tennessee River at Lake Guntersville, Alabama's largest lake. Goose Pond Colony ...

Action needed to manage climate change risks -- new report

2011-05-13

WASHINGTON — Warning that the risk of dangerous climate change impacts is growing with every ton of greenhouse gases emitted into the atmosphere, a National Research Council committee today reiterated the pressing need for substantial action to limit the magnitude of climate change and to prepare to adapt to its impacts. The nation's options for responding to the risks posed by climate change are analyzed in a new report and the final volume in America's Climate Choices, a series of studies requested by Congress. The committee that authored the report included not only ...

Existing drug treatment reduces pain in young sickle cell anemia patients

2011-05-13

DALLAS – May 12, 2011 – A cancer drug already used to treat adults and school-age children with sickle cell anemia is safe and significantly reduces pain and other complications of the disease in children as young as 9 months, according to a national study involving a UT Southwestern Medical Center researcher. Pediatric researchers at UT Southwestern and 13 other academic medical centers say hydroxyurea should be offered to all young children with sickle cell anemia, regardless of disease severity and clinical symptoms. The findings of the Pediatric Hydroxyurea in Sickle ...

Guoman Hotels' The Royal Horseguards Unveils The Equus Bar

2011-05-13

Guoman Hotels' flagship five star hotel, The Royal Horseguards, has opened the doors to The Equus Bar, London's newest destination bar created specifically with the modern gent in mind. The transformed stylish bar and lounge area of the AA London Hotel of the Year has a strong gentlemen's club feel, styled with crushed velvet reds, chain mail gold and period oil paintings to signify the hotel's historic past. Fabrics in leather, chenille and rich weaves give it a luxurious touch whilst illuminated carved glass panels display cognacs and fine malts. The bar menu - ...

Latitude and rain dictated where species lived

2011-05-13

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] — Aggregating nearly the entire landmass of Earth, Pangaea was a continent the likes our planet has not seen for the last 200 million years. Its size meant there was a lot of space for animals to roam, for there were few geographical barriers, such as mountains or ice caps, to contain them. Yet, strangely, animals confined themselves. Studying a transect of Pangaea stretching from about three degrees south to 26 degrees north (a long swath in the center of the continent covering tropical and semiarid temperate zones), a team of scientists ...

Was Millionaire Entrepreneur Keith Middlebrook Telling the Truth About Partying With Lindsay Lohan?

2011-05-13

From private dinners with Paris Hilton at the Sundance Film Festival to the Men's Luxury Toy Expo, to the Muhammed Ali "Night of Champions" charity dinner, millionaire entrepreneur Keith Middlebrook has a long standing reputation for funding charity events, funding promotions, and for funding just plain fun. This includes several weekends of partying at the Chateau Marmont Hotel with Lindsay Lohan. Keith Middlebrook was recently featured on the cover of Star magazine when someone from inside the Chateau Marmont sold his American Express credit card receipts ...

African Americans and the general public support banning menthol in cigarettes

2011-05-13

According to a new study released online today, a majority of Americans, including most African Americans, stand together in support of banning menthol in cigarettes just as other cigarette flavorings have now been banned by the FDA. According to established reports, 83 percent of African American smokers and 24 percent of white smokers smoke menthol cigarettes. This new study was done by the Center for Child and Adolescent Health Policy at MassGeneral Hospital for Children (MGHfC), the American Academy of Pediatrics' Julius B. Richmond Center of Excellence, and the ...

Mixing fluids efficiently in confined spaces: Let the fingers do the working

2011-05-13

Getting two fluids to mix in small or confined spaces is a big problem in many industries where, for instance, the introduction of one fluid can help extract another — like water pumped underground can release oil trapped in porous rock — or where the mixing of liquids is the essential point of the process. A key example of the latter is microfluidics technology, which allows for the controlled manipulation of fluids in miniscule channels often only a few hundred nanometers wide. Microfluidic devices were first introduced in the 1980s and for many years were best known ...

NREL's multi-junction solar cells teach scientists how to turn plants into powerhouses

2011-05-13

Plants can overcome their evolutionary legacies to become much better at using biological photosynthesis to produce energy, the kind of energy that can power vehicles in the near future, an all-star collection of biologists, physicists, photochemists, and solar scientists has found. A U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) workshop that drew a prestigious collection of 18 scientists to compare the efficiency of plants and photovoltaic solar cells led to an important and provocative scholarly article in today's issue of the journal Science. Two of the scientists are from DOE's ...