(Press-News.org) Families from rural Mexico who receive health care from centralized clinics run by the federal government pay up to 30 percent less in out-of-pocket expenses and utilize preventive services more often than those families who access decentralized clinics run by states, according to a study by researchers at the UCLA School of Public Health.
The findings are published in the September issue of the Journal of Social Science and Medicine and are currently available online.
The data were drawn from a comprehensive survey of 8,889 rural families from seven states in Mexico conducted in 2003 by Oportunidades, Mexico's principal anti-poverty program. The findings contradict the widely perceived notion that decentralized systems — in which local knowledge and resources can be more effectively used to address local needs — are superior to centralized organizations.
The study measured the effectiveness of centralized and decentralized providers using two measures: overall health expenditures by users (both centralized and decentralized providers offer free health care and drugs at rural clinics) and the utilization of preventive services (higher use reduces the cost of treating preventable conditions in the future).
Since centralized and decentralized organizations rarely operate within the same country during the same time period or cater to comparable populations, Mexico's health care–delivery system provides a unique opportunity to compare the two approaches side by side.
Starting the mid-1940s, the public safety net for Mexicans not covered by the Mexican Social Security Institute or other federal social security institutes was administered by the federal government. The government provided a limited bundle of cost-effective services, including primary and preventive care and basic hospitalization to the poorest rural areas of the country.
During the 1980s, the government undertook an ambitious decentralization plan that gave half the Mexican states oversight over these health services. A new administration interrupted the process, but it was restarted in the 1990s. Since then, both centralized and decentralized health care services have co-existed in 17 Mexican states without competing with one another.
The study revealed that households serviced by decentralized providers reported higher out-of-pocket health expenditures and lower utilization of preventive services, spending almost 40 percent more out-of-pocket and utilizing preventive care 7 percent less than households serviced by centralized providers. The households studied showed no differences in terms of age, years of schooling, family size, insurance status, employment, need and most community infrastructure measures.
Providers that were devolved to state governments during the first round of decentralization in the early '80s performed slightly better than providers decentralized in the '90s. This suggests that over time the performance of decentralized providers may improve.
"We find that the Mexican experience can be useful to other developing countries in Latin America (e.g. Chile or Brazil) and other areas of the developing world (e.g. China, Iran, Turkey) where relatively professional centralized governments have considered decentralization as a policy mechanism to reform their national health systems," said Arturo Vargas Bustamante, the study's lead investigator and an assistant professor of health services at the UCLA School of Public Health.
Vargas Bustamante suggests that the centralized providers have four attributes that may give them an advantage:
Type of service: Because the types of services provided to rural populations do not require a high degree of specialization and are relatively homogenous and less sensitive to local taste and variation, centralized providers may be able offer these services more efficiently.
Quality of care: Centralized providers have more public resources to provide better services and employ more incentives and monitoring to improve the quality of care. For example, centralized providers can offer more generous pensions and benefits to their employees, compared with the average decentralized provider.
Experience: In the three decades since decentralization began, centralized providers may have resolved functional issues that decentralized providers may still be tackling.
Local capacity: Even if local authorities are closer to their communities and are more familiar with their characteristics and limitations, they still need managerial skills to provide health services that require some level of expertise. If these skills are less developed among decentralized providers, they will not be able to perform better than centralized providers.
The study suggests that decentralization may be less effective because state governments do not always match the public resources that are taken away by the federal government.
The researchers note that the single advantage enjoyed by those served by decentralized clinics is access to health campaigns. These are useful in providing basic interventions such as vaccinations, screenings and health education. The study suggests that decentralized providers could reduce users' out-of-pocket costs by offering more mobile health services and strengthening the network of clinics where follow-up treatments would be available to people reached by health campaigns.
INFORMATION:
The UCLA School of Public Health is dedicated to enhancing the public's health by conducting innovative research; training future leaders and health professionals; translating research into policy and practice; and serving local, national and international communities.
For more news, visit the UCLA Newsroom and follow us on Twitter.
Centralized health care more cost-effective, offers better access to preventive services
UCLA comparison of Mexico's federal and state health care–delivery systems provides important insights for other developing nations
2010-09-14
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
OHSU researchers able to determine brain maturity through analyzing MRI scans
2010-09-14
PORTLAND, Ore. — Using MRI technology and mathematical analysis, researchers at Oregon Health & Science University and Washington University in St. Louis are now able to accurately predict a young person's age simply by studying their brain scans. The research, which will likely have several clinical applications, including assessment and diagnosis, is published in the current edition of the journal Science.
For several years, OHSU researcher Damien Fair, Ph.D., and his colleagues at Washington University, Nico Dosenbach, M.D., Ph.D., and Bradley Schlaggar, M.D., Ph.D., ...
Computer in wrapping-paper form
2010-09-14
Washington, D.C. (September 14, 2010) -- Driven by rapid global industrialization, finite fossil fuel reserves, and the high cost of many alternative energy options, meeting the world's energy challenge may demand novel solutions. One potential solution has its roots in the ubiquitous industrial invention: the factory.
Investigators at SUNY Binghamton's Center for Advanced Microelectronics Manufacturing (CAMM) -- the only center of its kind in the United States -- are giving factory production of solar energy cells a modern makeover. Their approach includes the use of ...
Lead-free piezoelectric materials of the future
2010-09-14
Washington, D.C. (September 14, 2010) -- Piezoelectric materials have fantastic properties: squeeze them and they generate an electrical field. And vice-versa, they contract or expand when jolted with an electrical pulse. With a name derived from the Greek word meaning to squeeze or press, the piezoelectric effect was just a curiosity after it was discovered in several crystals in 1880. But in 1917, a quartz piezoelectric crystal was at the heart of the world's first submarine-detecting sonar.
Piezoelectric materials really took off after the 1950s, with the development ...
New microfluidic chip for discriminating bacteria
2010-09-14
Washington, D.C. (September 14, 2010) -- A new "on-chip" method for sorting and identifying bacteria has been created by biomedical engineers at Taiwan's National Cheng Kung University. The technique, developed by Hsien-Chang Chang, a professor at the Institute of Biomedical Engineering and the Institute of Nanotechnology and Microsystems Engineering, along with former graduate student I-Fang Cheng and their colleagues, is described in the AIP journal Biomicrofluidics.
Using roughened glass slides patterned with gold electrodes, the researchers created microchannels to ...
Improving crisis prediction, disaster control and damage reduction
2010-09-14
Washington, D.C. (September 14, 2010) -- Some disasters and crises are related to each other by more than just the common negative social value we assign to them. For example, earthquakes, homicide surges, magnetic storms, and the U.S. economic recession are all kindred of a sort, according to a theoretical framework presented in the journal CHAOS, which is published by the American Institute of Physics.
The researchers who developed this framework contend that these four types of events share a precursory development pattern -- a specific change of scale in indicators ...
How do your crystals grow?
2010-09-14
Washington, D.C. (September 14, 2010) -- Because one of the main bottlenecks in determining the structure of protein molecules is producing good isolated single crystals, improved crystallization techniques would be useful in a wide range of genomics and pharmaceutical research.
Research reported in The Journal of Chemical Physics uses fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to investigate the processes at the surface of a growing crystal. By focusing a laser on the crystal surface and measuring the resulting fluorescence, FCS can resolve dimensions as small as a ...
Ending the oceans' 'tragedy of the commons'
2010-09-14
Leading international marine scientists are proposing radical changes in the governance of the world's oceans to rescue them from overfishing, pollution and other human impacts.
Based on a successful experiment in Chile, the researchers say a new approach to marine tenure could help to reverse the maritime 'tragedy of the commons' which has led to the depletion of fish stocks worldwide.
"Marine ecosystems are in decline around the world. New transformational changes in governance are urgently required to cope with overfishing, pollution, global changes, and other drivers ...
Study shows tranquil scenes have positive impact on brain
2010-09-14
Tranquil living environments can positively affect the human brain function, according to researchers at the University of Sheffield.
The research, which was published in the journal NeuroImage, uses functional brain imaging to assess how the environment impacts upon our brain functions.
The findings demonstrated that tranquil environmental scenes containing natural features, such as the sea, cause distinct brain areas to become 'connected' with one another whilst man-made environments, such as motorways, disrupt the brain connections.
The research involved academics ...
Measuring preference for multitasking
2010-09-14
INDIANAPOLIS – A new study led by Elizabeth Poposki, Ph.D., assistant professor of psychology in the School of Science at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, may help employers identify employees who enjoy multitasking and are less inclined to quit jobs involving multitasking. The study presents a new tool developed to measure preference for multitasking, information which may be of interest to bosses who tire of repeatedly hiring and training new employees.
A growing number of individuals must multitask at work and positions requiring a significant amount ...
Largest ever white-shouldered ibis count
2010-09-14
A record-breaking 429 White-shouldered Ibis Pseudibis davisoni have just been recorded in Cambodia, making the known global population much larger than previously thought. With so many birds remaining in the wild the chances of conservation success are greatly improved – welcome news for this Critically Endangered bird species.
The University of East Anglia (UEA), UK, brought together a group of conservationists for a coordinated survey of 37 roost sites across Cambodia. Participants came from the Cambodian Forestry Administration and General Department for Administration ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Heat and heavy metals are changing the way that bees buzz
What’s behind the enormous increase in early-onset gastrointestinal cancers?
Pharmacogenomics expert advances precision medicine for bipolar disorder
Brazilian researcher explores centenarian stem cells for aging insights
Dr. Xuyu Qian's breakthrough analysis of 18 million brain cells advances understanding of human brain development
Gene networks decode human brain architecture from health to glioma
How artificial light at night damages brain health and metabolism
For ultrasound, ultra-strength not always a good thing
Matching your workouts to your personality could make exercising more enjoyable and give you better results
Study shows people perceive biodiversity
Personality type can predict which forms of exercise people enjoy
People can accurately judge biodiversity through sight and sound
People diagnosed with dementia are living longer, global study shows
When domesticated rabbits go feral, new morphologies emerge
Rain events could cause major failure of Waikīkī storm drainage by 2050
Breakthrough in upconversion luminescence research: Uncovering the energy back transfer mechanism
Hidden role of 'cell protector' opens cancer treatment possibilities
How plants build the microbiome they need to survive in a tough environment
Depression due to politics and its quiet danger to democracy addressed in new book 'The Sad Citizen'
International experts and patients unite to help ensure all patients are fully informed before consenting to new surgical procedures
Melting glaciers could trigger more explosive eruptions globally, finds research
Nearly half of U.S. grandchildren live within 10 miles of a grandparent
Study demonstrates low-cost method to remove CO₂ from air using cold temperatures, common materials
Masonic Medical Research Institute (MMRI) welcomes 13 students to prestigious Summer Fellowship program
Mass timber could elevate hospital construction
A nuanced model of soil moisture illuminates plant behavior and climate patterns
$2.6 million NIH grant backs search for genetic cure in deadly heart disease
Pennsylvania’s medical cannabis program changed drastically when anxiety was added as a qualifying condition
1 in 5 overweight adults could be reclassified with obesity according to new framework
Findings of study on how illegally manufactured fentanyl enters U.S. contradict common assumptions, undermining efforts to control supply
[Press-News.org] Centralized health care more cost-effective, offers better access to preventive servicesUCLA comparison of Mexico's federal and state health care–delivery systems provides important insights for other developing nations