July 08, 2011 (Press-News.org) As the RACs continue to focus on medical necessity issues in inpatient hospital admissions, hospitals are left with few good options to effectively address these issues. The Medicare definitions regarding the terms "inpatient" and "outpatient" are circuitous and do not give hospitals much guidance, if any, as to when patients should be kept in outpatient observation as opposed to being admitted as an inpatient. If these admissions are subsequently audited, a RAC's decision that the services were medically necessary but should have been performed in a different setting (outpatient) does not result in a reduction in payment from a higher Part A inpatient amount to a lower Part B outpatient amount. It results in the hospital receiving virtually no payment for medically necessary services that a RAC claims was merely performed in the wrong setting.
CMS published FAQ 9462 in November 2008 (and updated it only last month) taking the position that a hospital that receives a demand letter stating that services should have been performed in an outpatient setting can only rebill at the outpatient level for ancillary services and only if all the claim processing rules and claim timeliness rules are met. Unlike the demonstration program, there are no exceptions to these rules. Therefore, in most cases, hospitals are left which no choice but to appeal the RAC's decision in order to receive any level of payment for medically necessary observation and underlying services including but notlimited to emergency department care, surgical procedures, recovery room and anesthesia.
While there are no statistics that we are aware of published on the rates of overturning medical necessity decisions in short stay cases, both from our experiences and anecdotally, it seems that hospitals are having significant success in this arena. On appeal to the ALJs, hospitals have frequently sought to prove that the services were medically necessary and properly performed on an inpatient basis. However, as alternative relief in the event that the ALJ does not agree that the services were performed in the proper setting, hospitals have requested that the ALJ order CMS to pay for the services at the outpatient rate. In all the cases that we are aware of, either ALJs or the Medicare Appeals Council have agreed to pay at the outpatient rate when this was the appropriate setting for a medically necessary service.1 However, absent appealing the RAC's decision to the ALJ (or the Council), hospitals have no method to receive full payment for the services provided.
This landscape has forcedhospitals to appeal a RAC's decision even in cases when the hospital would otherwise just agree to accept payment at the outpatient rate as CMS has created no process for the hospitals to rebill at the outpatient rate. While reasons for this policy have been unclear, there are no legal impediments to a policy change which would eliminate the need for hospitals to appeal virtually every RAC inpatient medical necessity denial in order to secure some meaningful level of payment for medically necessary services provided to beneficiaries.
On March 29, Andrew Wachler along with the American Hospital Association, the Greater New York Hospital Association, representatives from three major healthcare systems and Don Romano met with representatives from CMS to discuss the issues of medical necessity denials in short stay cases. These hospital representatives advocated for reinstituting a method for resubmitting an adjusted bill, such as occurred during the RAC demonstration, to allow hospitals to resubmit claims when necessary services were provided in the wrong setting. CMS 1 For example, UMDNJ - University Hospital v. Riverbend GBA (March 14, 2005) and O'Connor Hospital v. National Government Services (February 1, 2010) - appeared sensitive to the hospitals concerns on this issue and continues to explore whether this concept could be reinstituted during the RAC permanent program.
The current system is neither equitable nor efficient. Even the Statement of Work for the Recovery Audit Contractor Program published by CMS states that the mission of the program "is to reduce Medicare improper payments through the efficient detection and collection of overpayments, the identification of underpayments and the implementation of actions that will prevent future improper payments." But even though proper payment is the stated goal, hospitals have been given no way to receive payment for services that even the RAC agrees were medically necessary (albeit in a different setting). This failing creates inefficiencies by forcing hospitals to incur the costs of appeal and increase the caseload for ALJs unnecessarily. While some short stay cases will clearly still be appealed even if hospitals are enabled to submit an adjustment bill, in a number of cases hospitals would choose to avoid the costs of appeal and simply accept payment at the outpatient rate. Additionally, any concerns about the possibility of beneficiary's received bills for larger Part B co-payments years after a procedure could be addressed through an understanding between CMS and hospitals that such collection efforts would be unreasonable in light of both the passage of time and the failure to notify beneficiaries in advance of the possibility that these services would later be rebilled under Part B.
In summary, it is time for CMS to fix this inequity of the RAC program and allow the submission of an adjustment bill when a RAC finds that services provided in an inpatient setting were medically necessary but provided in the improper setting. Fixing this would both be equitable in that it would pay the hospitals for medically necessary services provided and efficient as it would eliminate the need for hospitals to appeal virtually every short stay case. We will continue to update the RAC Monitor of developments as they occur.
By Andrew Wachler, Esq. and Alicia Chandler, Esq., Wachler & Associates, P.C.
About Wachler & Associates:
Wachler & Associates, P.C., has been representing healthcare providers, suppliers and entities nationwide for over 20 years. Our law firm will guide you through the regulatory maze of RAC audits and claim denials and Medicare appeals.
Wachler & Associates, P.C.
210 East 3rd Street Suite 204
Royal Oak, MI 48607
Phone: 248-544-0888
RAC Medical Necessity Denials of Inpatient Services - Fair & Equitable Reimbursement
As the RACs continue to focus on medical necessity issues in inpatient hospital admissions, hospitals are left with few good options to effectively address these issues.
2011-07-08
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
MU study identifies protective factors that help women recover from childhood violence
2011-07-08
COLUMBIA, Mo. –Children who witness domestic violence are more likely to be in abusive intimate relationships and experience psychological problems such as post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in adulthood, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. A University of Missouri researcher has found that certain protective factors foster resilience and increase the likelihood that the cycle of violence will end for women who, as children, were exposed to their mothers' battering.
Kim Anderson, associate professor in the MU School of Social Work, found that ...
Coast Guard Releases Statistics on Virginia Boating Accidents
2011-07-08
Virginia's many bays, estuaries and rivers are a magnet for the quarter of a million registered watercraft in the state, especially during the summer months. Chesapeake Bay, the Potomac and other waterways provide many great destinations for a day of fishing or pleasure boating. But these waters can quickly turn dangerous when power boats or jet skis are piloted by drunk or otherwise negligent operators.
Recently released statistics reveal that 2010 was a less deadly year for Virginia boaters. The U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) recently released national statistics on boating ...
'Pinkwashing' is a form of social injustice asserts article in Environmental Justice
2011-07-08
New Rochelle, NY, July 7, 2011—Companies that try to increase sales of their products by adopting the color pink and pink ribbons to imply that they support breast cancer research—a practice called pinkwashing—but at the same time permit the use of chemicals shown to cause cancer are committing a form of social injustice against women, according to a thought-provoking article in Environmental Justice, a peer-reviewed journal published by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. (www.liebertpub.com) The entire issue is available online at www.liebertpub.com/env
Amy Lubitow, Portland State ...
Drunk Driving Bills Fail in the Legislature
2011-07-08
As the spring legislation session ends, many are wondering about the cluster of anti drunk driving bills that failed to garner support. The session began with lawmakers vowing to pass tougher laws that would keep more offenders off the road. Ultimately, lawmakers only agreed to send one proposal to the governor's office.
One proposal called for deferred adjudication for first time offenders, but it was defeated. It would have allowed for them to be acquitted if they completed court ordered treatment and supervision. Proponents believed it would help offenders get the ...
Discovery of natural antibody brings a universal flu vaccine a step closer
2011-07-08
LA JOLLA, CA – July 7, 2011 – Annually changing flu vaccines with their hit-and-miss effectiveness may soon give way to a single, near-universal flu vaccine, according to a new report from scientists at The Scripps Research Institute and the Dutch biopharmaceutical company Crucell. They describe an antibody that, in animal tests, can prevent or cure infections with a broad variety of influenza viruses, including seasonal and potentially pandemic strains.
The finding, published in the journal Science Express on July 7, 2011, shows the influenza subtypes neutralized with ...
Lack of Bike Helmet Law in Idaho May Increase Injuries and Deaths
2011-07-08
The state of Idaho has an unusually high rate of bicyclist injuries and fatalities, according to statistics from 2009. Children and young adults who do not wear helmets when they ride are the most common victims of injury-causing bicycle accidents. However, Idaho does not currently have a bicycle helmet statute, so bicyclists who choose not to wear helmets are not violating any laws. While it is difficult to know how much a universal bicycle helmet law would reduce bicyclist injuries and deaths, such a law is a good place for Idaho to start.
Bicycle Crashes
According ...
'Unnatural' chemical allows Salk researchers to watch protein action in brain cells
2011-07-08
LA JOLLA, CA - Researchers at the Salk Institute have been able to genetically incorporate "unnatural" amino acids, such as those emitting green fluorescence, into neural stem cells, which then differentiate into brain neurons with the incandescent "tag" intact.
They say this new technique, described in the June 16 online issue of Stem Cells, may help scientists probe the mysteries of many different kinds of stem cells in humans as well as the cells they produce. This could be a boon to both basic and clinical research, such as helping to speed development of stem cell-based ...
How visual cues help us understand bodily motion
2011-07-08
"Our visual system is tuned towards perceiving other people. We spend so much time doing that—seeing who they are, what they are doing, what they intend to do," says psychology professor Nikolaus F. Troje of Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario.
This process is called biological motion perception, and humans are so good at it that even a few dots on a screen representing the major joints of a body are enough to retrieve all the information we need—as long as they move.
But what role does motion play in that process? Does the visual system use it only to connect the ...
Ironic effects of anti-prejudice messages
2011-07-08
Organizations and programs have been set up all over the globe in the hopes of urging people to end prejudice. According to a research article, which will be published in an upcoming issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, such programs may actually increase prejudices.
Lisa Legault, Jennifer Gutsell and Michael Inzlicht, from the University of Toronto Scarborough, were interested in exploring how one's everyday environment influences people's motivation toward prejudice reduction.
The authors conducted two experiments ...
Wayne State University researcher argues that sex reduces genetic variation
2011-07-08
DETROIT – Biology textbooks maintain that the main function of sex is to promote genetic diversity. But Henry Heng, Ph.D., associate professor in WSU's Center for Molecular Medicine and Genetics, says that's not the case.
Heng and fellow researcher Root Gorelick, Ph.D., associate professor at Carleton University in Canada, propose that although diversity may result from a combination of genes, the primary function of sex is not about promoting diversity. Rather, it's about keeping the genome context – an organism's complete collection of genes arranged by chromosome ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
McGill discovery sheds new light on autism, intellectual disabilities
Cellular changes occur even below the hexavalent chromium limit
Study suggests a new way to curb social media’s body image toll
Plant doctor: An AI system that watches over urban trees without touching a leaf
Study tracks chromium chemistry in irradiated molten salts
Scientists: the beautiful game is a silver bullet for global health
Being physically active, even just a couple of days a week, may be key to better health
High-fat diet promote breast cancer metastasis in animal models
A router for photons
Nurses and AI collaborate to save lives, reduce hospital stays
Multi-resistance in bacteria predicted by AI model
Tinker Tots: A citizen science project to explore ethical dilemmas in embryo selection
Sensing sickness
Cost to build multifamily housing in California more than twice as high as in Texas
Program takes aim at drinking, unsafe sex, and sexual assault on college campuses
Inability to pay for healthcare reaches record high in U.S.
Science ‘storytelling’ urgently needed amid climate and biodiversity crisis
KAIST Develops Retinal Therapy to Restore Lost Vision
Adipocyte-hepatocyte signaling mechanism uncovered in endoplasmic reticulum stress response
Mammals were adapting from life in the trees to living on the ground before dinosaur-killing asteroid
Low LDL cholesterol levels linked to reduced risk of dementia
Thickening of the eye’s retina associated with greater risk and severity of postoperative delirium in older patients
Almost one in ten people surveyed report having been harmed by the NHS in the last three years
Enhancing light control with complex frequency excitations
New research finds novel drug target for acute myeloid leukemia, bringing hope for cancer patients
New insight into factors associated with a common disease among dogs and humans
Illuminating single atoms for sustainable propylene production
New study finds Rocky Mountain snow contamination
Study examines lactation in critically ill patients
UVA Engineering Dean Jennifer West earns AIMBE’s 2025 Pierre Galletti Award
[Press-News.org] RAC Medical Necessity Denials of Inpatient Services - Fair & Equitable ReimbursementAs the RACs continue to focus on medical necessity issues in inpatient hospital admissions, hospitals are left with few good options to effectively address these issues.