(Press-News.org) The introduction of a sugar tax, increasing the price of fizzy drinks and other products high in sugar content, has had only a limited, moderate effect in shifting people's dietary habits and behaviours, according to a new study.
Fresh research from an international team of economists published in the journal Social Science & Medicine, focused on the impact of a sugar tax on people's shopping baskets comparing customer spending in Catalonia in Spain (where a tax had been introduced), with the rest of the country (where it had not been) from May 2016 - April 2018.
A sugar-sweetened beverages (SSB) tax was in introduced in Catalonia in May 2017, but not for the rest of Spain. The tax has a tiered structure whereby the rate increases dependent on the amount of sugar contained within a product. The Catalonian approach mirrors that of the UK Soft Drinks Industry Levy, which came into force on 6 April 2018.
The SSB tax meant that, on average, a one litre bottle of Fanta, Sprite or Seven Up!, which cost around €1.02 the month before the tax increased to €1.18. However, one of the additional effects of tax has been reformulation - whereby drinks producers have created and marketed new products with much lower overall sugar content (e.g. Coke Zero).
Drawing on customer data derived from loyalty cards at a Spanish supermarket chain and comparing shopping baskets for nearly a million households (844,943) both before and after the tax was introduced, the research team found that households did reduce purchases of high sugar (taxed) beverages and increased purchases of lower sugar (untaxed) options in response.
However, this reduction was modest. Overall, they calculated this led to an average reduction in sugar of 2.2%, which spread out on a per person basis equalled only a tiny, 3.7 calories per month. Their results also showed a distributional effect with regular (i.e. those doing most of their shopping at this supermarket chain) and high-income customers most affected by the tax.
This might be either due to the fact that the tax was more salient for these groups or that these groups represented the largest share of the sample. Consequently, the researchers argue that much more is needed to influence behaviours and reduce obesity in particular among poorer households.
Lead researcher, Dr Eleonora Fichera from the Department of Economics at the University of Bath (UK) explains: "In response to rising levels of obesity and the serious and significant negative effects this is having for individuals, their families and wider healthcare systems, over the past five years there has been growing interest in the potential effectiveness of sugar taxes.
"By analysing the effect of a tiered tax system for sugar-sweetened beverages in Catalonia and by comparing its impact with the rest of Spain (where a tax was not introduced) our results provide important evidence to policymakers keen to explore the potential effectiveness of this approach.
"And whilst our results demonstrate some impact in shifting behaviours towards products lower in sugar, this effect is modest at best. If these taxes are to be more effective, they need to be more visible at the checkout so that consumers become increasingly aware of the added cost of their high-sugar choices. This requires that the tax is more specific too, ensuring producers are forced to pass the tax through to consumers. Although more than 20% of the Catalan tax was passed through to consumers, not all of it was, making the tax less impactful."
A wide range of additional policies have recently been introduced to tackle growing obesity, including high sugar and high calorie labelling as well as different taxes. In August 2020, Dr Fichera published separate research suggesting that nutritional labelling is helping to improve the nation's diet.
She added: "There is no one, single, silver bullet which will resolve the obesity crisis that many countries in the West are facing. Obesity is a complex problem, exacerbated by a proliferation of high-sugar, high-fat products but also our increasingly sedentary lifestyles. Our approach to tackle it needs to be holistic and co-ordinated."
INFORMATION:
The full research team included Dr Eleonora Fichera at the University of Bath, Professor Toni Mora and Dr David Roche at Universitat Internacional de Catalunya, and Professor Lopez-Varcarcel at Universidad de Las Palmas in Spain.
To access the new study 'How do consumers respond to "sin taxes"? New evidence from a tax on sugary drinks' published in Social Science & Medicine see https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953621001313?via%3Dihub. DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.113799.
A rare pulmonary disease that is linked to bats has made Alberta home, according to new research led by provincial lab scientists.
Infectious disease experts at Alberta Precision Laboratories (APL) and the University of Alberta have confirmed that histoplasmosis - a fungal infection transmitted through bat and bird droppings - is now found in Alberta. Their study extends the known range of the disease much further northwest from its traditional home in the central United States and parts of southern Ontario and Quebec.
"We were surprised at how many cases were locally acquired, as histoplasmosis has ...
An international, open-label Phase 3 study, co-led by Susanna McColley, MD, from Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, found that a regimen of three drugs (elexacaftor/tezacaftor/ivacaftor) that targets the genetic cause of cystic fibrosis was safe and effective in 6-11-year-olds with at least one copy of F508del mutation in the CFTR gene, which is estimated to represent almost 90 percent of the cystic fibrosis population in the United States.
For children in this age group who have only one copy of F508del mutation - or about 40 percent of patients with cystic fibrosis ...
A UCLA-led research team has identified a chemical cocktail that enables the production of large numbers of muscle stem cells, which can self-renew and give rise to all types of skeletal muscle cells.
The advance could lead to the development of stem cell-based therapies for muscle loss or damage due to injury, age or disease. The research was published in Nature Biomedical Engineering.
Muscle stem cells are responsible for muscle growth, repair and regeneration following injury throughout a person's life. In fully grown adults, muscle stem cells are quiescent -- they remain inactive until they are called to respond to injury by self-replicating and creating all of the cell types necessary to repair damaged tissue.
But that regenerative capacity decreases as people ...
Researchers from Skoltech were part of a research consortium studying a case of vertical COVID-19 transmission from mother to her unborn child that resulted in major complications in the pregnancy, premature birth and death of the child. The consortium used a Skoltech-developed proteomics method to verify the diagnosis. The paper was published in the journal Viruses.
The effects of SARS-CoV-2, the novel coronavirus, on maternal and perinatal outcomes are poorly understood due to limited data and research in pregnant women with COVID-19. There is some evidence suggesting vertical transmission from mother to fetus during pregnancy is possible, as, for instance, in China, immunoglobulin ...
Dogs infected with the Leishmania parasite smell more attractive to female sand flies than males, say researchers.
The study published in PLOS Pathogens is led by Professor Gordon Hamilton of Lancaster University.
In Brazil, the parasite Leishmania infantum is transmitted by the bite of infected female Lutzomyia longipalpis sand flies.
Globally over 350 million people are at risk of leishmaniasis, with up to 300,000 new cases annually. In Brazil alone there are approximately 4,500 deaths each year from the visceral form of the disease and children under 15 years old are more likely to be affected.
Leishmania parasites ...
WASHINGTON -- Even as vaccines are becoming more readily available in the U.S., protecting against the asymptomatic and pre-symptomatic spread of the virus (SARS-CoV-2) that causes COVID-19 is key to ending the pandemic, say two Georgetown infectious disease experts.
In their Perspective, " END ...
CAMBRIDGE, MA -- Much of the carbon in space is believed to exist in the form of large molecules called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Since the 1980s, circumstantial evidence has indicated that these molecules are abundant in space, but they have not been directly observed.
Now, a team of researchers led by MIT Assistant Professor Brett McGuire has identified two distinctive PAHs in a patch of space called the Taurus Molecular Cloud (TMC-1). PAHs were believed to form efficiently only at high temperatures -- on Earth, they occur as byproducts of burning fossil fuels, and they're also found in char marks on grilled ...
One of great mysteries of human biology is how a single cell can give rise to the 37 trillion cells contained in the average body, each with its own specialized role. Researchers at Yale University and the Mayo Clinic have devised a way to recreate the earliest stages of cellular development that gives rise to such an amazing diversity of cell types.
Using skin cells harvested from two living humans, researchers in the lab of Yale's Flora Vaccarino were able to track their cellular lineage by identifying tiny variations or mutations contained within the genomes of those cells.
These "somatic" or non-inherited mutations are generated at each cell division during a human's development. The percentage of cells bearing the traces of any ...
The small intestine is ground zero for survival of animals. It is responsible for absorbing the nutrients crucial to life and it wards off toxic chemicals and life-threatening bacteria.
In a new study published March 18 in the journal Science, Yale researchers report the critical role played by the gut's immune system in these key processes. The immune system, they found, not only defends against pathogens but regulates which nutrients are taken in.
The findings may provide insights into origins of metabolic disease and malnutrition that is common in ...
93 million years ago, bizarre, winged sharks swam in the waters of the Gulf of Mexico. This newly described fossil species, called Aquilolamna milarcae, has allowed its discoverers to erect a new family. Like manta rays, these 'eagle sharks' are characterised by extremely long and thin pectoral fins reminiscent of wings. The specimen studied was 1.65 metres long and had a span of 1.90 metres.
Aquilolamna milarcae had a caudal fin with a well-developed superior lobe, typical of most pelagic sharks, such as whale sharks and tiger sharks. Thus, its anatomical features thus ...
