(Press-News.org) Humans often cooperate, but ample research has shown that they're conditionally cooperative; that is, they are far more likely to cooperate with those who they consider "good."
In large societies, however, people don't always know the reputations of the people with whom they interact. That's where reputation monitoring systems--such as the star ratings for eBay sellers or the scores assigned by credit bureaus--come into play, helping guide people's decisions about whether or not they want to help or interact with another person.
In a new paper in the journal Nature Communications, a team from Penn uses mathematical modeling to study how public institutions of reputation monitoring can foster cooperation and also encourage participants to adhere to its assessments instead of relying on their own subjective judgments of each others' reputations.
"We show how to construct institutions of public monitoring that foster cooperation, regardless of the social norm of moral judgement," says Joshua Plotkin, a professor in the Department of Biology in Penn's School of Arts & Sciences who coauthored the paper with postdoctoral fellows Arunas Radvilavicius and Taylor Kessinger. "And then adherence to the public institution will naturally spread."
The work explores the concept known as indirect reciprocity. Unlike direct reciprocity, in which two people may take turns helping one another, indirect reciprocity depends on a shared moral system.
"Under the theory of indirect reciprocity, if I encounter someone who is known to be good, then I'll probably cooperate with them, even without any tangible benefit to myself," Plotkin says. "By doing this I gain something intangible--social capital, or reputation--that is potentially valuable down the line. I'll be seen as a good person, and a third party may later repay my kindness. But if I defect against that good person, then I'll likely end up with a bad reputation, and I won't benefit from anyone else's help in the future."
Different social norms vary in how they assign moral reputations to individuals based on their actions. Stemming from game theory, one classic social norm is called "stern judging," in which cooperating with someone good earns you a good reputation, but cooperating with someone bad earns you a bad reputation. Another is "simple standing," "a more forgiving norm," Plotkin says, in which cooperating with someone bad also gains you a good reputation.
When studying how social norms might foster cooperation, however, prior studies assumed that everyone knows each other's reputations and that those views are all consistent. In the real world, of course, people can make individual decisions about others' reputations. And when these views are inconsistent and opinions differ, "it can lead to a collapse of cooperation," says Plotkin.
One way to solve this is to have an institution offer a public assessment of each member's reputation. In the current work, the researchers aimed to test what features of such an institution will lead to the highest levels of cooperation and when individuals will adhere to the public broadcast.
They considered a scenario in which individuals could choose whether to make decisions based on their own perceptions of others' reputations, or choose to rely on the assessments of the designated public institution.
"You can imagine a simple institution consisting of just two observers, who compare their observations and come up with a consensus view of reputations to broadcast publicly," Plotkin says.
By varying the number of observers and the strictness with which they form their consensus views, the researchers found they could always get cooperation to flourish in their models, no matter which social norm was present--simple standing, stern judging, or others.
What's more, individuals evolved to adhere to the institution's assessments.
"Even if only a few people in the population adhere to the institution's judgements to begin with," Plotkin says, "those individuals will be better off. And so institutional adherence will tend to spread by social contagion. So there's a nice sense in which we can specify institutions that foster cooperation and then get adherence for free."
In follow-up work, Plotkin and colleagues hope to probe what happens to cooperation and adherence under different scenarios. What happens when individuals must pay a "tax" to support a public monitoring system? Can such an institution resist corruption, or avoid bias? And what happens when a variety of social norms exist in a population? Such variables could bring the team's work closer to applications in human society.
"Unlike other theories of cooperation, which make sense for simple organisms such as bacteria," Plotkin says, "this study explores an explanation for cooperation that is compelling in human societies, where reputations are carefully monitored and valued."
INFORMATION:
Joshua Plotkin is the Walter H. and Leonore C. Annenberg Professor of Natural Sciences in the University of Pennsylvania School of Arts & Sciences' Department of Biology.
Arunas L. Radvilavicius was a postdoctoral fellow in the School of Arts & Sciences' Department of Biology at Penn and is now an editor at the journal Nature Human Behaviour.
Taylor A. Kessinger is a postdoctoral fellow in the School of Arts & Sciences' Department of Biology at Penn.
In fighting the COVID-19 pandemic, it's not just the vaccines that require complicated cold supply chains and refrigerated storage. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests -- often considered the "gold standard" of testing -- also have enzymes and reagents that need to be frozen.
Northwestern University researchers have discovered that commercially available PCR tests can withstand the freeze-drying process, making them shelf-stable for up to 30 days and 50 degrees Celsius (122 degrees Fahrenheit), without sacrificing sensitivity and accuracy.
The researchers ...
In 2007, the American housing boom ended, and there was heightened risk of a housing crisis. Private securitizers withdrew from purchasing high-risk mortgages, while government-sponsored enterprises, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, dramatically increased their acquisitions of risky mortgages. By 2008, the agencies reversed course, decreasing their high-risk acquisitions.
In a new article, an economist proposes a scenario in which large lenders temporarily boost high-risk activity at the end of a boom. According to her model, lenders with many outstanding mortgages have incentives to extend risky credit to prop up housing prices, which lessens the losses on their outstanding portfolio of mortgages. As the bust continues, lenders slowly wind down their mortgage exposure.
The ...
BOSTON - The cost of cancer care in United States was an estimated $183 billion in 2015 and is projected to rise by 30 percent by 2030, according to the American Cancer Society. While private and government insurance may cover much of the cost of care, even patients with insurance can struggle to pay for office visit co-payments, prescription medications or other cancer-related expenses. Yet limited data describes how financial hardship impacts patient behavior and how that in turn may impact patient health.
In a new study designed to provide a more comprehensive picture of how a diverse cohort of gynecologic cancer patients are affected by financial distress -- also called "financial toxicity" in acknowledgment of the health ...
RIVERSIDE, Calif. -- When two similar atomic layers with mismatching lattice constants -- the constant distance between a layer's unit cells -- and/or orientation are stacked together, the resulting bilayer can exhibit a moiré pattern and form a moiré superlattice.
Moiré patterns are interference patterns that typically arise when one object with a repetitive pattern is placed over another with a similar pattern. Moiré superlattices, formed by atomic layers, can exhibit fascinating phenomena not found in the individual layers, opening the door to technological revolutions in many areas, including electricity transmission, information engineering, and ...
White men who had a Black neighbor when they were growing up are more likely to be Democrats and less likely to be Republican, an influence that can last several decades later.
That's according to a Harvard study published Friday in Science Advances that takes individual level data from 650,000 Americans recorded in the 1940 U.S. Census. Using machine learning, the analysis links those records to contemporary voter files to see if there are correlations between having a Black neighbor as a child and political views later in life. The paper includes only men because the common practice of surname changes at marriage made it difficult to accurately track women.
The scientists found that those 650,000 white men who had a Black neighbor growing up are believed to be more likely ...
There is no question that the pandemic has been immensely stressful for health care workers, especially for those on the frontline of patient care. Yet, even before the pandemic, the regular demands of many health care industry jobs put these workers at risk for burnout.
Now, a new study from the University of Georgia suggests that investing in more physical activity programming could mitigate the effects of stress and improve worker mental and emotional health.
Tackling burnout in health care is critical to ensuring patient safety, said lead author Marilyn ...
(Boston)-- Prevalence rates of opioid use disorder (OUD) have increased dramatically, accompanied by a surge of overdose deaths--nearly 50,000 in the U.S. in 2019. While opioid dependence has been extensively studied in preclinical models, an understanding of the biological alterations that occur in the brains of people who chronically use opioids and who are diagnosed with OUD remains limited.
To address this issue, researchers from Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) have conducted the largest transcriptomic (the study of all the RNA molecules within a cell) study to date using postmortem ...
People with end-stage renal disease often undergo hemodialysis, a life-sustaining blood-filtering treatment. To make the process as fast and efficient as possible, many people have "hemodialysis grafts" surgically implanted. These grafts are like bypasses, connecting a vein to a major artery, making it easier to access blood and ensuring the same blood doesn't get filtered twice.
But the grafts have a notorious problem: Clots tend to form where the graft is attached to the vein. For the person undergoing dialysis, this means not only a break from treatment, but also surgery to remove the graft and then surgery to implant another.
A multidisciplinary team from Washington University School of Medicine ...
Scientists know that developing cells in a healthy embryo will transform into a variety of cell types that will make up the different organ systems in the human body, a process known as cell differentiation. But they don't know how the cells do it.
A Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) study in Cell Reports led by Stephen Duncan, D.Phil., examines how an endodermal cell - a type of developing cell - becomes a liver cell and not some other type of cell. Duncan and his team found that the development of naive cells into differentiated liver cells ...
Researchers have developed a new approach to gene therapy that leans on the common pain reliever acetaminophen to force a variety of genetic diseases into remission.
A paper published in Science Translational Medicine describes how the novel technique successfully treated the blood-clotting disorder hemophilia and the debilitating metabolic disease known as phenylketonuria, or PKU, in mice.
The approach uses a benign lentivirus to both correct disease-causing mutations and to insert a new gene that makes liver cells immune to the potentially toxic effects of acetaminophen. The latter ...
