(Press-News.org) As the United States continues to lead global oil and gas production—accounting for roughly 20% of worldwide output in 2024—understanding how different extraction methods affect ecosystems has never been more urgent. A new study in ACS ES&T Water offers new clarity: conventional, often decades-old oil-and-gas infrastructure leaves a deeper, more persistent mark on freshwater biodiversity than unconventional shale (fracking) development.
The research was conducted by a multi-institutional team led by Ryan Olivier-Meehan, a former undergraduate and now a graduate student in the Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences (EES) in the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University, in collaboration with EES Assistant Professor Tao Wen and partners at UCLA, Carnegie Institution for Science and the University of Colorado Boulder. Their analysis integrates ecology, geology and data science to move the conversation beyond assumptions and toward evidence-based environmental stewardship.
Pennsylvania as a Natural Laboratory
The study focused on streams in Pennsylvania, which Wen describes as the perfect natural laboratory. “Pennsylvania has a very long history of conventional oil and gas drilling with some wells dating back more than 100 years,” notes Wen. “At the same time, it has been at the center of modern shale gas development. On top of that, the state has a very strong stream monitoring program.”
This overlap of legacy infrastructure, newer technology and consistent biological data created a unique chance to compare ecological impacts at scale. “What makes this moment special is that we now have decades of high-quality biological monitoring data available,” Wen says. “That gave us a rare opportunity to step back and ask, what has all of this development meant for stream life at a statewide scale?”
Measuring Stream Health Using Native Organisms
To quantify ecological change, the team analyzed more than 6,800 benthic macroinvertebrate samples, which include bottom-dwelling insect larvae, small crustaceans and worms. They compared them across watershed characteristics and detailed oil-and-gas records. The team then applied modeling and network analysis to tease apart the relative influences of shale versus conventional development on community composition and biological integrity.
“Benthic macroinvertebrates are excellent indicators of stream health because they live in the water year-round, constantly exposed to local conditions” says Olivier-Meehan. “If conditions deteriorate, sensitive species disappear and are replaced by more tolerant ones. By looking at the community as a whole, we get a long-term picture of stream condition—not just a snapshot of water chemistry on a single day.”
These organisms also form the base of the food web. They recycle nutrients, break down organic matter and support fish and bird populations. Therefore, understanding how drilling affects their biodiversity is essential, because any disruption to these foundational species can ripple upward through the entire ecosystem and signal broader declines in watershed health.
Analyzing the Data
The statewide patterns were clear. Conventional development was linked with fewer species, less variety among them, and an overall decline in the ecosystem’s health. It also caused the community of aquatic organisms to shift toward hardy, pollution-tolerant species—signs that the ecosystem is becoming less resilient. The effects from shale development showed limited but detectable effects.
“Public debate often centers on shale gas because it’s newer and more visible. Our results show the story is more nuanced,” says Olivier-Meehan. “In Pennsylvania, conventional drilling—much more widespread and often decades old—was more strongly associated with declines in stream biodiversity.”
The researchers stress that this does not imply shale development is impact-free. Rather, environmental risk reflects the age and density (number of wells within a specific region) along with infrastructure, regulatory oversight and landscape factors that influence ecological impacts.
Implications and What Comes Next
Beyond Pennsylvania, Wen sees broad applicability. “While our study focuses on Pennsylvania, many other states and countries have similar histories of conventional oil and gas development,” he says. “The broader message—that legacy infrastructure can have lasting ecological effects—likely applies elsewhere. Our framework provides a way to evaluate cumulative impacts and prioritize restoration where it will matter most.”
The team’s next steps include examining how outcomes differ based on the density of inactive, abandoned and orphaned wells, their proximity to streams and local geology, as well as expanding the analysis to other regions. “Our goal is to help communities make informed decisions that balance energy needs with environmental protection,” Wen says. “Good long-term monitoring lets us move beyond assumptions to evidence-based conversations about sustainability.”
END
Where wells run deep, biodiversity runs thin
2026-03-10
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Q&A: Gassing up bioengineered materials for wound healing
2026-03-10
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Biomaterials are specifically engineered to support tissue, nerve and muscle regeneration across the body, yet physicians and researchers have limited control over the size and connectivity of the internal pores that transfer oxygen and vital nutrients to where they are most needed. To solve this problem and better support tissue regeneration, a team at Penn State has designed a new class of tunable biomaterials.
Led by corresponding author Amir Sheikhi, the Dorothy Foehr Huck and J. Lloyd Huck Early Career Chair in Biomaterials and Regenerative Engineering and associate professor of chemical engineering, the team developed a highly ...
From genetics to AI: Integrated approaches to decoding human language in the brain
2026-03-10
VANCOUVER - March 8, 2026 - Learning French, reading the latest Andy Weir novel, hanging out with friends for St. Patrick’s Day — language is central to all these everyday activities. Seemingly effortless from childhood, language, it turns out, is quite complex, not constrained to one set of genes or one region in the brain. Cognitive neuroscientists are now using a diverse arsenal of tools, including novel genetic analyses and AI, to gain insights into both healthy and disordered communication across individuals.
“We still tend ...
Leora Westbrook appointed executive director of NR2F1 Foundation
2026-03-10
We are excited to share an important milestone for the NR2F1 Foundation: Leora Westbrook has joined our organization as our first Executive Director.
Since the Foundation was established in 2018, our work has been driven entirely by families and volunteers dedicated to advancing research, supporting families, and building a global community affected by Bosch–Boonstra–Schaaf Optic Atrophy Syndrome (BBSOAS). Together, we have built something truly special, powered by determination, collaboration, ...
Massive-scale spatial multiplexing with 3D-printed photonic lanterns achieved by researchers
2026-03-10
Researchers have developed a microscopic 3D-printed optical device that can efficiently combine light from dozens of small semiconductor lasers into a single multimode optical fiber with very low loss. The team demonstrated photonic lanterns that multiplex 7, 19, and 37 multimode VCSEL lasers directly into a fiber while preserving brightness and easing alignment constraints. By enabling scalable incoherent beam combining of many multimode lasers, the technology could simplify and improve high-power laser systems, optical communications, and other ...
Younger stroke survivors face greater concentration, mental health challenges — especially those not employed
2026-03-10
Analysis of a large, nationally representative survey shows that stroke survivors under age 50 have more problems concentrating and running errands and experience more poor mental health days than older stroke survivors do.
Younger survivors who were not working faced the greatest challenges in their recovery. The study comes as stroke rates among younger people have increased rapidly in recent years, driven in part by sedentary lifestyles and rising obesity rates.
The researchers behind the study say that ...
From chatbots to assembly lines: the impact of AI on workplace safety
2026-03-10
The use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools, spearheaded by generative AI, is expanding into various spheres of society, including the labour market. A study conducted by the Universitat Oberta de Catalunya (UOC) and published as open access has examined the occupational health and safety implications of this technology.
"Artificial intelligence is already making decisions that directly affect the way we work and how we feel at work, often without adequate consideration of the consequences for people," said Xavier Baraza, dean of the UOC's Faculty ...
Low testosterone levels may be associated with increased risk of prostate cancer progression during surveillance
2026-03-10
Study found men with low testosterone levels were associated with a 60% higher likelihood that prostate cancer managed on active surveillance would progress to a more aggressive state over time
Research challenges the long-held belief that high testosterone fuels early-stage prostate cancer growth, suggesting instead that low testosterone may be associated with prostate cancer progression
Baseline testosterone may ...
Analysis of ancient parrot DNA reveals sophisticated, long-distance animal trade network that pre-dates the Inca Empire
2026-03-10
New analysis of ancient parrot DNA has revealed vibrant Amazonian parrots were transported alive across the Andes to coastal Peru centuries before the Inca Empire, highlighting a sophisticated pre-Inca, long-distance trade network spanning rainforest, highlands and deserts.
The international team of researchers, including scientists from The Australian National University (ANU), analysed parrot feathers that were discovered at Pachacamac, Peru – one of the preeminent religious centres of the Andean civilisation – ...
How does snow gather on a roof?
2026-03-10
WASHINGTON, March 10, 2026 — No two snowflakes may be the same, but models that fail to take these variations into consideration often fall short when calculating the way snow accumulates on roofs.
In Physics of Fluids, by AIP Publishing, researchers from Harbin Institute of Technology in China modeled the way snow gathers on a roof based on snowflake size and distribution.
“In cold regions, snow load is a critical factor in structural design,” said author Qingwen Zhang. “However, traditional models often simplify snow as a uniform material with a single particle size, overlooking the natural heterogeneity of snowflake sizes and distributions.”
This simplification ...
Modeling how pollen flows through urban areas
2026-03-10
WASHINGTON, March 10, 2026 — Due to climate change, plants’ pollination season has been growing longer and longer. As a result, people are exposed to allergens for extended periods each year, raising a major public health concern.
In Physics of Fluids, by AIP Publishing, researchers from Embry‑Riddle Aeronautical University and two French universities, the University of Rouen Normandy and the University of Lille, developed an advanced computational model of outdoor airflow through trees. They used ...