(Press-News.org) After soliciting feedback from its members, the American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology sent nine recommendations to the National Institutes of Health last week related to proposed changes to the research grant application peer-review process.
The society’s March 1 letter suggested:
Validating the proposed framework with a pilot study
Revamping the study section grant triage process
Conducting outreach before and during implementation
Using alternative criteria for certain types of projects
Moving forward with simplifying scored criteria and administrative document review
The NIH Office of Extramural Research published a request for information on Dec. 7 seeking public input on a proposed revised framework for evaluating and scoring of peer-reviewed research project grant applications from the NIH Center for Scientific Review.
The proposed framework reduces the number of categories reviewers must evaluate and asks that reviewers focus on two major questions: “Should it be done?” and “Can it be done well?” In addition, the framework proposes removing individual scoring for the investigator and environment. Instead, reviewers would qualitatively evaluate and rate an applicant’s expertise and resources with the goal of reducing bias in peer review. Finally, study section volunteers would review less material from the “Additional Review Considerations” section of the application.
The goal of the revised framework is two-fold. First, the NIH seeks to reduce the emphasis on investigator reputation during grant review. Second, the NIH seeks to reduce the administrative burden on study section members.
The ASBMB was compelled to respond because the society is composed of predominately NIH-funded investigators, many of whom serve on study sections.
“Since the majority of our members will be directly affected by any changes to NIH grant review processes, we felt it was our responsibility to make sure their voices are heard as well as support their continued success in receiving federal funding,” Sarina Neote, director of public affairs at the ASBMB, said. “In addition, since part of our mission is advocating for underrepresented groups, we want to ensure that these proposed changes are making the review process more equitable for researchers at all levels.”
Although the ASBMB expressed support for NIH’s efforts to simplify and make peer review less biased, Neote said, the society wants to ensure the proposed changes also accomplish NIH’s goals.
In its comment letter to CSR, the society wrote: “To validate that the proposed framework reduces reputational bias and ensure that the proposed changes are data-driven, the ASBMB asks CSR to conduct a thorough pilot study of the proposed framework across all research project grants.”
During study section, only the preliminarily top scoring grants are discussed. This process leaves all borderline and low-scoring grants behind, known as triage. Every study section member has the opportunity to bring forward a triaged proposal that may have received a borderline score due to receiving two outstanding and one low, outlier score. However, this rarely occurs. Therefore, the ASBMB recommended revamping the triage process to build in time for study section discussion of borderline-scoring applications.
“This goal could be accomplished in two ways: First, task the scientific review officer with initiating discussion of borderline-scoring proposals and/or second, automatically include a set time for discussion of these proposals,” the ASBMB wrote. “The ASBMB urges CSR to ensure that quality scientific research projects are not left behind during the triage process.”
Because the current framework has been in place for decades, the ASBMB asserted that substantial outreach and education will be needed to ensure a seamless transition to the new framework. The society called upon NIH to make educational resources such as toolkits broadly available, not only to high-research-activity institutions but to emerging and minority-serving institutions as well.
The society also expressed concern about using the proposed framework to evaluate all research grants, in particular R15 awards. According to the NIH, R15 awards are research enhancements that are designed to support “small-scale research projects at educational institutions that provide baccalaureate or advanced degrees for a significant number of the nation’s research scientists but that have not been major recipients of NIH support.”
The society wrote: “Although R15s are similar to other research grants that fund meritorious research projects, the mechanisms of scope and feasibility can vary depending on the capacity of the institution. … (T)he smaller scope of work that is feasible at primarily undergraduate institutions may be disadvantaged under the new framework in comparison with larger labs that host undergraduate research.”
END
ASBMB offers feedback on NIH’s proposed grant review framework
The society expresses support for measure to reduce bias, calls for pilot study and triage reform
2023-03-06
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
The marathon runners of the immune system
2023-03-06
When it comes to chronic infections and cancer, a particular type of immune cell plays a central role in our defenses. Researchers at the University of Basel have uncovered the key to the tenacity of these immune cells in coping with the marathon that is fighting a chronic infection. Their results lay the foundations for more effective therapies and vaccination strategies.
Infected and abnormal cells have to go. And as quickly as possible, before any more damage is done. This is the task of what are known as cytotoxic T cells. ...
A wholly sustainable plastics economy is feasible
2023-03-06
Plastic is everywhere. Our society cannot do without it: plastics have numerous advantages, are extremely versatile, and are also cost effective. Today, plastics are mainly produced from crude oil. When the products reach the end of their life, they often end up in a waste incineration plant. The energy-intensive production of plastics and their incineration release large amounts of CO2 into the atmosphere, making plastic products a major contributor to climate change.
One way out would be to rely on sustainable production methods, such as the circular economy, in which as much plastic as possible is recycled. Then the main raw material for ...
Graphene quantum dots show promise as novel magnetic field sensors
2023-03-06
Trapped electrons traveling in circular loops at extreme speeds inside graphene quantum dots are highly sensitive to external magnetic fields and could be used as novel magnetic field sensors with unique capabilities, according to a new study.
Electrons in graphene (an atomically thin form of carbon) behave as if they were massless, like photons, which are massless particles of light. Although graphene electrons do not move at the speed of light, they exhibit the same energy-momentum relationship as photons and can be described as “ultra-relativistic.” ...
Parental nonadherence to recommendations for COVID-19 prevention among children
2023-03-06
About The Study: In this survey study of U.S. parents, one-quarter engaged in misrepresentation or nonadherence regarding public health measures for their children. The most common reason was to preserve parental autonomy. Additional reasons included wanting to resume a normal life for their child and the inability to miss work or other responsibilities, among other reasons.
Authors: Andrea Gurmankin Levy, Ph.D., M.B.E., of Middlesex Community College in Middletown, Connecticut, is the corresponding author.
To access the embargoed study: Visit our ...
Mineral particles and their role in oxygenating the Earth’s atmosphere
2023-03-06
Mineral particles played a key role in raising oxygen levels in the Earth’s atmosphere billions of years ago, with major implications for the way intelligent life later evolved, according to new research.
Up to now, scientists have argued that oxygen levels rose as the result of photosynthesis by algae and plants in the sea, where oxygen was produced as a by-product and released into the atmosphere.
But a research ...
Two-dimensional quantum freeze
2023-03-06
Glass nanoparticles trapped by lasers in extreme vacuum are considered a promising platform for exploring the limits of the quantum world. Since the advent of quantum theory, the question at which sizes an object starts being described by the laws of quantum physics rather than the rules of classical physics has remained unanswered.
A team formed by Lukas Novotny (Zurich), Markus Aspelmeyer (Vienna), Oriol Romero-Isart (Innsbruck), and Romain Quidant (Zurich) is attempting to answer precisely this question within the ERC-Synergy project Q-Xtreme. A crucial step ...
Scientists twist chemical bonds beyond their limits
2023-03-06
A group of scientists from Durham University and University of York have twisted molecules to their breaking point in order to challenge the understanding of chemical bonds.
The researchers explored how far the chemical bonding in an aromatic ring can be twisted before its aromatic bonding breaks.
They achieved this by making overcrowded aromatic rings. Rather than benzene, they used tropylium, which shares electrons around a ring of seven carbon atoms.
Each of these carbon atoms can be functionalised and having seven attachment points in the ring, rather than the six carbon atoms of benzene, allowed ...
Siblings should be screened in cases of suspected child physical abuse
2023-03-06
Siblings of a child suspected of experiencing physical abuse should also be screened for abusive injuries, according to a new international consensus statement led by researchers at UCL (University College London) and Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children (GOSH).
The team of 27 researchers, from six different continents, are calling for a policy change to stop inconspicuous injuries being missed in contact children (i.e. siblings, cohabiting children, or children who are under the same care), and to help prevent further ...
Rewarding accuracy instead of partisan pandering reduces Republican-Democrat divide over the truth – study
2023-03-06
Offering a tiny cash reward for accuracy, or even briefly appealing to personal integrity, can increase people’s ability to tell the difference between misinformation and the truth, according to a new study.
The findings suggest that fake news thrives on social media not only because people are tricked into believing it, but also due to a motivational imbalance: users have more incentive to get clicks and likes than to spread accurate content.
Social psychologists from the University of Cambridge and New York University argue that their study, published in the journal ...
New study compares human contributions to Mississippi river delta land loss, hints at solutions
2023-03-06
Research from scientists at Louisiana State University and Indiana University reveals new information about the role humans have played in large-scale land loss in the Mississippi River Delta—crucial information in determining solutions to the crisis.
The study published today in Nature Sustainability compares the impacts of different human actions on land loss and explains historical trends. Until now, scientists have been unsure about which human-related factors are the most consequential, and why the most rapid land loss in the Mississippi River Delta occurred between the 1960s and 1990s and ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Program takes aim at drinking, unsafe sex, and sexual assault on college campuses
Inability to pay for healthcare reaches record high in U.S.
Science ‘storytelling’ urgently needed amid climate and biodiversity crisis
KAIST Develops Retinal Therapy to Restore Lost Vision
Adipocyte-hepatocyte signaling mechanism uncovered in endoplasmic reticulum stress response
Mammals were adapting from life in the trees to living on the ground before dinosaur-killing asteroid
Low LDL cholesterol levels linked to reduced risk of dementia
Thickening of the eye’s retina associated with greater risk and severity of postoperative delirium in older patients
Almost one in ten people surveyed report having been harmed by the NHS in the last three years
Enhancing light control with complex frequency excitations
New research finds novel drug target for acute myeloid leukemia, bringing hope for cancer patients
New insight into factors associated with a common disease among dogs and humans
Illuminating single atoms for sustainable propylene production
New study finds Rocky Mountain snow contamination
Study examines lactation in critically ill patients
UVA Engineering Dean Jennifer West earns AIMBE’s 2025 Pierre Galletti Award
Doubling down on metasurfaces
New Cedars-Sinai study shows how specialized diet can improve gut disorders
Making moves and hitting the breaks: Owl journeys surprise researchers in western Montana
PKU Scientists simulate the origin and evolution of the North Atlantic Oscillation
ICRAFT breakthrough: Unlocking A20’s dual role in cancer immunotherapy
How VR technology is changing the game for Alzheimer’s disease
A borrowed bacterial gene allowed some marine diatoms to live on a seaweed diet
Balance between two competing nerve proteins deters symptoms of autism in mice
Use of antifungals in agriculture may increase resistance in an infectious yeast
Awareness grows of cancer risk from alcohol consumption, survey finds
The experts that can outsmart optical illusions
Pregnancy may reduce long COVID risk
Scientists uncover novel immune mechanism in wheat tandem kinase
Three University of Virginia Engineering faculty elected as AAAS Fellows
[Press-News.org] ASBMB offers feedback on NIH’s proposed grant review frameworkThe society expresses support for measure to reduce bias, calls for pilot study and triage reform