PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

The Israeli Override Clause: a threat to the health in all policies approach

2023-08-11
(Press-News.org) On July 24, 2023, Israel's Parliament sanctioned a substantial amendment to the Basic Law, prompting apprehensions regarding power equilibrium and its potential influence on public well-being. In response, a coalition of prominent Israeli and global public health experts has united to dissect the profound ramifications of this revision in an article titled “Israel's Judicial Overhaul: A Threat to the Health in All Policies Approach” featured in The Lancet.

The amendment, restricts court scrutiny of the reasonableness of ministerial decisions, aiming to curtail judicial supervision over political choices, which has sparked nationwide protests and concerns. As public health advocates, the co-authors of the article express their apprehension about the significant threat this amendment poses to public health and the Health in All Policies (HiAP) principle.

The HiAP principle, adopted globally and shaped by various health declarations, advocates for the incorporation of health implications in decision-making across sectors. This approach recognizes that health determinants extend beyond the health sector and emphasizes collaboration for better health outcomes. The co-authors stress the pivotal role of health in governance and societal well-being. However, the amendment's potential to weaken the HiAP principle raises concerns about unchecked decisions that might neglect public health considerations.

Dr. Shelly Kamin-Friedman from the Zulat for Equality and Human Rights "In Israel's legal landscape, the absence of constitutional protection for the right to health leaves citizens vulnerable to government decisions that disregard health considerations and expert opinions with a singular avenue: filing a petition with the High Court, citing the grounds of unreasonableness."

Through the careful examination of history, the authors paint a vivid picture of how judicial review has historically safeguarded public health. They recount the Finance Minister's decision in 2018, when the choice not to raise taxes on loose tobacco was made, in isolation from health considerations. Public health advocates took to the courts, highlighting the potential dangers of such a decision on public health. The Supreme Court's intervention forced a reevaluation, emphasizing that policies, even seemingly unrelated ones, must consider their effects on public health. This serves as a stark reminder of how judicial oversight acts as a guardian against policies that may compromise the well-being of the people.

Prof. Aron Troen from Hebrew University stated: "In a world where science is often overshadowed by politics, it is our duty to be the voice of reason, demanding evidence-based policies that prioritize public health and welfare. Our data speak for those who need it the most, urging us to bridge the gap between research and action."

A more recent example involves sugary beverages. Israel's high sugar consumption rates contribute to escalating health issues. In 2022 a successful beverage tax was introduced, aligned with global practices and generating 890 million NIS in revenue, effectively curtailed sugary drink purchases. However, yielding to powerful industry pressures, the government abruptly revoked the tax in 2023 without due process or expert consultation. This decision, bereft of consideration for evidence-backed health concerns, underscores the need for a supreme court petition to champion public health interests over political and vested interests. The Finance Minister's choice to repeal the tax, despite global health warnings and local expert advice, highlights the fragility of public health when unchecked by judicial scrutiny.

"We have diligently assessed the implications of this amendment, carefully navigating the complex interplay between judicial oversight, the imperatives of public health, and the fundamental dynamics of governance. The potential repercussions of this amendment on the equilibrium of political power and its profound impact on societal well-being must not be underestimated.” said Prof. Nadav Davidovitch, Director, School of Public Health, Ben Gurion University of the Negev.

Prof. Hagai Levine, Chair of the Israeli Association of Public Health Physicians, expresses his concern: "The legal change constitutes a direct assault on public health, leaving it vulnerable to extreme and irrational ministerial decisions, devoid of defense against political or vested interests."

The story transcends national borders, as the authors highlight the potential global implications of this amendment. The risk of political interests superseding public health isn't confined to Israel alone; it sets a precedent that may echo in countries with weaker legal systems. The erosion of the Health in All Policies (HiAP) principle could have far-reaching consequences, compromising health considerations in policy-making.

"In an era where well-being takes precedence, the elimination of judicial oversight represents more than a mere legal alteration; it poses a threat to the essential vitality of Israel, carrying ramifications that extend globally." - Y. Tony Yang, Endowed Professor of Health Policy, The George Washington University, USA.

As we emerge from the challenges of a global pandemic, the article serves as a rallying cry for the prioritization of public health in all government decisions. It urges readers to engage in thoughtful dialogue about the delicate balance between policy, judicial oversight, and the well-being of a nation.

For more information about the study, please refer to the article: “Israel's Judicial Overhaul: A Threat to the Health in All Policies Approach” published at Lancet https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)01663-X 

Team: Shelly Kamin-Friedman1, Hagai Levine2, Nadav Davidovitch3, Aron M. Troen4, Y. Tony Yang5

Institutions: 1- Research Fellow, Zulat for Equality and Human Rights; 2- Chair, Israel Association of Public Health Physicians; 3- Professor, School of Public Health, Ben Gurion University of the Negev; 4-Associate Professor, The Robert H. Smith Faculty of Agriculture Food and Environment, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem; 5-Endowed Professor of Health Policy, The George Washington University.

END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Indicator of PFAS found in some — but not all — period products

2023-08-11
SAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 10, 2023 — Period products come in a variety of styles — liners, pads, tampons, cups and underwear — to help people feel comfortable during a menstrual bleed. But their labels don’t usually list the ingredients, so consumers don’t know what’s in their product of choice. Now, researchers have analyzed over 100 period products for fluorinated compounds, an indicator of potentially harmful per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS. Their results show that while PFAS are absent from many products, ...

Exercise training and yoga can help improve lung function in adults with asthma

2023-08-11
Yoga and breathing control practices, in combination with aerobic training, are particularly key exercises for asthmatic people seeking to improve their lung function, a new peer-reviewed study suggests. The research which is published today in the journal Annals of Medicine highlights the importance of integrating appropriate exercise training into asthma management plans. The findings demonstrate just how effective specific types of exercise training can be to enhance lung function for those with adults, explains ...

Fat burning during exercise varies widely between individuals

Fat burning during exercise varies widely between individuals
2023-08-11
New York, NY [August 10, 2023]—The best heart rate for burning fat differs for each individual and often does not align with the “fat burning zone” on commercial exercise machines, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai researchers report. Instead, the researchers said, clinical exercise testing—a diagnostic procedure to measure a person’s physiological response to exercise—may be a more useful tool to help individuals achieve intended fat loss goals. The study, which used a machine learning-based modeling approach, was published online today in Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Disease. “People with a goal of weight or fat loss may ...

The health impact of climate change is not adequately recorded: study

2023-08-11
A Monash University-led study has proposed a solution for the urgent need to capture real-time data on the impact of climate change-related events on human health, healthcare workforces, and healthcare systems at the point of care. As the global community faces growing climate challenges, the study calls for action, collaboration, and innovation to safeguard human health and wellbeing in the face of environmental crises. Published in the Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, it highlighted key climate ...

New research shows genetic mutation known for Alzheimer’s disease is associated with higher fertility in women

New research shows genetic mutation known for Alzheimer’s disease is associated with higher fertility in women
2023-08-10
(Santa Barbara, Calif.) — Previous research has revealed that the Apolipoprotein-ε4 (APOE-ε4) allele increases the risk for a variety of diseases in aging populations, specifically Alzheimer’s and cardiovascular disease. And yet, despite the negative effects of this genetic variant, it remains prevalent in approximately 20% of the human population. In a quest to determine how this negative allele is surviving natural selection, a group of researchers have discovered that the APOE-ε4 allele is associated with higher fertility in women.  In a new paper released in Science Advances, researchers including UC Santa ...

Trinity research looks to Latin America for clues on healthy brain ageing

2023-08-10
Researchers at Trinity College Dublin study the factors influencing healthy brain ageing in Latin American and Caribbean (LAC) countries and find the lessons learned there, can also be applied to home. Ageing is not a uniform process across the globe. Most research into cognitive and functional ageing has been conducted in the US and Europe, in high-income settings. Researchers from the Global Brain Health Institute (GBHI) at Trinity College are filling the knowledge gap that exists for Latin American populations on the factors ...

Transplant recipients experience limited protection with primary COVID-19 vaccination series, but third dose boosts response

2023-08-10
Key Takeaways Lung and heart transplant recipients experienced diminished and delayed antibody responses to the first two COVID-19 mRNA vaccine doses, but most developed stronger responses following a third dose A third dose also boosted cross-protection against SARS-CoV-2 viral variants For lung and heart transplant recipients, vaccine doses beyond the third dose are likely important for maintaining immunity BOSTON – Transplant recipients must take life-long immunosuppressive medications to prevent rejection, but these drugs ...

Department of Energy announces $11 million for exploratory research in extreme-scale science

2023-08-10
WASHINGTON, D.C. - Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced $11 million in funding for 15 projects in exploratory research for extreme-scale science that will leverage emerging trends and advances in high-end computing, massive datasets, scientific machine learning, artificial intelligence, and novel computing architectures. “There is a wide expanse of exciting opportunities as we reach beyond exascale computing,” said Ceren Susut, DOE Acting Associate Director of Science for Advanced Scientific Computing Research. “These ...

Simple ballpoint pen can write custom LEDs

Simple ballpoint pen can write custom LEDs
2023-08-10
Researchers working with Chuan Wang, an associate professor of electrical and systems engineering at the McKelvey School of Engineering at Washington University in St. Louis, have developed ink pens that allow individuals to handwrite flexible, stretchable optoelectronic devices on everyday materials including paper, textiles, rubber, plastics and 3D objects. In a paper published Aug. 7 in Nature Photonics, the team reports their simple and versatile fabrication approach to allow anyone to make a custom light-emitting diode (LED) or photodetector ...

Community health program boosts child vaccinations in remote areas of Madagascar

Community health program boosts child vaccinations in remote areas of Madagascar
2023-08-10
URBANA, Ill. – Madagascar is one of the poorest countries in the world and access to health care is limited for many people. Childhood vaccinations are a crucial component of preventative care, but vaccination rates remain below the World Health Organization’s goal of reaching 95% of children. A new study from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign examines the effectiveness of a health intervention program that enlists community-based health workers to promote child vaccination uptake. “Childhood vaccinations are a cost-effective investment that can have large ripple effects. Vaccines can reduce child mortality ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Einstein Probe releases its Science White Paper

Music-based therapy may improve depressive symptoms in people with dementia

No evidence that substituting NHS doctors with physician associates is necessarily safe

At-home brain speed tests bridge cognitive data gaps

CRF appoints Josep Rodés-Cabau, M.D., Ph.D., as editor-in-chief of structural heart: the journal of the heart team

Violent crime is indeed a root cause of migration, according to new study

Customized smartphone app shows promise in preventing further cognitive decline among older adults diagnosed with mild impairment

Impact of COVID-19 on education not going away, UM study finds

School of Public Health researchers receive National Academies grant to assess environmental conditions in two Houston neighborhoods

Three Speculum articles recognized with prizes

ACM A.M. Turing Award honors two researchers who led the development of cornerstone AI technology

Incarcerated people are disproportionately impacted by climate change, CU doctors say

ESA 2025 Graduate Student Policy Award Cohort Named

Insomnia, lack of sleep linked to high blood pressure in teens

Heart & stroke risks vary among Asian American, Native Hawaiian & Pacific Islander adults

Levels of select vitamins & minerals in pregnancy may be linked to lower midlife BP risk

Large study of dietary habits suggests more plant oils, less butter could lead to better health

Butter and plant-based oils intake and mortality

20% of butterflies in the U.S. have disappeared since 2000

Bacterial ‘jumping genes’ can target and control chromosome ends

Scientists identify genes that make humans and Labradors more likely to become obese

Early-life gut microbes may protect against diabetes, research in mice suggests

Study raises the possibility of a country without butterflies

Study reveals obesity gene in dogs that is relevant to human obesity studies

A rapid decline in US butterfly populations

Indigenous farming practices have shaped manioc’s genetic diversity for millennia

Controlling electrons in molecules at ultrafast timescales

Tropical forests in the Americas are struggling to keep pace with climate change

Brain mapping unlocks key Alzheimer’s insights

Clinical trial tests novel stem-cell treatment for Parkinson’s disease

[Press-News.org] The Israeli Override Clause: a threat to the health in all policies approach