PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Zoom bias: The social costs of having a ‘tinny’ sound during video conferences

Zoom bias: The social costs of having a ‘tinny’ sound during video conferences
2025-03-24
(Press-News.org) New Haven, Conn. — Most job candidates know to dress nicely for Zoom interviews and to arrange a professional-looking background for the camera. But a new Yale study suggests they also ought to test the quality of their microphones.

A tinny voice caused by a cheap mic, researchers say, could sink their chances.

Through a series of experiments, the study demonstrates that tinny speech — a thin, metallic sound — during video conferences can have surprisingly deep social consequences, leading listeners to lower their judgments of a speaker’s intelligence, credibility, and romantic desirability. It also can hurt an individual’s chances of landing a job. These effects could be a potential source of unintentional bias and discrimination, given the likelihood that microphone quality is correlated with socioeconomic status, the researchers said.

“Now that videoconferencing has become so ubiquitous, we wondered how the sounds of people’s voices might be influencing others’ impressions, beyond the actual words they speak,” said senior author Brian Scholl, professor of psychology in Yale’s Faculty of Arts and Sciences and the Wu Tsai Institute. “Every experiment we conducted showed that a familiar tinny or hollow sound associated with a poor-quality microphone negatively affects people’s impressions of a speaker — independent of the message conveyed.

“This is both fascinating and concerning, especially when the sound of your voice is determined not just by your vocal anatomy, but also by the technology you’re using.”

The study was published March 24 in the journal the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Robert Walter-Terrill, a Ph.D. candidate in psychology in Yale’s Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, is the study’s lead author. Joan Danielle K. Ongchoco, an assistant professor in the psychology department of the University of British Colombia, and a former Ph.D. student at Yale, is a co-author.  

Scholl, who is also director of the Yale Perception & Cognition Lab, was inspired to pursue the study by a faculty meeting that he had participated in over Zoom during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. During that video conference, one colleague was using a high-quality microphone in his home recording studio, which made his voice sound especially rich and resonant. Another colleague was using an old laptop that lent a tinny quality to his voice.

In that moment, it occurred to Scholl that the points raised by the colleague with the better sound quality seemed more profound, and those raised by the colleague with the weak mic seemed less compelling, even though he tended to see eye to eye with the latter colleague. It made him curious how superficial audio quality may affect listeners’ perceptions of a speaker.

To answer that question, the researchers performed a series of six experiments in which participants listened to a short speech recording and then made judgments about the speaker.

In each experiment, half of the participants were randomly assigned to listen to a recording that was clear and lively as though delivered through a high-quality microphone, while the other half heard a distorted version of the same message that mimicked the tinny and hollow sound associated with poor-quality microphones. Importantly, the words themselves were always identical, and the distortions did not affect the comprehensibility of the messages: In each experiment, the participants were asked to transcribe the words and sentences they had heard to confirm they had understood them.

Across the experiments, the researchers varied both the speaker’s gender (male and female) and accent (American and British). In some experiments, they even used obviously computer-synthesized voices, for which the “speakers” clearly couldn’t be responsible, in terms of either their vocal anatomy or their microphone choices.

In an experiment testing the effects of microphone quality on whether a candidate is hirable, participants listened to a male human voice deliver a standard elevator pitch for a sales job. (This experiment was repeated using a computerized voice. It was also used to test effects of audio quality on perceptions of intelligence.) In an experiment concerning romantic desirability, they listened to a female human voice responding positively to a potential suitor’s profile on a dating app. In one focused on credibility, participants listened to a computerized female voice with a British accent deny culpability for a traffic accident.

In these and the other experiments, participants’ value judgments significantly favored the recordings with the richer and more resonant tones. They perceived the people from the higher quality recordings as more hirable, desirable, intelligent, and credible. This work shows that judgments from speech are based not only on the content of their message, but also on the superficial vehicle through which that message is delivered.

The researchers noted that this effect may be particularly difficult to notice in practice. 

“During videoconferencing, of course you know how you look, since you can see yourself too,” Walter-Terrill noted. “But on a call with dozens of people, you may be the only one who doesn’t know how you sound to everyone else: you may hear yourself as rich and resonant, while everyone else hears a tinny voice.”

# # #

END


[Attachments] See images for this press release:
Zoom bias: The social costs of having a ‘tinny’ sound during video conferences

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Biologists discover ancient neurohormone that controls appetite

Biologists discover ancient neurohormone that controls appetite
2025-03-24
A team of biologists at Queen Mary University of London has discovered that a neurohormone controlling appetite in humans has an ancient evolutionary origin, dating back over half a billion years. The findings, published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, reveal that this satiety-inducing molecule, known as bombesin, is not only present in humans and other vertebrates but also in starfish and their marine relatives.  Bombesin, a small peptide, plays a key role in regulating hunger by signalling when we’ve had enough to eat. But its story doesn’t start with humans or even mammals. New research shows that ...

The right moves to reign in fibrosis

2025-03-24
By Leah Shaffer The cells in human bodies are subject to both chemical and mechanical forces. But up until recently, scientists have not understood much about how to manipulate the mechanical side of that equation. That’s about to change. “This is a major breakthrough in our ability to be able to control the cells that drive fibrosis,” according to Guy Genin, the Harold and Kathleen Faught Professor of Mechanical Engineering in the McKelvey School of Engineering at Washington University in St. Louis, speaking of research recently published in Nature Materials. Fibrosis is an affliction wherein ...

Exploring why it is harder to hear in noisy environments

2025-03-24
Imagine trying to listen to a friend speak over the commotion of a loud party. It is difficult to detect and process sounds in noisy environments, especially for those with hearing loss. Previous research has typically focused on how competing sounds influence cortical brain activity, with the end goal of informing treatment strategies for people who are hard of hearing. But in a new eNeuro study, Melissa Polonenko and Ross Maddox, from the University of Rochester, explored a lesser-studied influence of competing sounds on subcortical brain ...

Type 2 diabetes may suppress reward

2025-03-24
The high comorbidity of type 2 diabetes (T2D) with psychiatric or neurodegenerative disorders points to a need for understanding what links these diseases. A potential link is the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). The ACC supports behaviors related to cognition and emotions and is involved in some T2D-associated diseases, like mood disorders and Alzheimer’s disease (AD). James Hyman and colleagues, from the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, used a rat model of T2D that affects only males to explore whether diabetes affects ACC activity and behavior. Their work is featured in JNeurosci’s ...

Healthy eating in midlife linked to overall healthy aging

2025-03-24
Embargoed for release: Monday, March 24, 12:00 PM ET Key points: Maintaining a healthy diet rich in plant-based foods, with low to moderate intake of healthy animal-based foods and lower intake of ultra-processed foods, was linked to a higher likelihood of healthy aging—defined as reaching age 70 free of major chronic diseases, with cognitive, physical, and mental health maintained—according to a 30-year study of food habits among more than 105,000 middle-aged adults. All the eight dietary patterns studied were associated with healthy aging, suggesting that there is no one-size-fits-all healthy diet.  The study is among the ...

New non-surgical contraceptive implant is delivered through tiny needles

New non-surgical contraceptive implant is delivered through tiny needles
2025-03-24
Mass General Brigham and MIT investigators have developed a long-acting contraceptive implant that can be delivered through tiny needles to minimize patient discomfort and increase the likelihood of medication use.   Their findings in preclinical models provide the technological basis to develop self-administrable contraceptive shots that could mimic the long-term drug release of surgically implanted devices.   The new approach, which would reduce how often patients need to inject themselves and prove valuable for patients with less access to hospitals and other medical care ...

Motion sickness brain circuit may provide new options for treating obesity

2025-03-24
Motion sickness is a very common condition that affects about 1 in 3 people, but the brain circuits involved are largely unknown. In the current study published in Nature Metabolism, researchers at Baylor College of Medicine, the University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston and the Jan and Dan Duncan Neurological Research Institute at Texas Children’s Hospital describe a new brain circuit involved in motion sickness that also contributes to regulating body temperature and metabolic balance. The findings may provide unconventional strategies ...

New research reveals secrets about locust swarm movement

2025-03-24
      MEDIA INQUIRES   WRITTEN BY Laura Muntean   Adam Russell laura.muntean@ag.tamu.edu     601-248-1891     FOR ...

Age-specific trends in pediatric and adult firearm homicide after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic

2025-03-24
About The Study: This study found a disproportionate spike in firearm homicide among children and adults older than age 30 after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, indicating a change in the association between age and firearm victimization risk. This trend moved the peak victimization risk from age 21 to 19, and rates for children up to age 16 were markedly elevated. These age-specific patterns were most pronounced in later post-onset years.  Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Jonathan ...

Avoidable mortality across US states and high-income countries

2025-03-24
About The Study: This study found that avoidable mortality (comprising both preventable deaths related to prevention and public health and treatable deaths related to timely and effective health care treatment) has worsened across all U.S. states, while other high-income countries show improvement. The results suggest poorer mortality is driven by broad factors across the entirety of the U.S. While other countries appear to make gains in health with increases in health care spending, such an association does not exist across U.S. states, raising questions regarding U.S. health spending efficiency.  Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Irene ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Father’s mental health can impact children for years

Scientists can tell healthy and cancerous cells apart by how they move

Male athletes need higher BMI to define overweight or obesity

How thoughts influence what the eyes see

Unlocking the genetic basis of adaptive evolution: study reveals complex chromosomal rearrangements in a stick insect

Research Spotlight: Using artificial intelligence to reveal the neural dynamics of human conversation

Could opioid laws help curb domestic violence? New USF research says yes

NPS Applied Math Professor Wei Kang named 2025 SIAM Fellow

Scientists identify agent of transformation in protein blobs that morph from liquid to solid

Throwing a ‘spanner in the works’ of our cells’ machinery could help fight cancer, fatty liver disease… and hair loss

Research identifies key enzyme target to fight deadly brain cancers

New study unveils volcanic history and clues to ancient life on Mars

Monell Center study identifies GLP-1 therapies as a possible treatment for rare genetic disorder Bardet-Biedl syndrome

Scientists probe the mystery of Titan’s missing deltas

Q&A: What makes an ‘accidental dictator’ in the workplace?

Lehigh University water scientist Arup K. SenGupta honored with ASCE Freese Award and Lecture

Study highlights gaps in firearm suicide prevention among women

People with medical debt five times more likely to not receive mental health care treatment

Hydronidone for the treatment of liver fibrosis associated with chronic hepatitis B

Rise in claim denial rates for cancer-related advanced genetic testing

Legalizing youth-friendly cannabis edibles and extracts and adolescent cannabis use

Medical debt and forgone mental health care due to cost among adults

Colder temperatures increase gastroenteritis risk in Rohingya refugee camps

Acyclovir-induced nephrotoxicity: Protective potential of N-acetylcysteine

Inhibition of cyclooxygenase-2 upregulates the nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2 signaling pathway to mitigate hepatocyte ferroptosis in chronic liver injury

AERA announces winners of the 2025 Palmer O. Johnson Memorial Award

Mapping minds: The neural fingerprint of team flow dynamics

Patients support AI as radiologist backup in screening mammography

AACR: MD Anderson’s John Weinstein elected Fellow of the AACR Academy

Existing drug has potential for immune paralysis

[Press-News.org] Zoom bias: The social costs of having a ‘tinny’ sound during video conferences