PRESS-NEWS.org - Press Release Distribution
PRESS RELEASES DISTRIBUTION

Placing value, price on new drugs: The challenge facing new UK policy, say Hopkins bioethicists

Commentary on ethical concerns about "value-based pricing" in NEJM April 7

2011-04-07
(Press-News.org) The United States should pay close attention to how the United Kingdom carries out plans to assess a new drug's worth using factors that go beyond clinical and cost effectiveness, according to researchers at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics.

In a commentary to appear in the April 7 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, the bioethicists detail and discuss a new, "value-based pricing" policy proposed by the British government. Up to now, companies have been able to price their drugs freely. But if the new policy is implemented, the U.K. will start negotiating drug prices.

The authors point out that key to the policy is the requirement that Britain's national health-care system factor in some difficult-to-measure criteria, as well as more conventional ones, when deciding how much to pay for a new drug.

The nontraditional criteria include the extent of therapeutic innovation, the "burden of illness" that the drug aims to treat, and the prospect of "wider societal benefits." The NEJM commentary quotes statements from Britain's Department of Health that promise value-based pricing will better reflect "all the components that contribute to a treatment's impact on health and quality of life," including "important factors that patients and society value."

In their "Perspective" piece, Berman Institute Director Ruth Faden, Ph.D., M.P.H., and visiting faculty member Kalipso Chalkidou, M.D., Ph.D., acknowledge that the U.K. and U.S. health-care systems have fundamental differences. But, with skyrocketing health-care costs on both sides of the Atlantic, each country is looking for a more comprehensive approach to pricing new drugs and medical treatments. And whether or not officials in the U.K. succeed with value-based pricing, the authors say the experience could provide valuable lessons for the crisis in America.

"As important as improving the health of the population is, we know that what makes health care valuable is more than what is captured in health-outcomes statistics," says Faden, the Philip Franklin Wagley Professor of Biomedical Ethics at Johns Hopkins University. "There is value in the security of knowing dying loved ones will be cared for, that the burden on family members of people with dementias will be lessened, and in improving prospects for disadvantaged children and communities."

As proposed, this value-based pricing policy would take effect in 2014 and change the way drugs are offered through Britain's National Health Service (NHS). Currently, an independent agency known as NICE, the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, reviews all new drugs that are likely to have an impact on health or the NHS budget, Chalkidou explains.

The NHS has always been able to offer drugs turned down by NICE, but it is constitutionally required to pay for those that NICE approves, says Chalkidou, the founding and current director of NICE's international program. In that role, she helps governments develop the ability to use evidence to inform health policy.

Chalkidou says ongoing talks about the new drug-pricing approach may result in changes before the policy takes effect. "The next few months will be key to solving the technical challenges of making drug-pricing decisions, and more importantly, addressing the political and ethical challenges of making those decisions," Chalkidou says. "There is no question that both the U.S. and the U.K. already make difficult decisions about access to health services every single day. But in the U.K., we are a bit ahead with regard to transparency and an explicit reliance on evidence."

Currently, NICE recognizes the need to incorporate social values into its decision-making and has adopted as core principles not only transparency, but also public consultation, independence and an openness to patients appealing the agency's decisions, according to the commentary.

NICE periodically conducts public-opinion surveys, and its decision-making committees include laypeople as voting members, the authors point out. In addition, the agency has a formal program in place for patient and public involvement, as well as a Citizens' Council, which generates reports that inform NICE's Social Value Judgments document.

Faden and Chalkidou also note that when the proposal was first announced in October 2010, media reports stated that NICE "was being stripped of its power." These reports were misleading, as NICE is likely to play a central role in the new pricing policies. However, the co-authors assert that it remains to be seen whether the new approach will be better, more acceptable or more comprehensive than the system that Britain has in place now.

"Arguably, NICE and the NHS have gone as far, if not further, than health agencies in other countries in attempting to elicit and incorporate the values and preferences of the public," Faden says. "But there are still many deficiencies in this regard."

In both Britain and the United States, Faden adds, it remains unclear what exactly the public's values and wishes are, especially given each population's diversity. For example, the co-authors point out that the category of "wider societal benefits" is open to much interpretation and could include everything from "narrowing health inequities" to "advancing children's life prospects" to "decreasing workforce absenteeism."

Chalkidou says the main difference between the two countries is not whether cost is considered when making decisions about drug coverage, but whether those considerations are done openly or covertly. "What would be interesting for the U.S.," she explained, "would be to use the U.K. debate to inform its own discussions on whether and how to make the system more transparent, more consultative, more contestable, more independent, and hence, more consistent and more legitimate."

### END


ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

NYU Cancer Institute experts present at the AACR 102nd Annual Meeting 2011

2011-04-07
Experts from The Cancer Institute at NYU Langone Medical Center presented new research findings at the American Association for Cancer Research 102nd Annual Meeting 2011 held April 2-6, 2011 in Orlando, Florida. NYU Cancer Institute researchers discussed various breakthroughs such as a novel test for early-stage asbestos-related pulmonary cancer, a promising treatment strategy for glioblastomas, genome-wide mapping of nickel-related cancer and greater understanding of melanoma and bladder cancer. Detection of Mesothelioma in Asbestos Exposed Individuals with Aptamer ...

Trion:Z Announces Masters Tournament Active Series Contest

Trion:Z Announces Masters Tournament Active Series Contest
2011-04-07
To participate in the Trion:Z Masters Tournament giveaway contest, all you have to do is pick which of the three Rs is going to win. Trion:Z's triple threat; Rickie Fowler, Rory Mc Ilroy and Ryo Ishikawa - all will be competing for the coveted green jacket. Each possess the skill, talent, and drive to be the next Masters Champion. According to Reuters' Mark Lamport-Stokes, "Mc Ilroy long regarded as a future world #1 is probably the most spectacular member of the emerging generation to watch." However, Ishikawa is playing for the pride of Japan and is donating his 2011 ...

UPCI, Pitt researchers present findings of cancer studies at AACR 102nd Annual Meeting

2011-04-07
Orlando, Fla. – How do certain multiple myeloma treatment drugs cause complications? How does the immune system become dysfunctional due to cancer? How safe is a vaccine that could prevent development of precancerous colon polyps? Those are among the many questions that will be answered by researchers from the University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute (UPCI) and the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine during the American Association for Cancer Research 102nd Annual Meeting 2011, April 2 to 6, in Orlando, Fla. UPCI and Pitt researchers will present more than 80 ...

The Business Age is Discussed in This Month's Business Review India

The Business Age is Discussed in This Months Business Review India
2011-04-07
Welcome to the April issue of Business Review India! The Smartphone market in India is predictably growing and how! After all, with better browser speeds, affordable rates and a holistic user-friendly experience, the customer is lured into buying these palm-candies that promise oodles and fun and functionality. This issue of Business Review India helps buyers pick their ideal soul-Smartphone! Plus, discover how online chatting on social media is an untapped market that has lots to offer! Read this story to discover some essential secrets of this segment. Along with ...

Substance in tangerines fights obesity and protects against heart disease

2011-04-07
VIDEO: New research by Murray Huff, a vascular biology scientist with the University of Western Ontario has found a flavanoid in tangerines called Nobiletin not only prevents obesity, but also offers... Click here for more information. New research from The University of Western Ontario has discovered a substance in tangerines not only prevents obesity, but also offers protection against type 2 diabetes, and even atherosclerosis, the underlying disease responsible for most ...

Amount of AIDS virus in genital secretions predicts risk of heterosexual transmission

2011-04-07
Higher concentrations of the AIDS virus in genital secretions are linked to a greater risk of virus transmission between opposite-sex couples. The effect is independent of blood level of the virus. These findings will be reported in the April 7 edition of Science Translational Medicine, a publication of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. This is the first study to evaluate directly the relationship between genital concentrations of the HIV-1 virus and heterosexual transmission risk. The researchers demonstrated that high levels of HIV in mucus ...

Control the cursor with power of thought

2011-04-07
The act of mind reading is something usually reserved for science-fiction movies but researchers in America have used a technique, usually associated with identifying epilepsy, for the first time to show that a computer can listen to our thoughts. In a new study, scientists from Washington University demonstrated that humans can control a cursor on a computer screen using words spoken out loud and in their head, holding huge applications for patients who may have lost their speech through brain injury or disabled patients with limited movement. By directly connecting ...

iPhone, Blackberry or Droid: Finding the Right Smartphone For You, in Business Review India

iPhone, Blackberry or Droid: Finding the Right Smartphone For You, in Business Review India
2011-04-07
Three Smartphone giants are competing big time to offer the best user-friendly features. So how does one make the right choice? What is the most important feature in a Smartphone? E-mail usage, Internet browsing or tons of applications? Whatever the need, rest assured there is a Smartphone out there that now caters to every demand of the user! Authored by Pooja Thakkar, this special piece on Smartphones reveals how this market is growing in India and has something for everyone - whatever their budget may be. Read the full article, here.About Business Review India Business ...

Twitter & Facebook Marketing Tips in Business Review India

Twitter & Facebook Marketing Tips in Business Review India
2011-04-07
Social media represents a huge opportunity for established and emerging businesses across the world with Facebook and Twitter being top players in this field. Marketing on both these platforms offers businesses the possibility of exhibiting their product and services to an audience that is vast, anonymous yet intimately acquainted. It further allows the additional benefit of targeting the market based on age, region, race, income level among other factors. Tips in this article guide the reader to take optimum advantage of both these popular platforms. Read the full ...

South East Labels: a Greener Supply Chain

2011-04-07
A new report by the Confederation of British Industry describes changes in labeling as a 'win win for businesses and consumers' and one that will help the UK meet its carbon reduction targets. South East Labels welcomes the report with its endorsement of clear labeling policies as a vital part of commercial success and environmental gains. The report offers particular encouragement for SMEs, which can often be quicker to seize the initiative, to innovate and therefore to gain market share and status. The CBI report Buying into it: making the consumer case for low carbon ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

Development of a global innovative drug in eye drop form for treating dry age-related macular degeneration

Scientists unlock secrets behind flowering of the king of fruits

Texas A&M researchers illuminate the mysteries of icy ocean worlds

Prosthetic material could help reduce infections from intravenous catheters

Can the heart heal itself? New study says it can

Microscopic discovery in cancer cells could have a big impact

Rice researchers take ‘significant leap forward’ with quantum simulation of molecular electron transfer

Breakthrough new material brings affordable, sustainable future within grasp

How everyday activities inside your home can generate energy

Inequality weakens local governance and public satisfaction, study finds

Uncovering key molecular factors behind malaria’s deadliest strain

UC Davis researchers help decode the cause of aggressive breast cancer in women of color

Researchers discovered replication hubs for human norovirus

SNU researchers develop the world’s most sensitive flexible strain sensor

Tiny, wireless antennas use light to monitor cellular communication

Neutrality has played a pivotal, but under-examined, role in international relations, new research shows

Study reveals right whales live 130 years — or more

Researchers reveal how human eyelashes promote water drainage

Pollinators most vulnerable to rising global temperatures are flies, study shows

DFG to fund eight new research units

Modern AI systems have achieved Turing's vision, but not exactly how he hoped

Quantum walk computing unlocks new potential in quantum science and technology

Construction materials and household items are a part of a long-term carbon sink called the “technosphere”

First demonstration of quantum teleportation over busy Internet cables

Disparities and gaps in breast cancer screening for women ages 40 to 49

US tobacco 21 policies and potential mortality reductions by state

AI-driven approach reveals hidden hazards of chemical mixtures in rivers

Older age linked to increased complications after breast reconstruction

ESA and NASA satellites deliver first joint picture of Greenland Ice Sheet melting

Early detection model for pancreatic necrosis improves patient outcomes

[Press-News.org] Placing value, price on new drugs: The challenge facing new UK policy, say Hopkins bioethicists
Commentary on ethical concerns about "value-based pricing" in NEJM April 7