Business students better equipped to evaluate peers

Concordia study shows repeated evaluation experiences can lead to more effective management

2012-05-28

(Press-News.org) Montreal, May 24, 2012 – Peer evaluation is a touchstone of many business school classes. But does the process of rating the work of one's classmates really shape better businesspeople? A new study from Concordia's John Molson School of Business, published in the journal of the Academy of Management Learning and Education, answers that question with a resounding yes.

Stéphane Brutus, Professor and Chair of the Department of Management, undertook the research that led to these findings after developing a standardized online peer evaluation system, or PES, in 2004. To develop the system, Brutus, who holds a PhD in ndustrial and organizational psychology, used his expertise in the field of performance appraisal within organizations to create a practical tool for both students and teachers.

The tool was originally designed to restore equity in the evaluation of group work by assessing cooperation, creativity and group-related competencies. But the present study proves that the program goes far beyond that in added value.

With more than 10,000 students having taken part in the process over the years, Brutus had a solid dataset with which to produce results. His findings prove that the repeated experience of evaluating peers in undergraduate classes result in students becoming more confident and skilled in the task of evaluating others. It also helped improve the quality of the evaluations they provided: experienced students provided more specific and positive comments.

That means that students who have gone through the repeated experience of evaluating their peers emerge better equipped to act as effective managers. "These findings demonstrate the added value of incorporating standardized evaluations into business school group work. It is an efficient way to build evaluation skills, which is very relevant to managerial practice in the workplace," Brutus explains.

In addition to shedding light on how the process of evaluating peers unfolds over time, the study indicates that such systems are beneficial to more than just business schools. "Students work directly with their peers in undergraduate classes that range from engineering to English literature, so it would make sense to implement such a system university-wide. A standardized PES can contribute toward students' development of additional skills that not only have direct value in the classroom, but will also be immediately transferable and relevant to shaping more effective employees. That's something that most students want – not just those in business school."

Could the skills developed in school be incorporated into the workplace? Most probably, says Brutus. "Managers very often see employee evaluations as something unpleasant that is best avoided, or gone through as quickly as possible. I am confident that experience with the PES increases students' level of comfort with performance evaluations once they hit the workplace,"

Although no plans currently exist to develop a version of Brutus's PES for the workplace, the system is currently being moved into the university-wide "Moodle" system – a content-management platform that provides a virtual learning environment for students. The plan is to eventually develop a benchmarking database across several universities so that use of the tool can one day become standard classroom practice.

###Partners in research: This study was co-authored by Magda Donia from the University of Ottawa and Sigalit Ronen from Trident University International.

Related links: John Molson School of Business http://johnmolson.concordia.ca/ Department of Management http://johnmolson.concordia.ca/en/faculty-research/departments/management Stéphane Brutus http://www.stephanebrutus.com/index.php Evaluating group work – NOW, November 8, 2010 http://www.concordia.ca/now/what-we-do/teaching/20101108/evaluating-group-work.php

Media contact: Cléa Desjardins
Senior Advisor, External Communications
Concordia University
Phone: 514-848-2424, ext. 5068
Mobile: 514-909-2999
Email: clea.desjardins@concordia.ca
Twitter: twitter.com/CleaDesjardins
Concordia news: www.concordia.ca/now

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Max Planck Florida Institute study: Persistent sensory experience is good for aging brain

2012-05-28

Despite a long-held scientific belief that much of the wiring of the brain is fixed by the time of adolescence, a new study shows that changes in sensory experience can cause massive rewiring of the brain, even as one ages. In addition, the study found that this rewiring involves fibers that supply the primary input to the cerebral cortex, the part of the brain that is responsible for sensory perception, motor control and cognition. These findings promise to open new avenues of research on brain remodeling and aging. Published in the May 24, 2012 issue of Neuron, the ...

Relationship between social status and wound-healing in wild baboons

2012-05-28

Turns out it's not bad being top dog, or in this case, top baboon. Results of a study by University of Notre Dame biologist Beth Archie and colleagues from Princeton University and Duke University finds that male baboons that have a high rank within their society recover more quickly from injuries, and are less likely to become ill than other males. The finding is somewhat surprising, given that top-ranked males also experience high stress, which should suppress immune responses. Archie, Jeanne Altmann of Princeton and Susan Alberts of Duke examined health records ...

Newly modified nanoparticle opens window on future gene editing technologies

2012-05-28

AMES, Iowa – The scientific and technological literature is abuzz with nanotechnology and its manufacturing and medical applications. But it is in an area with a less glitzy aura—plant sciences—where nanotechnology advancements are contributing dramatically to agriculture. Researchers at Iowa State University have now demonstrated the ability to deliver proteins and DNA into plant cells, simultaneously. This is important because it now opens up opportunities for more sophisticated and targeted plant genome editing—techniques that require the precise delivery of both ...

Key gene found responsible for chronic inflammation, accelerated aging and cancer

2012-05-28

NEW YORK, May 24, 2012 – Researchers at NYU School of Medicine have, for the first time, identified a single gene that simultaneously controls inflammation, accelerated aging and cancer. "This was certainly an unexpected finding," said principal investigator Robert J. Schneider, PhD, the Albert Sabin Professor of Molecular Pathogenesis, associate director for translational research and co-director of the Breast Cancer Program at NYU Langone Medical Center. "It is rather uncommon for one gene to have two very different and very significant functions that tie together ...

LiDAR technology reveals faults near Lake Tahoe

2012-05-28

CARNELIAN BAY, Calif. — Results of a new U.S. Geological Survey study conclude that faults west of Lake Tahoe, Calif., referred to as the Tahoe-Sierra frontal fault zone, pose a substantial increase in the seismic hazard assessment for the Lake Tahoe region of California and Nevada, and could potentially generate earthquakes with magnitudes ranging from 6.3 to 6.9. A close association of landslide deposits and active faults also suggests that there is an earthquake-induced landslide hazard along the steep fault-formed range front west of Lake Tahoe. Using a new high-resolution ...

Device may inject a variety of drugs without using needles

2012-05-28

MIT researchers have engineered a device that delivers a tiny, high-pressure jet of medicine through the skin without the use of a hypodermic needle. The device can be programmed to deliver a range of doses to various depths — an improvement over similar jet-injection systems that are now commercially available. The researchers say that among other benefits, the technology may help reduce the potential for needle-stick injuries; the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that hospital-based health care workers accidentally prick themselves with needles ...

Positive words: The glue to social interaction

2012-05-28

Scientists at ETH Zurich have studied the use of language, finding that words with a positive emotional content are more frequently used in written communication. This result supports the theory that social relations are enhanced by a positive bias in human communication. The study by David Garcia and his colleagues from the Chair of Systems Design is published in the first issue of the new SpringerOpen journal EPJ Data Science, and is freely available to the general public as an Open Access article. Previous studies focused on word lengths and frequency. They demonstrated ...

University of Florida physicists set new record for graphene solar cell efficiency

2012-05-28

GAINESVILLE, Fla. — Doping may be a no-no for athletes, but researchers in the University of Florida's physics department say it was key in getting unprecedented power conversion efficiency from a new graphene solar cell created in their lab. Graphene solar cells are one of industry's great hopes for cheaper, durable solar power cells in the future. But previous attempts to use graphene, a single-atom-thick honeycomb lattice of carbon atoms, in solar cells have only managed power conversion efficiencies ranging up to 2.9 percent. The UF team was able to achieve a record ...

Childhood cancer scars survivors later in life

2012-05-28

CHICAGO--- Scars left behind by childhood cancer treatments are more than skin-deep. The increased risk of disfigurement and persistent hair loss caused by childhood cancer and treatment are associated with emotional distress and reduced quality of life in adulthood, according to a new study led by a Northwestern Medicine advanced practice nurse, Karen Kinahan, and based on data from the Childhood Cancer Survivor Study (CCSS). The largest study of its kind, published May 21 in the Journal of Clinical Oncology, compared scarring, disfigurement and persistent hair loss ...

'Metamaterials,' quantum dots show promise for new technologies

2012-05-28

WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. - Researchers are edging toward the creation of new optical technologies using "nanostructured metamaterials" capable of ultra-efficient transmission of light, with potential applications including advanced solar cells and quantum computing. The metamaterial - layers of silver and titanium oxide and tiny components called quantum dots - dramatically changes the properties of light. The light becomes "hyperbolic," which increases the output of light from the quantum dots. Such materials could find applications in solar cells, light emitting diodes ...

Business students better equipped to evaluate peers

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: