(Press-News.org) Popular web browser extensions designed to protect user privacy and block online ads are falling short, according to NYU Tandon School of Engineering researchers, who are proposing new measurement methodologies to better uncover and quantify these shortcomings.
Led by Rachel Greenstadt, professor in the NYU Tandon Computer Science and Engineering (CSE) Department, the team will present its study at the 19th ACM ASIA Conference on Computer and Communications Security, taking place July 1–5, 2024 in Singapore.
Through an analysis of over 40,000 user reviews of seven of the most most popular privacy-preserving Chrome extensions, the researchers identified five key concerns among users: Performance, referring to the extent the extensions slowed down the system; Web compatibility, indicating how much they disrupted websites or caused substantial rendering delays; Data and Privacy Policy, pertaining to how the extensions handled user data; Effectiveness, evaluating how well they fulfilled their advertised purpose; and Default Configurations, assessing users' trust in the default settings.
"Our study found that there's a disconnect between what users want and what these extensions are actually providing," said Ritik Roongta, CSE PhD student who is the lead author of the study. "Developers need to do a much better job of understanding and addressing the real-world pain points."
The researchers analyzed extensions that fall into two main groups. The first category, dubbed “Ad-Blockers & Privacy Protection,” comprised extensions that block advertisements and third-party trackers. These include AdBlock Plus (ABP), uBlock Origin, Adguard, and Ghostery.
The second category, called “Privacy Protection,” encompasses extensions primarily focused on enhancing user privacy by blocking trackers and other privacy-invasive elements. This category includes Privacy Badger, Decentraleyes, and Disconnect.
The research team found that existing academic studies and benchmarking efforts had comprehensively explored just 4 out of the 14 key metrics underlying these five main user concerns. Crucial aspects like RAM usage overhead, ad-blocker detection likelihood, privacy policy soundness and adequacy of filtering rules were overlooked.
To bridge these research gaps, the researchers designed novel measurement methodologies and conducted extensive evaluation of the extensions against the unexplored metrics, providing a new benchmarking framework for evaluating the strengths and shortcomings of these privacy tools.
Their experiments involved smart crawlers visiting over 1,500 websites to analyze performance hits, compatibility issues, privacy policy strengths, ad-blocking capabilities and filter list configurations.
"The goal of this study is not to compare extensions specifically but to come up with a standardized benchmarking framework that addresses all user concerns so that the user can make informed decisions,” said Roongta. “As extensions evolve with every update, they might over- or underperform in different metrics at different times.”
The new measurement methodologies the researchers applied painted a mixed picture of the extensions they studied. While extensions like uBlock Origin optimized performance overheads well, most others like ABP exhibited significant CPU and memory overheads. Privacy Badger blocked ads and third-party trackers effectively while Ghostery struggled with them.
“Most of our analysis shows ABP needs to improve on metrics,” said Roongta. “That’s because it whitelists certain ads to show to the users. While this new dimension is often perceived critically by the users, it is important to sustain a free Internet. It will be interesting to see how user preferences change as these standards evolve with the advertiser policies over time and the system gets better so that the overhead caused by the extensions is negligible."
The study highlighted instances of potential permission abuse and non-compliance with data protection regulations by some of the evaluated extensions. It provided recommendations for extension developers to enhance transparency around data practices.
The research underscores the pressing need for more rigorous analysis and systematic benchmarking of privacy-preserving browser additions that millions entrust with their online data and browsing experience daily. It contributes to Greenstadt’s body of research that explores what happens when people try to use privacy-enhancing technologies and how the Internet responds.
The following chart shows the new and re-assessed metrics the NYU Tandon researchers introduced to evaluate browser extensions, as presented in From User Insights to Actionable Metrics: A User-Focused Evaluation of Privacy-Preserving Browser Extensions.
User Concern
Measurements
Performance
RAM usage: measure of the RAM used by the extensions during website loading.
CPU usage: Measure of the CPU cycles used by the extensions during website loading (studied before but researchers re-assessed with enhanced measurement methods)
Data Usage: Measure of the disk space used by the extensions during website loading (studied before but researchers re-assessed with enhanced measurement methods).
Web compatibility
Ad-Blocker Detection Prompt: the number of websites that either employ javascript to detect the presence of an ad-blocker extension, or display a prompt asking the user to disable their ad-blocker.
Unable to Load: websites taking longer than 60 seconds to load when the extensions are present.
Data and Privacy Policy
Permissions: evaluation of the extra permissions requested for the actual functioning of the extension..
Privacy Policy: evaluation of the privacy policies of the extensions..
Extension Effectiveness
Ads: the extension's ability to block third-party trackers..
Default Configurations
Default Filter Lists: set of rules to identify and block various web content like advertisements, trackers, and other unwanted elements from being loaded or displayed.
Acceptable Ads: ABP filterlist that allows certain advertisements to appear that adhere to acceptable ad standards. Acceptable Ad Standards.
About the New York University Tandon School of Engineering
The NYU Tandon School of Engineering is home to a community of renowned faculty, undergraduate and graduate students united in a mission to understand and create technology that powers cities, enables worldwide communication, fights climate change, and builds healthier, safer, and more equitable real and digital worlds. The school’s culture centers on encouraging rigorous, interdisciplinary collaboration and research; fostering inclusivity, entrepreneurial thinking, and diverse perspectives; and creating innovative and accessible pathways for lifelong learning in STEM. NYU Tandon dates back to 1854, the founding year of both the New York University School of Civil Engineering and Architecture and the Brooklyn Collegiate and Polytechnic Institute. Located in the heart of Brooklyn, NYU Tandon is a vital part of New York University and its unparalleled global network. For more information, visit engineering.nyu.edu.
END
Privacy-enhancing browser extensions fail to meet user needs, new NYU Tandon School of Engineering study finds
2024-06-13
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
Sweaty cattle may boost food security in a warming world
2024-06-13
Sweaty cows may not sound like the most exciting company, but in a warming world, researchers can’t get enough of them.
When cattle are too hot, they tend to stop eating, said Raluca Mateescu, University of Florida Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences (UF/IFAS) professor in the department of animal science. This affects the cattle’s health and growth and threatens the longevity of the food supply coming from that herd.
Climate change is making it more difficult to raise cattle – growth and reproduction are affected by heat – so ...
Researchers issue ‘call to action’ for data on more diverse range of dog owners
2024-06-13
Virginia Tech’s Audrey Ruple and Courtney Sexton, already deeply involved in data collection and analysis for dog health and connections to humans through the Dog Aging Project, are imploring fellow scientists to cast the net even wider for data on the shared environments of humans and dogs in a perspective piece that appears this month in the journal Science.
“Human environments and the impacts of environmental factors can vary substantially, and this variation should be captured by future studies of dogs to more accurately assess exposure risks for different and vulnerable populations,” ...
UTA awards more than $130,000 to spark new research
2024-06-13
The Office of the Vice President for Research and Innovation at The University of Texas at Arlington has granted 10 Research Enhancement Program (REP) awards valued at more than $130,000 to support new research initiatives.
The REP grant serves as seed funding for launching new research, providing a foundation for recipients to pursue future research and funding from external sources.
“UTA is committed to fostering a culture of innovation and research discoveries for our community of scholars,” said Kate C. Miller, vice ...
The Protein Society announces its Protein Science 2023 Best Paper recipients
2024-06-13
LOS ANGELES, CA
The Protein Society is proud to announce that the winners of the 2023 Protein Science Best Paper awards are Evan T. Liechty from the University of Colorado, USA, and Sophie Rizzo, from Lehigh University, USA.
Evan T. Liechty
Protein Science 2023 August;32(8):e4719.doi:10.1002/pro.4719
Analysis of neutral mutational drift in an allosteric enzyme
Evan T. Liechty1, Andrew Hren1, Levi Kramer1, Gregory Donovan1, Anika J. Friedman1, Michael R. Shirts1, Jerome M. Fox1
1Department of Chemical and ...
A conservation market could incentivize global ocean protection
2024-06-13
(Santa Barbara, Calif.) — The countries of the world agreed: Our planet needs more protection from human activity. And with the globe facing an assortment of environmental crises, they realized the plan needed to be ambitious. Thirty-by-thirty was their proposal: protect 30% of the planet by 2030. But while conservation is popular in principle, the costs of actually enacting it often stall even the most earnest efforts.
Three researchers at UC Santa Barbara have proposed a market-based approach to achieving the 30x30 targets in the ocean. They tested whether a system that allowed countries to trade conservation ...
New fabric makes urban heat islands more bearable
2024-06-13
This year has already seen massive heatwaves around the globe, with cities in Mexico, India, Pakistan and Oman hitting temperatures near or past 50 degrees Celsius (122 degrees Fahrenheit).
As global temperatures and urban populations rise, the world’s cities have become “urban heat islands,” with tight-packed conditions and thermal radiation emitting from pavement and skyscraper trapping and magnifying these temperatures. With 68 percent of all people predicted to live in cities by 2050, this is a growing, ...
Public more confident connecting increasing heat, wildfires with climate change than other extreme weather events, study finds
2024-06-13
Oregon State University researchers found that U.S. adults are fairly confident in linking wildfires and heat to climate change, but less confident when it comes to other extreme weather events like hurricanes, flooding or tornadoes.
The recent study found that politics and personal experience played significant roles in people’s responses: Self-identified Republicans were less likely than Democrats to attribute extreme weather events to climate change, though Republicans who had personally experienced negative impacts from extreme weather events were more likely to link them to climate change than those who hadn’t.
Looking at ...
Marine heatwaves devastate red gorgonians in the Medes Islands
2024-06-13
The increase in the frequency and intensity of marine heatwaves in recent decades is one of the effects of global climate change. A study by the University of Barcelona, published in the Journal of Animal Ecology, shows that the extreme heatwave of 2022 caused an “unprecedented” increase in mortality of the red gorgonian Paramuricea clavata, affecting 70% of the colonies located in the Montgrí Natural Park, the Medes Islands and the Baix Ter. According to the researchers, these results are “alarming ...
Only one in 20 therapies tested in animals reach approval for human use
2024-06-13
An analysis of reviews of translational biomedical research reveals that just 5% of therapies tested in animals reach regulatory approval for human use. The study, an umbrella review, published June 13th in the open access journal PLOS Biology, summarizes other systematic reviews and provides high level evidence that while the rate of translation to human studies is 50%, there is steep drop off before final approval. The authors argue that improved robustness and generalizability of experimental approaches could help increase the chances of translation and final approval.
Animal studies are used in basic research ...
Antimalarial compounds show promise to relieve polycystic ovary syndrome
2024-06-13
Plant-derived compounds best known for their antimalarial properties relieve polycystic ovary syndrome, a major public health problem that affects millions of women worldwide. These compounds, called artemisinins, achieve their affect by suppressing ovarian androgen production in multiple rodent models as well as in a small cohort of human patients, according to a new study. The findings not only underscore the versatility of artemisinins but reveal a promising new approach for preventing and treating the disorder. Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is one of the most common ...