Pioneering survey methodology sets new standards for gauging global scientific consensus

Embargoed until 1900 GMT on Friday 6 December 2024

2024-12-06

(Press-News.org) -With images-

A pioneering international study led by Professor Peter Vickers of Durham University introduces a novel methodology for rapidly assessing scientific consensus on a global scale.

This innovative approach offers the ability to collect real-time, representative data on scientists' opinions across fields, geographical locations, and over time – a breakthrough that could reshape policy-making and public understanding in fields from health sciences to climate change.

The study, conducted in June 2023, brought together a global network of 30 institutions spanning 12 countries. Over 20,000 scientists were invited to participate, resulting in 6,807 responses to a single-statement survey on COVID-19 causation.

The success of this methodology points to a robust, scalable approach for gauging scientific opinion with high response rates, a low opt-out percentage, and quick turnarounds.

By creating a concise, 10-second survey accessible through a network of local academic representatives, researchers were able to secure the highest ever response rate for a large-scale, global scientific survey.

This method is designed not only for rapid implementation but also for adaptability, ensuring its relevance for future research in evolving fields.

Reflecting on the study Professor Peter Vickers of Durham University said: “Humanity has never before had access to data on global scientific community opinion, on any topic, at any time.

“We’re right on the cusp of being able to deliver that and I’m truly excited to see where this could lead.”

The study achieved a 33.9% overall response rate, a significant improvement over traditional survey approaches, which often yield lower engagement.

The response rate was particularly high among physicists, biologists, and earth scientists, reaching as much as 55% at select institutions.

By leveraging local academic contacts, the new approach has real potential to overcome common barriers in large-scale research, such as low international representation and slow data collection.

The survey also revealed important trends: institutions across multiple countries reported high levels of agreement, though notable variations were observed.

A follow-up survey at Argentina's CONICET, prompted by an initially lower agreement rate, achieved nearly unanimous agreement, illustrating the method’s capacity to reveal regional differences, and explore ways in which results can be affected by methodological decision points.

This survey methodology holds vast potential for repeated, large-scale scientific assessments that can quickly inform pressing policy debates.

The method has already expanded to include over 50,000 scientists across 80 institutions worldwide.

By building a sustainable framework for rapidly assessing scientific consensus, this initiative offers an unparalleled resource for policymakers, educators, and the public.

ENDS

Media Information

Professor Peter Vickers from Durham University is available for interview and can be contacted on peter.vickers@durham.ac.uk.

Alternatively, please contact Durham University Communications Office for interview requests on communications.team@durham.ac.uk or +44 (0)191 334 8623.

Source

‘Development of a novel methodology for ascertaining scientific opinion and extent of agreement’, (2024), Peter Vickers et. al., PLOS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0313541

An embargoed copy of the paper is available from Durham University Communications Office. Please email communications.team@durham.ac.uk.

Graphics

Associated images are available via the following link: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/vurc9kk2i4w24drheargf/AKOuZIvkfawJzAhLvvV3RwQ?rlkey=6iec9tp4ab457ukud2pw8d6rf&st=dacx7aca&dl=0

About the Research Team

The project is a collaboration among over 30 experts in philosophy, social science, and empirical methods, with local representatives across Europe, North America, South America, Asia, Africa, and Australasia. This global effort underscores the methodology's capacity to bridge diverse academic and cultural perspectives while providing rigorous, reliable data.

About Durham University

Durham University is a globally outstanding centre of teaching and research based in historic Durham City in the UK.

We are a collegiate university committed to inspiring our people to do outstanding things at Durham and in the world.

We conduct research that improves lives globally and we are ranked as a world top 100 university with an international reputation in research and education (QS World University Rankings 2025).

We are a member of the Russell Group of leading research-intensive UK universities and we are consistently ranked as a top 10 university in national league tables (Times and Sunday Times Good University Guide, Guardian University Guide and The Complete University Guide).

For more information about Durham University visit: www.durham.ac.uk/about/

END OF MEDIA RELEASE – issued by Durham University Communications Office.

END

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

A connection between quantum theory and information theory proved

2024-12-06

“Our results have no clear or direct application right now. It’s basic research that lays the foundation for future technologies in quantum information and quantum computers. There’s enormous potential for completely new discoveries in many different research fields,” says Guilherme B Xavier, researcher in quantum communication at Linköping University, Sweden. But to understand what the researchers have shown, we need to start at the beginning. That light can be both particles and waves is one of the most illogical – but at the same time fundamental – characteristics ...

How do marine food webs respond to increasing alkalinity?

2024-12-06

The ocean naturally absorbs a quarter to a third of man-made CO2 emissions, but this process also leads to the acidification of seawater. By increasing the alkalinity of seawater through the addition of certain minerals (e.g., carbonates and silicates), the ocean can chemically bind more CO2 without further acidification. However, there is still little research on the environmental effects of Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement (OAE). Scientists from Prof. Ulf Riebesell´s group at GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, as ...

NCCN hosts patient advocacy summit on improving access to accurate health information

2024-12-06

WASHINGTON, D.C. [December 6, 2024] — The National Comprehensive Cancer Network® (NCCN®)—a non-profit alliance of leading cancer centers—hosted a Patient Advocacy Summit in Washington, D.C., today. The annual event brings together leading experts to promote strategies and best practices for improving cancer care. This year’s summit focused on practice and policy solutions for sharing accurate, evidence-based health information with patients and caregivers. It featured a keynote address from W. Kimryn Rathmell, MD, PhD, MMHC, Director of the National Cancer Institute (NCI), along with panel discussions that included Robin Vanderpool, DrPH, Chief of the ...

New hope in the fight against Hepatitis C: Broadly effective innovative vaccine design

2024-12-06

Globally, approximately 58 million people are chronically infected with HCV, resulting in 290,000 annual deaths due to complications such as liver cirrhosis and liver cancer. Although modern antiviral treatments achieve high cure rates, the global elimination of HCV remains a difficult goal due to inadequate early detection and limited treatment options. Indeed, HCV has been identified as one of the globally prioritized endemic pathogens for vaccine research and development in the World Health Organization's “Immunization Agenda 2030.” It ...

Suicide rate is low during the holidays, but the holiday-suicide myth persists

2024-12-06

As in most years that we’ve followed news reporting about the myth that suicides peak during the end-of-year holidays, an analysis of the past year showed again that more newspaper accounts supported the false idea that the suicide rate increases during the holiday season than debunked it. Over the past 25 years that we have been studying this phenomenon, in just over a third (nine years or 36%) have we found more debunking of the myth than support for it. Despite years of debunking by mental health researchers, journalists, and others, ...

New insights into NPC: A form of childhood dementia

2024-12-06

In the journal “Science Translational Medicine”, scientists from DZNE and LMU Hospital report on new insights into the mechanisms of “Niemann-Pick type C” (NPC), a rare neurodegenerative disease associated with dementia that can manifest as early as childhood. Their findings, based on studies in mice, cell cultures and patients, emphasize that neuroinflammation, which is mediated by the brain’s immune system, plays a crucial role in NPC. In addition, their research points ...

Love thy neighbor

2024-12-06

Helping out your neighbor or minding your own business? A challenging choice with different benefits for each decision. Game theory provides guidance in making such choices—from a theoretical perspective. Novel findings by Jakub Svoboda and Krishnendu Chatterjee at the Institute of Science and Technology Austria (ISTA) reveal new network structures that enhance cooperation throughout a system. These insights have potential applications also in biology. The question of cooperation has puzzled scientists for a long time. Whether it is in the fields of biology, sociology, ...

So you want to build a solar or wind farm? Here’s how to decide where

2024-12-06

Deciding where to build new solar or wind installations is often left up to individual developers or utilities, with limited overall coordination. But a new study shows that regional-level planning using fine-grained weather data, information about energy use, and energy system modeling can make a big difference in the design of such renewable power installations. This also leads to more efficient and economically viable operations. The findings show the benefits of coordinating the siting of solar farms, wind farms, and storage ...

Cholesterol, triglyceride, and glucose levels across birth cohorts in the US

2024-12-06

About The Study: In this cross-sectional study of 52,000 participants representing 264 million U.S. adults, population-level improvements in total cholesterol and triglyceride levels decelerated and adverse trends in glucose levels accelerated in more recent birth cohorts, which was partially mediated by concurrent increases in body mass index. Public health initiatives that target antecedent health behaviors are needed to improve cardiometabolic health across generations. Corresponding Author: To contact the corresponding author, Xiaoning Huang, PhD, email jack.huang@northwestern.edu. To access the embargoed study: Visit our For The Media ...

Desert ants use the polarity of the geomagnetic field for navigation

2024-12-06

Desert ants of the Cataglyphis nodus species use the Earth's magnetic field for spatial orientation, but these tiny insects rely on a different component of the field than other insects, a research team led by Dr Pauline Fleischmann from the University of Oldenburg, Germany, reports in the journal Current Biology. As the team explains in its paper, this suggests that they also use a different mechanism for magnetoreception than most insects studied to date, including, for example, the famous monarch butterflies. The researchers suspect that magnetoreception in these desert ants is based on a mechanism involving ...

Pioneering survey methodology sets new standards for gauging global scientific consensus

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: