(Press-News.org) Researchers released a peer-reviewed analysis in the academic journal Climate Policy today arguing that the urgent work of removing excess carbon from the atmosphere — known as carbon dioxide removal (CDR) — can’t just rely on complex, untested techniques to capture carbon dioxide (CO2) and inject it deep underground or pump it into the ocean. Rather, they show that nature-based solutions, which include restoring forests and other ecosystems that capture atmospheric CO2 using the ancient biochemical process of photosynthesis and store organic carbon in plants and soil, are also necessary for achieving global climate goals.
“We must rapidly reduce the production of new greenhouse gas emissions worldwide. At the same time, we must also remove and store excess carbon already polluting the atmosphere. In recent years, innovative high-tech CDR companies have introduced promising solutions for capturing carbon. However, these solutions are still in research and development stages, and they are not yet proven at the scale needed,” said Charlotte Streck, a professor at the University of Potsdam, the founder of Climate Focus and the lead author of the Climate Policy journal analysis, “Considering durability in carbon dioxide removal strategies for climate change mitigation.”
“At the same time, it’s well established that forests and other ecosystems are effective at storing carbon — while also providing clean air and water, safeguarding biodiversity and keeping the planet cool. We must embrace both high-tech and natural methods of CDR to succeed,” she said.
Countries and companies have embraced CDR, which was written into the Paris climate agreement, as a key strategy for fulfilling their climate goals and net zero commitments. It’s estimated that companies will invest some $250 billion in CDR by 2050, most of which will go to high-tech concepts that aren’t yet operational.
Nature and tech CDR are often pitted against either. In those comparisons, nature CDR is referred to as “temporary” and tech CDR as “permanent.” Such binary classification implies the necessity of giving priority to tech over nature. However, creating such false choice does not help as available CDR strategies are all contributing to climate change mitigation, but differ in their risk profile, short- and long-term benefits. While tech CDR is more durable, nature CDR is tested, can be deployed now and can yield benefits for nature and people.
“Nature-based and engineered CDR can be deployed synergistically, including through investment portfolios that balance the conditions of feasibility, durability, and sustainability,” said Matthew Brander, professor of carbon accounting at the University of Edinburgh Business School. “Engineered novel CDR methods offer higher durability and lower reversal risks. However, conventional nature-based CDR methods that rely on storing carbon in vegetation and soil are the most immediately deployable methods at scale, and costs are comparatively low. It’s clear that high-tech and natural CDR methods can complement—not compete with—one another.”
The authors demonstrate that a balanced, comprehensive approach to investments in all forms of CDR offers the best prospect of meeting the long-term temperature goal of the Paris Agreement in the context of sustainable development.
What is CDR?
The authors of the authoritative Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) define CDR as human "activities removing carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere and durably storing it in geological, terrestrial or ocean reservoirs, or in products."
CDR is classified according to how it captures carbon (for example, through photosynthesis or inorganic chemistry); where the carbon is stored (for example, land or sea); and the way in which it is stored, which can include plants and trees, soil, deep underground rock formations, minerals and the ocean floor.
The most successful CDR methods demonstrate readiness, feasibility, and the ability to remove a large amount of carbon without delay; sustainability, including the delivery of social and environmental benefits; and the durability of storage over the long term. Currently, no single CDR technique optimizes all three of these conditions and can sustain them over long periods of time.
“Engineered CDR is extremely expensive and will require huge amounts of cheap renewable energy, along with years of investment in research and development, before it’s ready to scale.” said Peter Ellis, the global director of natural climate solutions science at The Nature Conservancy. “In contrast, nature-based CDR is cheap and powered by photosynthesis, which has been in research and development in efficient self-replicating prototypes called plants for 3 billion years.”
The risk that stored carbon is released back into the atmosphere (e.g., through hazards, fire, pests or logging) is a key consideration in the CDR debate. Plans to store carbon in rocks, for example, are risky early on, before the carbon successfully hardens into minerals (mineralization). Over time, however, the risk of this CDR approach failing is significantly reduced. At the same time, natural approaches to CDR face different types and levels of risk over time. Not all newly planted ecosystems, for example, survive, and, even after these ecosystems are successfully established, they are vulnerable to unexpected human activities or the impacts of climate change, including fire, which releases carbon stored in wood back into the atmosphere.
“Policymakers and investors should encourage a balanced, comprehensive approach to investments in both nature- and tech-based CDR,” said Streck. “A balanced portfolio mitigates against risks of any one strategy and is most likely to make meaningful contributions toward achieving Paris Agreement goals.”
END
MISSION VIEJO, Calif. (June 11, 2025) – A new study suggests that eating one avocado a day may positively impact sleep. Science now confirms sleep is as important for good health as nutrition and exercise. In a secondary analysis of the largest randomized controlled trial on avocados to date, researchers found adults who consumed one avocado daily for six months reported better sleep compared to those who ate fewer than two avocados per month.
As, per the CDC, getting enough sleep can help lower the risk factors for heart disease, these findings add to a growing body of evidence supporting avocados as a heart-healthy food and mark the first time avocado consumption ...
A team from the Institute for Neurosciences (IN), a joint center of the Spanish National Research Council (CSIC) and the Miguel Hernández University (UMH) in Elche, has revealed how a structure essential for fly flight, the haltere, is formed. This small organ, located behind the main wings, functions as a biological gyroscope that helps the insect stay stable in the air. The study, published in the journal Current Biology, was led by researcher José Carlos Pastor Pareja, head of the Cell-to-tissue architecture in the nervous system laboratory at the IN.
This work shows that, contrary to previous ...
Telehealth patients were not more likely to develop substance use disorder
Researchers found that a small number of people who received initial stimulant prescription via telehealth developed stimulant disorder and emphasize the importance of follow-up care
Telehealth can make health care easier to access for patients with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) who need treatment, but experts worry about an increased risk of substance use disorder for patients being prescribed controlled medications such as stimulants for ADHD during these appointments. Mass General Brigham researchers scrutinized this concern with the first-ever study comparing ...
The oceans are full of living things, with microscopic algae (phytoplankton) at the base of the marine food chain. These organisms make a living in the same way as land plants, using the sunlight that penetrates the upper 100 meters or so of the ocean as the energy source by which they synthesise organic matter for their cells. Every year, these tiny algae make about as much organic carbon as land plants. Like land plants, they obtain the building blocks of their cells from the surrounding environment – not a soil in this case but the seawater solution they live in.
But unlike the land ecosystem, when these algae die, they fall into the dark ...
Bioengineering researchers at the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) have developed a soft, thin, stretchable bioelectronic device that can be implanted into a tadpole embryo’s neural plate, the early-stage, flat structure that folds to become the 3D brain and spinal cord.
The researchers demonstrated that the device could integrate seamlessly into the brain as it develops and record electrical activity from single brain cells with millisecond precision, with no impact on normal tadpole embryo development or behavior.
These so-called cyborg tadpoles offer a glimpse into a future in which profound mysteries of the brain could be illuminated, ...
Art restoration takes steady hands and a discerning eye. For centuries, conservators have restored paintings by identifying areas needing repair, then mixing an exact shade to fill in one area at a time. Often, a painting can have thousands of tiny regions requiring individual attention. Restoring a single painting can take anywhere from a few weeks to over a decade.
In recent years, digital restoration tools have opened a route to creating virtual representations of original, restored works. These tools apply techniques of computer vision, image recognition, and color matching, to generate a “digitally restored” version of a painting relatively quickly.
Still, there has ...
Randomness is incredibly useful. People often draw straws, throw dice or flip coins to make fair choices. Random numbers can enable auditors to make completely unbiased selections. Randomness is also key in security; if a password or code is an unguessable string of numbers, it’s harder to crack. Many of our cryptographic systems today use random number generators to produce secure keys.
But how do you know that a random number is truly random? Classical computer algorithms can only create pseudo-random numbers, and someone with enough knowledge of the algorithm or the system could ...
Infection control researchers at Mass General Brigham have developed a virtual reality (VR) tool to train clinicians on core concepts in infection control, including cleaning and disinfecting portable medical equipment, to prevent the spread of infections throughout healthcare facilities. They successfully piloted the VR training tool at seven facilities across the United States, and their hope is such training can increase staff competency and improve patient safety. The work is published in Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology.
“Devices ...
MADISON — Once only a part of science fiction, lasers are now everyday objects used in research, healthcare and even just for fun. Previously available only in low-energy light, lasers are now available in wavelengths from microwaves through X-rays, opening a range of different downstream applications.
In a new study publishing June 11, 2025, in the journal Nature, an international collaboration led by scientists at the University of Wisconsin–Madison has generated the shortest hard X-ray ...
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Silicon is king in the semiconductor technology that underpins smartphones, computers, electric vehicles and more, but its crown may be slipping according to a team led by researchers at Penn State. In a world first, they used two-dimensional (2D) materials, which are only an atom thick and retain their properties at that scale, unlike silicon, to develop a computer capable of simple operations.
The development, published today (June 11) in Nature, represents a major leap toward the realization of thinner, faster and more energy-efficient electronics, the researchers said. They created a complementary metal-oxide semiconductor ...
