(Press-News.org) LOGAN, Utah, USA — A recent critique from a team led by Utah State University ecologist Dan MacNulty and published in Forest Ecology and Management has prompted a formal correction to a high-profile study on aspen recovery while raising broader questions about how scientific conclusions are drawn and defended in complex ecological systems.
The original study, published last year by Luke Painter and colleagues, concluded that restoration of large carnivores — including the reintroduction of wolves in the mid-1990s — triggered a strong, ecologically significant trophic cascade that fostered widespread recovery of aspen trees in northern Yellowstone. Central to their evidence was a reported 152-fold increase in the average density of young aspen, a dramatic result widely cited in media coverage.
The formal correction to the reported increase in young aspen density shifted the figure down from a 152-fold increase to 17.5-fold. Painter’s team asserted that the corrected estimate still supports their original conclusion about aspen recovery.
“But the point is not just about a single number,” said MacNulty. “It’s about whether average values can reliably support claims about how strong, how widespread, and how representative aspen recovery really is.”
At the core of the disagreement is how ecological change is summarized in an uneven system: many of the measured sites have no aspen saplings, while a small minority contain large numbers.
MacNulty’s analysis indicates that a minority of sites drove the increase in average sapling density, giving an inflated impression of typical or landscape-wide recovery: 20% of sites accounted for 80% of the increase, while more than half of the sites contained no saplings at all, even as the overall average rose.
Painter’s assertion didn’t address whether averages themselves are appropriate measures of trophic cascade strength, MacNulty notes, leaving their original conclusion unchanged.
MacNulty also notes that the assertion relies on shifting interpretations of data published by his group that originally indicated a weaker trophic cascade. Although those data were previously described as methodologically limited and warranted caution, they are nonetheless used to calculate averages and cited as independent, “strikingly similar” confirmation of a strong cascade, without explaining why the same evidence is weighed differently across contexts.
MacNulty stresses that he does not dispute that trophic cascades have occurred in Yellowstone, nor that large carnivores can have important ecological effects. Rather, his critique challenges how confidently the strength and generality of those effects are claimed — especially in a system that remains dynamic and far from equilibrium.
“Because Yellowstone is a global symbol for predator-driven ecological restoration, how we interpret the data matters,” MacNulty said. “Applying rigorous standards ensures that claims about the magnitude of plant recovery reflect what the data actually support, providing more reliable guidance for both science and environmental management.”
###
END
Gaps in the nation’s stroke transfer system are drastically reducing survivors’ chances of receiving critical treatment and increasing the likelihood that they will leave the hospital with a disability, a new study suggests.
Around one-third of ischemic stroke survivors are eligible for endovascular thrombectomy, an effective intervention that changed the landscape of stroke treatment more than a decade ago.
More than 40% of people who receive endovascular therapy are initially seen at hospitals that don’t offer the treatment. These patients require transfer to more advanced facilities capable of delivering thrombectomy.
New findings published in The Lancet ...
Gaps in the U.S. stroke transfer system are drastically reducing survivors’ chances of receiving critical treatment and increasing the likelihood that they will leave the hospital with a disability, according to a new study published in The Lancet Neurology.
Around one-third of ischemic stroke patients are eligible for endovascular thrombectomy, an effective intervention that changed the landscape of stroke treatment more than a decade ago.
More than 40% of people who receive endovascular therapy initially arrive at hospitals that don’t offer the treatment. These patients require transfer to more advanced facilities capable of delivering ...
The long term use of proton pump inhibitors (PPIs), a class of drugs widely used to treat acid reflux and ulcers, may not be linked to any increased risk of developing gastric (stomach) cancer, finds a study of Nordic health data published by The BMJ today.
This finding should offer relief for patients needing long term proton pump inhibitor therapy and is valuable for clinical decision making in healthcare settings, say the researchers.
A fear that proton pump inhibitors could lead to stomach cancer has been ongoing since the 1980s. Recent research has linked their use to around a twofold increased risk, but ...
Offering non-monetary incentives such as free access to outpatient consultations to frequent blood donors is linked to an increase in donations without compromising blood safety, finds a study from China published by The BMJ today.
The researchers say their findings could encourage policymakers in other countries to design their own incentive models to address blood shortages.
Many countries, particularly developing ones, struggle to sustain an adequate blood supply due to challenges of retaining blood donors under the “gift model” - a ...
Natural ovulation before frozen embryo transfer is as effective as hormone treatment for achieving a healthy baby by vitro fertilisation (IVF), finds a clinical trial from China published by The BMJ today.
Natural ovulation is also linked to a lower risk of several complications for the mother, such as pre-eclampsia (abnormally high blood pressure), the results show.
Globally, the use of frozen embryo transfer after IVF has increased substantially and accounts for more than 60% of all embryo transfers.
Doctors prepare the womb lining (endometrium) for frozen ...
A major UK clinical trial has shown that adding the corticosteroid dexamethasone to standard antiviral treatment for encephalitis (brain inflammation), caused by herpes simplex virus (HSV) does not improve long-term outcomes overall, although early use may lead to better recovery, and the treatment is safe for patients in whom encephalitis is suspected.
The DexEnceph study, led by researchers at The Pandemic Institute, the University of Liverpool, and Walton Centre NHS Foundation Trust in partnership with Encephalitis International and research teams around the country, provides the most definitive evidence so far on whether corticosteroids should be used ...
Severe vitamin D deficiency is associated with a higher rate of hospitalisation for respiratory tract infections such as bronchitis and pneumonia, according to a new study led by the University of Surrey. Scientists found that those with a severe deficiency (below 15 nnmol/L) were 33 per cent more likely to be admitted to hospital for treatment than those with sufficient levels of vitamin D (at least 75 nmol/L).
In the largest study of its kind, analysing NHS data from the UK Biobank, researchers from Surrey, in collaboration with the University of Reading ...
There has been a lasting and disproportionate impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on diagnosis rates for conditions including depression, asthma and osteoporosis.
Depression is the most severely impacted, with almost a third fewer diagnoses than expected compared with pre-pandemic trends.
The King’s College London study is the first to evaluate whether diagnosis rates have recovered after emerging from the pandemic. Published today in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), it uses anonymised data from over 29 million people in England.
The pandemic had an unprecedented impact on healthcare systems around the world, leading to abrupt decreases ...
A 66 million-year-old mystery behind how our planet transformed from a tropical greenhouse to the ice-capped world of today has been unravelled by scientists.
Their new study has revealed that Earth’s massive drop in temperature after the dinosaurs went extinct could have been caused by a large decrease in calcium levels in the ocean.
An international team of experts led by the University of Southampton discovered that concentrations of calcium in the sea dropped by more than half across the last 66 million years.
The ...
Key points:
Red light therapy is an emerging therapy which shines near-infrared light into the brain through the skull, aiming to reduce inflammation.
A preliminary study with 26 football players suggests that red light therapy could prevent brain inflammation caused by repetitive impacts.
IMPACT: If larger studies confirm the results, red light therapy could help protect people who experience frequent head impacts, like soldiers and athletes, from long-term health consequences.
Punch-drunk syndrome, boxer’s madness, chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). The name has changed over the years, but the cause is clear: repeated impacts can affect long-term brain health, with symptoms ...
