(Press-News.org) Vienna, Austria: Adding magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to standard breast cancer screening approaches is expensive, though it could be cost effective for a group of women who may not have inherited the breast cancer susceptibility genes, but who have a familial risk of developing the disease. This is the conclusion of research presented at the eighth European Breast Cancer Conference (EBCC-8) today (Wednesday).
Women who carry the BRCA1/2 gene mutations are known to be at much higher risk of developing breast cancer, and at an early age; for this reason most breast cancer screening programmes start examining them with mammography from a younger age than for the general population in order to reduce deaths from the disease in this high-risk group. The use of MRI in addition has been shown to be cost-effective for these women who carry the BRCA1/2 mutations or who have a 50% (or higher) risk of carrying it. However, until now it has not been clear whether it is cost-effective for women who do not carry the mutations, but who have first and/or second degree relatives with breast cancer, to have MRI examinations as well as standard mammography. These women have a 20% or greater chance of developing breast cancer by the age of 70 due to their familial medical history.
A group of researchers in The Netherlands conducted a cost-effectiveness analysis of 1,597 women enrolled in the Dutch MRI Screening Study between 1999 and 2007, who had an estimated cumulative lifetime risk of between 15-50% for developing breast cancer before the age of 70. The women were screened by way of a clinical breast examination every six months and an annual mammography and MRI between the ages of 25-70.
The researchers used data on diagnosis, screening and treatment costs of the women with familial risk to calculate the cost per detected cancer and estimate the life-years gained. Then they used a computer modelling technique called microsimulation to simulate screening programmes with different methods of screening and time intervals.
"We found that it costs approximately three times as much to add MRI to the screening process for every estimated one year of life saved," said Dr Sepideh Saadatmand, who is a physician and PhD student at the Erasmus University Medical Center (Rotterdam, The Netherlands). "When women were screened using clinical breast examinations, mammography and MRI, the cost per detected cancer was about €103,000. We predicted that screening women between the ages of 35-60 in this way would reduce deaths from breast cancer by 24%, at a cost per year of life gained of €30,000.
However, if these women were screened by annual mammography and clinical breast examination alone, the estimated reduction in deaths was 20%, at a cost per year of life gained of €10,000.
"It is clear from the results of this study that adding MRI to screening programmes for all women with a cumulative life time risk of 15-50% for breast cancer is highly effective, but possibly too expensive. However, it may be cost-effective for a select sub-group."
She continued: "The subgroups we expect to benefit from MRI screening are women with a cumulative lifetime risk above 20% due to their family history, who have very dense breast tissue. Breast density may strongly influence screening results, since it increases breast cancer incidence significantly and decreases the sensitivity of mammography, but not of MRI. Therefore, for women with high breast density, MRI might be cost-effective. There is a multi-centre randomised controlled trial running in The Netherlands to investigate this."
The randomised controlled trial, with which Dr Saadatmand is involved, is expected to finish in 2015. It is randomising women aged between 30-55 with a family history of breast cancer and a cumulative lifetime risk of over 20% for developing the disease into two groups: 1) annual screening by clinical breast examination and mammography, or 2) annual screening by breast examination and MRI, with a mammography every other year. Researchers will be looking at the number of tumours detected at screening examinations and in between examinations (interval tumours), and at how advanced the cancer is when diagnosed. They will also be taking into account the varying densities of the women's breasts.
Dr Saadatmand concluded: "The results of the cost-effectiveness study presented today are likely to be of relevance to other countries that have screening programmes similar to The Netherlands, such as the UK and the Scandinavian countries."
Professor David Cameron, from the University of Edinburgh (Edinburgh, UK), and chair of EBCC-8 said: "This study produces an estimate of the cost-benefit of additional MRI in screening high-risk women. It will inform the important ongoing debate about the role of MRI in screening, particularly for younger women who have a higher-than average lifetime risk of developing breast cancer."
INFORMATION:
Abstract no: 27, Wednesday 17.30 hrs, proffered paper session on screening, Hall F1.
END
Hairtrade, the UK's leading retailer of hair extensions, hair care and beauty products has added an exciting new line to its hair styling range.
No Inhibition is a sophisticated hair styling line which consists of a number of products, from smoothing creams, styling gels and shaping pomades to moulding muds, modelling wax and texturizing foams. The elegance of this line is evident in the unique and stylish shaped bottles and colourful chic packaging.
Keven Kou, managing director of I&K International Limited said: "We've been looking for some new and exciting ...
Vienna, Austria: A Dutch study of the effectiveness of breast cancer screening shows that, even with improved treatments for the disease, population-based mammography programmes still save a significant number of lives.
The finding, presented today (Wednesday) at the eighth European Breast Cancer Conference (EBCC-8) in Vienna, will add further fuel to the debate about whether or not breast cancer screening does more harm than good. Those who argue against national screening programmes say that treatment for the disease is so effective nowadays that the chances of surviving ...
When observing a fly buzzing around the room, we should have the impression that it is not the fly, but rather the space that lies behind it that is moving. After all, the fly is always fixed in our central point of view. But how does the brain convey the impression of a fly in motion in a motionless field? With the help of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) scientists from the Werner Reichardt Centre for Integrative Neuroscience and the Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics in Tübingen have identified two areas of the brain that compare the movements ...
Confused.com has revealed shocking research showing the extent of driver habits on UK roads, with a range of behaviours admitted.
Apparently some drivers across the UK are getting in the driving seat wearing nothing more than pyjamas and with their feet clad in just their slippers or even barefoot. Applying make-up is another part of the morning routine which some women leave until they are actually driving the car: 1 in 10 women put make-up on and drive at the same time and 15% of men have had a shave while driving.
Car insurance experts at Confused.com are warning ...
Studies in monkeys are unlikely to provide reliable evidence for links between social status and heart disease in humans, according to the first ever systematic review of the relevant research.
The study, published in PLoS ONE, concludes that although such studies are cited frequently in human health research the evidence is often "cherry picked" and generalisation of the findings from monkeys to human societies does not appear to be warranted.
Psychosocial factors such as stress, social instability and work dynamics are often believed to play an important role in ...
With buds bursting early, only for a mild winter to turn Arctic and wipe them out, we are witnessing how warm weather can trigger flowering, even out of season, and how important it is for plants to blossom at the right time of year.
BBSRC-funded scientists have unpicked why temperature has such a powerful affect on how plants flower. In research to be published in the journal Nature, scientists from the John Innes Centre on the Norwich Research Park have identified the switch that accelerates flowering time in response to temperature.
With warm air, a control gene, ...
(Boston) - Researchers from the Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) and Boston University School of Public Health (BUSPH) have conducted a study on a modified version of the Short Inventory of Problems (SIP) to help promote early intervention and treatment for patients with drug use in primary care. The findings, which validate this modified version of the SIP in a primary care setting, will appear online in the American Journal on Addictions in the March issue.
The SIP, originally designed to measure the health and social consequences of alcohol use, was adapted ...
Bioethicists at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics are co-authors on a consensus article placing "significant responsibility" on biobanks to report individual research results (IRRs) and incidental findings (IFs) to the contributors of genetic material.
"The biobank should set the rules for the overall process of recognizing (and subsequently analyzing and returning) IFs and IRRs," the authors write in Genetics in Medicine.
Biobanks should define and manage a system by which "findings that are analytically valid, reveal an established and substantial risk ...
(March 21, 2012 - Chicago, IL) Large-scale microfinance programs are widely used as a tool to fight poverty in developing countries, but a recent study from the Consortium on Financial Systems and Poverty suggests that they can have varying results for participants and may be the most cost-effective use of funds only in limited situations.
The Thai Million Baht Village Fund is one of the largest government microfinance initiatives of its kind. Beginning in 2001, Thailand transferred one million Thai baht ($1.8 billion) in government funds to create almost 80,000 village ...
Hollywood mini-star and pop culture icon, Verne Troyer, joins the NavTones brand of celebrity GPS voices. Known for his roles in blockbuster films such as Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, Men In Black, and The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus, Verne Troyer's films have grossed over a billion dollars worldwide, but it was his role as "Mini Me" alongside Mike Myers in the Austin Powers franchise that catapulted him to international stardom. His tough attitude from the Powers films carries over to his GPS voice, albeit with the hilarious vocalization that the muted ...