Expert Testimony on Victim's Behavior Allowed in Pennsylvania Sex Assault Trials

Pennsylvania will now allow expert testimony to help explain an alleged victim's response to a sexual assault.

2012-09-22

September 22, 2012 (Press-News.org) Gov. Tom Corbett signed a law that will permit expert testimony in criminal sexual assault trials on victim's response to assaults. Pennsylvania was the last state to approve such legislation.

The recent high-profile trials involving Jerry Sandusky and Msjr. William J. Lynn helped with the passage of the law, according to one prosecutor quoted by the Philadelphia Inquirer. At the Governor's signing of the bill, the prosecutor noted without those cases, "[W]e would not be here this afternoon."

Victim's Response

The law is designed to address the problem of juror's perception of how sexual assault victims behave. Many jurors expect after a traumatic event that the victim will immediately call the police or other authorities.

The expert, in the words of the statute, can help the jury with "understanding the dynamics of sexual violence, victim responses to sexual violence and the impact of sexual violence on victims during and after being assaulted."

Some victims react unexpectedly, and the use of experts is seen by the prosecution has giving them a powerful tool to help explain this behavior to a jury.

Unfair Advantage?

Criminal defense attorneys generally opposed the bill, as they see it as providing an extra witness for the prosecution. While the law prohibits the use of the expert witness's opinion to assess the credibility of the victim, there is clearly a fear that that could happen by implication.

The concern is twofold. The expert, often a doctor or psychologist, carries the weight of their profession, and their statements bolstering the reaction of the victim may be interpreted by the jury as supporting the credibility of the victim.

The other concern is many defendants would not be able to afford an expert to counter the prosecution's witness. This would leave some jurors with the impression that the state's expert must be correct, as the defense failed to provide a rebuttal witness.

A defense attorney will need to clarify to the jury the expert's role. The attorney needs to ensure that the jury understands the testimony only supports how an alleged victim could behave, and that the question of the actual behavior of the alleged victim and their credibility remains an open question.

Article provided by The Law Offices of David S. Shrager
Visit us at www.shragerlawfirm.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Surgery Fires: Is that Smoke You Smell?

2012-09-22

When you think about all the risks you face in an operating room during a surgical procedure, fire probably does not rank high on your list. They could operate on the wrong side of the body or the wrong limb, they could leave surgical tools in your body, you could develop an infection or they could administer incorrect drugs, but you may not have even given thought to the possibility of a fire in the operating room. Nevertheless, you should. Surgical fires, while not an everyday occurrence, happen all too frequently. This is not all that surprising, once you consider ...

The Park at Walnut Ridge is Opening Fall 2012 in Frederick, Maryland

2012-09-22

The Park at Walnut Ridge is pleased to announce that it will be opening in the fall of 2012. Located in beautiful Frederick, MD, The Park at Walnut Ridge is conveniently located near Washington National Pike, I-70 and US Route 340. Only an hour away from the heart of Washington, D.C., and Baltimore, Frederick offers the perfect access to these career hubs. The Park at Walnut Ridge offers a wide array of amenities, including a stunning swimming pool with sundeck, an expansive dog park, convenient elevators in multi-storey buildings, a "Tot Lot" play area, ...

Plusnet Reveals Eight Out of Ten People are Proud to be British

2012-09-22

Plusnet has revealed that, with the world's spotlight having shone on the UK this year, 81% of the nation feel proud to be a Brit, with nearly a third claiming they feel more proud than they have for a decade. Plusnet has commissioned a survey, supplemented with focus groups and insights from leading psychologist Dr. Cliff Arnall, which has found that: - Nearly a third of the UK claim they feel the proudest they have for a decade - 69% are proud of the British sense of humour - 80% of Brits say family gives them sense of pride - 50% feel proud of bagging a bargain ...

Jumeirah Emirates Towers Named Best Business Hotel in the Middle East by UK Business Traveller Magazine

2012-09-22

Jumeirah Emirates Towers, the luxury city hotel and a Dubai landmark, was presented with the award for the Best Business Hotel in the Middle East at the Business Traveller Magazine Awards. Jumeirah Hotels & Resorts were also awarded Best Business Hotel Chain in the Middle East. The Business Traveller Magazine Awards are judged independently by the magazine's readers and are widely recognised as the leading accolades in the business travel industry. On receiving the award at the ceremony held at The Royal Garden Hotel in London, Imran Changezi, Hotel Manager ...

Eurostar 2013 Ashden Award for Sustainable Travel Opens for Entries

2012-09-22

The search is on for the best sustainable travel initiatives in Europe as the 2013 Eurostar Ashden Award for Sustainable Travel opens for entries. The Award, which is free to enter, recognises pioneering sustainable travel schemes from Belgium, France and the UK that are leading the way in encouraging people to adopt more sustainable forms of travel, helping improve quality of life, reducing congestion and pollution, and cutting CO2 emissions. Entry to the Award is open until the 30th October 2012, and up to two winners will be awarded with a share of the GBP30,000 ...

The National Trust Joins Fight to Save the Great British Pud

2012-09-22

The National Trust has announced it is backing a Government Minister's call to save the great British pudding. After being appointed in a recent cabinet reshuffle, Environment Secretary Owen Paterson urged people to be patriotic with their puddings, choosing traditional British recipes over foreign imports. In an interview with Farmers Weekly, Paterson said: "There is a huge dessert deficit in this country. We have a huge opportunity to replace imported desserts with desserts made here." He encouraged diners to swap desserts such as creme brulee and panna ...

New Product Gallery and Trends at International Casual Furniture & Accessories Market Offer Look at Outdoor Room Design Options for Next Season

2012-09-22

Merchandise Mart Properties, Inc. (MMPI) kicked-off the International Casual Furniture & Accessories Market at the Chicago Merchandise Mart this week. While the Casual Market is a trade show, a special New Product Gallery and near-countless product and style trends on display at the event are a comprehensive tell-tale of how consumers will decorate their outdoor spaces for the year to come. With the Casual Market now open, the New Product Gallery includes a wide range of casual outdoor furniture and accessories from showrooms and exhibitors, including furniture designs, ...

KMR Medical, LLC Announces Joint Venture Partnership with USlifecare

2012-09-22

KMR Medical, LLC is pleased to announce a new Join Venture Partnership with leading Medical Alert provider USlifecare. USlifecare provides industry-leading medical alert devices that help protect seniors in case of a medical emergency or other medical related needs they have in their home. KMR Medical will provide 100% of the installation and training on the medical alert device for all USlifecare customers. "We are extremely excited about this relationship as it helps strengthen our mission to better service our senior customers and help keep them in their own ...

Mosquito virus could lead to new vaccines and drugs

2012-09-21

A mosquito sample collected three decades ago in Israel's Negev Desert has yielded an unexpected discovery: a previously unknown virus that's closely related to some of the world's most dangerous mosquito-borne pathogens but, curiously, incapable of infecting non-insect hosts. Researchers believe this attribute could make the Eilat virus a uniquely useful tool for studying other alphaviruses, a genus of largely mosquito-borne pathogens that includes the viruses responsible for chikungunya, Venezuelan equine encephalitis, western equine encephalitis and eastern equine ...

New turtle tracking technique may aid efforts to save loggerhead

2012-09-21

The old adage "you are what you eat" is helping scientists better understand the threatened loggerhead turtle, which is the primary nester on Central Florida's beaches. A study published today in the journal PLOS ONE describes how scientists at the University of Central Florida used a technique that links chemical signatures of the turtles' diets and their watery environments to their migratory routes. They found the technique just as effective as expensive satellite tracking. Little is known about the turtles, which spend 99 percent of their time in the water and return ...