October 26, 2012 (Press-News.org) Bratz dolls took the toy-making world by storm in 2001, replacing the formerly wildly popular Barbie doll as the top-selling fashion doll by 2006. Mattel, the manufacturer of Barbie Dolls, alleged that MGA, the manufacturer of Bratz dolls, stole the idea for the dolls from Mattel. Mattel sued MGA, setting off a lengthy court battle over copyright infringement allegations. In 2011, a jury found that Mattel, not MGA, stole trade secrets and awarded MGA damages. Mattel has announced plans to appeal the copyright infringement finding.
Eight-Year Ordeal
Mattel originally sued MGA, the maker of Bratz dolls, in 2004 for copyright infringement. Mattel claimed that Bratz designer Carter Bryant was working for Mattel when he came up with the idea of Bratz dolls. In 2008, a federal jury awarded Mattel $100 million in damages for copyright infringement. MGA appealed the award and counter-sued.
After another trial, a jury found that MGA did not infringe on Mattel's copyright. Furthermore, the jury found Mattel stole 26 of 114 trade secrets that MGA listed in its counter-suit and awarded the company $85 million in damages. The judge presiding over the trial added an additional $85 million in punitive damages and $137 million in attorney fees and costs.
Not Challenging Copyright Infringement Finding
Representatives from Mattel announced its intention not to appeal the jury's finding that MGA did not infringe on Mattel's copyrights. Mattel stated that it disagreed with the jury's decision, but wanted to avoid another protracted trial on the issue. Mattel is, however, appealing the jury's finding that it stole trade secrets from MGA.
Trade Secret Law
Under the Uniform Trade Secret Act, which California has adopted, in order for information to constitute a trade secret it must:
-Have independent economic value to the owner by remaining secret
-Been subject to reasonable precautions to keep the information secret
Mattel will argue in its appeal that the statute of limitations had passed on MGA's claims and were therefore time-barred at the time of the counter-suit. Additionally, Mattel claims that MGA failed to provide sufficient evidence that the information listed in the counter-suit was actually protected as trade secrets.
Mattel also argued that the court abused its discretion and erred in calculating the attorney fees and punitive damages.
Contact an Attorney
Intellectual property disputes can often be complex. Individuals and companies with trade secrets or intellectual property to protect should seek the advice of an experienced business lawyer who can advise them about the best way to defend their hard work.
Article provided by William B. Hanley, Attorney at Law
Visit us at http://www.hanley-law.com
Mattel Appeals $310 Million Award to Maker of Bratz Dolls
Bratz dolls took the toy-making world by storm in 2001, replacing the Barbie doll as the top-selling fashion doll. Mattel alleged that the manufacturer of Bratz dolls stole its idea.
2012-10-26
ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:
An Explanation of Wrongful Death Lawsuits in Illinois
2012-10-26
A wrongful death lawsuit is a legal claim that arises when someone dies as a result of another party's negligence or wrongdoing. A wrongful death may be caused by a negligent act such as a car crash or medical malpractice, or by a deliberately harmful act such as physical assault. Individuals as well as corporations and other entities can be held liable in an Illinois wrongful death lawsuit, as can their insurance companies.
The Purpose of the Wrongful Death Statute
The purpose of a wrongful death lawsuit is to provide financial compensation to the people who have ...
IRS Determinations of Responsibility for Unpaid Payroll Taxes
2012-10-26
One of the more difficult parts of being a business owner is dealing with tax issues. The tax laws in the U.S. can be complicated, and those who own or run business can easily make mistakes in payroll taxes. When the IRS believes that a business has not paid all of the payroll taxes it owes, it may pursue payment from not just the business owners, but any person whom it deems a responsible party. People should understand how the IRS determines who is a responsible party, what constitutes willful failure to pay taxes and the potential penalties a person faces for willful ...
Police Retaliation? 71-Year-Old New Yorker Facing Weapons Charges
2012-10-26
A 71-year-old New York man is currently facing charges of possessing dangerous weapons. The weapons at issue are not dangerous semi-automatic guns. In fact, the weapons in question are not even guns, switchblade knives, or brass knuckles.
Instead, according to the Huffington Post, the man received the weapons charges because a penknife and commemorative, miniature baseball bat were found within his vehicle.
The man facing these weapons charges, Joseph "Jazz" Hayden, has a reputation in his community as a civil rights advocate. Many members of this community ...
New Ignition Interlock Standard for Virginia
2012-10-26
Virginia drivers who are convicted of a first-time drunk driving offense now must install and use an ignition interlock system on their vehicles as a condition of receiving a restricted permit. The requirement took effect July 1, 2012. Previously, Virginia law required ignition interlock only for repeat offenders or for first-time offenders with very high blood alcohol levels, at 0.15 and above.
How Ignition Interlock Works
An ignition interlock system uses an analyzing device attached to the vehicle's ignition. In order to start the car, the driver must provide a ...
How Does a Parent Modify an Arizona Child Support Order?
2012-10-26
Parents have an obligation to support their children financially. When parents divorce, or when parents who were never married split up, one of the ways that a parent fulfills this obligation is by paying child support. In some cases, a parent's circumstances will change after the court enters a child support order and he or she will need to have the order modified. Arizona parents should be aware of what a child support modification is, when a parent may seek a modification and why a parent should use the court to modify child support.
When Can a Parent Seek Modification?
A ...
Protecting a Small Business in an Arizona Divorce
2012-10-26
Divorce is a difficult thing for most people to endure and the pain of divorce can increase exponentially for those small-business owners if they end up losing part of their business in a divorce property settlement. Arizona is a "community property" state, which means that the court splits a couple's marital assets evenly in the event of a divorce. Arizona business owners can take steps to prevent the court from viewing their businesses as marital property, and also to ensure that the court treats the businesses fairly in an asset division in the event that the ...
Chinese Court Takes a Bite Out of Apple
2012-10-26
Apple, Inc. is renowned for being the maker of wildly popular electronic devices such as the iPod, the iPad and the Macbook. The company is trying to expand its sales into China, and has opened four Apple Stores in the country. However, Apple has run into some legal issues regarding the use of the name "iPad." A Chinese company, Proview Technology, owns the trademark to the name in China and the two companies have been battling over the rights to the name since 2006. A December 2011 Chinese court decision rejected Apple's claim that Proview was infringing on Apple's ...
Improving Credit Scores After Bankruptcy
2012-10-26
While there is no quick fix to improving a bad credit score, there are steps that savvy consumers can take to improve their credit scores after filing bankruptcy. The first step is to review a copy of the credit report and make sure that any debts previously paid off or discharged in the bankruptcy are correctly indicated as such on the credit report. Otherwise, the amounts will continue to show up as delinquent, keeping the credit score down.
Consumers should also try to establish new credit. At first, it may not be easy to get a traditional credit card, but obtaining ...
San Francisco Bay Area Discrimination Lawsuit Gains National Attention
2012-10-26
A lawsuit filed by Kleiner Partner Ellen Pao is continuing to draw attention to discrimination allegations within technology businesses located in Silicon Valley. Silicon Valley, popular for its innovations in the technology industry, is facing heat as the lawsuit fuels a debate on the presence of sexism throughout the technology industry, according to Reuters.
Kleiner, a venture capital firm, is known for backing big names including Amazon.com and browser company Netscape. The firm not only denies the presence of discrimination within the company but also claims that ...
Houston Men's Club Sued for Providing Alcohol Leading to DUI Accident
2012-10-26
A recent drunk driving accident resulted in the death of an 18-year-old Caney Creek High School senior. The young woman was driving along the Sam Houston Parkway when another vehicle, allegedly driving at speeds over 130 mph by an intoxicated Erasmo Ramirez, collided with her pickup truck.
The force of the collision caused the bed to separate from the cab of the truck and become airborne. The truck bed ultimately landed on and crushed the cab. The high school senior suffered serious injuries from the drunk driving accident and died the next morning. Mr. Ramirez was charged ...
LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:
Study reveals beneficial microbes that can sustain yields in unfertilized fields
Robotic probe quickly measures key properties of new materials
Climate change cuts milk production, even when farmers cool their cows
Frozen, but not sealed: Arctic Ocean remained open to life during ice ages
Some like it cold: Cryorhodopsins
Demystifying gut bacteria with AI
Human wellbeing on a finite planet towards 2100: new study shows humanity at a crossroads
Unlocking the hidden biodiversity of Europe’s villages
Planned hydrogen refuelling stations may lead to millions of euros in yearly losses
Planned C-sections increase the risk of certain childhood cancers
Adults who have survived childhood cancer are at increased risk of severe COVID-19
Drones reveal extreme coral mortality after bleaching
New genetic finding uncovers hidden cause of arsenic resistance in acute promyelocytic leukemia
Native habitats hold the key to the much-loved smashed avocado’s future
Using lightning to make ammonia out of thin air
Machine learning potential-driven insights into pH-dependent CO₂ reduction
Physician associates provide safe care for diagnosed patients when directly supervised by a doctor
How game-play with robots can bring out their human side
Asthma: patient expectations influence the course of the disease
UNM physician tests drug that causes nerve tissue to emit light, enabling faster, safer surgery
New study identifies EMP1 as a key driver of pancreatic cancer progression and poor prognosis
XPR1 identified as a key regulator of ovarian cancer growth through autophagy and immune evasion
Flexible, eco-friendly electronic plastic for wearable tech, sensors
Can the Large Hadron Collider snap string theory?
Stuckeman professor’s new book explores ‘socially sustainable’ architecture
Synthetic DNA nanoparticles for gene therapy
New model to find treatments for an aggressive blood cancer
Special issue of Journal of Intensive Medicine analyzes non-invasive respiratory support
T cells take aim at Chikungunya virus
Gantangqing site in southwest China yields 300,000-year-old wooden tools
[Press-News.org] Mattel Appeals $310 Million Award to Maker of Bratz DollsBratz dolls took the toy-making world by storm in 2001, replacing the Barbie doll as the top-selling fashion doll. Mattel alleged that the manufacturer of Bratz dolls stole its idea.