Patent attorney malpractice: Who hears the case?

The U.S. Supreme Court will decide which court has jurisdiction to hear patent attorney malpractice cases.

2013-02-06

February 06, 2013 (Press-News.org) Patent attorney malpractice: Who hears the case?

Federal courts have jurisdiction over lawsuits "arising under any Act of Congress relating to patents, plant variety protection, copyrights and trademarks." But does that then mean federal courts have jurisdiction when a client sues his patent litigation attorneys?

Generally, claims for legal malpractice are decided by state courts and claims regarding patent laws are governed by federal courts. However, the United States Supreme Court has just agreed to review the case Gunn v. Minton to determine whether an attorney malpractice claim that asserts malpractice in handling a patent lawsuit "arises under" patent laws and is therefore under federal court jurisdiction.

The facts ofGunn v. Minton

Minton developed software for investment trading. In 1995, he licensed the software to NASDAQ. More than a year later he applied for a patent. When he later sued NASDAQ in a $100 million patent infringement lawsuit, his patent was determined invalid because he sold the software more than a year before applying for a patent. Post judgment, Minton moved the court to consider that the early licensing did not invalidate his patent, because it was an experimental use. His motion was denied for being untimely. Minton then sued his patent litigation lawyers for failing to plead the experimental use issue in a timely manner.

Minton brought his legal malpractice lawsuit in Texas state courts where it was dismissed for lack of evidence. He appealed the dismissal to the state appellate court. During the appeal, the Federal Circuit court ruled, on two similar cases, that when a malpractice case arises from a patent law issue, federal courts have jurisdiction. Based on those rulings, Minton asked the appellate court to dismiss the case for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. While the appellate court denied that request, the Texas Supreme Court did not and held that the case should be brought in federal court.

The attorneys for the patent attorneys petitioned the United States Supreme Court for review, asking them to decide once and for all: Who decides patent attorney malpractice claims (which involve no actual patents) -- state or federal courts? The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to review the issue.

Legal malpractice claims

Legal malpractice suits are complex, especially if the underlying lawsuit involved intellectual property. If you have had a legal malpractice or ethical complaint made against you from someone seeking financial compensation, contact an experienced legal malpractice attorney to defend your rights, your reputation and your career.

Article provided by Leritz, Plunkert & Bruning, PC
Visit us at http://www.leritzlaw.com

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Hands Free Technology Does Little to Mitigate Distracted Driving Risk

2013-02-06

Hands Free Technology Does Little to Mitigate Distracted Driving Risk In recent years, the proliferation of smart phones and Global Positioning System (GPS) navigation devices has changed the way that people in the United States travel on the highway. Some of these changes have been good: drivers on long trips can use their phones to easily stay in touch with loved ones and commuters can use their navigation systems to help bypass construction and arrive at their destinations on time. Other changes, however - most significantly, the rise in distracted driving related ...

Be Aware of Tennessee's DUI Penalties No Matter the Level of Enforcement

2013-02-06

Be Aware of Tennessee's DUI Penalties No Matter the Level of Enforcement When it comes to drinking and driving, police often step up enforcement measures on the weekends and around holidays. No holiday may better demonstrate the time when police increase the enforcement of drinking and driving laws than New Year's Eve. This recent holiday was a busy one for the Tennessee Highway Patrol, but no matter the season, drivers in Tennessee should be aware of the legal and non-legal ramifications of driving under the influence. Stepped-up enforcement of drinking and driving ...

Foreclosure prevention in Pennsylvania

2013-02-06

Foreclosure prevention in Pennsylvania Recent reports indicate that the number of home foreclosures in Pennsylvania is decreasing. According to RealtyTrac, foreclosures in November 2012 decreased by 67 percent from a year ago. In fact, foreclosure rates are down in 28 states compared to 2011. Nationwide, there were 77,494 foreclosures in November 2012, which is a 13 percent decrease from October 2012 and a 28 percent decrease from November 2011. In spite of these statistics, some experts aren't overly optimistic about the decrease in foreclosures. The vice president ...

Treasury Department proposal asks hedge funds to turn themselves in

2013-02-06

Treasury Department proposal asks hedge funds to turn themselves in Unlike many financial institutions, hedge funds traditionally operated without a lot of regulation and reporting requirements. That may soon change as an office of the Treasury Department, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, considers a rule that may require hedge funds to report potential wrongdoing within the business. The self-regulation will effectively turn every hedge fund employee into a mandated whistleblower, which is not uncommon in the banking industry. However, the proposed regulation ...

Watch out for retained surgical objects

2013-02-06

Watch out for retained surgical objects Georgia residents depend on their physicians and other medical caregivers when they are injured or ill. If surgery is required, patients expect medical staff to see them through the operation and recovery with careful attention to every detail. What patients do not deserve or expect is a surgical error to be made by their caregivers that leads to further complications. When surgeons fail to finish the job According to researchers at the Johns Hopkins University, every week in the United States, including Georgia, an estimated ...

Modification of child custody and visitation in Georgia

2013-02-06

Modification of child custody and visitation in Georgia During the divorce process child custody can be one of the most contentious issues either parent may face. Often neither parent is happy to give up time with his or her child. Thankfully if a substantial change in a parent's or a child's life occur the child custody order can be changed. Modifying visitation or parenting time In Georgia there is a difference in requirements when a parent may request a change in visitation or parenting time and when a parent may request a change to the child custody order. ...

Cerebral palsy and medical negligence

2013-02-06

Cerebral palsy and medical negligence According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, cerebral palsy is the most common childhood motor disability in the United States. There are various causes of cerebral palsy, a few of which include medical negligence. Cerebral palsy victims may need a lifetime of care and, potentially, even 24-hour care. Given that cerebral palsy has such profound implications on a person's life, and if the cerebral palsy was the result of medical negligence, an injured party may be entitled to significant compensation for his or ...

Idolumic Unveils Multi-Platform Updates of Rhyme Genie and TuneSmith

2013-02-06

With the release of Rhyme Genie 5 Idolumic unveils a new iOS version to complement the updated Mac and Windows versions of the dynamic rhyming dictionary. With 30 different rhyme types and over 10 million phonetic references the iOS version of Rhyme Genie 5 is an exact clone of the desktop version requiring the use of an iPhone 5, an iPad 4 or an iPad Mini. "Even though we have completely re-designed Rhyme Genie 5 to run as efficiently as possible on all platforms, Apple's latest mobile devices are strongly recommended to achieve optimum performance on iOS," ...

The Ocean Meets the Mountains this March at Park Hyatt Saigon

2013-02-06

The month of March at Park Hyatt Saigon presents cuisine originating from the waters of Vietnam to the hilltops of Italy. Unique seasonal creations will be available to discover, and rediscover, specialties at Square One and Opera. A SQUARE ONE SEAFOOD SENTIMENT Experience the refined seafood styling and sophistication of Square One. For the month of March, Chef Soren brings the taste of the ocean with a menu that incorporates fresh seafood and produce from different regions of Vietnam. Seafood lovers will enjoy the subtle textures, flavours and nuances prepared with ...

GenScript Launches eBlot Protein Transfer System

2013-02-06

GenScript USA Incorporation has launched the eBlot Protein Transfer System, a semi-dry electric blotter for transferring proteins from mini polyacrylamide gels onto membranes, expanding its bench-top tool offerings for protein analysis. Western blot is a widely applied technique for the analysis of proteins in biological samples following gel electrophoresis. Efficient and consistent blotting of proteins from polyacrylamide gels onto membranes is crucial for a successful western analysis. Traditional blotting methods usually take hours with variable transfer efficiencies ...

Patent attorney malpractice: Who hears the case?

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES: