The outcome of fertility treatments using donor sperm is dependent on the quality of sperm

Analysis of all registered sperm donation treatments in national database

2014-06-30

(Press-News.org) Munich, 30 June 2014: Despite emerging evidence of a decline in sperm quality with increasing age, an analysis of every first fertility treatment cycle performed in the UK using sperm donation shows that outcome in terms of live birth is not affected by the age of the sperm donor. Results from the study, said its principal investigator Dr Meenakshi Choudhary, from the Newcastle Fertility Centre at Life, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom, reaffirm the observation that a couple's fertility appears significantly more dependent on the age of the female partner than on that of the male.

The results of the study are reported this week at the Annual Meeting of ESHRE in Munich by Dr Choudhary's colleague, Commonwealth Clinical Fellow Dr Navdeep Ghuman.

Their conclusions were derived from an analysis of all UK treatment cycles with sperm donation registered by the Human Fertilisation & Embryology Authority (HFEA) between 1991 and 2012. From a total of more than 230,000 sperm donation cycles, 39,282 were from a first cycle of treatment (with either IVF or donor insemination) and were included in the analysis (a first cycle would avoid any bias from previous attempts). The authors note that it is the first study to conduct an analysis of the effect of sperm donor age on live birth using a large national database.

With the assumption that female fertility clearly declines with age, the study divided its female subjects into two groups: those who were treated with donor sperm between the ages of 18 and 34, and those who were treated after the age of 37. They were further sub-divided according to treatment - donor insemination or IVF. The sperm donors were then divided into six age groups for the analysis (under 20, 21-25, 26-30, 31-35, 36-40, 41-45).

As expected, results showed a difference according to female age, both in the IVF and the donor insemination treatments. Thus, live birth rate from IVF with donated sperm was around 29% in the 18-34 age group, but only around 14% in the over-37 age group.

However, within these same two female age bands, no significant differences were found in live birth rate (LBR) relative to the age of sperm donor. Thus: in the younger IVF patients LBR was 28.3% with a sperm donor aged under 20 and 30.4% with a donor aged 41-45 in the younger donor insemination patients LBR was 9.7% with a donor aged under 20 and 12% with a donor aged 41-45.

The women in the 18-34 age group were defined as at the peak of their reproductive potential. Less likely to conceive were women in the age group over 37, and here some differences in outcome were observed, though not of statistical significance. There was a trend, for example, that sperm donors under the age of 20 were associated with a less successful outcome than older donors. Thus: in the older IVF patients LBR was 11% with a donor under the age of 20, 17% with donor aged 26-30, and 16.6% with a donor aged 41-45 in the older donor insemination patients LBR was 3.1% with a donor under 20, and 4.6% with a donor aged 41-45

"Despite these trends," said Dr Choudhary, "it's important to note that the impact of sperm donor age on live birth failed to reach statistical significance in any of the age groups we studied. Indeed, this trend of less likelihood of live birth with younger sperm donor age might simply be explained by the fact that younger men who donate sperm are less likely to have proven fertility themselves than older sperm donors with proven fertility."

However, with emphatic results from such a large cohort study, Dr Choudhary was confident that the age of the sperm donor was of little significance in couples having sperm donation for fertility treatment. " It's sperm quality rather than male age that matters," she said.

Regulatory requirements on the maximum age of sperm donors tend to range between 40 and 45 years.(1) These regulatory thresholds reflect a decline in sperm quality with age and the greater likelihood of DNA mutations and higher risk of genetic abnormality in offspring. These risks have been highlighted in many recent studies. Studies have also suggested that the principal semen parameters - semen volume, sperm motility and sperm concentration - all decline as men grow older. These declines, however, do not necessarily prevent conception, as the many well recorded examples of celebrity senior fathers illustrate. And many studies, like this one, have failed to find a strong effect of paternal age on a couple's fertility.(2) Conversely, there are still many other studies suggesting that increased paternal age is associated with reduced fertility and that this effect is evident in both natural and assisted conception.

"Whilst advancing female age is clearly associated with fertility decline," said Dr Choudhary, "there is still no consensus about advancing paternal age and fertility outcome. This is an area which is still much under-researched. A few studies show an effect on DNA mutations which might explain a higher rate of miscarriage, pregnancy loss and birth defect. Advanced paternal age has also been associated with long-term disorders in offspring. But the available evidence is limited.

"Our results suggest that, up to the age of 45, there is little effect of male age on treatment outcome, but sperm donors are a selected population based on good sperm quality. Our study shows that we are good at selecting the right sperm donors with the right sperm quality - and that's why we found no difference in live birth rate despite the increasing age of sperm donors. This confirms the view that a man's age doesn't matter in achieving a live birth provided his sperm quality is good."

INFORMATION: Abstract O-157, Tuesday 1 July 15.30 CET Age of the sperm donor: does it really matter - an analysis of 1,048,576 assisted reproduction treatment cycles

Notes 1. Current UK guidelines, for example, recommend that sperm should not be taken from donors aged 41 or over. The HFEA states that centres should normally observe the relevant donor age limit, but, "due to less substantial evidence on age limits for sperm donors", centres can assess the possible effect of a donor's age on a case by case basis. Regulations require sperm samples to be screened for certain viral, sexually transmitted and genetically transmitted diseases, and freeze-stored in quarantine for at least six months. 2. See for example, Dain L, Auslander R, Dirnfeld M. The effect of paternal age on assisted reproduction outcome. Fertil Steril 2011; 95: 1.

When obtaining outside comment, journalists are requested to ensure that their contacts are aware of the embargo on this release.

For further information on the details of this press release, contact: Christine Bauquis at ESHRE
Mobile: +32 (0)499 25 80 46
Email: christine@eshre.eu

ELSE PRESS RELEASES FROM THIS DATE:

Researchers estimate 5.8 million A&E visits occur after patients unable to see a GP

2014-06-30

Researchers have estimated that in 2012-2013 there were 5.77 million A&E attendances in England that were preceded by an inability to get a timely GP appointment. Unplanned attendances at accident and emergency (A&E) departments in England have increased by 11 per cent (2.2 million attendances) between financial years 2008-2009 and 2012-2013. Recent reviews and research based on interviews have suggested that a reason for some attendances is that people who cannot obtain a GP appointment, or one they consider timely, visit A&E as an alternative. This is the first study ...

Countdown to 2015 and beyond: Fulfilling the health agenda for women and children

2014-06-30

The Lancet today [Monday 30 June] publishes a new Review from the Countdown to 2015 collaboration, summarising results from the Countdown 2014 report, examining the data supporting evidence-based decisions in women's and children's health, describing elements of the Countdown process that might inform ongoing efforts to hold the world to account for progress, and listing concrete steps that can be taken now to ensure continued progress for women and children. The Review is published to coincide with the 2014 Partners' Forum, held in Johannesburg, South Africa from June ...

Watching individual neurons respond to magnetic therapy

2014-06-29

DURHAM, N.C. -- Engineers and neuroscientists at Duke University have developed a method to measure the response of an individual neuron to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) of the brain. The advance will help researchers understand the underlying physiological effects of TMS -- a procedure used to treat psychiatric disorders -- and optimize its use as a therapeutic treatment. TMS uses magnetic fields created by electric currents running through a wire coil to induce neural activity in the brain. With the flip of a switch, researchers can cause a hand to move or ...

A single gene separates aggressive and non-aggressive lymphatic system cancer

2014-06-29

WASHINGTON — For a rare form of cancer called thymoma, researchers have discovered a single gene defining the difference between a fast-growing tumor requiring aggressive treatment and a slow-growing tumor that doesn't require extensive therapy. Thymoma is a cancer derived from the epithelial cells of the thymus, an organ critical to the lymphatic system where T-cells, or so-called "killer cells," mature. Very little is known about the role of the gene mutation GTF2l in human tumors, but scientists from Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center and the National Cancer ...

High CO2 levels cause warming in the tropics

2014-06-29

The impact of the greenhouse gas CO2 on the Earth's temperature is well established by climate models and temperature records over the past 100 years, as well as coupled records of carbon dioxide concentration and temperature throughout Earth history. However, past temperature records have suggested that warming is largely confined to mid-to-high latitudes, especially the poles, whereas tropical temperatures appear to be relatively stable: the tropical thermostat model. The new results, published today in Nature Geoscience, contradict those previous studies and indicate ...

Single-pixel 'multiplex' captures elusive terahertz images

2014-06-29

CHESTNUT HILL, MA (June 29, 2014) – A novel metamaterial enables a fast, efficient and high-fidelity terahertz radiation imaging system capable of manipulating the stubborn electromagnetic waves, advancing a technology with potential applications in medical and security imaging, a team led by Boston College researchers reports in the online edition of the journal Nature Photonics. The team reports it developed a "multiplex" tunable spatial light modulator (SLM) that uses a series of filter-like "masks" to retrieve multiple samples of a terahertz (THz) scene, which are ...

Marine bacteria are natural source of chemical fire retardants

2014-06-29

Researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine have discovered a widely distributed group of marine bacteria that produce compounds nearly identical to toxic man-made fire retardants. Among the chemicals produced by the ocean-dwelling microbes, which have been found in habitats as diverse as sea grasses, marine sediments and corals, is a potent endocrine disruptor that mimics the human body's most active thyroid hormone. The study is published in the June 29 online issue of Nature Chemical Biology. "We find it very surprising and a tad alarming ...

NIH-funded researchers extend liver preservation for transplantation

2014-06-29

Researchers have developed a new supercooling technique to increase the amount of time human organs could remain viable outside the body. This study was conducted in rats, and if it succeeds in humans, it would enable a world-wide allocation of donor organs, saving more lives. The research is supported by National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering (NIBIB) and the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Disease (NIDDK), both parts of the National Institutes of Health. The first human whole organ transplant 60 years ago—a living kidney ...

Massachusetts General-developed protocol could greatly extend preservation of donor livers

2014-06-29

A system developed by investigators at the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Center for Engineering in Medicine allowed successful transplantation of rat livers after preservation for as long as four days, more than tripling the length of time organs currently can be preserved. The team describes their protocol – which combines below-freezing temperatures with the use of two protective solutions and machine perfusion of the organ – in a Nature Medicine paper receiving advance online publication. "To our knowledge, this is the longest preservation time with subsequent ...

Reconstructing the life history of a single cell

2014-06-29

Researchers have developed new methods to trace the life history of individual cells back to their origins in the fertilised egg. By looking at the copy of the human genome present in healthy cells, they were able to build a picture of each cell's development from the early embryo on its journey to become part of an adult organ. During the life of an individual, all cells in the body develop mutations, known as somatic mutations, which are not inherited from parents or passed on to offspring. These somatic mutations carry a coded record of the lifetime experiences of ...

LAST 30 PRESS RELEASES:

One of the largest studies of its kind finds early intervention with iron delivered intravenously during pregnancy is a safe and effective treatment for anemia