(Press-News.org) Even as misinformation proliferates across the Internet, sites containing low-credibility health information remain relatively scarce and unseen.
That’s according to new research from University of Utah communication scholars who tracked web-surfing activities of more than 1,000 U.S. adults for four weeks. But the findings, published in Nature Aging, illuminate a dark side. Traffic to such sites is concentrated heavily among older adults, especially among those who lean right politically.
This indicates the most vulnerable population is the most likely to be exposed to potentially harmful health-related information online, according to lead author Ben Lyons, an associate professor in the Department of Communication.
Good news with a catch
“It’s sort of good news, though. Overall, the levels are pretty low,” Lyons said, emphasizing that it’s still a small number of people, young and old, who are drawn to dubious medical information while surfing the web. “Not all older adults are like this, but the outliers are concentrated among older adults.”
Prior research by Lyons and others has established that older Americans are more likely to engage with and share political misinformation. To investigate whether this is also true for health information as well, Lyons and his colleagues, Andy King and Kimberly Kaphingst, collaborated with the U’s School of Medicine and Huntsman Cancer Institute.
They found that older folks do not generally engage with questionable health information on the same scale as they do with partisan political content.
“The age effect is way bigger for politics,” Lyons said. “People see politics as way more entertaining than they would health-related content. So there's less of a motivation to want to share these things. You don't get a feeling of team identity from sharing health misinformation like you would for information that puts down your political opponents.”
Analyzing 9 million page views
To conduct the study, the team analyzed both survey results and actual web-browsing and YouTube-viewing data. The survey data were gathered via questionnaires midway through the four-week study period.
During this period, the participants landed on about 9 million URLs, including 500,000 YouTube videos, according to the trace data. Lyons and King coded the websites for health content, separating those by commercial and informational content. Of the 1,055 domains categorized with the health tag, just 78 or 6.8% trafficked in low-credibility health information.
Only 13% of participants visited even one such site during the four-week period, and those visits made up just 3% of all health-related browsing.
But the exposure was highly concentrated in a small group of people. The top 10% of participants accounted for more than three-quarters of all visits to low-credibility health sites.
Since older adults have more health burdens and make more medical decisions, they tend to spend more time seeking out health information online. It would naturally follow that they may be more likely to be exposed to medical misinformation, so the researchers examined the ratios of visits involving low-credibility information. They found these ratios to be much higher for older adults.
“Most people are not visiting these kinds of websites,” Lyons stressed. “Visits are pretty rare overall, but the sort of patterns we've seen in numerous trace-data studies tend to be replicated here. It's older adults, in particular, those who consume more right-leaning partisan news. We wouldn't necessarily hypothesize that from the get-go.”
How Internet users wind up on websites with low-credibility information
This aspect of the findings surprised Lyons’s team, which explored the “referral” sites, the ones that directed the user to URLs with low-credibility health information, to see what was driving this traffic.
“Are people going through Google search, or are they being referred through Facebook? We're not really seeing that in this data,” Lyons said. “We’re also not seeing people being referred through partisan news media, even though that is a correlate. What we found, at least in the referral data, is that it's a more insular type of thing. They're visiting these because they visit other low-credibility sites, they're clicking through, and they're spending more time on these sites. They're going to them directly.”
In another finding, the team discovered people who already believed false health claims or had more conspiratorial views were more likely to encounter dubious health content, indicating exposure isn’t random.
This study suggests that improving online health information environments and helping people better evaluate what they encounter may be especially important for seniors. At the same time, the findings show this isn’t just a “health misinformation” problem, but rather something tied to broader patterns of how people navigate the internet, which makes solutions more complicated.
#####
The study, titled “Exposure to low-credibility health websites is limited and is concentrated among older adults,” was published in the journal Nature Aging on Feb. 4. Co-author Rebecca Barter is a research assistant professor of epidemiology at the University of Utah. Lyons, King and Kaphingst hold cross appointments in the U’s Cancer Control and Population Sciences Program, run by the Huntsman Cancer Institute, which funded the research. These findings will be incorporated into Lyons’ forthcoming book, “Dubious News and the Aging American,” published by Oxford University Press.
END
Adult survivors of childhood cancers are at higher risk for another cancer – such as breast, colorectal, sarcomas and thyroid cancer – that is not a relapse of their original illness. Previous cancer therapies are largely responsible, however up to 13 percent of survivors also have hereditary predisposition that elevates their risk of subsequent cancer. A recent clinical trial found that genetic services via remote centralized telehealth and in collaboration with primary care increased the uptake of genetic ...
Recent global crises have exposed the limits of a universal mortality threshold for declaring famine—an approach that can obscure how famine actually unfolds across different populations. In a paper published in the Lancet, researchers at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and colleagues call for a fundamental re-examination of how famine thresholds are defined.
“The mortality thresholds used by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) were developed for rural African settings, not middle-income urban populations,” said L.H. Lumey, MD, PhD, Columbia Mailman School professor of Epidemiology. “There are stark disparities ...
A newly identified soil bacterium may help unlock cleaner ways to recycle carbon dioxide and produce valuable chemicals using electricity. In a recent study, researchers report that the sulfate reducing bacterium Fundidesulfovibrio terrae possesses an unusual ability to both export and absorb electrical energy while converting carbon dioxide into acetate, an industrially important organic compound. The findings reveal a previously unknown microbial strategy that could support future carbon neutral technologies and sustainable chemical production.
The research team isolated the microorganism from paddy soil and discovered that ...
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Antibiotic treatments are losing effectiveness against a range of common bacterial pathogens, including E. coli, K. pneumoniae, Salmonella and Acinetobacter, according to a warning issued by the World Health Organization last October. For the microbe that gives rise to tuberculosis, a team of researchers from Penn State and The University of Minnesota Medical School found that a potential solution may be chemically changing the structure of a naturally occurring ...
A new study has uncovered that the Erhai Lake Basin in southwest China is releasing far more atmospheric nitrogen pollution than it absorbs, raising concerns about regional air quality, ecosystem health, and long-distance pollution transport.
Atmospheric reactive nitrogen is a group of nitrogen compounds that influence air pollution, climate, and ecosystem stability. These compounds play important roles in forming fine particulate matter, worsening smog, and driving water eutrophication that threatens biodiversity and drinking water safety. Understanding where these pollutants originate and how they move through the environment is essential for designing effective pollution control strategies.
In ...
Scientists are highlighting biochar, a carbon-rich material produced from biomass, as a promising solution to help soils store carbon and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, offering new hope in global climate mitigation efforts.
In a new comprehensive review, researchers synthesized current knowledge on how biochar improves soil carbon storage, reduces greenhouse gases, and provides practical frameworks to measure its climate benefits. The findings demonstrate that biochar could play a crucial role in transforming soils into ...
Ikoma, Japan—
Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are tiny membrane-bound particles released by cells to transport proteins and other molecules to neighboring cells. Because of this natural delivery ability, EVs have attracted growing interest as potential vehicles for therapeutic protein and genome-editing enzyme delivery. However, EVs can originate either from intracellular endosomal compartments or directly from specialized protrusions on the cell surface, and until now, it has remained unclear which EV type is more effective at delivering functional protein cargo.
To address this question, researchers in ...
The American Meteorological Society has released the following Rapid Response Statement in response to the repeal of the EPA’s 2009 Endangerment Finding.
A Response to the Decision to Rescind EPA’s 2009 Endangerment Finding
The American Meteorological Society (AMS) is deeply concerned by the repeal of EPA’s 2009 Endangerment Finding, which correctly concluded that greenhouse gas emissions harm health and well-being for current and future generations.
AMS reaffirms key scientific conclusions of climate change that relate to the Endangerment Finding:
1. The impacts of climate change are harmful to people ...
“Like father, like son? Can parenting styles break the intergenerational pattern of alcohol and drug use?” A group of Brazilian researchers analyzed data on the behavior of 4,280 adolescents and their guardians based on this question, arriving at two important conclusions.
Yes, parental attitudes are one of the most relevant factors in preventing alcohol and drug use among young people. However, the way guardians educate their children can significantly mitigate the risk, even in families where caregivers use these substances, including cigarettes, vapes (which are banned in Brazil), and marijuana.
The reduction in risk is more significant when the relationship ...
The research team led by Hanmin Huang and Bangkui Yu at the University of Science and Technology of China developed a palladium-catalyzed diastereoselective and enantioselective cascade cyclization strategy, achieving the modular synthesis of chiral nitrogen-bridged ring skeletons. Using readily available salicylaldehyde and aminodiene as starting materials, and based on the team's previously developed strategy of "in-situ generation of three-membered ring palladium active intermediates from aldehydes and amines," the bridged oxazole bicyclic compounds were constructed with high diastereoselectivity ...
